' \
JUDGMENT No. ........ .. g?-
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA 1 GENERAL DIVISION
1 QLD E190 Of 1985 BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE SOUTHERN ) DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND )
RE: RODNEY WARREN HOFFMAN
EX PARTE: IVOR WORRELL Applicant
GREGORY RUDOLPH SCHILLING
Respondents
MINUTES OF ORDER
JUDGE MKING ORDER:
OF DATE ORDER: 1989 7 APRIL
- _ _ _
WHERE MADE: BRISBANE THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
- NOTE : Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in
Rule 124 of the Bankruptcy Rules. 1. the words "the Trustee i6 to repay to Mr Schilling any sum paid by Mr Schilling in reduction of the said sum of $25,000.00" in the order made on 3 February 1989 be deleted;
2. paragraph 2(a) of the same order be amended to read: "the applicant pay Mr Schilling's costs of and incidental to the application, to be taxed, up
to a maximum of $3,500".
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA 1
DIVISION GENERAL ) QLD E190 of 1985 BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE SOUTHERN )
DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND RE: RODNEY WARREN HOFFMAN
EX PARTE: IVOR WORRELL Applicant
GREGORY RUDOLPH SCHILLING
HEATHER GRACE MAY HOFFMAN Respondents
PINCUS J. 7 APRIL 1989
EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT In this matter, the orders which I have to date made are
conveniently to be found in the affidavit of Mr Worrcll, the trustee, sworn on 21 March 1989. They state in part that:
"2. ...
(a) the Applicant is to pay Mr Schilllng's costs of and incidental to the action to be taxed;
(b) (i) the Applicant I s to pay out the amount
presently due by Mr Schilling to the AN2 Bank in respect of the loan of $25,000.00;
(b) (ii) the Trustee is to repay to Hr
Schilling any sum paid by Mr
Schilliing in reduction of the said sum of $25,000.00;
(c) the balance sum held by the Applicant is to be
L .
available as part of the bankrupt's estate".
Subsequent to my making those orders, counsel for Mr
Worrell appeared before me and informed me that because of a deficiency in the funds in the estate, it was desirable to vary
them. That is conceded, but there is a dispute as to the proper extent of variation.
The papers reveal that at the time when I heard the
matter last year, Wr Worrell's opinion was that the net assets in
the estate were in the region of $96,000. He has since discovered that the assets are nowhere so great, and he says, and I accept, that they are insufficient to enable the orders which I made to be carried out from the existing assets. I have some sympathy with Mr Worrell because he, as I
have said in my original reasons, acted rightly in bringing the
matter to the court. Nevertheless, in the result, his contention
was unsuccessful and I cqnnot fully relieve him of the obligation which would fall on him personally if my order…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Standish v University of Tasmania and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1989] FCA 166
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the trustee's submissions and found that the original orders could not be fulfilled due to insufficient funds in the estate. While the trustee had acted appropriately in bringing the matter before the court, the court could not fully absolve him of personal liability if the orders were to remain unchanged. The judge proposed variations to the previous order, including the deletion of a provision that required the trustee to repay any sums paid by Mr Schilling towards a bank debt and a limitation on the costs payable by the applicant to a maximum of $3,500. The judge reasoned that these adjustments were necessary to ensure the orders could be implemented within the available estate assets.
In conclusion, the court varied the earlier orders by deleting the provision that required the trustee to repay sums paid by Mr Schilling towards the bank debt and limiting the applicant's costs to a maximum of $3,500. These changes were made to address the shortfall in the estate's assets and to ensure the orders could be executed. The final orders were made on 7 April 1989, reflecting these adjustments and providing a resolution to the dispute.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi