Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

SCHENSCHER v ADELAIDE MUSHROOMS (NOMINEES) PTY LTD

[2020] SASC 101

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bampton

16 June 2020

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

MAGISTRATES - COMMENCEMENT OF PROCEEDINGS - WITHDRAWAL, STRIKING OUT AND REINSTATEMENT OF INITIATING PROCESS - REINSTATEMENT

MAGISTRATES - COMMENCEMENT OF PROCEEDINGS - WITHDRAWAL, STRIKING OUT AND REINSTATEMENT OF INITIATING PROCESS - STRIKING OUT AND DISMISSAL OF PROCEEDINGS

Appeal against Magistrate’s refusal to set aside an order dismissing a claim for damages – where alleged cause of action arose in 2009 – where multiple applications for extension of time to serve the claim were filed – where no affidavit of service filed – where claim was dismissed for want of prosecution on 25 May 2015 – where claim reinstated on 27 April 2016 – where claim dismissed again on 28 September 2016 – where an application for reinstatement filed 10 April 2018 and served 10 months later – whether Magistrate erred in finding that reasonable excuse for not having complied with the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 or Court orders had not been established pursuant to r 87(2)(b) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 – whether exercise of judicial discretion miscarried.

HELD: Appeal dismissed – the delay in the prosecution of the claim is inordinate and inexcusable – no reasonable excuse for the delay has been established – the discretion prescribed by r 87(1) to set aside the order dismissing the claim has not been enlivened.

Magistrate Court (Civil) Rules 2013 (SA) r 28, r 87, referred to.
Williams v SF Evans & Sons (1988) 52 SASR 237; Maramidis v Germain [2017] SASC 103; In the matter of K-Bek Motors Pty Ltd [2017] NSWSC 183; Re: Harris Scarfe Ltd (in liq) & Harris Scarfe Wholesale P/L (in liq) [2006] SASC 277; Langanis v Roberts (Unreported, 15 July 1993, S4043), discussed.
Watson v Anderson (1976) 13 SASR 329; Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 139 ALR 1; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd [2020] SASC 19, considered.

SCHENSCHER v ADELAIDE MUSHROOMS (NOMINEES) PTY LTD
[2020] SASC 101

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

  1. BAMPTON J:     Over 11 years ago, on 15 February 2009, Beverley Schenscher alleges that she slipped on a mushroom and fell onto the ground landing on her buttocks (“the fall”).  At the time of the fall, Ms Schenscher was employed by Labour Contract Solutions Pty Ltd (“Labour Solutions”) and working as a mushroom picker at the premises of Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd (“Adelaide Mushrooms”).

  2. Ms Schenscher claims that as a result of the fall she suffered personal injuries (“the injuries”) and has been unable to work since August 2009.  She commenced a claim for damages in the Magistrates Court on 15 February 2012, just prior to the expiry of the limitation period, against Adelaide Mushrooms and Labour Solutions (“the claim”).

  3. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd, the appellant, Ms Schenscher, sought to appeal the decision of a magistrate to refuse her application to reinstate a claim for damages. The underlying cause of action dated back to 2009, and Ms Schenscher had made multiple applications for extensions of time to serve the claim. However, no affidavit of service was filed, and the claim was dismissed for want of prosecution on 25 May 2015. The claim was subsequently reinstated on 27 April 2016, only to be dismissed again on 28 September 2016. Ms Schenscher then applied for reinstatement on 10 April 2018, but the application was served 10 months later. Ms Schenscher contended that the magistrate had erred in finding that she had not established a reasonable excuse for not having complied with the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 2013 or the court orders, pursuant to r 87(2)(b) of the Rules, and that the exercise of judicial discretion had miscarried.

The legal issues before the court were whether the magistrate erred in finding that Ms Schenscher had not established a reasonable excuse for the delay in prosecuting the claim and whether the exercise of judicial discretion was miscarried. The court considered the matter by reference to the three periods of delay identified by Ms Schenscher's counsel. The court found that the delay in prosecuting the claim was inordinate and inexcusable, and no reasonable excuse for the delay had been established. Consequently, the discretion prescribed by r 87(1) to set aside the order dismissing the claim had not been enlivened.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed. The court held that the delay in prosecuting the claim was inordinate and inexcusable, and no reasonable excuse for the delay had been established. The discretion prescribed by r 87(1) to set aside the order dismissing the claim had not been enlivened. The court's fundamental duty was to do justice between the parties, and it was satisfied that the discretion should not be exercised. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the order dismissing the claim was upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 1 July 2019, Ms Schenscher filed a notice of appeal against the Magistrate’s dismissal of her application to reinstate the claim. A second notice of appeal was filed on 23 September 2019.Background Ms Schenscher first instructed Mason Westover Homburg in November 2010 regarding a common law and WorkCover action in respect of the injuries. In an affidavit sworn 9 May 2019 Philip Westover, now a solicitor at Tindall Gask Bentley, deposed that throughout the 2000s Mason Westover Homburg had a relationship with the firm Johnston Withers whereby Johnston Withers provided advice and assistance in WorkCover matters and personal injury matters. Ms Schenscher’s WorkCover claim form was lodged on 23 June 2011 and the claim was filed on 15 February 2012 by Johnston Withers as agent for Mason Westover Homburg. On 21 January 2013, the Magistrates Court Registry sent Ms Schenscher’s solicitors a notice of intent to inactivate action.First ex parte application (13 February 2013) On 13 February 2013, Ms Schenscher made an ex parte application for an extension of time of six months to serve the claim. In the affidavit filed in support sworn 12 February 2013, a solicitor employed by Johnston Withers deposed that: workers compensation claim involving both the first and second defendants concluded in mid 2012. … the plaintiff has recently completed a formulated claim to be forwarded to the Defendants for their consideration … We seek a further six months to serve … The plaintiff is hopeful that an informal conference may be convened in the near future and that the matter may be resolved” On 14 February 2013, Magistrate Gumpl granted the 13 February 2013 ex parte application.Second ex parte application (12 August 2013) On 12 August 2013, Ms Schenscher filed an ex parte application seeking a further six months to serve the claim. In the affidavit in support sworn 12 August 2013, Ms Schenscher’s solicitor who was employed by Johnston Withers and acted as an agent for Mason Westover Homburg (“the solicitor” or “Ms Schenscher’s solicitor”) repeated matters deposed to by his colleague in the affidavit sworn 12 February 2013 filed in support of the first ex parte application. Over the course of this matter, the solicitor has been employed by Johnston Withers, Maurice Blackburn, and Grope Hamilton whilst acting for Ms Schenscher as an agent for Mason Westover Homburg. On 13 August 2013, Magistrate Eldridge granted Ms Schenscher’s ex parte application for a further six-month extension to serve the claim. On 17 February 2014, the Magistrates Court Registry sent a second notice of intent to inactivate action.Third ex parte application (12 February 2014) On 12 February 2014, Ms Schenscher filed an ex parte application for an extension of time to serve the claim. In the affidavit sworn 12 February 2014 filed in support, the solicitor deposed that Ms Schenscher:… had some difficulties in being able to fund the purchase of up to date medical evidence.The Workcover insurer has arranged for appointments coming up in the next two months after which time it will be possible to complete the formulated claim with up to date medical evidence which there has been a delay in obtaining.The other issue that has arisen is that in May 2013 the defendant may have gone into liquidation and we are ascertaining the status of the company whether it is going to be necessary to take out an application to seek leave to proceed and to ascertain the identity of the appropriate insurer behind the company via the administrator.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At [42] of her reasons, the Magistrate commented that Ms Schenscher may not be without remedy. Counsel for Adelaide Mushrooms submitted on appeal that in the circumstances of the inordinate unexplained delay in this matter that the remedy is not against the proposed defendant in the claim sought to be reinstated but rather the solicitors responsible for the want of prosecution.Conclusion I dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Adelaide Mushrooms reiterated on appeal that it would suffer actual prejudice if the claim were reinstated.Consideration The Court’s discretion to set aside or vary a judgment (not being a final judgment) prescribed by r 87(1) is not enlivened until Ms Schenscher establishes that she has both an arguable case on the merits and a reasonable excuse for not having complied with the Rules, or an order of the Court, or any time limit fixed by the Rules or order of the Court, in respect of the claim. In determining this matter the fundamental duty of the Court is to do justice between the parties. If I am satisfied that that the discretion should be exercised, I will make an order setting aside the 28 September 2016 order dismissing the claim and then make an order reinstating it. In assessing whether Ms Schenscher has a reasonable excuse for the failure to comply with the Rules and the inordinate delay in the prosecution of this matter, I need to consider whether the excuse given is one which in all the circumstances the ordinary person would consider warrants forgiveness for non‑compliance. As Hinton J said in Maramidis v Germain:[9]As to rule 87(2)(b), a reasonable excuse is one which in all circumstances the ordinary person would consider warrants forgiveness for non-compliance. Here it is necessarily the case that the ordinary person will appreciate the high premium that the community places upon compliance with rules of courts and orders of courts in order that justice be administered effectively and efficiently. That appreciation reflects an understanding of the importance to the functioning of the community of the effective and efficient exercise of judicial power to quell controversies arising in the community. With this understanding, the community, no less than the courts, expects litigants to discharge the obligations placed upon them by the law and the courts.[9] [2017] SASC 103 at [83]. It is not in dispute that Ms Schenscher has an arguable case. In determining whether she has a reasonable excuse for the inordinate delay and the failure to comply with the Rules, I will consider the issue by reference to the three periods of delay identified by her counsel.The first period of delay – 15 February 2012 to December 2015 Ms Schenscher maintained that during this period following the issuing of the claim, the matter was in abeyance whilst she was awaiting the outcome of the WorkCover claim. Ms Schenscher deposed in her affidavit 14 May 2019 that “The WorkCover claim ran from about 2010, possibly into 2015 when I received compensation”. It is to be noted that during this period eight applications for extension of time were made and the claim was dismissed on 25 May 2015. The solicitor in support of the various applications for extension of time to serve:·deposed in an affidavit sworn 12 August 2013 that Ms Schenscher had completed a formulated claim to be forwarded to the defendants.·deposed in an affidavit sworn 12 February 2014 that:The Workcover insurer has arranged for appointments coming up in the next two months after which time it will be possible to complete the formulated claim with up to date medical evidence which there has been a delay in obtaining.The other issue that has arisen is that in May 2013 the defendant may have gone into liquidation and we are ascertaining the status of the company whether it is going to be necessary to take out an application to seek leave to proceed and to ascertain the identity of the appropriate insurer behind the company via the administrator.·is recorded in the Court record as having assured a Magistrate on 3 March 2014 “that the employer of the plaintiff is on notice of the claim”. It is also recorded in the record dated 3 March 2014 that “it is possible that the name of the defendant may need to be amended”.·in an affidavit sworn 8 May 2014 deposed that “both defendants have notice of the claim”.·in an affidavit sworn 29 January 2015 that Mr Moffatt had informed him that the registered office of Adelaide Mushrooms was vacant and devoid of signage. Further, in his email to the solicitor, annexed to the affidavit, Mr Moffatt said he had undertaken searches that revealed that the two accountancy firms that had previously occupied 77 Palmer Place and had moved to an address on Greenhill Road. Mr Moffatt stated that he was able to follow this up if necessary, but that it was too early to do so. (I infer, noting the email was sent at 7.40 am, that he meant it was too early in the morning to follow up that line of inquiry).·in an affidavit sworn 27 February 2015 that Adelaide Mushrooms had not been served due to its registered office being vacant.