Hobbs and Town of Vincent

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   HOBBS and TOWN OF VINCENT [2009] WASAT 167

MEMBER:   MR P McNAB (MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   24 AUGUST 2009

FILE NO/S:   DR 442 of 2008

BETWEEN:   CATHERINE MARY  HOBBS

Applicant

AND

TOWN OF VINCENT
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application for retrospective approval - Proposal for substantial lattice or trellis extension to existing front wall - Heritage considerations - Group of four adjoining three storey terrace houses built in 1897 - Considered as rare and distinctive examples of the 'Federation Filigree' style - Properties subject to recent Ministerial Conservation Order - Property entered in local Municipal Heritage Inventory - Property classified by local authority as 'Conservation Essential' - Substantial contribution of property to cultural heritage - Siginificant heritage conservation values underlying planning framework of Town - Hierarchy of planning instruments discussed in such circumstances ­ Whether security or privacy concerns could displace heritage concerns - No expert evidence called in rebuttal by applicant ­ Development clearly inconsistent with desired sub­precinct streetscape and heritage style ­ Development would neither respect nor enhance the heritage significance of the place - Tribunal acknowledging burden on owner by reason of heritage development controls - Tribunal refused approval - Application dismissed

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA)
Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme No 1

Result:

Application for review dismissed and decision under review affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Ms T Woodhouse (Acting as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Town of Vincent

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Filton Pty Ltd and Town of Vincent [2006] WASAT 70

Miktad Holdings Pty Ltd and City of South Perth [2009] WASAT 77

Moslem Alawy Society Ltd v Canterbury Municipal Council (1983) 51 LGRA 79

Optus Mobile Pty Ltd and Town of Vincent [2006] WASAT 179

Slusarczyk and City of Stirling [2008] WASAT 194

Tooth v City of Subiaco [2005] WASAT 317; (2005) 41 SR (WA) 198

Tran v Town of Vincent (2006) 46 SR (WA) 75; [2006] WASAT 316

Truong and East Perth Redevelopment Authority [2008] WASAT 283

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. This review dealt with a proposal to add a lattice or trellis extension to a solid front wall on a heritage property in Perth.  The property was one of four adjoining three storey terrace houses built in 1897.  The application sought retrospective planning approval.

  2. The heritage significance of the property was substantial.  The Tribunal accepted that the property was a 'rare and highly distinctive' example of the 'Federation Filigree' style, and was a site 'nationally acknowledged [as a] work of excellence'.  The Town of Vincent had previously rated the property as 'Conservation Essential'.  Moreover, the property had previously been interim listed on the State Register of Heritage Places, and was currently the subject of a ministerial Conservation Order.

  3. The Town of Vincent had refused planning approval on various bases but the Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hobbs and Town of Vincent and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASAT 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Hobbs and the Town of Vincent arose from an application for retrospective approval of a proposed lattice or trellis extension to the front wall of a terrace house in Vincent. The proposed development was considered inconsistent with the desired streetscape and heritage style of the area. The local authority had classified the property as 'conservation essential' due to its significant contribution to the cultural heritage and its classification in the Municipal Heritage Inventory. The Town opposed the development on the basis that it would diminish the heritage significance of the property. The applicant did not call any expert evidence in rebuttal.

The legal issues before the court included whether security or privacy concerns could override the requirements to preserve the heritage value of the property. The court needed to consider the hierarchy of planning instruments, including the Ministerial Conservation Order and the local authority's classification of the property. The court also had to assess whether the proposed development respected and enhanced the heritage significance of the property.

The court held that the proposed development was inconsistent with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style, and would not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place. The court acknowledged the burden on the owner due to the heritage development controls but found that the proposed development did not meet the necessary standards. The court dismissed the application and affirmed the decision of the local authority. The court emphasised that the proposed lattice work did not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the property, and that the existing solid brick wall had already diminished the authenticity and aesthetic value of the property.

The final orders of the court were that the application for review was dismissed, and the decision under review was affirmed. The proposed development was not approved, and the property remained subject to the heritage development controls.

Orders

Orders of the court

For the reasons set out above, the Tribunal orders that: 1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The decision under review is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In Richard Apperly, et al, A pictorial guide to identifying Australian architecture: styles and terms from 1788 to the present, Angus & Robertson, 1989, the following matters relating to this style are noted, at page 111 (emphasis added):BackgroundContinued mass-production of cheap decorative cast-iron components and machine-processed timber decoration. Decorative components more commonly made in Australia than imported. Extension of Australian veranda tradition Broad CharacteristicsIntricately textured veranda screen designed to stand proud of the mass of the main building gave a filigree character. Machine-turned and band sawn timber decoration abounded. Filigreed veranda often became exterior rooms. The style became part of the veranda'd Australian pub tradition …Exterior RelationshipsMasonry form of the building usually decorated with classical, medieval or Italianate detailing … Most of the façade concealed by decorative filigree. Filigree divided into bays by slender timber or iron columns. Loggia and colonnade interpreted in filigree … Art Nouveau motifs commonly appeared in both timber and iron decoration … In hot-climate areas, louvres and lattice often constituted the filigree …Structure and ConstructionHeavy load-bearing quality complemented by the lightness of filigree.Other QualitiesEnveloping lace-like veil provided deep shading, yet encouraged air circulation. Interestingly, the lattice work connected with this style (which is similar in appearance to what is proposed here) and is identified in this standard reference work, is confined to 'hot, humid, coastal areas' of Australia, with an emphasis on the lattice additions providing both decoration and ventilation to verandas: see above, and page 108. These views are consistent with the expert opinions offered by the Town. In October 2008, a 'Heritage Impact Statement' was prepared by the Town's Heritage Officer (Hoping Au) in connection with Ms Hobbs' application for planning approval. That assessment includes the following observations of the subject property:The terraces are setback approximately 6 metres from the footpath by a low pillared brick rendered fence with mesh above, the exception being the subject property whereby a solid brick wall has been constructed above the original low rendered portion, making the existing brick wall to a height of approximately 1.8 metres. All four terraces have maintained the rendered pillars capped with stucco and corbelled detail. The two central terraces have retained their galvanized tube framed gates with spring catches, the subject property at No. 241 being replaced with a timber picket gate and No. 235 has a new steel gate made to appear as wrought iron. The conclusion of the Heritage Officer was as follows:The proposal comprising the addition of the lattice work above the solid brick wall fence of the subject property does not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place. Already the construction of the solid brick fence has served to diminish the authenticity of the property and inhibit the overall aesthetic value of the four terraces, and thus a further addition to increase the height of the fence is not considered appropriate.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the proposed lattice or trellis extension to the front wall of the property comply with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style?
2. Would the proposed lattice or trellis extension respect and enhance the heritage significance of the place?
3. Can security or privacy concerns override the heritage conservation values in this case?
4. Does the substantial contribution of the property to cultural heritage and the classification by the local authority as 'Conservation Essential' affect the decision on the proposed extension?
5. How does the hierarchy of planning instruments apply in cases where there are conflicting interests between development and heritage conservation?
6. Was there sufficient evidence presented by the applicant to rebut the Town's expert opinions regarding the heritage impact of the proposed extension?
7. What is the appropriate balance between the burden on the property owner due to heritage development controls and the preservation of cultural heritage values?

Held
1. The proposed lattice or trellis extension to the front wall of the property does not comply with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style. The court concluded that the development was clearly inconsistent with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style.

2. The proposed lattice or trellis extension would neither respect nor enhance the heritage significance of the place. The court found that the development would not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place.

3. Security or privacy concerns cannot override the heritage conservation values in this case. The court concluded that security or privacy concerns could not displace heritage concerns.

4. The substantial contribution of the property to cultural heritage and the classification by the local authority as 'Conservation Essential' affects the decision on the proposed extension. The court acknowledged the substantial contribution of the property to cultural heritage and its classification by the local authority as 'Conservation Essential'.

5. The hierarchy of planning instruments applies in cases where there are conflicting interests between development and heritage conservation. The court discussed the hierarchy of planning instruments and their application in such circumstances.

6. There was insufficient evidence presented by the applicant to rebut the Town's expert opinions regarding the heritage impact of the proposed extension. The court found that no expert evidence was called in rebuttal by the applicant.

7. The appropriate balance between the burden on the property owner due to heritage development controls and the preservation of cultural heritage values was upheld by the court. The court acknowledged the burden on the owner due to heritage development controls while emphasizing the preservation of cultural heritage values.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Hobbs and Town of Vincent, the Central Planning Authority (CPA) Tribunal dismissed the applicant's application for retrospective approval of a proposed lattice or trellis extension to the front wall of her property, a four-storey terrace house built in 1897. The property is part of a group of four adjoining terrace houses, considered as rare and distinctive examples of the 'Federation Filigree' style. The tribunal's decision was grounded in several key issues, primarily focusing on the compliance of the proposed development with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style, the enhancement of the property's heritage significance, and the hierarchy of planning instruments in cases of conflicting interests between development and heritage conservation.

The tribunal began by examining whether the proposed lattice or trellis extension complied with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style. The tribunal noted that the property, along with its neighbours, was subject to a recent Ministerial Conservation Order and was entered in the local Municipal Heritage Inventory. Furthermore, the property was classified by the local authority as 'Conservation Essential', indicating its substantial contribution to cultural heritage. The tribunal relied on the expert opinion of the Town's Heritage Officer, Hoping Au, who prepared a 'Heritage Impact Statement' in October 2008. The officer concluded that the proposed addition of lattice work above the solid brick wall fence would not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place, as it would further diminish the authenticity of the property and inhibit the overall aesthetic value of the four terraces. This conclusion was supported by the reference work "A pictorial guide to identifying Australian architecture: styles and terms from 1788 to the present", which indicated that lattice work was typically confined to 'hot, humid, coastal areas' of Australia, a description that did not align with the proposed development's location.

The tribunal also considered whether the proposed lattice or trellis extension would respect and enhance the heritage significance of the place. The tribunal agreed with the Heritage Officer's assessment that the proposed development would not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place. The tribunal emphasized that the proposed addition of lattice work above the solid brick wall fence would further diminish the authenticity of the property and inhibit the overall aesthetic value of the four terraces. The tribunal further noted that the applicant had not presented any expert evidence in rebuttal of the Town's expert opinions regarding the heritage impact of the proposed extension.

In addressing the issue of whether security or privacy concerns could override the heritage conservation values in this case, the tribunal found that the proposed development was clearly inconsistent with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style. The tribunal held that the proposed lattice or trellis extension would not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place, and thus, security or privacy concerns could not displace the heritage concerns in this case.

The tribunal also considered the hierarchy of planning instruments in cases where there are conflicting interests between development and heritage conservation. The tribunal acknowledged the substantial contribution of the property to cultural heritage and its classification by the local authority as 'Conservation Essential'. However, the tribunal held that the proposed development was clearly inconsistent with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style, and thus, the interests of heritage conservation took precedence over the applicant's security or privacy concerns.

In conclusion, the tribunal found that the proposed lattice or trellis extension to the front wall of the property was not in compliance with the desired sub-precinct streetscape and heritage style, would not respect or enhance the heritage significance of the place, and that security or privacy concerns could not override the heritage conservation values in this case. The tribunal also considered the hierarchy of planning instruments and held that the interests of heritage conservation took precedence over the applicant's security or privacy concerns. The tribunal refused approval of the proposed development and dismissed the application. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases where there are conflicting interests between development and heritage conservation, the interests of heritage conservation take precedence, particularly where the property is classified as 'Conservation Essential' and has a substantial contribution to cultural heritage.