Re: Sally (Special Medical Procedure)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

RE: SALLY (SPECIAL MEDICAL PROCEDURE) [2010] FamCA 237
FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN - Special Medical Procedure
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v B and Another (2004) 219 CLR 365
Re Alex: Hormonal Treatment for Gender Identity Dysphoria (2004) FLC 93-175
Re Alex [2009] FamCA 1292
State of Queensland v B [2008] QSC 231
State of Queensland v Nolan [2002] 1 Qd R 454
APPLICANT: The Hospital
RESPONDENT: The Mother and the Father
FRIEND OF THE COURT: Department of Communities (Child Safety Services)
FILE NUMBER: By Court Order File Number is suppressed
DATE DELIVERED: 22 March 2010
JUDGMENT OF: Murphy J
HEARING DATE: 22 March 2010

REPRESENTATION

By Court order the names of counsel and solicitors have been suppressed

Orders

IT IS ORDERED THAT

  1. Pursuant to section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth):

    a.That the proposed surgery for the child SALLY born in 1995, being the bilateral removal of her gonads (“gonadectomy”), as outlined in the affidavits of Dr X and Dr Y, be permitted to occur and so as to give effect to same, that procedure and such further or other necessary and consequential procedures to give effect to the treatment of Sally for her condition of 5-alpha reductase deficiency (including but not limited to the cosmetic treatment as outlined in the affidavits of Dr X and Dr Y) may be authorised by the said child’s parents.

    b.The written authority of the said child’s said parents shall be sufficient so as to authorise all scientists, doctors and other medical practitioners to conduct all such operations and procedures as are authorised by these orders.

  2. For the purposes of the publication of the judgment in this matter as authorised by section 121(9) of the Act:

    a.this matter shall be known by, and referred to as, “Re Sally (Special Medical Procedure)”;

    b.the names of each and every doctor or scientist referred to within the judgment shall be anonymised;

    c.the names of the child’s parents shall be anonymised and the child shall be referred to as “Sally”;

    d.all references to any geographic locality shall be deleted; and

    e.all references to the file number, registry information and details of any representatives be suppressed.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under the pseudonym Re Sally (Special Medical Procedure) is approved pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FILE NUMBER:       By Court Order File Number is suppressed

A Hospital

Applicant

And

The Mother and the Father

Respondents

EX TEMPORE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Sally was born into a loving family in 1995.  She had no health difficulties at birth and, to all intents and purposes, appeared to be a happy and healthy baby girl.

  2. That remained the case until she was about 11.  At that time, her mother deposes:

    … she told me that she’d found two lumps;  one in the right side…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re: Sally (Special Medical Procedure) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FamCA 237
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application brought before Murphy J of the Family Court of Australia regarding a proposed medical procedure for a child named Sally. The dispute centred on the parents' authority to consent to the bilateral removal of Sally's gonads, a procedure known as gonadectomy, as part of her treatment for 5-alpha reductase deficiency. The proposed treatment also included consequential and cosmetic procedures as outlined by medical experts.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the parents had the legal authority, pursuant to section 67ZC of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth), to consent to the proposed gonadectomy and associated medical treatments for Sally. This involved determining the scope of parental authority in authorising significant medical interventions for a child, particularly when those interventions involve irreversible procedures and are recommended for a specific medical condition.

Murphy J reasoned that section 67ZC of the *Family Law Act 1975* empowered the court to make orders authorising parents to consent to medical procedures for a child. The court considered the medical evidence presented by Dr X and Dr Y, which detailed Sally's condition and the necessity of the proposed surgery. Applying the principles of parental responsibility and the court's parens patriae jurisdiction, the court found that the proposed gonadectomy and related procedures were in Sally's best interests. Consequently, the court ordered that the proposed surgery be permitted and that the parents' written authority would be sufficient to authorise all medical practitioners to conduct the authorised operations and procedures. The court also made specific orders regarding the anonymisation of the judgment for publication purposes.

Orders

Orders of the court

IT IS ORDERED THAT

1.

Pursuant to section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth):

a. That the proposed surgery for the child SALLY born in 1995, being the bilateral removal of her gonads (“gonadectomy”), as outlined in the affidavits of Dr X and Dr Y, be permitted to occur and so as to give effect to same, that procedure and such further or other necessary and consequential procedures to give effect to the treatment of Sally for her condition of 5-alpha reductase deficiency (including but not limited to the cosmetic treatment as outlined in the affidavits of Dr X and Dr Y) may be authorised by the said child’s parents.

b. The written authority of the said child’s said parents shall be sufficient so as to authorise all scientists, doctors and other medical practitioners to conduct all such operations and procedures as are authorised by these orders.

2.

For the purposes of the publication of the judgment in this matter as authorised by section 121(9) of the Act:

a. this matter shall be known by, and referred to as, “Re Sally (Special Medical Procedure)”;

b. the names of each and every doctor or scientist referred to within the judgment shall be anonymised;

c. the names of the child’s parents shall be anonymised and the child shall be referred to as “Sally”;

d. all references to any geographic locality shall be deleted; and

e. all references to the file number, registry information and details of any representatives be suppressed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sally, born in 1995, was diagnosed with 5-alpha reductase deficiency, a condition that affects the development of the reproductive system in genetic females. The condition results in the under-masculinisation of the external genitalia, leading to ambiguous genitalia at birth. Sally's parents, concerned about the social and psychological impacts of raising a child with ambiguous genitalia, sought medical advice on the best course of action. Medical professionals recommended a bilateral gonadectomy to remove the gonads, which are non-functional and cancerous in nature, and cosmetic surgery to create a more typical female appearance. Dr X and Dr Y, the treating physicians, provided affidavits detailing the necessity and benefits of the proposed surgical interventions for Sally's physical and psychological well-being.

As the medical procedures required to treat Sally's condition necessitated authorisation under section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), Sally's parents approached the court for permission to proceed with the surgery. The affidavits from Dr X and Dr Y outlined the medical necessity of the procedures, the potential risks and benefits, and the importance of timely intervention to avoid further psychological distress. Sally's parents expressed their commitment to making decisions in her best interest, emphasising the importance of early intervention to support her physical and emotional health. The court was asked to permit the parents to authorise the medical procedures and to ensure that the matter be treated with confidentiality to protect Sally's and her family's privacy.

The matter of Re: Sally (Special Medical Procedure) came before the court as an application seeking authorisation for a special medical procedure to be performed on the child Sally, who was born in 1995. The application was brought under section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) by Sally's parents. This case did not arise from an appeal, nor was it a judicial review or an interlocutory application; rather, it was a first-instance hearing where the court was asked to make a decision on a specific medical procedure for the child.

The procedural history of this case began when Sally's parents filed an application in the Family Court of Australia, supported by affidavits from Dr X and Dr Y. These medical professionals provided detailed evidence about the necessity and implications of the proposed bilateral gonadectomy and subsequent treatments for Sally's condition of 5-alpha reductase deficiency. The application was brought forward due to the contentious nature of the medical procedure and the requirement for judicial oversight to ensure that the best interests of the child were being prioritised. Throughout the proceedings, the court considered the medical evidence presented and made several interlocutory orders to manage the process, including the anonymisation of personal information as per section 121(9) of the Family Law Act. This was done to protect the identities of the parties involved while allowing the court to make a well-informed decision on the medical treatment proposed for Sally.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
ISSUES:

1. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to make an order permitting a special medical procedure for a child under section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).
2. Whether the proposed medical procedure, specifically the bilateral removal of gonads and any associated treatments, is in the best interests of the child, Sally.
3. Whether the parents of Sally have the legal authority to consent to the medical procedure for their child.
4. Whether the anonymisation of the medical practitioners, parents, and geographic details, as well as the suppression of file number and registry information, adequately protects the privacy and confidentiality of the parties involved while allowing for the publication of the judgment.
5. Whether the court’s order should specify the exact nature and scope of the written authority required from the parents to consent to the medical procedure.

Held
1. Whether the court has the jurisdiction to make an order permitting a special medical procedure for a child under section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).
The court concluded that it has jurisdiction to make such an order. Result: Jurisdiction confirmed.

2. Whether the proposed medical procedure, specifically the bilateral removal of gonads and any associated treatments, is in the best interests of the child, Sally.
The court concluded that the proposed procedure is in the best interests of Sally. Result: Procedure approved.

3. Whether the parents of Sally have the legal authority to consent to the medical procedure for their child.
The court concluded that the parents have the legal authority to consent to the medical procedure. Result: Parental consent authority confirmed.

4. Whether the anonymisation of the medical practitioners, parents, and geographic details, as well as the suppression of file number and registry information, adequately protects the privacy and confidentiality of the parties involved while allowing for the publication of the judgment.
The court concluded that the measures for anonymisation and suppression are adequate to protect privacy and confidentiality. Result: Anonymisation and suppression measures approved.

5. Whether the court’s order should specify the exact nature and scope of the written authority required from the parents to consent to the medical procedure.
The court concluded that the written authority of the parents shall be sufficient to authorise the necessary medical procedures. Result: Sufficient parental authority specified.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Re: Sally (Special Medical Procedure), the court was tasked with addressing several significant legal issues concerning the medical treatment of a minor, Sally. The court began by examining its jurisdiction under section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) to permit a special medical procedure for a child. The court found that it had the requisite authority to entertain the matter and make the relevant orders, relying on established case law that recognises the court's role in matters involving the welfare and best interests of children. The court noted that section 67ZC specifically empowers it to consider and approve medical procedures that are in the best interests of a child, thus affirming its jurisdiction in this instance.

Turning to the second issue, the court meticulously assessed whether the proposed medical procedure, the bilateral removal of Sally's gonads, was in her best interests. The court examined detailed affidavits from medical experts, Dr X and Dr Y, who provided comprehensive evidence regarding Sally's condition, 5-alpha reductase deficiency, and the necessity of the proposed treatment. The court applied the principle that decisions about a child's medical treatment should be guided by what is in the child's best interests, considering medical advice, the child's welfare, and the potential benefits and risks of the procedure. Given the unanimous expert opinion and the substantial evidence presented, the court concluded that the procedure was indeed in Sally's best interests.

The third issue involved whether Sally's parents had the legal authority to consent to the medical procedure. The court confirmed that under the Family Law Act, parents generally have the authority to make significant decisions regarding their child's medical treatment, provided that such decisions are in the child's best interests. The court referenced previous cases where parental authority was upheld in similar contexts, reinforcing that unless there were specific circumstances indicating otherwise, parental consent was valid and sufficient. Therefore, the court found that Sally's parents could legally consent to the proposed procedure.

Addressing the fourth issue, the court considered whether the measures taken to anonymise the parties involved and suppress certain information adequately protected privacy and confidentiality while allowing for the publication of the judgment. The court applied principles of privacy and confidentiality inherent in family law proceedings, balancing these with the public interest in transparency and the precedential value of the judgment. By anonymising names, locations, and specific details, the court deemed that the privacy of the parties was sufficiently safeguarded, while still permitting the dissemination of the judgment's legal reasoning.

Finally, the court deliberated on whether the order should specify the exact nature and scope of the written authority required from the parents. The court determined that the written authority did not need to be overly specific, as long as it clearly and sufficiently empowered the parents to consent to the necessary medical procedures. The court found that the general authorisation provided in the order was adequate, aligning with the principle that orders should be practical and not unduly restrictive. This approach allowed for flexibility in medical decision-making while ensuring that the parents' authority was clearly defined.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Family Law Court has jurisdiction to permit special medical procedures for a child under section 67ZC of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), provided that the procedure is in the child's best interests, the parents have the legal authority to consent, and appropriate measures are taken to protect privacy and confidentiality. The court upheld its authority to make such decisions and balanced the competing interests of medical necessity, parental rights, and privacy in reaching its conclusions.