Slusarczyk and City of Stirling

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SLUSARCZYK and CITY OF STIRLING [2008] WASAT 194



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2008] WASAT 194
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:87/200821 MAY 2008
Coram:MR P McNAB (MEMBER)26/08/08
24Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: The decision under review is affirmed and the application for review is dismissed
B
PDF Version
Parties:CARL ANTHONY SLUSARCZYK
CITY OF STIRLING

Catchwords:

Town planning
Development application for demolition
Heritage considerations
c1920 bungalow in Mount Lawley
Property in Heritage Protection Area
Property substantially modified over time and in need of repair
State of intactness of subject property
Absence of State or local heritage listing
Whether Scheme and corresponding Guidelines presumed conservation of such properties as a starting point
Contribution of property to cultural heritage discussed
Differing views of heritage experts
Significant heritage conservation values underlying planning framework
Planning framework not inconsistent with 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation
Interpretation of heritage values
Whether Tribunal should inquire into the creation of and assumptions that underlay the local planning framework
Demolition refused by Tribunal
Application dismissed

Legislation:

City of Stirling District Planning Scheme No 2, cl 2.1, Sch 4
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), Pt 3

Case References:

Branca and City of Stirling [2008] WASAT 69
May and Town of Victoria Park [2008] WASAT 40
Tooth v City of Subiaco (2005) 41 SR (WA) 198; [2005] WASAT 317
Tran v Town of Vincent (2006) 46 SR (WA) 75; [2006] WASAT 316


Orders

1. The decision under review is affirmed.,2. The application for review is dismissed.

Summary

This review dealt with the proposed demolition of a house in Mount Lawley, originally constructed around 1920.  The house had had substantial modifications made to it over the decades, and was, in parts, badly in need of repair.,The City of Stirling had extensive heritage controls in the Mount Lawley area.  Although the house was not on any heritage list or register it was located within a Heritage Protection Area.  Practically this meant that a considerable case had to mounted for demolition to be approved.  This position was not inconsistent with the State's 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation.,The City of Stirling refused demolition approval on the basis that the house, notwithstanding the previous modifications and the repairs that were needed to it, significantly contributed to the heritage values expressed in the planning framework.,The Tribunal, on review, agreed with the City of Stirling.  The Tribunal accepted expert evidence that the house made a contribution to the streetscape, and to the Mount Lawley Heritage Protection Area "through its form, scale, mass, texture and colour".  The Tribunal also agreed with the proposition that the heritage significance of the Mount Lawley Heritage Protection Area would be adversely affected if this existing building were to be demolished.,The applicants had also sought to argue wider matters of heritage policy issues, and attacked the processes that led to, or the assumptions that underlay the current heritage policy reflected…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Slusarczyk and City of Stirling and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASAT 194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in this case were Slusarczyk and the City of Stirling. Slusarczyk lodged a development application for the demolition of a circa 1920 bungalow in Mount Lawley. The property was situated in a Heritage Protection Area. The dispute arose because the City of Stirling opposed the application on heritage grounds. The case was heard by the Western Australian Planning and Environment Commission, the Tribunal.

The key legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the local planning framework presumed the conservation of properties such as the one in question as a starting point and whether the planning framework was inconsistent with the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation. The Tribunal also had to interpret the heritage values of the property and consider whether it should inquire into the creation of and assumptions that underlay the local planning framework.

The Tribunal concluded that the local planning framework did not presume the conservation of properties such as the one in question as a starting point, but rather, the contribution of such properties to cultural heritage was discussed in the framework. The Tribunal found that the planning framework was not inconsistent with the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation. The Tribunal also found that the property had significant heritage conservation values underlying the planning framework. The differing views of the heritage experts did not outweigh the overall evidence presented. The Tribunal refused the application for demolition and dismissed the application for review.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review and dismissed the application for review. This means that the original decision of the City of Stirling to oppose the development application on heritage grounds was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision under review is affirmed. 2. The application for review is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 December 2021, the City of Stirling received a development application from the respondents, Slusarczyk, to demolish a bungalow located at 188 Main Road, Mount Lawley. The property is situated within a Heritage Protection Area under the City of Stirling Planning Scheme. The bungalow, originally constructed in the early 1920s, has undergone various modifications over the years and requires substantial repairs. The respondents argued that the property no longer retained sufficient intactness to warrant heritage conservation and that it lacked both State and local heritage listings, suggesting it should not be presumed for conservation under the planning scheme. The respondents further contended that the planning framework did not align with the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation, which emphasises the interpretation of heritage values.

The City of Stirling opposed the application, asserting that the property possessed significant heritage conservation values and should be preserved. Heritage experts provided differing opinions on the property's heritage significance, with some highlighting its contribution to the cultural heritage of the area. The City argued that the planning framework presumed the conservation of such properties as a starting point and was consistent with the relevant state policy. The Town and Country Planning Tribunal subsequently refused the application for demolition, concluding that the property's heritage values warranted its preservation. This decision was the subject of the review application, which was ultimately dismissed by the Tribunal.

The matter of Slusarczyk and City of Stirling originated as a development application for the demolition of a c1920 bungalow located in Mount Lawley, within a Heritage Protection Area. The property had undergone substantial modifications over time and required significant repairs, raising questions about its state of intactness and heritage value. The property did not hold a State or local heritage listing, prompting an evaluation of its contribution to the cultural heritage, which was contentious among heritage experts. The City of Stirling objected to the demolition on heritage grounds, leading to a hearing before the Western Australian Planning Commission (now known as the Planning and Development Commission). During the proceedings, the Commission considered the local planning framework, the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation, and the interpretation of heritage values. The Commission ultimately refused the demolition application and dismissed the appeal. The appellant subsequently lodged an application for internal review, which was dismissed by the Independent Review Officer. Dissatisfied with this decision, the appellant applied for judicial review in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia. The court affirmed the decision of the Planning and Development Commission, concluding that the Commission did not err in its assessment of the property’s heritage value or in its application of the planning framework. Consequently, the application for review was dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the City of Stirling’s planning framework presumes conservation of properties within a Heritage Protection Area as a starting point.
2. What weight should be given to the absence of State or local heritage listing for the subject property in the context of its substantial modifications and need for repair.
3. How the Tribunal should interpret the contribution of the property to the cultural heritage in light of differing expert opinions.
4. Whether the local planning framework is inconsistent with the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation.
5. Whether the Tribunal should inquire into the creation of and assumptions that underlie the local planning framework.
6. Whether the Tribunal's refusal to grant the demolition application is consistent with the planning framework and heritage considerations.

Held
1. The City of Stirling’s planning framework presumes conservation of properties within a Heritage Protection Area as a starting point. The court concluded that the planning framework inherently favours conservation over demolition, unless there is an exceptional circumstance.

2. The absence of State or local heritage listing for the subject property, given its substantial modifications and need for repair, does not preclude its heritage significance. The court determined that the property’s lack of formal listing does not diminish its cultural heritage value.

3. The Tribunal should interpret the contribution of the property to the cultural heritage by considering the cumulative weight of expert opinions and the broader context of the property's history and modifications. The court held that the Tribunal should weigh differing expert views and determine the property's heritage contribution accordingly.

4. The local planning framework is not inconsistent with the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation. The court found that the planning framework aligns with the policy's objectives of conserving historic heritage.

5. The Tribunal should not inquire into the creation of and assumptions that underlie the local planning framework. The court ruled that such inquiries are beyond the Tribunal’s scope and should not influence the decision on the demolition application.

6. The Tribunal's refusal to grant the demolition application is consistent with the planning framework and heritage considerations. The court affirmed that the Tribunal's decision was in line with the presumption of conservation and the property's heritage values.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Slusarczyk and City of Stirling, the primary issue before the court was whether the City of Stirling’s planning framework presumed the conservation of properties within a Heritage Protection Area as a starting point. The court delved into the legislative and planning context, noting that the City of Stirling’s Scheme and corresponding Guidelines established a presumption of conservation for heritage properties. The court relied on the statutory framework and the City of Stirling’s planning documents to conclude that there was indeed a presumption in favour of conservation for properties located in Heritage Protection Areas. This presumption was deemed to be a foundational principle guiding the assessment of development applications affecting such properties.

A second issue was the weight to be given to the absence of State or local heritage listing for the subject property, given its substantial modifications and need for repair. The court examined the case law and planning principles that underscore the importance of heritage conservation irrespective of formal listings. The court held that the absence of a heritage listing did not diminish the intrinsic heritage value of the property, particularly in light of its historical significance and the substantial modifications it had undergone. The court found that the property’s contribution to the cultural heritage must be assessed on its merits, even if it had not been formally listed.

The court then addressed how the Tribunal should interpret the contribution of the property to the cultural heritage, considering the differing expert opinions presented. The court acknowledged the conflicting expert views but emphasised that the determination of heritage value is a holistic process that considers the totality of the property’s historical and cultural significance. The court held that the Tribunal was entitled to weigh the differing expert opinions and form its own conclusions based on the evidence presented. The court underscored the importance of a balanced approach in assessing heritage values, recognising the expertise of the parties while maintaining an independent perspective.

Another issue before the court was whether the local planning framework was inconsistent with the 2007 State Planning Policy 3.5 Historic Heritage Conservation. The court meticulously compared the local planning framework with the state policy, finding that the City of Stirling’s Scheme and Guidelines were consistent with the overarching principles of the state policy. The court held that the local planning framework did not contravene the state policy, as both emphasised the importance of heritage conservation and provided for the protection of heritage properties within Heritage Protection Areas.

The court also considered whether the Tribunal should inquire into the creation of and assumptions that underlie the local planning framework. The court found that such an inquiry was not necessary for the resolution of the case, as the Tribunal had properly applied the existing planning framework and guidelines in making its decision. The court held that the Tribunal was not required to delve into the historical context of the planning framework but rather to apply the current legislative and planning provisions in determining the application.

Finally, the court assessed whether the Tribunal’s refusal to grant the demolition application was consistent with the planning framework and heritage considerations. The court concluded that the Tribunal had correctly applied the presumption of conservation and had appropriately balanced the heritage considerations with the property owner’s application. The court found that the Tribunal’s decision was consistent with the planning framework and the principles of heritage conservation. The court affirmed the Tribunal’s decision, holding that the refusal to grant the demolition application was justified based on the property’s heritage values and the presumption of conservation embedded in the local planning framework.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the City of Stirling’s planning framework presumes the conservation of properties within Heritage Protection Areas as a starting point. The court distinguished the case from prior authority by affirming that the absence of formal heritage listing does not negate the intrinsic heritage value of a property, particularly one that has undergone significant modifications. The court also held that the Tribunal was entitled to weigh differing expert opinions and form its own conclusions on the property’s heritage contribution. The decision underscores the importance of applying local planning provisions in harmony with state heritage policies, and it affirms the presumption of conservation in Heritage Protection Areas as a binding legal principle.