Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 91 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593    

File number(s): VID 480 of 2019
Judgment of: KERR J
Date of judgment: 17 December 2021
Catchwords:

TORTS – tort of false imprisonment – whether consular assistance provided to the Applicant for his ‘rescue’ in the aftermath of his having been kidnapped in Nigeria was imposed on him contrary to his consent – application dismissed

EVIDENCE – Applicant’s witnesses not giving evidence – whether the Court is entitled to draw a Jones v Dunkel inference

COSTS – whether manner of conduct of Respondent’s case may warrant limited departure from ordinary rule that costs follow event

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Oaths and Affirmations Act 2018 (Vic)

Cases cited:

Foots v Southern Cross Mine Management Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 56; (2007) 234 CLR 53

Jones v Dunkel [1959] 101 CLR 298

Nominal Defendant v Rooskov [2012] NSWCA 43

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 297
Date of hearing: 5-8 October 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr A Dinelli with Ms S Kearney
Solicitor for the Respondent: Maddocks Lawyers

ORDERS

VID 480 of 2019
BETWEEN:

ALISTAIR PETER SCHOLES

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

KERR J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 DECEMBER 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Applicant's application be dismissed.

2.Unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.

3.If either party seeks an alternative order as is provided for in Order 2 the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.

4.Unless the Court otherwise orders any question of costs so arising be determined on the papers.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

[1]

THE TRIAL: PROCEDURAL ADJUSTMENTS REQUIRED BY COVID-19

[13]

MR SCHOLES’ EVIDENCE

[20]

Evidence-in-Chief

[20]

Mr Scholes’ limited concession

[24]

Cross-examination

[28]

Mr Scholes’ history with Tola and Tayo Yusuf and the context of his travel to and conduct in Nigeria

[28]

Other evidence given by Mr Scholes in cross-examination

[62]

The balance of Mr Scholes’ case: the absence of his other scheduled witnesses

[99]

Documentary tenders

[108]

THE COMMONWEALTH’S EVIDENCE

[110]

Cleo Wilson

[110]

Paul John Lehmann

[123]

Brian Mitchell Taylor

[133]

Jennifer Ann Dee

[146]

Mustapha Oshoke Aliyu

[150]

Daniel Lemmer

[163]

CONSIDERATION

[169]

The credit of witnesses

[169]

The Commonwealth’s submission regarding the “bizarre” nature of Mr Scholes’ evidence undermining his general credit

[175]

The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1593
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Mr. Scholes filed a lawsuit against the Commonwealth of Australia, alleging the tort of false imprisonment. Mr. Scholes claimed that consular assistance provided for his "rescue" in Nigeria, following his kidnapping, was imposed on him against his consent. The case was dismissed by the Court. The primary legal issues the Court had to decide were whether Mr. Scholes was restrained against his will by the Respondent's agents and if the restraint was caused by a direct and intentional act of the Respondent's agents. The Court found that at no point was Mr. Scholes restrained against his will by the Respondent's agents, and therefore, there was no need to answer the subsequent questions. The Court also rejected the notion that the conduct of the Respondent's agents constituted the tort of false imprisonment.

The Court's reasoning was based on the evidence presented by Mr. Scholes, who was the only witness in his case. The Court found that Mr. Scholes' evidence did not corroborate his account of being seized by Pilgrims against his will from Ilero and taken to Lagos. Furthermore, Mr. Scholes made no complaint of the kind he now advances to any Australian official until after he had returned to Australia. The Court rejected the notion that Mr. Scholes' threatening legal action unless a visa was granted to Tayo counted against his credit as a witness of the truth.

In conclusion, the Court dismissed Mr. Scholes' case and ordered that unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021. If either party seeks an alternative order, the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Applicant's application be dismissed.

2. Unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.

3. If either party seeks an alternative order as is provided for in Order 2 the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.

4. Unless the Court otherwise orders any question of costs so arising be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

However, as I shall return to later, all three of the residents of Nigeria who Mr Scholes had given notice of intending to call as witnesses, including his fiancé, Tayo, failed to make themselves available for that purpose. Mr Scholes had earlier intimated that he had feared such a possibility might arise but had not applied for an adjournment. Upon it being established that his intending witness would not be giving evidence Mr Scholes indicated that he wished to continue nonetheless. The trial proceeded with Mr Scholes being the only witness in his case.MR SCHOLES’ EVIDENCEEvidence-in-Chief On the basis of the agreement between the parties, Mr Scholes thus opened his case and gave evidence-in-chief as follows:My initial contact with DFAT was on 6 December 2017 when I was handed the phone by … [my fiancé, Tayo Yusuf’s] stepfather, and I spoke to an unidentified DFAT female officer in a short conversation. I said to her that I did not wish any assistance, nor require any assistance, from DFAT and that I was returning to the village with the stepfather, Tayo, my fiancée and the security men that had rescued us from the jungle. The caller encouraged me to contact my mother and brother in Australia, which I subsequently did, and I told the woman during the conversation that I believed that Tola [Tayo’s sister] was behind the kidnapping and reiterated that I did not require DFATs assistance. She asked me if she could ring in the morning; I dismissed it with an unenthusiastic, “Yes, if you want.” That was the end of the phone call. The following morning we departed the hotel and returned to the village of [Ilero]. At or about 8.30 hours the stepfather handed to me the phone again, saying the same DFAT female had rung again. I again reiterated to her that I did not require any assistance. She said that – she said they had called for a rescue convoy come and get me – that it had left Lagos and would be there around midday, I said “Why?” I said I did not require their assistance, and I said I do not have any choice in the matter, and she said no. And I said I do not have any money to pay for the rescue, and that she said she would ring back within an hour to discuss that issue. She then made spurious allegations against my fiancée, Tayo, and the Yusuf family in general, and also claiming the stepfather was not who I believed he was. She claimed my life was in danger if I remained with the Yusuf family. I told her she was talking rubbish and all the information had come from Tola who I believed was behind the hijack. She said not to discuss our conversation with the Yusuf family – in particular, Tayo. I ended the call. At or about 9.30 the stepfather again handed me the phone, saying the same woman was calling. I told the caller I was not interested and I did not require their assistance. Again, I attempted to remain pleasant with her, reiterating I did not require DFATs assistance. She again made spurious allegations against the Yusuf family, and once again I terminated the call. …. For the remainder of 7 December 2017 there was no further contact between myself or any other Australian official or authority…. For the remainder of the day Tayo, and myself and other members of the Yusuf family went around [Ilero] shopping, having a haircut and shave, and thanking family members within the village for their support and concern during the horrific events that had overtaken Tayo and myself. At or about 2230 hours three vehicles arrived in front of the Yusuf home. They assumed they were the convoy that DFAT had sent. Upon meeting the team leader, who introduced himself as Muhammad, I protested, stating I did not require DFATs assistance. When he stated that he had been ordered by my government to come and pick me up and convey me safely to Lagos I continued protesting. He stated, “We have to leave immediately, because [Ilero] is not a safe place” for me to remain in. I said, “Why?” I continued protesting, saying that if I was going Tayo was coming with me. A short time later he came back and said, “We are – we only have to – we” – sorry. “We only have orders to pick you up at this time.” Between eight and 10 heavily armed men with AK-47 shotguns appeared to be moving towards myself and Muhammad. He demanded that I get into the vehicle and, to avoid any further arguments, I simply gave up when I realised whatever I wanted was not going to occur. I was apprehensive about travelling at night; apprehensive about being in – under the control of these people, considering that I had told DFAT that I was not interested in their services. Some 10 to 20 minutes into the drive Muhammad turned around and said to me, “We’ve made a mistake. We can’t go back. We’ve gone too far.” I continued protesting all the way to Ibadan, but to no avail. Muhammad asked me if I had any money to pay for the hotel. I said, “I have nothing.” And I continued protesting, realising nothing was going to happen in my favour, or change the mindset of Muhammad.In the morning I got woken up by Muhammad knocking on the door, and he told me that we had – “We are leaving shortly for Lagos.” I quickly packed myself up and readied for the departure, still protesting. When we reached the outskirts of what I believe is Lagos I had a massive panic attack, anxiety, and the onset of PTSD. I demanded that Muhammad stop the vehicle so I could get out and vomit. I dry-retched and felt terrible. Once my nerves had settled I was sitting back in the vehicle; Muhammad asked how did I feel and I said, I do not want to be with him. I wanted to go back to Tayo. ….Muhammad, who goes by another name in his affidavit, said that event occurred the previous day, and I say it didn’t. We later stopped briefly for breakfast and a toilet stop. Muhammad became concerned when I wished to go to the toilet by myself, and one of the police officers accompanied me the toilet…. We later stopped for fuel and I was left in the vehicle alone. I realised there was an opportunity to steal the car and drive back to [Ilero] and my fiancée, Tayo. When Muhammad, the driver, hopped back into the vehicle I told Muhammad what I had planned to do. He turned around and said, “I’m glad you did not do that, because people in Canberra would have been very upset.” There [were] numerous phone calls made by Muhammad. On two occasions he handed me the phone. One of the callers identified himself as Greg from DFAT. The other identified himself as Paul Lehmann. Upon arrival at the Sheraton Hotel I waited in the vehicle, as I was told to do by Muhammad, as it was surrounded by heavily armed police that had escorted us from [Ilero] whilst Muhammad located a DFAT officer. Upon entry into the hotel lobby I was introduced to Paul Lehmann, the Australian High Commission of – Commissioner for Nigeria. ….he [says] that meeting didn’t occur there. I again beg to differ.We had a preliminary introduction and I realised that I had been taken from the safety of my in-law’s village, [Ilero] and was no longer – had any control over what was about to happen to me, having been placed, now, in an alien environment where I was totally dependent on the respondent. I had no personal possessions; no identify; no money; absolutely nothing, and my phone was not charged at that point, nor did I have credit to make any phone calls.Mr Lehmann made a booking for the hotel room where I was going to stay, and I was also introduced to the manager at the hotel, Andrew, who was from Adelaide. The three of us took the lift to the fifth floor of the hotel and I was shown to my room by Paul Lehmann and Andrew. Paul Lehmann and I spent what I believed was some 30 to 60 minutes discussing what had occurred. I expressed my concerns and told him about my idea of stealing the car and returning to [Ilero] and my fiancée, Tayo Yusuf. …, he disputes that conversation in his affidavit. I say otherwise.He said to me that I should think about my safety and return to Australia. I said I wasn’t interested, and I wanted to return to [Ilero] and my fiancé Tayo. Mr Lehmann then informed me that Brian Taylor was coming from Abuja with my passport and other stuff, to which I was completely unaware of, because I had not informed DFAT where any of my personal property was. Mr Lehmann requested that I did not leave the room and did not go down to the lobby and mingle with other guests, or have – or go to the drinks night that Andrew, the hotel manager, had invited me to…. As I was so tired and missing Tayo, I wasn’t really interested.Upon leaving, Paul Lehmann gave me 5000 – 15,000 naira [equivalent to about $A50.00], his contact details and that of Brian Taylor and the High Commission in Abuja, and the name of a female officer I was talking to; Cleo Wilson. Upon Mr Lehmann leaving, I rang Cleo Wilson protesting about what had occurred and told her I considered stealing the car, of which she notes in the DFAT emails. …She again reiterated the advice given by Paul Lehmann. I protested again, given I was in a hostile environment; I knew nobody; had no idea where I was in Lagos; I had no money; no identity, and I was now totally dependent on DFAT. I rang Tayo on the hotel phone and explained where I was; what had happened, and I said to her that I wanted to come back… but there was nothing either of us could do about what had happened. I said, “Don’t worry.” …. I asked Paul Lehmann about the visas, how to go about applying for her, and the [kids] to come and see me in Australia. I said I was going to have a shower and go to sleep and there was some other DFAT officers coming from Abuja that afternoon. I had a shower and went to sleep. I was awoken by a telephone call on the hotel telephone. The caller identified himself as Brian Taylor from DFAT. After a brief discussion, Brian Taylor came to the room, we sat down and had a brief discussion. I informed him of being removed from safety of [Ilero] and brought to Lagos against my will. We sat down in the beer garden and continued our discussion where he returned the property. I explained to him what had happened, the hijacking, the kidnapping, and being held captive in the jungle and a trip into Lagos. I also explained to him that I was going to steal a car and return to the Yusuf family village and my fiancé, Tayo. I formed the opinion…even though I believed Brian Taylor was sympathetic to my situation, he was following DFATs program of returning me to Australia no matter what I said. After dinner that evening, realising nothing I would say or do would change the situation, with Brian’s assistance, I changed my departure airline ticket to return to Australia. Brian Taylor also organised that afternoon a meeting with Nigerian DSS the following day. Some time later, after further conversations, Brian Taylor walked me back to my room, upon saying goodnight, I retired to bed after speaking to Tayo.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Once on route from Ilero (and in Lagos until Mr Taylor returned his possessions to him) Mr Scholes was without money, identification or means of self-protection. The Commonwealth’s own case is that his safety was at significant risk. I reject that the possibility that he might at any point have directed Mr Aliyu to let him out of the vehicle he was travelling in, had I not found he had consented to that, would serve in the circumstances of his extreme vulnerably as a plausible window for his escape.CONCLUSION I dismiss the Applicant’s case. For completeness I formally record the following conclusions the Court has reached in respect of the agreed issues that the parties submitted for trial.Issue 1At any time between the evening on 7 December 2017, when the Applicant was collected by the Respondent’s agents from Ilero, and the morning of 8 December 2017, when the Respondent’s agents delivered the Applicant to the Sheraton Hotel in Lagos, was the Applicant’s restrained against his will by the Respondent’s agents?Answer: NoIssue 2If yes to Issue (1), was the restraint of the Applicant caused by a direct and intentional act of the Respondent’s agents?Answer: Unnecessary to answerIssue 3At any time between the morning of 8 December 2017, when the Applicant arrived at the Sheraton Hotel in Lagos, and when Mr Scholes boarded his flight to Australia at the Lagos international airport on 10 December 2017, was the Applicant restrained against his will by the Respondent’s agents? Answer: NoIssue 4If yes to Issue (3), was the restraint of the Applicant caused by a direct and intentional act of the Respondent’s agents? Answer: Unnecessary to answerIssue 5If yes to any of the above, did the relevant conduct of the Respondent’s agents, in the circumstances, constitute the tort of false imprisonment with regard to the Applicant? Answer: Unnecessary to answerIssue 6If yes to Issue (5), what is the measure of the damages or compensation for that tort to which the Applicant has proven an entitlement?Answer: Does not arise.COSTS The ordinary consequence, as Gleeson CJ, Gummow, Hayne and Crennan JJ explained in Foots v Southern Cross Mine Management Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 56; (2007) 234 CLR 53 at [25]–[26] is that while there is “no absolute rule” generally the discretion to award costs is to be exercised in favour of a successful party. However, it is trite that ultimately the discretion to award costs is not fettered. I note that on day 3 of the trial an unfortunate event occurred. It involved significant and cruel mockery of Mr Scholes as he was attempting to cross-examine Mr Lemmer. As the transcript of the following day reveals I noted that I did not accept Mr Dinelli’s submission that the conduct in question was not to be attributed to his client. I have chosen to be oblique in these remarks because to refer in detail to the those circumstances without the necessity for doing so may well not only expose Mr Scholes to the hurt reliving that event but also cause the person who was inadvertently responsible: a person who has unconditionally apologised to Mr Scholes and the Court in terms which I accept are genuine, to be exposed to unnecessary public humiliation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, I also reject that I should find that Mr Aliyu spoke the words Mr Scholes gave evidence of as I have recorded at [82] but again even if Mr Scholes’ evidence was to be accepted that which he gives evidence of being said by Mr Aliyu has no bearing on whether or not he had earlier consented or later withdrawn his consent. Mr Scholes gave no evidence that he had responded in any manner suggesting either of those conclusions.Absence of corroboration Out of an abundance of caution I reject that anything Mr Scholes said to Australian officials in the aftermath of his being brought to Lagos amounts to corroboration of his now clear memory of having been seized by Pilgrims against his will from Ilero and taken to Lagos. I accept that Mr Scholes did promptly raise with Mr Lehmann his distress regarding his having to leave his fiancé behind in Ilero. Mr Lehmann responded to him that it was DFAT’s policy to confine assistance to Australian nationals where others were citizens of the country in which they were in distress. What Mr Scholes said to Mr Lehmann does not corroborate his account beyond the reality that he had been compelled to make a heart wrenching choice. As noted above at [250]–[251] Mr Scholes would be taken from where he had been told he was not safe only if he was prepared to leave behind the woman he loved, who he intended to marry and with whom he had just endured the trauma of being held captive for ransom for 8 days. Mr Scholes’ complaint about his having been put in that position and his seeking Mr Lehmann’s assistance to obtain a visa for Tayo is consistent with that aspect of his account but it does not corroborate his evidence of having been restrained against his will in leaving Ilero. It is conspicuous that Mr Scholes made no complaint of the kind he now advances to any Australian official until after he had returned to Australia. He made no claims of the kind he now advances whilst in Nigeria. Mr Scholes gives evidence that he told the AFP welfare team who assisted him in Melbourne that he had been brought from Ilero to Lagos against his will but he had not done so previously, he did not identify when or in what circumstances that occurred, and he did not call those persons as witnesses. I place little store on that account. The first time Mr Scholes appears to have articulated such a claim is in the letter he wrote to the Australian High Commission in South Africa on 13 December 2017 which was sent in the circumstances I have described above after his return to Australia. In that letter Mr Scholes articulated the basic premises of his present claim and intimated that if Tayo was granted a visa he would not take legal proceedings of the kind he ultimately pursued. I reject that is plausible corroboration of his present evidence. Threatening legal action unless a visa was to be granted to Tayo was ill-judged on Mr Scholes’ part but, consistently with my reasoning as to his honesty I reject his doing so counts against his credit as a witness of the truth.