Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2022] FCAFC 132

Appeal from: Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia [2021] FCA 1593
File number: VID 7 of 2022
Judgment of: LOGAN, KATZMANN AND GOODMAN JJ
Date of judgment: 8 August 2022
Catchwords:

TORTS – tort of false imprisonment – where appellant was kidnapped in Nigeria and released after payment of ransom — where consular assistance provided for his safe return to Australia but appellant alleged that he was taken and held against his will — where appellant’s account contrary to accounts of all other witnesses at trial and inconsistent with contemporaneous records —whether in rejecting his account primary judge fell into appealable error

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE –  application to adduce further evidence on appeal – where after notice of appeal filed, subpoena issued to Commissioner of Australian Federal Police for production of telephone records and records produced, whether leave should be granted to appellant to tender those records

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – adjournment application – where, after production of the subpoenaed records, appellant applied for an adjournment of the appeal so he could issue further subpoenas, whether adjournment should be granted

Cases cited:

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 52
Date of hearing: 5 May 2022
Counsel for the Appellant: The appellant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr A M Dinelli with Ms Kearney
Solicitor for the Respondent: Maddocks Lawyers

ORDERS

VID 7 of 2022
BETWEEN:

ALISTAIR PETER SCHOLES

Appellant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

LOGAN, KATZMANN AND GOODMAN JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

8 AUGUST 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be fixed by a Registrar of the Court if not agreed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. It is uncontroversial that at Ibadan in Nigeria, on the evening of 28 November 2017 (West African time, as are all other times and dates mentioned below unless otherwise indicated), the appellant, Mr Alistair Peter Scholes and his fiancée, Ms Tayo Yusuf (Tayo), boarded the overnight bus to Abuja.  The bus departed about two hours behind schedule, at around 11:30pm. Mr Scholes and Tayo did not reach Abuja.  In the course of the journey the bus was stopped. Mr Scholes and Tayo were kidnapped by armed men.  They were held in the bush by their captors for eight days.  After a ransom was paid, they were released on 6 December 2017.

  2. In proceedings instituted in the Court’s original jurisdiction, Mr Scholes alleged that, from 7 to 10 December 2017, he was falsely imprisoned (at a Sheraton Hotel) and before  by servants or agents of the respondent Commonwealth after he rejected an offer of consular assistance made by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCAFC 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Scholes v Commonwealth of Australia, the appellant, Mr Scholes, sought to challenge the findings of the primary judge, who dismissed his claims of false imprisonment and negligence against the respondent, the Commonwealth. Mr Scholes was kidnapped in Nigeria and subsequently released after a ransom was paid. He alleged that he was held against his will despite the provision of consular assistance for his safe return to Australia. His account of the events was contradicted by other witnesses and inconsistent with contemporaneous records. The legal issues before the court included whether the primary judge erred in rejecting Mr Scholes' account and whether leave should be granted to tender subpoenaed telephone records and to adjourn the appeal to issue further subpoenas.

The court considered the diplomatic cables and evidence presented, highlighting the contingency planning by the Australian High Commission in Nigeria for Mr Scholes' anticipated release. The cables indicated that Mr Scholes was encouraged to leave Nigeria as soon as practicable but that it would ultimately be his decision. The court found that Mr Scholes' account was inconsistent with the diplomatic communications and the evidence of the High Commission staff. The court rejected the appeal, finding no appealable error in the primary judge's conclusions. The court also denied leave to tender the subpoenaed records and to adjourn the appeal, finding no justification for the adjournment.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be fixed by a Registrar of the Court if not agreed. This ruling underscores the importance of aligning personal accounts with contemporaneous records and the responsibilities of consular officers in ensuring the safety and security of Australian citizens abroad. The decision also highlights the court's cautious approach to applications for further evidence and adjournments on appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be fixed by a Registrar of the Court if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A diplomatic cable, sent by Ms Wilson on 6 December 2017 to DFAT in Canberra (“Update 11”), reveals that, by that date, the High Commission staff in Nigeria were developing contingency plans against various scenarios in relation to an anticipated release by the kidnappers of Mr Scholes and Toya to Kareem. In the cable Ms Wilson stated (at para 3): “Post's security provider Pilgrims is on stand-by, if the above scenarios fail to play out and/or Mr Scholes needs to be collected from a yet to be nominated location in South West Nigeria”. Significantly, having regard to the challenge by Mr Scholes to the conclusion reached by the primary judge, she added (para 8):Mr Scholes plans on his release are of course unknown. Post will strongly encourage Mr Scholes to leave as soon as practicable after his release, medical assessment/treatment and debrief with DSS, but it will ultimately be his decision.(Emphasis added.)“Post” is a reference to the Australian High Commission, Nigeria. The sentence emphasised above is inconsistent with the existence of any plan by, or intention of, DFAT officers resident in Nigeria for Mr Scholes to be held on his release against his will until his removal from Nigeria. This cable also reveals that detailed contingency planning was being undertaken within the High Commission in Nigeria in relation to an anticipated release of Mr Scholes and Toya. Mr Brian Taylor was the person undertaking the planning. Mr Taylor also gave evidence at the trial. In 2017 he held the role of Senior Administrative Officer (SAO) at the High Commission in Nigeria but by the time of trial he had retired. It was Mr Taylor who dealt directly with Pilgrims in relation to the planning for Mr Scholes’ anticipated release in the event that he required assistance. In this regard, Mr Taylor dealt with Mr Lemmer. A survey of the diplomatic cables in evidence also reveals that both DFAT staff and officers of the Australian Federal Police were at pains to advise Mr Scholes’ family in Australia of developments, his brother, Ian, in particular. These communications similarly reveal that a combination of the following factors told against the deployment of a member of the High Commission staff on a retrieval mission: the assessed personal security risk on any journey to and from where Mr Scholes was thought to be held and likely released; the need for Australian citizen High Commission personnel to maintain a presence at both the High Commission’s offices in the capital, Abuja, as well as in Lagos; and the small number of Australian citizen personnel staffing the High Commission. At the time, including the High Commissioner, the Deputy High Commissioner and the SAO, the total number of DFAT’s Australian citizen staff at the High Commission was five. In addition, there were a number of locally engaged support staff. The assessed personal security risk was high, especially the risk of kidnapping particularly if travelling at night. In a “Release Summary” email of 7 December 2017 to an officer of DFAT in Canberra, Ms Glenda Price (Release Summary), Ms Wilson reported:Post (DHOM) told CCD she spoke to Kareem at 0945 AEST 7 December (2145 local time 6 December). Language difficulties impeded communication and attempts to confirm Scholes current location were unsuccessful. At DHOMs request, Kareem passed the phone to Alistair Scholes, who told DHOM that he was “OK”. He planned to return to Mr Kareem’s village the next day. DHOM strongly discouraged him [from] this course of action and noted the need for him to ensure his ongoing security by returning safely to Lagos or Abuja. Scholes said he agreed and indicated he would go to Lagos. DHOM suggested that they (Post/Scholes) discuss ways to ensure his safe return to either city in the morning at 0830, once he had had the opportunity to rest.He agreed and indicated that he could be contacted on his own Nigerian mobile number. DHOM confirmed that the kidnappers had returned his phone. He responded in the affirmation, they (the kidnappers) had provided them with a number of phones. They had treated them well.He said he aware that he needed to provide information to DSS and AFP and asked DHOM if she knew where this would occur. DHOM repeated her concerns about ensuring his own and ongoing security. He noted that the driver in the car that had collected him and Toya Yusuf had been from DSS.On his general health, DHOM noted that Post could provide consular assistance with getting access to medical facilities in Abuja and Lagos. Scholes confirmed he was ‘ok’. DHOM asked if he still had his blood pressure medication with him. Scholes said it had been at the ‘front of the bus’ which had been ‘blown up’ and the driver killed. He made no reference to other victims.DHOM again noted that ensuring his own security going forward was essential – going to Mr Kareem’s village was not advisable. Scholes agreed to talk in the morning.“DHOM” refers to Ms Wilson, Deputy Head of Mission.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.