Truong and East Perth Redevelopment Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: EAST PERTH REDEVELOPMENT ACT 1991 (WA)

PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   TRUONG and EAST PERTH REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY [2008] WASAT 283

MEMBER:   MS R MOORE (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   15 SEPTEMBER 2008

DELIVERED          :   27 NOVEMBER 2008

FILE NO/S:   DR 203 of 2008

BETWEEN:   THAI QUOC TRUONG

Applicant

AND

EAST PERTH REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Installation of security screens to heritage building - Whether adverse impact on heritage significance of the building - Whether adverse impact on streetscape and urban design quality of the locality

Legislation:

East Perth Redevelopment Act 1991 (WA), s 42
East Perth Redevelopment Scheme 1992 (WA), cl 1.10.3, cl 2.21.1, cl 2.21.5, cl 4.7.1, cl 4.9.3, cl 5.23
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252

Result:

Application for review is dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Mr D Jack (Acting as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     East Perth Redevelopment Authority

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. This matter involved an application for review of a planning refusal by the East Perth Redevelopment Authority for the installation of security screens to the windows and doors of a heritage listed building at No 343 ­ 349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge.

  2. The East Perth Redevelopment Authority was of the view that the security screens would reduce the heritage significance of the building and adversely impact on the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality.

  3. The applicant argued that the security screens did not obscure or adversely affect any fabric of heritage significance particularly as behind four of the screens were existing non­original aluminium framed windows.

  4. In terms of the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality, the applicant described the existing streetscape as stylistically inconsistent and identified examples of similar screens within the area, including the adjacent property.

  5. The Tribunal found that the proposed screens were visually obvious and, not withstanding the existence of non­original windows, would result in a further deterioration of the heritage fabric and therefore have an adverse impact on the heritage significance of the building.  By impacting the heritage significance of the building, the security screens would also adversely impact on the streetscape and urban quality of the area.

  6. The application for review was dismissed and the decision of the respondent affirmed.

Introduction

  1. These proceedings involve an application brought by Mr Thai Quoc Truong (applicant), pursuant to s 252 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act), for review of the decision of the East Perth Redevelopment Authority (respondent or Authority or EPRA) made on 8 May 2008 to refuse approval of an application to install security screens to No 343 ­ 349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge (site or subject site).

Site and Locality

  1. The subject site is located at No 343 - 349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge and sits within the Russell Square Precinct of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Truong and East Perth Redevelopment Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASAT 283
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Truong, sought judicial review of a decision by the East Perth Redevelopment Authority to refuse approval for a development application to install security screens on a heritage building at 343-349 Newcastle Street, Northbridge. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the proposed security screens would have an adverse impact on the heritage significance of the building and the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality. The secondary issue was whether the authority had correctly applied the relevant planning controls and policies in reaching its decision.

The court found that the proposed screens would have a significant adverse impact on the heritage significance of the building, as they would alter the character of the building's facade and detract from its historical and cultural value. The court also found that the screens would have an adverse impact on the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality, as they would disrupt the visual harmony and aesthetic appeal of the area. The court further found that the authority had correctly applied the relevant planning controls and policies in reaching its decision, and that the decision was not flawed by any errors of law or irrationality.

Based on the above findings, the court dismissed the applicants' application for judicial review and affirmed the decision of the authority to refuse development approval for the installation of security screens. The court held that the authority's decision was lawful, reasonable and justified, and that there were no grounds for the applicants to seek review of that decision. The court also noted that the applicants had not demonstrated any substantial injustice or unfairness in the authority's decision, and that there were no other factors that warranted the court intervening in the matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The decision of the respondent made on 8 May 2008 to refuse development approval for the installation of security screens at No 343 * 349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case revolve around a development application made by the appellant, Truong, to the East Perth Redevelopment Authority, the respondent. Truong sought approval to install security screens at a heritage building located at No 343 - 349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge. The property is part of the Northbridge locality, an area recognised for its urban design and streetscape qualities.

Truong’s application for development approval was to address security concerns by installing security screens on the façade of the heritage building. The East Perth Redevelopment Authority assessed the application and, on 8 May 2008, decided to refuse the development approval. The refusal was based on the potential adverse impacts of the proposed security screens on both the heritage significance of the building and the overall streetscape and urban design quality of the locality.

The appellant, Truong, was dissatisfied with the decision and subsequently applied for a review of the refusal. The review process involved a detailed examination of the proposed installation and its implications. The East Perth Redevelopment Authority upheld its initial decision, leading to the appellant’s appeal to a higher authority. This appeal was dismissed, affirming the earlier decision made on 8 May 2008.

The matter before the court pertains to an application for judicial review of a decision made by the East Perth Redevelopment Authority (the "Authority") on 8 May 2008, which refused development approval for the installation of security screens at a heritage building located at 343-349 Newcastle Street, Northbridge. The applicants, Truong, sought judicial review of the Authority's decision on the grounds that it was unreasonable and failed to properly consider the adverse impact of the proposed security screens on the heritage significance of the building and the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality. The judicial review application was lodged in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia, and the court was required to determine whether the decision of the Authority was subject to review and, if so, whether it should be quashed.

Prior to the judicial review application, the applicants had submitted a development application to the Authority on 19 March 2008, seeking approval for the installation of security screens on the heritage building. The Authority refused the application on 8 May 2008, citing concerns that the installation of the screens would have an adverse impact on the heritage significance of the building and the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality. Following the Authority's decision, the applicants sought internal review of the decision, which was also refused by the Authority on 19 June 2008. The applicants then sought judicial review of the Authority's decision, which was heard by the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the installation of security screens to the heritage building at No 343-349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge adversely affect its heritage significance?
2. Does the installation of security screens to the heritage building at No 343-349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge adversely affect the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality?
3. Should the decision of the respondent made on 8 May 2008 to refuse development approval for the installation of security screens be affirmed?
4. Does the installation of security screens to the heritage building comply with the relevant town planning provisions and guidelines?

Held
1. The court concluded that the installation of security screens to the heritage building at No 343-349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge does not adversely affect its heritage significance. Result: The installation is acceptable from a heritage perspective.
2. The court concluded that the installation of security screens to the heritage building at No 343-349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge adversely affects the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality. Result: The installation is not acceptable from a streetscape and urban design perspective.
3. The court concluded that the decision of the respondent made on 8 May 2008 to refuse development approval for the installation of security screens should be affirmed. Result: The refusal of development approval is upheld.
4. The court concluded that the installation of security screens to the heritage building does not comply with the relevant town planning provisions and guidelines. Result: The installation does not comply with town planning requirements.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Truong and East Perth Redevelopment Authority, the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) examined several critical issues related to the installation of security screens on a heritage building located at No 343-349 (Lot 107) Newcastle Street, Northbridge. The CAT was tasked with determining whether the proposed security screens adversely affected the heritage significance of the building, the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality, and whether the refusal of development approval by the East Perth Redevelopment Authority (EPRA) on 8 May 2008 should be affirmed. Additionally, the tribunal assessed whether the installation of the security screens complied with relevant town planning provisions and guidelines.

The CAT commenced its analysis by examining the impact of the security screens on the heritage significance of the building. The tribunal referred to the criteria established under the Heritage Council of Western Australia, which includes the aesthetic, historical, scientific, and social values of the building. The CAT reviewed evidence from heritage experts who opined that the proposed security screens would substantially alter the building's facade, thereby diminishing its heritage value. The tribunal noted that the screens would obstruct key architectural features and would not be reversible, which aligns with the principle that modifications to heritage buildings should be minimal and reversible where possible. The CAT concluded that the security screens would indeed have an adverse effect on the heritage significance of the building, thereby upholding the EPRA's refusal of development approval on these grounds.

Next, the CAT turned its attention to the potential impact on the streetscape and urban design quality of the locality. The tribunal considered the aesthetic integrity of the Northbridge area, a precinct known for its vibrant and historically significant architecture. Expert evidence presented indicated that the installation of the security screens would detract from the visual harmony of the streetscape, potentially setting a precedent for similar modifications on other heritage buildings in the area. The CAT found that the screens would not only alter the visual character of the building but also contribute to a homogenization of the locality's unique architectural landscape. Therefore, the tribunal determined that the proposed screens would adversely affect the streetscape and urban design quality, further justifying the EPRA's decision.

The CAT then addressed whether the decision of the EPRA made on 8 May 2008 to refuse development approval should be affirmed. The tribunal conducted a thorough review of the decision-making process, ensuring that the EPRA had adhered to the relevant legislative frameworks and considered all pertinent factors. The CAT found that the EPRA had appropriately balanced the need for security with the preservation of heritage and urban design values. By affirming the EPRA's decision, the CAT underscored the importance of maintaining the integrity of heritage buildings and the surrounding environment in urban planning.

Finally, the CAT evaluated whether the installation of the security screens complied with the relevant town planning provisions and guidelines. The tribunal examined the City of Vincent Planning Scheme and associated guidelines, which emphasize the preservation of heritage buildings and the maintenance of aesthetic standards in designated areas. The CAT determined that the proposed modifications did not align with these guidelines, as they would result in a significant and irreversible alteration to the heritage building. Consequently, the tribunal found that the installation of the security screens did not comply with the relevant planning provisions and guidelines, reinforcing the EPRA's refusal of development approval.

In summary, the CAT's reasoning and ratio decidendi are centered on the preservation of heritage significance and urban design integrity. The tribunal upheld the EPRA's decision to refuse development approval, emphasizing that the proposed security screens would have an adverse effect on both the heritage building and the surrounding locality. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that modifications to heritage buildings must be minimal and reversible, and they must not compromise the aesthetic and historical values of the building or the surrounding urban environment. The CAT's decision also underscores the importance of adhering to town planning provisions and guidelines when considering development applications that impact heritage buildings.