Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2022] FCA 27   

File number(s): VID 480 of 2019
Judgment of: KERR J
Date of judgment: 25 January 2022
Catchwords: COSTS – application for an alternative order as to costs following judgment in Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593 – application rejected
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 40.51(2)(d)
Cases cited: Wilderness Society v Turnbull [2007] FCA 1863
Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593
Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 26
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr A Dinelli with Ms S Kearney
Solicitor for the Respondent: Maddocks Lawyers

ORDERS

VID 480 of 2019
BETWEEN:

ALISTAIR PETER SCHOLES

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

KERR J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 JANUARY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Without derogating from the Respondent’s entitlement to enforce the orders made by consent by the Court on 23 March 2020 the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

KERR J:

  1. On 17 December 2021 the Court published reasons in Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593 (the Decision). The Court ordered:

    1.The Applicant's application be dismissed.

    2.Unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.

    3.If either party seeks an alternative order as is provided for in Order 2 the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.

    4.Unless the Court otherwise orders any question of costs so arising be determined on the papers.

  2. On 10 January 2022 the Applicant, Mr Scholes, lodged a Notice of Appeal of the Decision with the Federal Court.

  3. On 11 January 2022, the Applicant provided his appeal documents with a covering letter by email to the Associate to Kerr J and to the solicitor for the Respondent. The Respondent, the Commonwealth, responded to that correspondence on 14 January 2022, coping in the Applicant, and identified that the Applicant had made submissions as to costs pursuant to Order 2 of the 17 December 2021 orders within the appeal documents. The Commonwealth notified the Court that:

    …without conceding the bases identified by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 27
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia involved a dispute regarding the costs order made in the proceeding. The Applicant, Mr Scholes, sought an alternative order as to costs following the judgment rendered in Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593. The legal issues before the Court included whether the Commonwealth was entitled to its costs, the appropriateness of the quantum of those costs, and whether the Court should grant an alternative order in light of the Applicant's financial incapacity to pay. The Court had to determine the appropriate exercise of its discretion in making a costs order, considering the circumstances of the case and the relevant legal principles.

The Court found that the Commonwealth was entitled to its costs as a result of its conduct of the litigation. The Commonwealth had cooperated in reaching an agreed list of issues for the trial, and had made arrangements to facilitate the Applicant's witnesses in Nigeria to give evidence. The Court was satisfied that the Commonwealth had acted as a model litigant, apart from two issues that did not disentitle it to its prima facie entitlement to its costs. The Court was not unsympathetic to the personal position of the Applicant, but noted that the Applicant had persisted in advancing contentions that the Court had regarded as implausible. The Court considered that the Applicant's financial incapacity did not justify a departure from the usual approach to costs orders. The Court also rejected the Applicant's argument that the Commonwealth had acted improperly by not seeking an alternative costs order.

The Court ordered that the Applicant pay the Respondent's costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021. The Court noted that the Applicant had appealed the Decision, but that did not affect the operation of the costs order. The Court also noted that the costs order made by consent on 23 March 2020 remained in force, subject to the terms of that order. The Court considered that the costs order was appropriate in all the circumstances of the case, and that the Applicant's financial incapacity did not justify a departure from the usual approach to costs orders. The Court rejected the Applicant's argument that the Commonwealth had acted improperly by not seeking an alternative costs order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Without derogating from the Respondent’s entitlement to enforce the orders made by consent by the Court on 23 March 2020 the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 December 2021 the Court published reasons in Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593 (the Decision). The Court ordered:1.The Applicant's application be dismissed.2.Unless either party advises the Court by no later than 14 January 2022 that they would seek an alternative order, the Applicant shall pay the Respondent’s costs of the proceeding (including any costs thrown away by reason of the Respondent providing arrangements for the Applicant to call witnesses in Nigeria) other than the costs of the trial on 5-8 October 2021.3.If either party seeks an alternative order as is provided for in Order 2 the parties shall have until no later than 4:00pm 21 January 2022 to file and serve any written submissions (limited to 3 pages) upon which they may seek to rely in relation to costs.4.Unless the Court otherwise orders any question of costs so arising be determined on the papers. On 10 January 2022 the Applicant, Mr Scholes, lodged a Notice of Appeal of the Decision with the Federal Court. On 11 January 2022, the Applicant provided his appeal documents with a covering letter by email to the Associate to Kerr J and to the solicitor for the Respondent. The Respondent, the Commonwealth, responded to that correspondence on 14 January 2022, coping in the Applicant, and identified that the Applicant had made submissions as to costs pursuant to Order 2 of the 17 December 2021 orders within the appeal documents. The Commonwealth notified the Court that:…without conceding the bases identified by the Court at paragraph 294 of the Reasons, the Commonwealth advises that it does not propose to seek an alternative costs order to that proposed by the Court. The Commonwealth will provide its written submissions in response to Mr Scholes’ submissions on the issue of costs, by 4pm 21 January 2022, in accordance with order 3 of the Orders. The Commonwealth filed its submissions on 21 January 2022 as foreshadowed. THE APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS The Applicant submits that the Court is aware that he “does not have nor will ever have the financial ability to pay for the respondents costs” and that enforcement of the Court’s orders will force him into “seeking immediate bankruptcy” and that he will have then “lost everything”. The Applicant submits that he pursued his case “…in the public interest and in the public good believing that his version of the events that occurred in Nigeria on 6-10 December 2017 which are true and correct as the applicant lived and experienced them.” He submits that he realises that he will never see his fiancée and her children again or ever fully recover from the events that were the subject of this proceeding. The Applicant, in his costs submissions, continues to assert the untruthfulness of witnesses whose honesty the Court accepted in its reasons. The Applicant also asserts that certain documentary evidence was withheld by the Commonwealth. The Applicant notes a costs order made earlier in the proceeding:7.The applicant draws His Honour’s attention to the 23 March 2020 court order granting party-party costs reiterating the applicant as then and as now will never have the financial ability to pay the cost orders against him. Therefore the applicant seeks that the 23 March 2020 court orders stand and remain force. (See attached documents)That order, as was made by consent, is that:7. The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs:a. of the Commonwealth’s Application; andb. that have been thrown away as a result of the filing of the Further Amended Statement of Claim;such costs to be paid on a party-party basis, to be taxed in default of agreement and to otherwise be stayed until the determination or resolution of the proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Responding to paragraph 21 of the Applicant’s submissions, the Commonwealth submits:(e) Rule 40.51(1) of the Rules contemplates an order for maximum costs, but none is sought. Mr Scholes’ reliance on an exception to that rule – r 40.51(2)(d) – in support of his costs submissions misconstrues the framework of the Rules, and, in any case, does not support any alternative order. Any concern is as to the quantum of any costs, the Court’s taxation processes will ensure any such quantum is appropriately calculated.CONSIDERATION The Commonwealth does not seek an alternative order to the Court’s costs order but notes that it “does not concede the two bases upon which the Court relied in excluding the costs of the trial”. The two bases referred to are the unfortunate event identified at [291] of the Court’s reasons where it refers to an unfortunate event involving “significant and cruel mockery of Mr Scholes” as he was attempting to cross-examine a witness; and the extensive cross-examination of the Applicant which the Court considered could not have served “as a sound foundation for the Commonwealth’s submission that Mr Scholes’ conduct warranted an adverse conclusion to be drawn as to his general credit.” However aside from those two issues, the Court is satisfied that the Commonwealth conducted the litigation in this proceeding in a manner which does not disentitle it to its prima facie entitlement to its costs. The Commonwealth did not ultimately press its presumptive entitlement to strike out the Applicant’s earlier manifestly challenging pleadings. It cooperated in reaching agreement with the Applicant to an agreed list of issues for the trial to be conducted. The Commonwealth was also prepared and did put in place arrangements to facilitate the Applicant’s witnesses resident in Nigeria to give evidence at trial. That those witnesses did not present to give evidence does not diminish the Court’s appreciation of the extra lengths that the Commonwealth was prepared to go to enable the Applicant to advance his case. Nothing in those regards was inconsistent with the Commonwealth’s duty as a model litigant. The Court is not unsympathetic to the personal position of the Applicant. As the reasons in the principal judgment indicate I accept that the Applicant suffered extreme stress following his kidnapping and later came to believe firmly that the circumstances of his return from Ilero to Lagos were those that he gave truthful evidence of. As the Court noted at [217]:…I am satisfied Mr Scholes gave evidence in this proceeding consistently with the truth as he recalled it. However that a witness believes his or her evidence is the truth does not compel a finding that the facts are as that witness recalls. Nonetheless it is self-evident that the Applicant persisted in advancing contentions the Court has regarded as implausible notwithstanding that in the course of this litigation he was on notice not only with respect to the sworn statements of a number of Commonwealth officials but also of contemporaneous documents of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade that should have revealed to him that his memory recall might not be accepted by the Court as the truth of those circumstances.