Seymour v Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Seymour v Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1452

UNION DELEGATES – Redundancy and retrenchment – Dismissal for prohibited reasons – Reverse onus of proof – Presumption not displaced – Reinstatement.

Workplace Relations Ac 1996 (Cth) s 792, s 807, s 809.

Maritime Union of Australia & Ors v Geraldton Port Authority & Ors (1999) 93 FCR 34 referred to
R v GK (2001) 53 NSWLR 317 distinguished

TONY SEYMOUR AND JEFF GEARIN v SAINT-GOBAIN ABRASIVES PTY LTD
NSD 1923 OF 2006

BUCHANAN J
8 NOVEMBER 2006
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1923 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

TONY SEYMOUR
First Applicant

JEFF GEARIN
Second Applicant

AND:

SAINT-GOBAIN ABRASIVES PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 NOVEMBER 2006

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.It is declared that on 27 September 2006 the respondent, Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd (ACN 068 931420) contravened s 792 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) by dismissing the applicants, Mr Tony Seymour and Mr Jeff Gearin, from their employment with the respondent.

2.The respondent reinstate the applicants in their employment on and from 27 September 2006.

3.Service of the applicants with the respondent be regarded as continuous with the earlier period of their employment.

4.The respondent pay to the applicants the wages which they would have earnt in accordance with the rosters being worked by them at 27 September 2006.

5.Order 2 is conditional upon the applicants repaying to the respondent the net amount paid to them as severance pay as a result of the dismissal on 27 September 2006, less the net amount of any wages due to them under order 4 above.

6.The hearing is adjourned to a date to be fixed to hear evidence and submissions as to whether a penalty should be imposed upon the respondent under s 807 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) and, if so, the amount of such penalty.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1923 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

TONY SEYMOUR
First Applicant

JEFF GEARIN
Second Applicant

AND:

SAINT-GOBAIN ABRASIVES PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE:

8 NOVEMBER 2006

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BUCHANAN J:

Two Union Delegates are Retrenched

  1. Until 27 September 2006 Mr Tony Seymour and Mr Jeff Gearin (the applicants) were employed by Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd (the respondent).  On that day they were each compulsorily retrenched.  They were the delegates, at the respondent’s site at Lidcombe, of the National Union of Workers’ (‘the NUW’).  They were the only union delegates at the site.

  2. Mr Seymour had been employed by the respondent for 30 years.  He became a site delegate in the mid 1980s.  Mr Gearin had been employed by the respondent for 18 years.  He became a site delegate in 1988 at about the time, or shortly after, he commenced employment.

  3. It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Seymour v Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Seymour v Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd, the applicants, Mr Tony Seymour and Mr Jeff Gearin, challenged their dismissal from employment by the respondent, Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd. The applicants alleged that their dismissals were unlawful under s 792 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth), due to their status as union delegates and members. The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with determining the validity of the dismissal and whether it contravened the statutory provisions.

The court examined the selection criteria and process employed by the respondent to determine which employees would be retrenched. The primary issue was whether the applicants' union affiliation influenced their dismissal. The court also considered the role and influence of each decision-maker in the retrenchment process and whether the process was arbitrary or discriminatory. Furthermore, the court assessed whether the respondent's explanation for the dismissal met the legal requirements and whether the presumption of unfair dismissal was displaced.

The court concluded that the respondent had failed to prove that the dismissal of the applicants was not influenced by their union membership and delegate status. The selection process was found to be arbitrary and did not provide a realistic or objective foundation for excluding union-based prejudice. Consequently, the court found that the presumption of unfair dismissal was not displaced. The decision-makers, Ms Hobbs and Mr Grbic, were found to have been influenced by factors other than those legitimately considered in the dismissal process. The court declared that the dismissals contravened s 792 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) and ordered the applicants' reinstatement, back pay, and the repayment of severance pay, subject to certain conditions.

The court's final orders included the declaration that the respondent contravened s 792 by dismissing the applicants, the reinstatement of the applicants in their employment, the continuation of their service, the payment of wages due, and the conditional repayment of severance pay. The hearing was adjourned to determine if a penalty should be imposed on the respondent under s 807 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It is declared that on 27 September 2006 the respondent, Saint-Gobain Abrasives Pty Ltd (ACN 068 931420) contravened s 792 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) by dismissing the applicants, Mr Tony Seymour and Mr Jeff Gearin, from their employment with the respondent.

2. The respondent reinstate the applicants in their employment on and from 27 September 2006.

3. Service of the applicants with the respondent be regarded as continuous with the earlier period of their employment.

4. The respondent pay to the applicants the wages which they would have earnt in accordance with the rosters being worked by them at 27 September 2006.

5. Order 2 is conditional upon the applicants repaying to the respondent the net amount paid to them as severance pay as a result of the dismissal on 27 September 2006, less the net amount of any wages due to them under order 4 above.

6. The hearing is adjourned to a date to be fixed to hear evidence and submissions as to whether a penalty should be imposed upon the respondent under s 807 of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) and, if so, the amount of such penalty.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BUCHANAN J
Although the question of compliance with the Certified Agreement does not arise, the arbitrary and simplistic nature of this criterion, and of the use of the Skills Matrix, does not assist the respondent in any endeavour to suggest an objective and realistic foundation for the selection process which excludes union-based prejudice against the applicants. Indeed in the context of the uncertainty generated by the matters discussed earlier, it adds to the doubts and my lack of conviction about the respondent’s position.Who were the Decision-Makers? I am satisfied that the decision-makers in this case were Ms Hobbs and Mr Grbic. Although Ms Hobbs gave evidence that Mr Freeman, the Managing Director of the respondent, was kept informed of the progress of the retrenchment procedures and gave final approval for the retrenchments themselves, there is no evidence that he was involved in the selection of those retrenched – that was left to local management with Ms Hobbs’ assistance. Ms Hobbs said in her evidence that she was the person with the authority to make the decision to dismiss. I am satisfied that she was one of the decision-makers and that her concurrence was required to the retrenchments of the applicants. However, it was clear that she relied on the judgements of Mr Grbic and Mr Davis in the discussion about who to retrench. She had no personal knowledge of the suggested skill requirements or the skills possessed by individuals. She had entered the meeting with the preliminary view that the volunteers would be first in line to be retrenched. She had directed that the final pays of the volunteers in the Maker Division be made up the day before the meeting. Despite my concerns about the way Mr Hobbs’ affidavit evidence was prepared I accept her evidence that when she contributed to the decision to dismiss the applicants she did not do so for the reason that they were either delegates or union members. Directing the calculation of entitlements of Messrs Bound and Kumar, along with Mr Salac, before the meeting would have been quite unnecessary if Ms Hobbs had a predetermined position about the selection issue. Mr Davis did not explicitly depose that the fact that the applicants were delegates and members of the NUW played no part in their dismissal. However, in my view Mr Davis was not a decision-maker in the relevant sense. Although he contributed to the selection of the applicants for retrenchments by reference to the Skills Matrix which he had prepared, in my view he did not set the parameters of the discussion. He responded to questions by Ms Hobbs and Mr Grbic. His acceptance of the outcome was a recognition of the inevitable. In any event, I do not think any contribution he made was influenced by the fact that the applicants were union delegates or union members. I do not regard the fact that he did not explicitly deny delegateship or membership as a reason for dismissal as critical in the circumstances. I am satisfied that Mr Grbic was an active participant in the decision to retrench the applicants and that his reasons for doing so are to be attributed to the respondent. The respondent needed to prove that those reasons did not include the fact that the applicants were delegates and members of the NUW. His evidence does not achieve that result, despite his sworn denial.The Presumption is not Displaced

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BUCHANAN J

The present case is not concerned with allegations of breach of the Certified Agreement and it is not necessary for me to form or express a view about whether, on the explanation offered by the respondent’s witnesses, the requirements of clause 22 were met. Such a matter, if it ever arises, would do so in other proceedings. However, it is apparent from the evidence that the provisions quoted above influenced some of the processes followed by the respondent in managing the selection process for redundancies.The Respondent’s Operations The respondent manufactures abrasive products including sandpaper. The operations are organised into four divisions – Maker, Bonded, Conversion and Maintenance. Ms Hobbs provided a summary of the work in the different divisions. The Maker Division, in which the applicants were employed, is involved in the electrostatic attaching of grains on to cloth or paper to form an abrasive product. The Bonded Division work involves forming abrasive materials into shapes for particular purposes. Work in the Conversion Division involves converting ‘jumbo’ sized rolls of abrasive product into various sized disks, sheets and rolls. The Maintenance Division is involved with the maintenance and service of machinery used in the other three divisions. Prior to 27 September 2006 there were 13 full-time employees in each of the Maker and Bonded Divisions, 19 full-time employees in the Conversion Division and 3 full-time employees in the Maintenance Division.The Coater and Off-line Printer The selection of persons in the Maker Division for retention or retrenchment turned on whether they were assessed as having proficiency in the operation of two machines in that division, the Coater and Off-line Printer. The Coater is the more complex of the two machines. It was described as a pressure-sensitive laminating and stearating machine. Mr Rajesh Kumar is a leading hand in the Maker Division. He deposed that it took two to three months to train an employee to learn all the skills required to operate the Coater machine. By contrast, in his view, the Off-line Printer was not a very complex piece of machinery. He said it would take about two to three hours to train an employee in how to use it and after about a day or two an employee should be proficient in its use. The Off-line Printer was described to me as having two main functions. It is called the Off-line Printer because one of the functions is to print grit numbers or bar codes on imported material and material earlier manufactured on site. This printing may also be done during the manufacturing process (i.e. ‘on-line’) but, if that does not occur it is done ‘off-line’ on this machine. The work requires some familiarity with different category codes and bar codes. It can take some time to become familiar with all of them but the work is performed to an extent under supervision. The supervisor of the Maker Division, Mr Davis, or one of the leading hands checks what is to be done.