Staley v Hill Family Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Staley v Hill Family Holdings Pty Ltd [2024] QSC 176

PARTIES:

KERIN ANNE STALEY

(first applicant)
AND

STALEY MANAGEMENT PTY LTD ACN 678 146 202 AS TRUSTEE OF THE HILL FAMILY TRUST

(second applicant)

v
HILL FAMILY HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 099 638 105 IN ITS OWN RIGHT AND AS (PURPORTED) TRUSTEE OF THE HILL FAMILY TRUST

(respondent)

FILE NO:

8456 of 2024

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

16 August 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

12 July 2024

JUDGE:

Muir J

ORDER:

1.   The declarations sought by the applicant are refused.

2.   I will hear the parties as to the form of orders (including as to costs) and any declarations (if they are agreed) that follow from my findings.      

CATCHWORDS:

EQUITY – TRUSTS – DISCRETIONARY TRUST – REMOVAL OF APPOINTOR – where the Trustee of a discretionary trust executed a Deed of Variation to remove and substitute the Appointor under the Trust Deed – where the Appointor seeks a declaration that the Deed of Variation is invalid – where the Appointer subsequently executed a Deed of Removal and Appointment replacing the Trustee – whether the power to vary the terms of the Trust Deed includes a power to change the identity of the Appointor or amend the terms of the Trust Deed to allow that to happen

Trusts Act 1973 (Qld), s 12.05

Armitage v Nurse [1998] Ch 241

Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd (1973) 129 CLR 99

Byrnes v Kendle (2011) 243 CLR 253
Cachia v Westpac Financial Services Ltd (2000) 170 ALR 65
Cihan v Cihan [2022] NSWSC 538
Cott UK Ltd v FE Barber Ltd [1997] 3 All ER 540
Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014) 251 CLR 640
ING Funds Management Ltd v ANZ Nominees Ltd (2009) 228 FLR 444
International Air Transport Association v Ansett Australia Holdings Ltd (2008) 234 CLR 151
Jenkins v Ellett [2007] QSC 154
Kearns v Hill (1990) 21 NSWLR 107
lezzi Constructions Pty Ltd v Watkins Pacific (Qld) Pty Ltd [1995] 2 Qd R 350
Mercanti v Mercanti (2016) 50 WAR 495
Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 104
Palmer v Palmer [2018] QSC 217
Provincial Insurance Australia Pty Ltd v Consolidated Wood Products Pty Ltd (1991) 25 NSWLR 541
Rinehart v Welker [2012] NSWCA 95

Royal Botanic Gardens and Domain Trust v South Sydney City Council (2002) 240 CLR 45

Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165

COUNSEL:

C Heyworth-Smith KC with MEB Williams for the applicants
G Beacham KC with K Kluss for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Thynne & Macartney for the applicants

Bartley Cohen for the respondent

  1. The Hill Family Trust was established by Deed on 19 February 2002 at the instigation of Mr Hill. The respondent (Hill Family Holdings) is the named Trustee.  Mr Hill and his wife were the original directors and shareholders of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Staley v Hill Family Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 176
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Staley v Hill Family Holdings Pty Ltd concerned the validity of a Deed of Variation executed by the Trustee of a discretionary trust to remove and substitute the Appointor under the Trust Deed. The dispute arose when the Appointor, Mrs Staley, sought a declaration that the Deed of Variation was invalid. This case required the Federal Court to determine whether the power to vary the terms of the Trust Deed included a power to change the identity of the Appointor or amend the terms of the Trust Deed to allow that to happen.

The court examined the Trust Deed, particularly clause 14.01, which granted the Trustee the power to vary all or any of the trusts, powers, or provisions declared or included in the Trust Deed. The court noted that clause 14 did not require the Trustee to obtain prior consent from the Appointor before exercising these powers. The court found that the Deed of Variation was effective as it was consistent with the Trustee's power under clause 14.01 to vary the terms of the Trust Deed. The court concluded that the Trustee had the authority to insert a new clause, including one that allowed for the removal and substitution of the Appointor, provided a replacement Appointor was nominated.

The court refused the declarations sought by Mrs Staley, holding that the Deed of Variation was valid. The court will hear the parties regarding the form of orders, including costs, and any agreed declarations flowing from the findings.

ORDERS:
1. The declarations sought by the applicant are refused.
2. I will hear the parties as to the form of orders (including as to costs) and any declarations (if they are agreed) that follow from my findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The declarations sought by the applicant are refused.

2. I will hear the parties as to the form of orders (including as to costs) and any declarations (if they are agreed) that follow from my findings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The construction of the Trust Deed is discussed under that heading later in these Reasons. The circumstances in which the Trust Deed came to be executed are not before the court; nor are the value of any Trust assets. The limited facts which give some context to the dispute are set out below. Facts Mr Hill died on 18 December 2009. Under the Trust Deed, Mrs Staley and her sister Mrs Porter (as Mr Hill’s executors) became the Appointors of the Trust. At that time, Mrs Hill became the sole director and shareholder of Hill Family Holdings. On 30 October 2013, Mrs Hill (on behalf of Hill Family Holdings) made an oral declaration, under clause 23.01 of the Trust Deed, removing Mrs Staley, her husband Dennis and their children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren as beneficiaries of the Hill Family Trust. On that same day, Mrs Hill appointed Mrs Porter as a director of Hill Family Holdings. On 18 November 2015, Hill Family Holdings purported to execute a Deed Poll removing Mrs Staley as Appointor and appointing Mrs Porter as a substitute Appointor of the Trust. It is accepted that this Deed Poll is invalid. On 22 July 2019, Mrs Porter appointed her daughter Mrs Mitchelmore as a director of Hill Family Holdings. Later that year, Mrs Porter died. Upon Mrs Porter’s death, Mrs Staley became the sole Appointor of the Trust. On 29 December 2022, Mrs Hill died. On 28 March 2024, Hill Family Holdings executed the Deed of Variation which purported to amend the terms of the Trust Deed, by the insertion of a new clause as follows: “2. VARIATIONWith effect on and from the Effective Date, the Trustee varies the Trust Deed by inserting the following new clause after clause 22.03:22.04 Special Removal of Appointor(a) This clause 22.04 only applies where Kerin Anne Staley is the Appointor.(b) The Trustee may in its absolute discretion remove Kerin Anne Staley as the Appointor, provided that the Trustee nominates a person (other than the Trustee) to become the replacement Appointor.3. REMOVAL OF APPOINTOROn the Effective Date and immediately following the variations made by the Trustee in clause 2, the Trustee, in accordance with its power in clause 22.04 of the Trust Deed:(a) removes Kerin as the Appointor of the Trust; and(b) appoints the New Appointor as the Appointor of the Trust in her place.…” The New Appointor is not defined or named in the Background or Operative Provisions of the Deed of Variation but is identified as Mr Porter in the “Details of Parties” section at the start of the document. The Deed of Variation is signed by Mrs Mitchelmore as sole secretary and director of Hill Family Holdings and by Mr Porter as the New Appointor. The recitals to the Deed of Variation include the following reference to the power in the Trust Deed to make such a variation: “H. Pursuant to clause 14.01 of the Trust Deed, The Trustee may revoke, add to, release, delete or vary all or any of the trusts, power or provisions declared or included in the Trust Deed or any trust, powers or provisions declared by or included in any revocation, addition, release, deletion or variation made to the Trust Deed.I. Clause 14 of the Trust Deed does not require the Trustee to obtain prior consent from the Appointor before exercising the powers in clause 14.01.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Sixth, as emerges from these reasons, I am satisfied on a proper construction of clause 14.01 that the Deed of Variation was effective. Conclusion The declarations sought are refused. I will hear the parties as to the form of orders (including as to costs) and any declarations (if they are agreed) that follow from my findings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the power of the Trustee to vary the terms of the Trust Deed under clause 14.01. The Trust Deed grants the Trustee broad discretion to vary the trusts, powers, or provisions declared or included in the Trust Deed. The court held that this power encompasses the ability to alter the identity of the Appointor and to make amendments allowing for the removal of an Appointor and the appointment of a new Appointor. The court found that clause 14.01 does not require the Trustee to obtain the Appointor’s consent before exercising these powers. The court rejected Mrs Staley’s argument that the power to vary did not extend to changing the Appointor’s identity or allowing for the removal and substitution of Appointors. The court’s decision hinged on the plain language of clause 14.01 and its interpretation of the Trustee’s discretion. This case reinforces the principle that trustees have broad powers to manage and vary trusts, subject to the terms of the Trust Deed and applicable law. The ratio decidendi is that the Trustee’s power to vary the terms of the Trust Deed includes the power to change the identity of the Appointor and to amend the Trust Deed to allow such changes.