FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593
File number(s): VID 480 of 2019 Judgment of: KERR J Date of judgment: 17 December 2021 Catchwords: TORTS – tort of false imprisonment – whether consular assistance provided to the Applicant for his ‘rescue’ in the aftermath of his having been kidnapped in Nigeria was imposed on him contrary to his consent – application dismissed
EVIDENCE – Applicant’s witnesses not giving evidence – whether the Court is entitled to draw a Jones v Dunkel inference
COSTS – whether manner of conduct of Respondent’s case may warrant limited departure from ordinary rule that costs follow event
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Oaths and Affirmations Act 2018 (Vic)
Cases cited: Foots v Southern Cross Mine Management Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 56; (2007) 234 CLR 53
Jones v Dunkel [1959] 101 CLR 298
Division: General Division Registry: Victoria National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights Number of paragraphs: 297 Date of hearing: 5-8 October 2021 Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person Counsel for the Respondent: Mr A Dinelli with Ms S Kearney Solicitor for the Respondent: Maddocks Lawyers ORDERS
VID 480 of 2019 BETWEEN: ALISTAIR PETER SCHOLES
Applicant
AND: COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
KERR J
DATE OF ORDER:
17 DECEMBER 2021
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The Applicant's application be dismissed.
2.Unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.
3.If either party seeks an alternative order as is provided for in Order 2 the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.
4.Unless the Court otherwise orders any question of costs so arising be determined on the papers.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
INTRODUCTION
[1]
THE TRIAL: PROCEDURAL ADJUSTMENTS REQUIRED BY COVID-19
[13]
MR SCHOLES’ EVIDENCE
[20]
Evidence-in-Chief
[20]
Mr Scholes’ limited concession
[24]
Cross-examination
[28]
Mr Scholes’ history with Tola and Tayo Yusuf and the context of his travel to and conduct in Nigeria
[28]
Other evidence given by Mr Scholes in cross-examination
[62]
The balance of Mr Scholes’ case: the absence of his other scheduled witnesses
[99]
Documentary tenders
[108]
THE COMMONWEALTH’S EVIDENCE
[110]
Cleo Wilson
[110]
Paul John Lehmann
[123]
Brian Mitchell Taylor
[133]
Jennifer Ann Dee
[146]
Mustapha Oshoke Aliyu
[150]
Daniel Lemmer
[163]
CONSIDERATION
[169]
The credit of witnesses
[169]
The Commonwealth’s submission regarding the “bizarre” nature of Mr Scholes’ evidence undermining his general credit
[175]
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] FCA 1593
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court's reasoning was based on the evidence presented by Mr. Scholes, who was the only witness in his case. The Court found that Mr. Scholes' evidence did not corroborate his account of being seized by Pilgrims against his will from Ilero and taken to Lagos. Furthermore, Mr. Scholes made no complaint of the kind he now advances to any Australian official until after he had returned to Australia. The Court rejected the notion that Mr. Scholes' threatening legal action unless a visa was granted to Tayo counted against his credit as a witness of the truth.
In conclusion, the Court dismissed Mr. Scholes' case and ordered that unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021. If either party seeks an alternative order, the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Applicant's application be dismissed.
2. Unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.
3. If either party seeks an alternative order as is provided for in Order 2 the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.
4. Unless the Court otherwise orders any question of costs so arising be determined on the papers.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Finally, I also reject that I should find that Mr Aliyu spoke the words Mr Scholes gave evidence of as I have recorded at [82] but again even if Mr Scholes’ evidence was to be accepted that which he gives evidence of being said by Mr Aliyu has no bearing on whether or not he had earlier consented or later withdrawn his consent. Mr Scholes gave no evidence that he had responded in any manner suggesting either of those conclusions.Absence of corroboration Out of an abundance of caution I reject that anything Mr Scholes said to Australian officials in the aftermath of his being brought to Lagos amounts to corroboration of his now clear memory of having been seized by Pilgrims against his will from Ilero and taken to Lagos. I accept that Mr Scholes did promptly raise with Mr Lehmann his distress regarding his having to leave his fiancé behind in Ilero. Mr Lehmann responded to him that it was DFAT’s policy to confine assistance to Australian nationals where others were citizens of the country in which they were in distress. What Mr Scholes said to Mr Lehmann does not corroborate his account beyond the reality that he had been compelled to make a heart wrenching choice. As noted above at [250]–[251] Mr Scholes would be taken from where he had been told he was not safe only if he was prepared to leave behind the woman he loved, who he intended to marry and with whom he had just endured the trauma of being held captive for ransom for 8 days. Mr Scholes’ complaint about his having been put in that position and his seeking Mr Lehmann’s assistance to obtain a visa for Tayo is consistent with that aspect of his account but it does not corroborate his evidence of having been restrained against his will in leaving Ilero. It is conspicuous that Mr Scholes made no complaint of the kind he now advances to any Australian official until after he had returned to Australia. He made no claims of the kind he now advances whilst in Nigeria. Mr Scholes gives evidence that he told the AFP welfare team who assisted him in Melbourne that he had been brought from Ilero to Lagos against his will but he had not done so previously, he did not identify when or in what circumstances that occurred, and he did not call those persons as witnesses. I place little store on that account. The first time Mr Scholes appears to have articulated such a claim is in the letter he wrote to the Australian High Commission in South Africa on 13 December 2017 which was sent in the circumstances I have described above after his return to Australia. In that letter Mr Scholes articulated the basic premises of his present claim and intimated that if Tayo was granted a visa he would not take legal proceedings of the kind he ultimately pursued. I reject that is plausible corroboration of his present evidence. Threatening legal action unless a visa was to be granted to Tayo was ill-judged on Mr Scholes’ part but, consistently with my reasoning as to his honesty I reject his doing so counts against his credit as a witness of the truth.