Starke v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

STARKE v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER

[2025] SASC 31

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein  

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY

The respondent seeks summary dismissal of an application for judicial review brought by the applicant pursuant to r 256.5(3) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA).  The applicant sought discovery of particular documents prior to the hearing and determination of the respondent’s summary dismissal application on the basis those documents were relevant to the Court’s determination.

Held (refusing the application):

1.The evident purposes of r 256.5 are to avoid unnecessary cost, time and delay and to ensure expedient determination of any application for summary judgment.  The materials necessary to determine the respondent’s application are presently before the Court. The documents sought are not required to address the summary dismissal application and the applicant has not demonstrated that he would be prejudiced by a refusal to order discover.  Accordingly, there are not sufficiently persuasive reasons to depart from r 256.5.

Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 143.2, 144.2, 256.5, 256.6, referred to.
Vansetten v State of South Australia [2020] SASC 158; Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Hallett Concrete Pty Ltd (2020) 137 SASR 117; Rana v Hyatt Regency Hotel Ltd [2007] SASC 7, considered.

STARKE v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER
[2025] SASC 31

Civil: Application

  1. STEIN J:  The applicant has applied for judicial review of a decision by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (“the Commissioner”) to lay a charge against the applicant in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (“the Tribunal”).  The Commissioner has sought summary dismissal of the application for judicial review.  The applicant seeks discovery and production of documents in advance of the hearing and determination of the summary dismissal application. 

  2. For the reasons which follow, I have determined to refuse the application for discovery and production in advance of the summary dismissal application.

    Background

  3. On 12 June 2024, the Commissioner laid a charge alleging that the applicant engaged in professional misconduct as a result of an alleged failure to comply with conditions placed on his practising certificate on 21 November 2016. 

  4. Since 2016, there have been conditions on the applicant’s practising certificate to the effect that he must not brief counsel without first having funds in trust before the brief is delivered to counsel or having informed counsel of the condition on his practising certificate and counsel having agreed in writing to await payment of their fees. 

  5. The background circumstances which gave rise to the laying of the charge commenced in about May 2021 when the Commissioner received a complaint about the applicant’s conduct which asserted that the applicant had failed to pay counsel fees.  The Commissioner, through his staff, asked the applicant to respond to the complaint and, in doing so, to address in his response whether he had told the complainant he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Starke v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Starke v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner involved an application for discovery and production of documents in advance of a summary dismissal application. The applicant, Starke, faced a charge of professional misconduct by the Commissioner, which stemmed from an alleged failure to comply with conditions on his practising certificate. These conditions required Starke to either have funds in trust before briefing counsel or to inform counsel of the conditions on his practising certificate and obtain written agreement to await payment of fees. The Commissioner had initiated an investigation following a complaint that Starke had failed to pay counsel fees and had not disclosed the conditions on his practising certificate. Starke sought various documents and particulars from the Commissioner, including evidence relied upon for the investigation, and questioned the legality and basis of the investigation. The Commissioner refused Starke’s requests.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Starke was entitled to discovery and production of the investigation file prior to the summary dismissal application. Starke argued that access to the investigation file was necessary to adequately address the summary dismissal application. The court had to determine if there was good reason to depart from the usual procedural rules, particularly r 256.5, which generally does not permit discovery before a summary dismissal application.

The court found that regardless of the potential discoverability of the investigation file or any claims of legal professional privilege or public interest immunity, Starke had not demonstrated how the lack of access to the investigation file would prejudice him or prevent him from addressing the summary dismissal application. The court noted that Starke already had sufficient material to respond to the allegations. Therefore, the court concluded that Starke had not shown a good reason to depart from the procedural rule, as the purposes of the rule would be undermined if such departures were allowed without compelling necessity.

The court refused Starke’s application for discovery and production of the investigation file in advance of the summary dismissal application. The court's decision was grounded in the lack of demonstrated necessity for the investigation file to address the summary dismissal application effectively.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow, I have determined to refuse the application for discovery and production in advance of the summary dismissal application. Background On 12 June 2024, the Commissioner laid a charge alleging that the applicant engaged in professional misconduct as a result of an alleged failure to comply with conditions placed on his practising certificate on 21 November 2016. Since 2016, there have been conditions on the applicant’s practising certificate to the effect that he must not brief counsel without first having funds in trust before the brief is delivered to counsel or having informed counsel of the condition on his practising certificate and counsel having agreed in writing to await payment of their fees. The background circumstances which gave rise to the laying of the charge commenced in about May 2021 when the Commissioner received a complaint about the applicant’s conduct which asserted that the applicant had failed to pay counsel fees. The Commissioner, through his staff, asked the applicant to respond to the complaint and, in doing so, to address in his response whether he had told the complainant he had money in trust from the client to pay her fees or if he had alerted her to the conditions on his practising certificate concerning briefing counsel. The complainant, in response to questions from the Commissioner, said she could not recall whether the applicant told her he had money in trust and there was never any discussion about the conditions on the applicant’s practising certificate. The applicant responded to the complaint including providing explanations and referring to mitigating factors. On 23 August 2021, the Commissioner wrote to the applicant to inform him that the Commissioner had decided to make an investigation on his own initiative under s 77B(1) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) (the “Act”) in relation to assertions the applicant did not comply with the conditions on his practising certificate when he briefed the complainant in May 2020 together with asserted failures to comply with the conditions in briefing two other counsel. The applicant responded to the Commissioner. In his response, and in subsequent correspondence, the applicant sought various documents and particulars including a copy of documentation or evidence relied on by the Commissioner for making the decision to conduct an own motion investigation. In further correspondence, the applicant questioned the legality of the investigations, asserted that the Commissioner had acted on tainted evidence and took the position the Commissioner had no proper basis for asking the questions asked of the applicant and complainant about compliance with his practicing certificate conditions. The Commissioner did not accept those criticisms. In April 2024, the Commissioner wrote to the solicitor for the applicant informing the applicant that the Commissioner had formed a preliminary view about his conduct and giving the applicant an opportunity to make further submissions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Irrespective of whether or not the investigation file was discoverable or could be subject to legal professional privilege or public interest immunity, the documents are not required for the purposes of addressing the summary dismissal application. The applicant has not established that lack of access to the investigation file will prejudice the applicant or prevent him from addressing the summary dismissal application in the context of the already filed material and the various allegations. Accordingly, the applicant has not shown good reason to depart from r 256.5 in light of the purposes of that rule. Conclusion and orders The applicant’s application for discovery in advance of the summary dismissal application is refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court’s reasoning in this case primarily revolves around the discovery of the investigation file in the context of a summary dismissal application and whether the applicant has demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant its production. Firstly, the court addressed whether the investigation file was discoverable. It noted that the determination of discoverability was not critical to the outcome as the court found that the investigation file was not necessary for effectively addressing the summary dismissal application. The court held that regardless of the file’s discoverability, the documents contained within it were not essential given the already filed material and the allegations at hand.

Secondly, the court considered whether the investigation file could be subject to legal professional privilege or public interest immunity. However, the court did not delve deeply into these issues as it concluded that the need for these documents was not substantiated. The court’s focus remained on the necessity of the investigation file for the purposes of the summary dismissal application rather than on the potential exemptions that might apply to it.

Thirdly, the court examined whether the applicant needed access to the investigation file to effectively address the summary dismissal application. It was determined that the applicant did not require the investigation file as the existing material was sufficient to address the allegations. The court emphasized that the applicant had not provided adequate justification for why the investigation file was indispensable for defending against the summary dismissal application.

Fourthly, the court assessed whether the applicant had demonstrated that the lack of access to the investigation file would prejudice them or prevent them from adequately addressing the summary dismissal application. The court found that the applicant had not made a compelling case for such prejudice. Given the comprehensive nature of the existing documentation and the applicant's ability to address the allegations without the investigation file, the court concluded that the applicant’s case was not prejudiced by the non-disclosure of the investigation file.

Finally, the court considered whether the applicant had shown good reason to depart from rule 256.5 in light of the purposes of that rule. Rule 256.5 pertains to the discretion of the court to order discovery in civil proceedings. The court held that the applicant had not demonstrated a sufficient reason to diverge from this rule. The purposes of the rule are to ensure that discovery is not granted frivolously or without substantial need, and the court found that the applicant’s application did not meet these criteria.

In distinguishing from prior authority, the court relied on the principle that discovery should not be granted unless it is necessary for the fair and just resolution of the proceedings. The court underscored the importance of balancing the need for disclosure with the potential for prejudice and the overarching objectives of the legal process. This decision aligns with the precedent that discovery should be limited to what is necessary and proportionate to the issues at hand.

Overall, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court will not order the discovery of documents in the context of a summary dismissal application unless the applicant demonstrates that such documents are essential for effectively addressing the application, and the lack of access would result in significant prejudice. This decision reinforces the principle that discovery should be judiciously granted to avoid unnecessary burden and delay in proceedings.