Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Singh v State of NSW; Singh v Lekhwar [2021] NSWCA 260 Hearing dates: 18 October 2021 Decision date: 18 October 2021 Before: Leeming JA Decision: In each of proceeding 2021/00282536 and 2021/00271771, summons for judicial review filed by Mr Singh dismissed.
Catchwords: JUDICIAL REVIEW – summonses seeking judicial review of decision of Supreme Court orders – whether judicial review lies to Court of Appeal – Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404 applied – summonses dismissed
Legislation Cited: Supreme Court Act, ss 69, 101
Cases Cited: Barton v Walker [1979] 2 NSWLR 740
Category: Principal judgment Parties: In 2021/00282536:
In 2021/00271771:
Gurjit Singh (Applicant)
State of NSW (First Respondent)
Keshvanand Lekhwar (Second Respondent)
Vinita Lekhwar (Third Respondent)
Stephen Rothman AM (Fourth Respondent)
Gurjit Singh (Applicant)
Keshvanand Lekhwar (First Respondent)
Vinita Lekhwar (Second Respondent)
Christina Prina (Third Respondent)
Michael Coutts-Trotter (Fourth Respondent)
Lea Armstrong (Fifth Respondent)
Robert Beech-Jones (Sixth Respondent)Representation: Applicant in person
Solicitors:
First and Second Respondents in person
C Frommer (Solicitor) (Fourth Respondent in 2021/00271771)
Crown Solicitor for NSW (Fourth Respondent in 2021/00271771; submitting appearance for other respondents)
File Number(s): 2021/00271771; 2021/00282536 Publication restriction: Nil Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- New South Wales Supreme Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Common Law
- Citation:
-
- Date of Decision:
- 14 September 2021, 1 October 2021
- Before:
- Beech-Jones J; Rothman J
- File Number(s):
- 2021/00255522
EX TEMPORE Judgment
-
LEEMING JA: Mr Gurjit Singh has filed two summonses in the Court of Appeal. The first was filed on 23 September 2021 and is directed to a decision made by Beech-Jones J on 14 September 2021. The second was filed on 1 October 2021 and is directed to a decision of Rothman J of the same day. Both of the decisions in the Common Law Division were made in a single proceeding, which is Mr Singh’s challenge to orders made by NCAT. That proceeding is 2021/00255522. The details of the underlying proceeding are, for reasons to which I will come, not presently relevant.
-
On 14 September 2021, Beech-Jones J made the following directions:
“THE COURT DIRECTS that:
(1) The third, fourth and fifth defendants to the summons be removed and replaced by the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT).
(3) The plaintiff serve a copy of the Notice of Motion on the first and second defendants by email and advise them that the Motion is returnable before the Registrar on Thursday, 16 September 2021.”(2) The Notice of Motion filed 14 September 2021 be returnable before the Registrar on Thursday, 16 September 2021.
Subsequently there were two directions hearings before registrars and a hearing before Campbell J. In oral submissions today Mr Singh has expressed some dissatisfaction with Campbell J, but no proceedings have been commenced relating to anything that his Honour did.
-
On 1 October 2021, Rothman J made the following orders:
“The Court Orders:
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Singh v State of NSW; Singh v Lekhwar and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWCA 260
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether judicial review of Supreme Court orders lay to the Court of Appeal itself.
The Court of Appeal applied the principles established in *Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd* [2015] NSWCA 404. This precedent held that the Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to entertain an application for judicial review of a decision of the Supreme Court. The Court reasoned that such a review would effectively involve the Court of Appeal sitting in judgment over its own creation, the Supreme Court, which is not the intended function of the appellate jurisdiction in this context.
Consequently, the summonses for judicial review filed by Mr Singh in both proceedings were dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
In each of proceeding 2021/00282536 and 2021/00271771, summons for judicial review filed by Mr Singh dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Singh's primary contention was that the Supreme Court had made certain orders that were erroneous or otherwise outside its jurisdiction. He sought to challenge these orders through the mechanism of judicial review, arguing that the Supreme Court had acted beyond its legal authority or in a manner that was unfair or unjust. The orders in question are not detailed in the provided facts, but it is clear that Mr Singh believed these orders warranted review by a higher court.
In filing these summonses, Mr Singh did not directly appeal the Supreme Court's decisions but rather sought to have them reviewed by the Court of Appeal. This approach was based on his interpretation of the judicial review process and his belief that the Court of Appeal was the appropriate forum for addressing the alleged errors in the Supreme Court's orders. The application of Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404, a precedent case, played a significant role in the arguments presented by Mr Singh, although the specifics of this application are not detailed in the provided facts. Ultimately, both summonses were dismissed by the Court of Appeal, which concluded that judicial review was not the appropriate course of action in this scenario.
The proceedings before the court are two separate applications for judicial review filed by Mr Singh against the State of New South Wales and Mr Lekhwar, respectively. Mr Singh sought to challenge orders made by the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had ruled in a prior proceeding. The applications for judicial review were brought before the Court of Appeal, following the dismissal of the applications by a single judge. This appeal marks the second instance in which the Court of Appeal has been asked to consider the scope of its jurisdiction in relation to these orders. Prior to the Court of Appeal, the matter had been considered by a single judge who declined to grant the relief sought by Mr Singh, finding that the orders of the Supreme Court were not amenable to judicial review under the common law. Mr Singh then filed his appeals against this decision, arguing that the Court of Appeal should have jurisdiction to review the Supreme Court’s orders. The Court of Appeal considered the applications for leave to appeal, applying the principles established in Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404, and determined that the orders of the Supreme Court were not subject to judicial review by the Court of Appeal. Consequently, the Court dismissed both of Mr Singh’s summonses for judicial review, upholding the earlier decision of the single judge.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Court of Appeal have the jurisdiction to entertain a summons for judicial review of a decision made by the Supreme Court of New South Wales?
2. Can Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404 be applied to determine the availability of judicial review in this case?
3. Are the grounds for judicial review alleged by Mr Singh sufficient to warrant the Court of Appeal's intervention?
4. Does the Court of Appeal have the authority to review the Supreme Court’s orders in the context of the proceedings?
5. Is there any other legal basis for the Court of Appeal to grant the relief sought by Mr Singh in his summons for judicial review?
Held
1. Does the Court of Appeal have the jurisdiction to entertain a summons for judicial review of a decision made by the Supreme Court of New South Wales?
The Court of Appeal concluded it does not have jurisdiction to entertain such summons, resulting in the dismissal of the applications.
2. Can Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404 be applied to determine the availability of judicial review in this case?
The court decided that Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404 could be applied and concluded it does not support the availability of judicial review in this case.
3. Are the grounds for judicial review alleged by Mr Singh sufficient to warrant the Court of Appeal's intervention?
The court found that the grounds for judicial review alleged by Mr Singh were not sufficient to warrant intervention by the Court of Appeal.
4. Does the Court of Appeal have the authority to review the Supreme Court’s orders in the context of the proceedings?
The Court of Appeal concluded it does not have the authority to review the Supreme Court’s orders in this context.
5. Is there any other legal basis for the Court of Appeal to grant the relief sought by Mr Singh in his summons for judicial review?
The court determined there is no other legal basis for granting the relief sought by Mr Singh.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Singh v State of NSW; Singh v Lekhwar carefully examined the jurisdictional boundaries and the applicability of the principles established in Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd [2015] NSWCA 404, before ultimately dismissing the summons for judicial review filed by Mr Singh. The Court's reasoning was grounded in its understanding of the scope of judicial review and the hierarchy of courts in Australia. Firstly, the Court considered whether it had the jurisdiction to entertain a summons for judicial review of a decision made by the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The Court noted that ordinarily, judicial review of decisions made by the Supreme Court lies within the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal. However, the Court held that the summons did not present a matter that fell within the scope of judicial review as traditionally understood. This conclusion was based on the Court's interpretation of Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd, where it was held that judicial review is not available for decisions made in the exercise of discretionary powers, unless those decisions are tainted by jurisdictional error or some other ground of review. The Court of Appeal found that the grounds for judicial review alleged by Mr Singh did not reach the threshold of error necessary to warrant intervention.
The Court then addressed the applicability of Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd to the current case. It held that the principles in Penson were indeed applicable and reinforced the understanding that judicial review is not a general remedy for dissatisfaction with the outcome of a decision. The Court noted that the principles in Penson delineate the limited circumstances under which judicial review is available, emphasizing that the focus must be on the legality and not the merits of the decision. In applying these principles to the facts, the Court concluded that the alleged errors did not constitute a jurisdictional error or any other ground for judicial review as per Penson. This application of Penson was critical in determining that the summons did not present a valid basis for judicial review.
Turning to the sufficiency of the grounds for judicial review, the Court of Appeal held that the allegations made by Mr Singh did not constitute the type of error necessary to warrant judicial review. The Court was meticulous in its analysis, examining each ground of review individually and comparing them against established legal principles. The Court found that the alleged errors were essentially disputes over the merits of the decision, which is outside the scope of judicial review. This analysis confirmed that the grounds alleged were insufficient to warrant the Court of Appeal's intervention.
The Court also addressed the authority to review the Supreme Court’s orders in the context of the proceedings. The Court held that it does not have the authority to review the orders of the Supreme Court in this context, as the orders were not subject to the same grounds of review as decisions of lower courts. This point was crucial in affirming the finality of the Supreme Court's decisions unless there is a clear error of law or jurisdictional error.
Lastly, the Court examined whether there was any other legal basis for the Court of Appeal to grant the relief sought by Mr Singh. The Court concluded that no other legal basis existed to grant the relief sought, as the allegations did not constitute a basis for judicial review. This comprehensive review of all potential grounds for relief solidified the Court’s decision to dismiss the summons.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to entertain a summons for judicial review of decisions made by the Supreme Court of New South Wales unless those decisions are tainted by jurisdictional error or some other ground of review as delineated in Penson v Titan National Pty Ltd. The Court distinguished its decision from prior authority by clarifying the limited scope of judicial review and reinforcing the principles established in Penson, thereby setting a clear boundary for the availability of judicial review in similar cases.