Background
Background to the litigation
Accordingly, the only ground in respect of which there is any prospect of an appeal is proposed ground (2).BACKGROUND FACTS At [2] of his Honour’s reasons, the FCCA judge set out the following relevant facts:The applicant is a citizen of India and arrived in Australia on 17 September 2008 as the holder of a Student visa. On 17 June 2010, the applicant again entered Australia as the holder of a Student visa. The applicant then applied for a further Student visa which was refused, and the applicant then sought to challenge that decision in the Tribunal and then before the Federal Court of Australia. The applicant then remained in Australia unlawfully for 156 days. The applicant’s last substantive visa expired on 15 December 2010. The applicant lodged the application for the Partner visa the subject of the current Tribunal’s decision on 19 December 2013, as a result of a relationship allegedly commencing on 31 December 2012 and the parties being married on 7 July 2013. On 2 August 2016, the Minister’s delegate refused to grant the partner visa. The applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision.TRIBUNAL’S DECISION On 21 November 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. At paras 6 to 8 of its decision record, the Tribunal set out background facts concerning the applicant. At paras 9 to 14, the Tribunal recorded the circumstances that led to the Tribunal’s hearing, including the various invitations to the applicant to attend the hearing, adjournments of the hearing and communications between the applicant and the Tribunal. At para 15 the Tribunal found that the sponsor was an eligible citizen within the meaning of the relevant law at the relevant times. At para 16, the Tribunal found that the applicant and the sponsor were validly married. At paras 17 to 29, the Tribunal considered whether the applicant and the sponsor were in a spousal relationship. Relevantly, the Tribunal’s reasons stated:19. On these aspects, the Tribunal has considered all the evidence before it and is satisfied the facts of this case are as follows.20. The parties previously stated that they share day to day expenses. The applicant provided bank statements for the parties’ joint account. The transactions on the statements are limited. They do not provide an insight into how the parties share their financial matters. Copies of the applicant’s bank statements in 2013 show a debt of over $12,000. Also in the applicant’s name dated June 2013, is an application for exemption for paying court fees. Other information includes copies of car insurance in the parties names dated 26 May 2016; a credit advice dated October 2015, to the sponsor about repayment opportunity for a debt of $1621.83 and unnamed ad hoc receipts. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant stated that he borrowed money from his family which he used for the parties household. In addition he said that he is employed and he provides money to the sponsor for the parties’ expenses. The sponsor is not employed and the parties, other than their joint bank account do not have any shared financial assets or liabilities.21. In their previous statements the parties claimed that since their marriage they lived at a residential address of The Crescent, Berala New South Wales. In support of this they have provided copies of correspondence address to them individually at this address. On 6 August 2013, in his application for exemption of court fees the applicant stated that he was paying fortnightly $80 in rent, $10 in utilities, $127 in loan repayments, $21 in insurance premiums, $50 for food, $15 for clothing $25, for travel and motor vehicle and $70 telephone and that he had a total debt of over $17,000. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant stated that the parties lived at the Berala address. He stated that the property is shared with another person who has the lease and that person is currently overseas. He told the Tribunal that the parties share the cooking and cleaning. He also stated that perhaps in two weeks he would sign a lease in the parties’ joint names.22. The parties previously stated that they present socially within their social circle. Previous third party statements attest to the parties’ relationship being genuine. Some authors state that they attended the parties wedding; wedding anniversary and cultural festivals and have known the applicant for many years. Photographic evidence depicts the parties at what appears to be their wedding ceremony together while other photographs in an album titled “Happy Wedding Anniversary” shows the parties together and with others. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant stated that at weekends the parties go to the temple and visited friends.23. In July 2013, the parties married. In June 2016, the applicant stated that the parties lived together and their relationship was genuine and continuing. At the same time the parties’ provided statements that they live together in a happy relationship.24. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant told the Tribunal that the sponsor told him on the night before the hearing she would attend the hearing but on the morning of the hearing changed her mind. He said she has been crying and is psychologically concerned about the applicant’s future. He stated that she is suffering from tension and he obtained a medical certificate for her last week but left it at home. He said that the parties live together and when the visa is granted they plan to have a baby and want to travel to India to visit his family. The Tribunal told the applicant that at the adjourned hearing it had explained to the applicant how vital it is that the sponsor provides her evidence in person to the Tribunal. It said that this is because there is no independent evidence what so ever before the Tribunal since June 2016 about the parties’ relationship.25. The applicant told the Tribunal he could not continue with his migration agent because of finances. He instructed that the Tribunal deal with him directly. The Tribunal told the applicant to ensure that he advise the Tribunal formally about this change. The applicant confirmed that the Tribunal had all the relevant information about the parties’ spousal relationship regarding the financial aspects of their relationship, the nature of any household, and social aspects of their relationship and the nature of their commitment to each other.Findings26. The applicant provided some evidence to the Department at the time of application in December 2013 and during the visa process with the Department until June 2016. At the Tribunal hearing the applicant gave oral evidence that the parties continue in a spousal relationship. Even if the Tribunal accepted that the sponsor was unwell and couldn’t attend the hearing, it does not consider it reasonable that the applicant is unable to provide any substantive evidence about the parties’ spousal relationship. Even after the Tribunal provided the applicant and the sponsor numerous opportunities to provide evidence about their relationship. The parties have not provided any documentary or corroborative evidence since June 2016 onwards, concerning the financial aspects of their relationship, the nature of any household, any social aspects of their relationship, or the nature of their commitment to each other. Because of the lack of documentary or corroborative evidence about the parties’ spousal relationship since June 2016, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is credible and it places limited weight on his oral evidence.27. The Tribunal, due to the lack of evidence to the contrary, is unable to be satisfied that at the time of decision the parties are in a spousal relationship because the parties have not provided to the Tribunal any evidence concerning their spousal relationship regarding the financial aspects of their relationship, the nature of any household, any social aspects of their relationship, or the nature of their commitment to each other.28. The Tribunal, on the evidence is not satisfied that at the time of this decision, the parties have a mutual commitment to a shared life as husband and wife to the exclusion of all others, that the relationship is genuine and continuing and that the couple live together, or not live separately and apart on a permanent basis.[Typographical errors in original]
Decision
Reasons for decision
The applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision.TRIBUNAL’S DECISION On 21 November 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. At paras 6 to 8 of its decision record, the Tribunal set out background facts concerning the applicant. At paras 9 to 14, the Tribunal recorded the circumstances that led to the Tribunal’s hearing, including the various invitations to the applicant to attend the hearing, adjournments of the hearing and communications between the applicant and the Tribunal. At para 15 the Tribunal found that the sponsor was an eligible citizen within the meaning of the relevant law at the relevant times. At para 16, the Tribunal found that the applicant and the sponsor were validly married. At paras 17 to 29, the Tribunal considered whether the applicant and the sponsor were in a spousal relationship. Relevantly, the Tribunal’s reasons stated:19. On these aspects, the Tribunal has considered all the evidence before it and is satisfied the facts of this case are as follows.20. The parties previously stated that they share day to day expenses. The applicant provided bank statements for the parties’ joint account. The transactions on the statements are limited. They do not provide an insight into how the parties share their financial matters. Copies of the applicant’s bank statements in 2013 show a debt of over $12,000. Also in the applicant’s name dated June 2013, is an application for exemption for paying court fees. Other information includes copies of car insurance in the parties names dated 26 May 2016; a credit advice dated October 2015, to the sponsor about repayment opportunity for a debt of $1621.83 and unnamed ad hoc receipts. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant stated that he borrowed money from his family which he used for the parties household. In addition he said that he is employed and he provides money to the sponsor for the parties’ expenses. The sponsor is not employed and the parties, other than their joint bank account do not have any shared financial assets or liabilities.21. In their previous statements the parties claimed that since their marriage they lived at a residential address of The Crescent, Berala New South Wales. In support of this they have provided copies of correspondence address to them individually at this address. On 6 August 2013, in his application for exemption of court fees the applicant stated that he was paying fortnightly $80 in rent, $10 in utilities, $127 in loan repayments, $21 in insurance premiums, $50 for food, $15 for clothing $25, for travel and motor vehicle and $70 telephone and that he had a total debt of over $17,000. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant stated that the parties lived at the Berala address. He stated that the property is shared with another person who has the lease and that person is currently overseas. He told the Tribunal that the parties share the cooking and cleaning. He also stated that perhaps in two weeks he would sign a lease in the parties’ joint names.22. The parties previously stated that they present socially within their social circle. Previous third party statements attest to the parties’ relationship being genuine. Some authors state that they attended the parties wedding; wedding anniversary and cultural festivals and have known the applicant for many years. Photographic evidence depicts the parties at what appears to be their wedding ceremony together while other photographs in an album titled “Happy Wedding Anniversary” shows the parties together and with others. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant stated that at weekends the parties go to the temple and visited friends.23. In July 2013, the parties married. In June 2016, the applicant stated that the parties lived together and their relationship was genuine and continuing. At the same time the parties’ provided statements that they live together in a happy relationship.24. At the Tribunal hearing of 15 November 2017 the applicant told the Tribunal that the sponsor told him on the night before the hearing she would attend the hearing but on the morning of the hearing changed her mind. He said she has been crying and is psychologically concerned about the applicant’s future. He stated that she is suffering from tension and he obtained a medical certificate for her last week but left it at home. He said that the parties live together and when the visa is granted they plan to have a baby and want to travel to India to visit his family. The Tribunal told the applicant that at the adjourned hearing it had explained to the applicant how vital it is that the sponsor provides her evidence in person to the Tribunal. It said that this is because there is no independent evidence what so ever before the Tribunal since June 2016 about the parties’ relationship.25. The applicant told the Tribunal he could not continue with his migration agent because of finances. He instructed that the Tribunal deal with him directly. The Tribunal told the applicant to ensure that he advise the Tribunal formally about this change. The applicant confirmed that the Tribunal had all the relevant information about the parties’ spousal relationship regarding the financial aspects of their relationship, the nature of any household, and social aspects of their relationship and the nature of their commitment to each other.Findings26. The applicant provided some evidence to the Department at the time of application in December 2013 and during the visa process with the Department until June 2016. At the Tribunal hearing the applicant gave oral evidence that the parties continue in a spousal relationship. Even if the Tribunal accepted that the sponsor was unwell and couldn’t attend the hearing, it does not consider it reasonable that the applicant is unable to provide any substantive evidence about the parties’ spousal relationship. Even after the Tribunal provided the applicant and the sponsor numerous opportunities to provide evidence about their relationship. The parties have not provided any documentary or corroborative evidence since June 2016 onwards, concerning the financial aspects of their relationship, the nature of any household, any social aspects of their relationship, or the nature of their commitment to each other. Because of the lack of documentary or corroborative evidence about the parties’ spousal relationship since June 2016, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant is credible and it places limited weight on his oral evidence.27. The Tribunal, due to the lack of evidence to the contrary, is unable to be satisfied that at the time of decision the parties are in a spousal relationship because the parties have not provided to the Tribunal any evidence concerning their spousal relationship regarding the financial aspects of their relationship, the nature of any household, any social aspects of their relationship, or the nature of their commitment to each other.28. The Tribunal, on the evidence is not satisfied that at the time of this decision, the parties have a mutual commitment to a shared life as husband and wife to the exclusion of all others, that the relationship is genuine and continuing and that the couple live together, or not live separately and apart on a permanent basis.[Typographical errors in original]
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Minister submitted that there is no merit in proposed ground (2) of the draft notice of appeal, saying:It was a matter for the Tribunal to assess the genuineness of the spousal relationship, and to do so on the basis of the available material. The sponsor did not attend either of the scheduled hearings, despite repeated requests from the Tribunal that she should attend, and in the absence of any satisfactory explanation given by the applicant for her non-attendance. The opportunities the Tribunal offered to the applicant to enable the sponsor to attend before it to give evidence are inconsistent with an allegation of bias.CONSIDERATION Proposed ground (2) of the draft notice of appeal is set out at [7] above. There is no evidentiary basis for the contention that the Tribunal misunderstood the facts presented to it concerning the sponsor’s physical or mental health. There was no suggestion that the Tribunal did not accurately record what she was told about that matter. The Tribunal did not receive any medical evidence concerning the sponsor. The Tribunal stated that it was not satisfied that the applicant was a credible witness “[b]ecause of the lack of documentary or corroborative evidence about the parties’ spousal relationship since June 2016”, not because the sponsor did not attend the hearing. The Tribunal’s role was to assess the appellant’s evidence: there is no basis for thinking that it made a jurisdictional error when it found that he was not credible. Further, there is no basis for the contention that the Tribunal’s assessment was biased. The applicant did not identify any particular basis for that contention, which is a serious one that should only be made on proper grounds.Other matters raised by the applicant The FCCA judge did not make an error by failing to consider the applicant’s unexpected circumstances and difficulties and the effect of dismissing his case. The issue for the Federal Circuit Court judge was whether the applicant had raised an arguable case for relief. His Honour correctly addressed that issue. The applicant did not identify why he said that the Tribunal’s decision was made on very limited evidence. There was no suggestion that the Tribunal did not look at all of the evidence that was available to it. The Tribunal gave the applicant a reasonable opportunity to bring forward more evidence, including, importantly, evidence from the sponsor herself. The fact that there was no positive evidence that the marriage was fake does not mean that it was not open to the Tribunal to conclude that there was no spousal relationship. Although the applicant said that the Tribunal overlooked the total documents and gave emphasis to irrelevant matters, he did not identify which documents were overlooked or which irrelevant matters were considered.CONCLUSION The application should be refused, because the proposed appeal has no prospects of success. Accordingly, it is not necessary to consider whether the applicant’s explanation for his delay was unsatisfactory. Costs must follow the event.