Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd v Sherrin Rentals Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd v Sherrin Rentals Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1107

Citation: Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd v Sherrin Rentals Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1107
Parties:

SHERRIN HIRE PTY LTD ABN 450 07 741 942 v SHERRIN RENTALS PTY LTD (FORMERLY SHERRIN EQUIPMENT PTY LTD) ABN 520 74 173 756 and MICHAEL PATRICK SHERRIN;

SHERRIN RENTALS PTY LTD (FORMERLY SHERRIN EQUIPMENT PTY LTD) ABN 520 74 173 756, MICHAEL PATRICK SHERRIN and SHERRIN EQUIPMENT PTY LTD ABN 39 083 732 012 v TIDD ROSS TODD LTD, TRT (AUST) PTY LTD, PANALAM TECHNOLOGIES LIMITED and AROTAHI TRADING LIMITED

File number: NSD 1981 of 2011
Judge: EDELMAN J
Date of judgment: 15 October 2015
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to amend statement of claim – written pleading not reflecting the oral submissions concerning what was intended to be pleaded – conflation of different duties – pleading of non-delegable duty of care – nature of non-delegable duty of care – lack of plea of causation
Legislation: Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 75B
Australian Consumer Law (Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)) s 18
Cases cited: Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175
Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281; (2006) 33 WAR 82
Barclay v Penberthy [2012] HCA 40; (2012) 246 CLR 258 State of New South Wales v Lepore [2003] HCA 4; (2003) 212 CLR 511
Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 [2014] HCA 36; (2014) 313 ALR 408
Dwyer v O’Mullen (1887) 13 VLR 933
Thomson v STX Pan Ocean Co Ltd [2012] FCAFC 15
Woodland v Swimming Teachers Association [2013] UKSC 66; [2014] 1 AC 537
Young Investments Group Pty Ltd v Mann [2012] FCAFC 107; (2012) 293 ALR 537
Date of hearing: 15 October 2015
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 65
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr F Corsaro SC with Ms J Wright
Solicitor for the Applicant: TressCox
Counsel for the First, Second and Third Respondents/First, Second and Third Cross-Claimants: Ms E Collins SC with Mr L Shipway
Solicitor for the First, Second and Third Respondents/First, Second and Third Cross-Claimants: Holding Redlich
Counsel for the First and Second Cross-Respondents: Mr R D Wilson SC
Solicitor for the First and Second Cross-Respondents: Coleman Greig
Counsel for the Third Cross-Respondent: The Third Cross-Respondent did not appear
Counsel for the Fourth Cross-Respondent: The Fourth Cross-Respondent did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1981 of 2011

BETWEEN:

SHERRIN HIRE PTY LTD ABN 450 07 741 942
Applicant

AND:

SHERRIN RENTALS PTY LTD (FORMERLY SHERRIN EQUIPMENT PTY LTD) ABN 520 74 173 756
First Respondent

MICHAEL PATRICK SHERRIN
Second Respondent

SHERRIN EQUIPMENT PTY LTD ABN 39 083 732 012
Third Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

SHERRIN RENTALS PTY LTD (FORMERLY SHERRIN EQUIPMENT PTY LTD) ABN 520 74…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd v Sherrin Rentals Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd v Sherrin Rentals Pty Ltd involved a legal dispute between Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd and Sherrin Rentals Pty Ltd, with the Old Sherrin Company and New Sherrin Company also being respondents. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. Sherrin Hire sought leave to amend its statement of claim for the eighth time, proposing a fourth further amended statement of claim. The primary focus of this application was the negligence claims against the Sherrin Parties, which included the Old Sherrin Company, the New Sherrin Company, and Mr. Sherrin.

The central legal issues in this case revolved around the nature and appropriateness of the proposed amendments to the statement of claim, specifically concerning the pleadings of negligence. The court was required to determine whether the proposed amendments accurately reflected the oral submissions and whether they introduced new legal concepts that had not been previously pleaded. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the plea of non-delegable duty of care was correctly framed and whether the causation aspect of the negligence claim was adequately addressed.

The court ultimately decided to refuse Sherrin Hire's application for leave to amend its statement of claim. The reasoning behind this decision included discrepancies between the written pleadings and the oral submissions, a conflation of different legal duties, and the lack of a proper plea of causation. Despite the refusal, the court acknowledged that some of the proposed amendments might not be objectionable if properly expressed. The court emphasised the importance of careful drafting of the ninth iteration of the statement of claim and suggested that senior counsel for all parties should confer in person to facilitate this process.

The final orders of the court were that Sherrin Hire's application filed on 17 April 2015 to amend its statement of claim in the form of the proposed fourth amended statement of claim was dismissed, and Sherrin Hire was ordered to pay the costs of the first, second, and third respondents of the application. This decision underscores the importance of precision and clarity in legal pleadings and the need for careful consideration of amendments to avoid unnecessary delays in litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s application filed 17 April 2015 to amend its statement of claim in the form of the proposed fourth amended statement of claim is dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the costs of the first, second and third respondents of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Sherrin Hire Pty Ltd is a company that purchased 16 EWPs (Elevated Work Platforms) between 2005 and 2008 from the Sherrin Parties. The Sherrin Parties are the Old Sherrin Company, the New Sherrin Company, and Mr Sherrin, who were involved in the manufacture and retail of the EWPs. Sherrin Hire is seeking to amend its statement of claim for the eighth time to include additional allegations of negligence against the Sherrin Parties. The proposed amendment includes a non-delegable duty of care, which the Sherrin Parties argue is not supported by the evidence. Additionally, Sherrin Hire's claim lacks a plea of causation.

Sherrin Hire has had eight attempts to amend its statement of claim over a four-year period. The current application to amend the statement of claim is the eighth iteration, proposed as the Fourth Further Amended Statement of Claim. The application was filed on 17 April 2015 and was due to be heard in May 2015, but the hearing was vacated after TRT indicated that it wished to provide supplementary evidence. The application was heard in August 2015. The court has previously considered a strike out application in relation to Sherrin Hire's current pleading of negligence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In oral submissions, senior counsel for Sherrin Hire submitted that this plea might not add anything to the plea of negligence in relation to approval. But senior counsel for the Sherrin Parties pointed to evidence that there is a distinct and separate concept of verification, including with legislative consequences. A further problem in relation to this plea of negligence is how a claim could be made that the Old Sherrin Company breached the duty by itself carelessly verifying the design (see paragraph 17LF). Senior counsel for the Sherrin Parties said that it was common ground, and pointed to evidence filed as well as earlier versions of the statement of claim that suggests that the Old Sherrin Company did not verify the design. The evidence suggests that a third party called Kwovis provided a certificate of verification of the EWP, and another certificate of verification that was provided in relation to fibreglass components by Mr Cumming.Conclusion For the reasons I have given, the application by Sherrin Hire for leave to amend its pleading in the form of its eighth iteration, the proposed Fourth Further Amended Statement of Claim, is refused. However, based on the submissions of senior counsel for Sherrin Hire this morning, there are at least some of the proposed amendments, even perhaps many of them, which would not be objectionable and would not cause any significant disruption to the timetable to trial if expressed in the manner orally submitted. Sherrin Hire should have an opportunity to express those amendments properly. Although I consider that significant periods of delays in this matter are not the responsibility of Sherrin Hire, it remains the case that Sherrin Hire has had eight attempts at its pleading of negligence over a four year period. It will now have an opportunity for a ninth attempt. It is extremely unlikely that there will be a tenth. In circumstances in which my preliminary view is that the current pleading of negligence (for which there is an extant strike out application) has some difficulty, Sherrin Hire should take great care in its drafting of the ninth iteration of its statement of claim. It would also be appropriate for senior counsel for all parties to confer when the pleading is drafted. This includes senior counsel for the TRT Parties who wish to file a cross-claim in similar terms to Sherrin Hire’s amended statement of claim concerning negligence. That conferral should occur in person rather than by correspondence. The time has passed when counsel for an opposing party could be treated as always having a right to object to a pleading without providing positive input concerning how the pleading might be appropriately pleaded. In the circumstances of this case, that positive input is essential if there is to be any opposition to the ninth iteration of the statement of claim. I should emphasise that the contrary approach was not suggested, indeed was positively denied, by senior counsel for the Sherrin Parties who appears to have adopted a very co-operative approach to conferral.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 31 March 2015, Sherrin Hire served a seventh iteration of its statement of claim for which it proposed to seek leave. The leave application was due to be heard in May 2015 but that hearing was vacated by the docket judge after TRT indicated that it wished to provide supplementary evidence. This occurred in early July. On 6 August 2015, Sherrin Hire served the eighth iteration of its statement of claim for which it now seeks leave to file.The proposed amendments in the eighth iteration of the statement of claim The eighth iteration of the statement of claim which is in issue now is the proposed Fourth Further Amended Statement of Claim. It is necessary to set out the manner in which that statement of claim is pleaded. Apart from the negligence pleading, none of the other matters are in issue in this application. Paragraphs 1 to 3 of the proposed statement of claim describe the parties to the action in detail. The applicant is Sherrin Hire and the respondents are the Sherrin Parties. The respondents are:(1)the Old Sherrin Company, the first respondent, which trades, or had traded, as the manufacturer and retailer of the Sherrin EWP;(2)the New Sherrin Company, the third respondent, which trades, or had traded, as the manufacturer and retailer, or just the retailer, of the Sherrin EWP;(3)Mr Sherrin, the second respondent, who was a director and actively engaged in the business of both the Old Sherrin Company and the New Sherrin Company.The pleadings of breach of contract and misleading or deceptive conduct Paragraphs 4-11 (i) describe various representations that were allegedly made by the Sherrin Parties which Sherrin Hire says that it relied upon in purchasing 16 EWPs between 2005 and 2008, and (ii) set out the terms of those contracts. Paragraphs 12 to 13A then allege that the Old Sherrin Company and the New Sherrin Company breached the contracts because the EWPs were defective. Numerous defects are pleaded including cracking, delamination, openings and discontinuities, poor materials, components being too thin, water egress and so on. Paragraphs 14 to 16 are not used. Paragraph 17 to 17GA make similar allegations of breach of contract in relation to other EWPs that were acquired by Sherrin Hire under “Financed Purchase Arrangements”. Paragraphs 17H to 17J rely upon the same pleadings of representation, reliance, and defects to allege that:(1)the Old Sherrin Company and the New Sherrin Company engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, in breach of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (now s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law which is Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)); and(2)Mr Sherrin was a person involved in the breach within the meaning of s 75B of the Trade Practices Act.The pleading of negligence This application is all about the allegations of negligence against the Sherrin Parties. There are, broadly, three different duties of care pleaded and three different allegations of negligence by the Old Sherrin Company. In broad terms they are as follows.