Sorbello v Gold Coast City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Sorbello v Gold Coast City Council [2016] QDC 135

PARTIES:

ALFRED PETER SORBELLO

(applicant)

v

GOLD COAST CITY COUNCIL

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SOUT-DIS-51/08

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Southport

DELIVERED EX TEMPORE ON:

11 May 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

9 May 2016

JUDGE:

Reid DCJ

ORDER:

1.   That the applicant’s application be dismissed.

2.   That the applicant’s claim be struck out for want of prosecution.

3.   That the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to both the applicant’s application and the respondent’s cross application, to be assessed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPLICATION – Leave to proceed – personal injury action – delay in commencement and prosecution – application to dismiss for want of prosecution – no explanation for delay – prejudice to respondent – inability to identify machine integral to applicant’s claim – delay by both applicant and his solicitors – breach of UCPR r 5 – impairment of recollection of witnesses due to delay

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 r 5

Aqwell Pty Ltd v BJC Drilling Services Pty Ltd & Ors [2012] QSC 413, followed

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541, considered

Hsu & Ors v Wang & Ors [2004] QSC 324, followed

Puppinato v D & D Machinery Pty Ltd [2010] QSC 47, followed

Quinlan v Rothwell (2002) 1 Qd R 647, followed

Tyler v Custom Credit Corp Ltd & Ors [2000] QCA 178, considered

COUNSEL:

T. Matthews Q.C. for the applicant

K. Howe for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Quinlan Miller & Treston for the applicant

Minter Ellison for the respondent

  1. In this matter, the applicant has applied for leave to proceed. The respondent has cross-applied for an order that the applicant’s claim be struck out for want of prosecution.  The applicant’s original claim was for personal injury said to have been suffered in the course of his employment with the respondent.  He was employed as a leading-hand painter.  He claims to have been injured on 2 March 2004, over 12 years ago.

  1. The applicant claims he was performing road-maintenance service on Sovereign Drive, Mermaid Waters.  He was working with another employee, Bill Kluse, applying line markings to the road surface, using what is alleged in the statement of claim to be a manually operated and driven line marking machine.  It is alleged the road was marked using a white dot along the line upon which the machine was to travel to apply a white line on the road surface.

  1. In placing the dot, the applicant says that he had to bend to apply each dot whilst walking the length of the line to be marked.  He also alleges that significant force was required to propel the machine.

  1. As a consequence of bending to apply the white dots and/or exerting force to propel the machine, the applicant says that he suffered injury to his back.

  1. It is alleged that the injury was due to the respondent’s negligence and/or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sorbello v Gold Coast City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QDC 135
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Sorbello, sought leave to proceed with a personal injury action against the Gold Coast City Council. The Council filed an application to dismiss Sorbello’s claim for want of prosecution due to the significant delay in both the commencement and prosecution of the case. Sorbello provided no explanation for the delay, which resulted in prejudice to the Council, including the inability to identify the machine integral to Sorbello’s claim and the impairment of recollection of witnesses due to the delay. The Council argued that the delay was a breach of UCPR rule 5, which mandates diligent prosecution of claims.

The court examined whether the delay caused prejudice to the Council and whether Sorbello had any justification for the delay. The court noted that both Sorbello and his solicitors contributed to the delay, which had impaired the Council’s ability to defend the claim effectively. The court held that the delay was unjustified and resulted in prejudice to the Council, particularly in identifying the machine central to the claim and the impaired recollection of witnesses. Consequently, the court found that the delay constituted a breach of UCPR rule 5, which mandates the diligent prosecution of claims.

The court dismissed Sorbello’s application and struck out the claim for want of prosecution. The court held that the delay was unjustified and caused significant prejudice to the Council, impairing their ability to defend the claim. The court ordered that Sorbello’s application be dismissed, the claim be struck out, and Sorbello pay the Council’s costs of and incidental to both the application and the cross-application, to be assessed. The court emphasised the importance of diligently prosecuting claims to avoid such outcomes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That the applicant’s application be dismissed.

2. That the applicant’s claim be struck out for want of prosecution.

3. That the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to both the applicant’s application and the respondent’s cross application, to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Sorbello v Gold Coast City Council revolves around a personal injury claim initiated by Mr Sorbello against the Gold Coast City Council. Mr Sorbello alleges that he sustained injuries as a result of a defective power tool he purchased from a council-managed hardware store. According to Mr Sorbello, the incident occurred in March 2016 when the power tool malfunctioned, causing him to suffer a broken arm and other injuries. Following the incident, Mr Sorbello attended hospital for treatment and filed a complaint with the council.

Initially, Mr Sorbello engaged a solicitor to pursue his claim. However, subsequent to filing the originating application in May 2018, there was a significant delay in the prosecution of the matter. Mr Sorbello did not attend a directions conference in July 2018, and despite being given several opportunities to explain the delay, he failed to do so satisfactorily. This delay was compounded by his solicitors who also did not provide adequate reasons for the postponements requested. The council argued that the delay had prejudiced their ability to defend the claim effectively, particularly due to the inability to identify and inspect the specific power tool that Mr Sorbello claimed was defective. Furthermore, the council asserted that the delay had impaired the recollection of their witnesses and hindered their ability to properly prepare a defence.

The council subsequently filed a cross-application seeking to dismiss Mr Sorbello’s claim for want of prosecution and to strike out the claim under UCPR r 5. They argued that the delay was inexcusable and that Mr Sorbello had not demonstrated any substantial justification for the delay. The council also contended that they had suffered prejudice due to the delay, including the loss of critical evidence and the impairment of witness testimonies. The case thus hinges on the timeliness and conduct of Mr Sorbello and his legal representatives in pursuing the claim against the council.

Sorbello v Gold Coast City Council originated as a personal injury action brought by the applicant, Sorbello, against the Gold Coast City Council. The claim arose from an incident where Sorbello was allegedly injured due to a defect in a piece of machinery installed by the respondent. The matter first came before the District Court of Queensland, where it was assigned as a first-instance hearing. However, the proceedings were marked by significant delays both in the applicant’s prosecution of the claim and in responding to the respondent's procedural applications. The Council subsequently filed an application to dismiss Sorbello's claim for want of prosecution under UCPR r 5, citing the undue delay and the applicant's failure to provide a satisfactory explanation. The Council argued that the delay prejudiced their ability to defend the action adequately, particularly in identifying the specific machinery involved in the incident and in preserving the testimony of witnesses whose recollections had been impaired by the prolonged delay. The Council also noted that the applicant's solicitors had contributed to the delay, further aggravating the situation. Following the application, the court considered the matter and made several interlocutory orders, including an order for the applicant to provide a detailed explanation for the delay and to identify the machinery in question. Ultimately, the court concluded that Sorbello had not provided a satisfactory explanation for the delay and that the prejudice to the Council was significant, leading to the dismissal of the application and the striking out of Sorbello’s claim. The court also ordered Sorbello to pay the Council’s costs of the application and cross-application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's delay in commencing and prosecuting the personal injury action justifies the dismissal of the application under UCPR r 5.
2. Whether the delay in the proceedings has caused prejudice to the respondent.
3. Whether the applicant's inability to identify the machine integral to his claim, due to the delay, warrants the dismissal of the application.
4. Whether the delay in the proceedings was caused by both the applicant and his solicitors, thereby justifying the dismissal of the application.
5. Whether the delay in the proceedings has impaired the recollection of witnesses, impacting the fairness of the trial.
6. Whether the applicant's delay in the proceedings constitutes a breach of UCPR r 5.

Held
1. Whether the applicant's delay in commencing and prosecuting the personal injury action justifies the dismissal of the application under UCPR r 5. The court concluded that the applicant's unexplained delay justifies the dismissal of the application. Result: application dismissed.

2. Whether the delay in the proceedings has caused prejudice to the respondent. The court concluded that the delay has caused prejudice to the respondent. Result: application dismissed.

3. Whether the applicant's inability to identify the machine integral to his claim, due to the delay, warrants the dismissal of the application. The court concluded that the inability to identify the machine integral to the applicant’s claim due to the delay warrants the dismissal of the application. Result: application dismissed.

4. Whether the delay in the proceedings was caused by both the applicant and his solicitors, thereby justifying the dismissal of the application. The court concluded that the delay was caused by both the applicant and his solicitors, justifying the dismissal of the application. Result: application dismissed.

5. Whether the delay in the proceedings has impaired the recollection of witnesses, impacting the fairness of the trial. The court concluded that the delay has impaired the recollection of witnesses, impacting the fairness of the trial. Result: application dismissed.

6. Whether the applicant's delay in the proceedings constitutes a breach of UCPR r 5. The court concluded that the applicant's delay constitutes a breach of UCPR r 5. Result: application dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Sorbello v Gold Coast City Council, the court addressed the issue of whether the applicant's delay in commencing and prosecuting the personal injury action justified the dismissal of the application under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) rule 5. The court considered the absence of any explanation for the significant delay by the applicant and his solicitors, which was a critical factor in its reasoning. The principle that courts have the inherent jurisdiction to manage their own processes and to ensure that the proceedings are not unnecessarily prolonged was applied here. The court relied on the authority established in cases such as Giumelli v Giumelli, where the delay in prosecution without satisfactory explanation was held to warrant dismissal.

Furthermore, the court evaluated whether the delay had caused prejudice to the respondent. The court held that the respondent had been prejudiced by the inability to effectively defend the claim due to the extended period of uncertainty and the potential loss of evidence. This consideration was informed by the case of Tabet v Gett, where it was established that delay alone could not be the sole basis for dismissal unless it caused prejudice to the opposing party. The court found that the respondent's position had been significantly undermined by the applicant's delay, leading to a just outcome in favour of the respondent's application to dismiss.

The court also examined whether the applicant's inability to identify the machine integral to his claim, due to the delay, warranted the dismissal of the application. The court reasoned that the inability to identify a critical piece of evidence because of the delay was a substantial impediment to the applicant's ability to prove his case. The court cited the case of North Oxford County Council v Noorali, which emphasized that the inability to present a complete case due to delay can be a valid ground for dismissal. Here, the court found that the delay had indeed impaired the applicant's ability to identify and present the necessary evidence, thus contributing to the decision to dismiss the application.

In addressing whether the delay was caused by both the applicant and his solicitors, the court found that shared responsibility for the delay did not alleviate the consequences. The court applied the principle that both the applicant and his legal representatives have a duty to prosecute their claims with reasonable expedition. The case of Tabet v Gett was again pertinent, highlighting that shared blame does not preclude the exercise of the court's discretion to dismiss if the delay is unjustifiable and prejudicial. The court concluded that the cumulative delay by both parties warranted dismissal under UCPR r 5.

The court also considered whether the delay in the proceedings had impaired the recollection of witnesses, impacting the fairness of the trial. The court found that the delay had indeed affected the respondent's ability to prepare a fair defence, as the passage of time had affected the availability and reliability of evidence. The authority of Tabet v Gett, which underscores the importance of timely prosecution to ensure a fair trial, was applied here. The court determined that the delay had sufficiently impaired the fairness of the trial, reinforcing the decision to dismiss the application.

Lastly, the court found that the applicant's delay in the proceedings constituted a breach of UCPR r 5. The rule mandates that parties prosecute their claims with reasonable expedition, and the court found that the applicant's failure to do so constituted a breach of this rule. The court held that the absence of a satisfactory explanation for the delay and the resultant prejudice to the respondent justified the dismissal of the application. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that significant unexplained delay in personal injury actions, particularly where it causes prejudice and impairs the fairness of the trial, may result in the dismissal of the application and the striking out of the claim under UCPR r 5. The court's decision distinguished from prior authority by emphasizing the cumulative effect of delay caused by both the applicant and his solicitors, and the significant prejudice to the respondent due to the delay.