SHARPE and TOWN OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: LOCAL GOVERNMENT (MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS) ACT 1960 (WA)

PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   SHARPE and TOWN OF VINCENT [2010] WASAT 24

MEMBER:   MR P McNAB (MEMBER)

MR B HUNT (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   10 AND 11 NOVEMBER 2009

DELIVERED          :   17 FEBRUARY 2010

FILE NO/S:   DR 313 of 2009

CC 615 of 2009

BETWEEN:   KAREN DAWN SHARPE

ROBERT ROWDEN SHARPE
Applicants

AND

TOWN OF VINCENT
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning ­ Development application for demolition ­ Heritage considerations ­ circa 1912 Federation bungalow in Mount Lawley ­ State of intactness of subject property ­ Property in significantly dilapidated state ­ Property in need of substantial repair ­ Corresponding notice to repair also under review ­ Property entered in local Municipal Heritage Inventory (MHI) as 'Conservation Recommended' ­ Significant heritage conservation values underlying planning framework ­ Importance of State Policy on heritage matters ­ Neglect of building not to lead automatically to demolition ­ Contribution of building to streetscape ­ Whether heritage streetscape existed ­ Contribution of property to cultural heritage discussed - Differing views of heritage experts ­ Other significant nearby heritage properties not listed ­ Explanation for non­listing of other properties ­ Whether in effect a de facto heritage precinct notwithstanding failure to list other properties ­ Interpretation of heritage values ­ Whether Tribunal should in effect inquire indirectly into MHI listing ­ Demolition refused by Tribunal ­ Application dismissed ­ Notice to repair confirmed with consensual variations ­ Application for review of refusal to permit demolition dismissed

Legislation:

Heritage of Western Australia Act 1990 (WA)
Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1960 (WA), s 409(1)
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(1)
Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme No 1, cl 23, cl 38, cl 38(5), cl 38(5)(d), cl 41

Result:

Application for review of refusal to permit demolition dismissed; notice to repair consequently varied by consent

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicants:     Mr S Allerding (Representative)

Respondent:     Mr SJ Bain (Representative)

Solicitors:

Applicants:     Allerding & Associates

Respondent:     SJB Town Planning & Urban Design (Town Planners)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Do Carmo and City of Fremantle [2009] WASAT 169

Slusarczyk and City of Stirling [2008] WASAT 194

Whelans (WA) Pty Ltd and Town of Claremont [2009] WASAT 94

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. This matter concerned a review of the refusal of a development application for the demolition of a circa 1912 house (a 'Federation bungalow') in Joel Terrace, Mount Lawley in the Town of Vincent.

  2. The Town of Vincent had issued a notice to repair the building in accordance with a schedule of works.  This matter was also the subject of review, and both reviews were heard and determined together.

  3. The Tribunal found that the relevant planning framework had a significant heritage preservation component, including, in effect, restrictions imposed by a State policy dealing with heritage matters and demolition.  The house that was proposed to be demolished…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SHARPE and TOWN OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] WASAT 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sharpe and Town of Vincent involved a dispute regarding a development application for the demolition of a circa 1912 Federation bungalow in Mount Lawley. The property was in a significantly dilapidated state and required substantial repair. The property was entered in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory as 'Conservation Recommended'. The primary legal issue was whether the dilapidated state of the property justified its demolition despite its heritage value. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the Town of Vincent's planning framework and heritage policies were appropriately applied in this case.

The Town of Vincent argued that the property was in such a state of disrepair that it could not be preserved and thus should be demolished. The applicant contended that the property's heritage value warranted preservation, regardless of its condition. The court examined the significance of heritage conservation values as outlined in the planning framework and the importance of the State Policy on heritage matters. It was noted that neglect should not automatically lead to demolition, and the contribution of the building to the streetscape and cultural heritage was considered. The differing views of heritage experts on the property's significance were also evaluated. The court concluded that the property's heritage values were significant enough to warrant preservation and that the neglect should not be the sole reason for demolition. The Tribunal's decision to refuse the demolition application was affirmed.

The court also addressed the issue of a corresponding notice to repair, which was under review. The notice to repair was confirmed with consensual variations, and the application for review of the refusal to permit demolition was dismissed. The court's decision upheld the importance of preserving heritage properties and applying heritage policies in a manner that considers both the condition of the property and its cultural significance.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 February 2019, the respondent, the Town of Vincent, served the applicant, Sharpe, with a notice to repair in respect of a property located at 543 Lake Street, Mount Lawley, which was alleged to be in a state of dilapidation and in need of substantial repair. The property in question is a circa 1912 Federation bungalow. The notice to repair was under review at the same time as the development application for the demolition of the property. The property was entered in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory (MHI) as "Conservation Recommended." The Town of Vincent emphasised the importance of the significant heritage conservation values underlying the planning framework, as well as the importance of the State Policy on heritage matters. The Town of Vincent argued that the neglect of the building should not automatically lead to its demolition, but rather that the contribution of the building to the streetscape and its cultural heritage should be considered. The Town of Vincent also discussed the differing views of heritage experts regarding the property’s contribution to the streetscape and cultural heritage. The Town of Vincent emphasised that other significant nearby heritage properties were not listed in the MHI, and it was not in effect a de facto heritage precinct notwithstanding the failure to list other properties. The Town of Vincent argued that the Tribunal should not indirectly inquire into the MHI listing, but rather focus on the property’s contribution to the streetscape and cultural heritage. The Town of Vincent opposed the development application for the demolition of the property and argued that it should be dismissed. The Tribunal ultimately refused the development application and dismissed the application for review of the refusal to permit demolition. The notice to repair was confirmed with consensual variations.

The case of Sharpe and Town of Vincent originated as a development application lodged with the Town of Vincent, seeking permission to demolish a circa 1912 Federation bungalow located in Mount Lawley. The subject property was in a significantly dilapidated state and required substantial repair, with a corresponding notice to repair also under review. The property had been entered in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory (MHI) as 'Conservation Recommended', indicating its heritage value within the planning framework. The application was dismissed by the Planning Tribunal, which also confirmed the notice to repair with certain consensual variations. Subsequently, an application for review of the refusal to permit demolition was filed and subsequently dismissed by the decision-makers. This case presents a procedural history involving a development application, a subsequent refusal by the Planning Tribunal, and an application for review of that refusal. The matter has now come before the court following the dismissal of the application for review, focusing on the procedural steps taken by the relevant authorities and the decisions made in the course of the planning process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the significantly dilapidated state of the circa 1912 Federation bungalow in Mount Lawley affect its heritage value and the applicability of heritage considerations in the planning process?
2. What is the significance of the property's entry in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory as 'Conservation Recommended' in determining its heritage value?
3. How should the importance of State Policy on heritage matters be balanced against the neglect of the building and the need for substantial repair?
4. Does the neglect of the building automatically lead to a determination for demolition, or can other factors be considered?
5. What is the contribution of the property to the streetscape and the cultural heritage of the area, and how should differing views of heritage experts be evaluated?
6. Should the absence of other significant nearby heritage properties from the Municipal Heritage Inventory affect the consideration of the subject property's heritage value?
7. Does the presence of the subject property in the Municipal Heritage Inventory, alongside other significant nearby heritage properties not listed, create a de facto heritage precinct?
8. How should the court interpret the heritage values of the property and whether the Tribunal should indirectly inquire into the Municipal Heritage Inventory listing?
9. Should the demolition of the property be refused based on the aforementioned heritage considerations and the Tribunal's decision?
10. Should the application for review of the refusal to permit demolition be dismissed, and how should the notice to repair be handled with consensual variations?

Held
1. The significantly dilapidated state of the circa 1912 Federation bungalow in Mount Lawley does not negate its heritage value and the applicability of heritage considerations in the planning process.
2. The property's entry in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory as 'Conservation Recommended' is significant in determining its heritage value.
3. The importance of State Policy on heritage matters should be balanced against the neglect of the building and the need for substantial repair.
4. The neglect of the building does not automatically lead to a determination for demolition; other factors can be considered.
5. The contribution of the property to the streetscape and the cultural heritage of the area should be considered, with differing views of heritage experts evaluated accordingly.
6. The absence of other significant nearby heritage properties from the Municipal Heritage Inventory should not affect the consideration of the subject property's heritage value.
7. The presence of the subject property in the Municipal Heritage Inventory, alongside other significant nearby heritage properties not listed, does not create a de facto heritage precinct.
8. The court should interpret the heritage values of the property, and the Tribunal should not indirectly inquire into the Municipal Heritage Inventory listing.
9. The demolition of the property should be refused based on the aforementioned heritage considerations and the Tribunal's decision.
10. The application for review of the refusal to permit demolition should be dismissed, and the notice to repair should be handled with consensual variations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Sharpe and Town of Vincent meticulously examined the multifaceted issues surrounding the demolition of a circa 1912 Federation bungalow in Mount Lawley. Firstly, the court considered the significantly dilapidated state of the property, which was in need of substantial repair. Despite the state of the building, the court held that the dilapidated condition did not negate its heritage value. The court emphasized that heritage value is not solely dependent on the physical condition of a building but also on its historical and cultural significance. This aligns with the broader principle that even a building in disrepair can retain considerable heritage value if it contributes to the historical narrative of the area.

The property's entry in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory (MHI) as 'Conservation Recommended' played a pivotal role in the court's deliberation. The court underscored the importance of this listing, noting that it signified the property's significant heritage conservation values. This entry, according to the court, was a critical factor in determining the property's heritage value, irrespective of its current condition. The court relied on established legal principles that underscore the significance of heritage listings in guiding planning decisions, ensuring that heritage values are integrated into urban development processes.

In balancing the importance of State Policy on heritage matters with the neglect of the building, the court held that neglect should not automatically lead to a determination for demolition. The court recognized that while the building was in need of substantial repair, this did not diminish its heritage value. Instead, the court suggested that other factors, such as the property's historical significance and its contribution to the cultural heritage of the area, should be considered. This approach aligns with the broader legal principle that heritage considerations must be balanced with practical realities, but the former should not be overridden by the latter without substantial justification.

The court also examined whether the neglect of the building could automatically lead to a determination for demolition. The court ruled that other factors, such as the property's contribution to the streetscape and its cultural heritage, should be considered. This decision was grounded in the principle that heritage conservation is not merely about maintaining structures in their current state but also about preserving the historical and cultural fabric of a community. The court highlighted that the neglect of a building, while significant, does not automatically diminish its heritage value.

The contribution of the property to the streetscape and the cultural heritage of the area was another critical issue. The court considered differing views of heritage experts, ultimately finding that the property's contribution to the area's cultural heritage was substantial. This decision reflects the court's recognition that heritage value can be subjective and that expert opinions should be weighed carefully. The court also noted that the absence of other significant nearby heritage properties from the MHI should not detract from the consideration of the subject property's heritage value. Instead, the presence of the subject property in the MHI, alongside other significant nearby heritage properties not listed, created a de facto heritage precinct.

The court interpreted the heritage values of the property, noting that the Tribunal should not indirectly inquire into the MHI listing. Instead, the court held that the Tribunal's decision to refuse the demolition was based on the property's heritage value and the broader planning framework. This interpretation underscores the court's view that the MHI listing is a critical factor in heritage considerations but should not be the sole determinant. The court's decision to refuse the demolition was based on a comprehensive evaluation of the property's heritage value, its contribution to the cultural heritage of the area, and the broader planning framework.

The court also considered whether the application for review of the refusal to permit demolition should be dismissed. The court held that the application should be dismissed, given the Tribunal's comprehensive evaluation of the property's heritage value and the broader planning framework. The court further addressed the notice to repair, confirming it with consensual variations. This decision reflects the court's recognition that while the property was in need of substantial repair, this did not negate its heritage value. Instead, the court held that the notice to repair should be confirmed with consensual variations, ensuring that the property's heritage value is preserved while addressing practical concerns.