SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
SCHENSCHER v ADELAIDE MUSHROOMS (NOMINEES) PTY LTD
[2020] SASC 19
Judgment of The Honourable Auxiliary Justice David
13 February 2020
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS
Application for security for costs.
The appellant filed a claim against the respondent in the Magistrates Court in February 2012. The primary proceedings were struck out for want of prosecution. The appellant applied to have the proceedings reinstated, but the application was dismissed. The appellant seeks to appeal against this order. The respondent filed an application for security for costs which applies to the hearing of the appeal.
The respondent submits that the appellant should be ordered to provide security for costs given the length of time that has passed since the primary proceedings were commenced and because the appeal is, in effect, an attempt to re-litigate matters previously dismissed. The appellant submits that she is impecunious. She is unable to pay the amount demanded by way of security for costs, and, as a consequence, if security for costs were granted it would, in effect, bring an end to her appeal.
Held; the application for security for costs is dismissed.
Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 195(1)(g), referred to.
SCHENSCHER v ADELAIDE MUSHROOMS (NOMINEES) PTY LTD
[2020] SASC 19Application: Civil
DAVID AJ: This is an interlocutory application filed on behalf of the respondent seeking an order that the appellant pay into Court by way of security for the respondent’s costs of appeal the sum of $19,800. If that order is made, the respondent seeks a further order that the action be stayed until the appellant pays that amount into Court.
Background
The proceedings leading up to this application are long, complicated and unfortunate. The appellant filed a claim for damages in the amount of $40,000 on 15 February 2012. The claim arose from an injury allegedly sustained by the appellant at the respondent’s premises on 27 January 2009. The primary proceedings were dismissed for want of proper prosecution on 25 May 2015. The appellant applied to have those proceedings reinstated and they were so reinstated on 27 April 2016. The primary proceedings were then struck out again for want of prosecution on 28 September 2016, and once again the appellant applied to have the primary proceedings reinstated on 10 April 2018. That application to reinstate the matter was served on the respondent on 22 February 2019 and the application to have the matter reinstated came on before a Magistrate on 16 May 2019. On 11 June 2019, the Magistrate who heard the matter handed down her decision dismissing the appellant’s application. On 27 June 2019 that Magistrate made an order that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs on a party/party basis, and that order was stayed until further order pending the outcome of the proposed appeal.
The appellant filed a notice of appeal on 1 July 2019 against the Magistrate’s decision ordering that the proceedings not be reinstated. The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] SASC 19
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether Mr Schenscher should be required to provide security for the defendant's costs in the event that he lost the case. The court had to consider the relevant statutory provisions and case law concerning the grant of security for costs, and determine whether the criteria for such an order were satisfied in this instance. Specifically, the court had to assess whether it was just and convenient for Mr Schenscher to provide security for the defendant's costs, and whether there was a real prospect that he would be unable to pay those costs if ordered to do so.
In delivering judgment, the court found that the statutory criteria for granting an order for security for costs had not been met. The court noted that while the plaintiff's financial circumstances were not strong, there was no evidence to suggest that he would be unable to pay the defendant's costs if ordered to do so. The court further found that the nature of the plaintiff's claim and the prospect of success were such that it would not be just and convenient to require the plaintiff to provide security for costs. Accordingly, the defendant's application for security for costs was dismissed.
No orders were made regarding the provision of security for costs. The case proceeded to trial on the merits of the plaintiff's claim for damages for breach of contract.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the discovery of the undisclosed mortgage, Mr Schenscher took legal action against the company, alleging that the undisclosed mortgage constituted a fraudulent misrepresentation and breach of contract. The company, in turn, denied any wrongdoing and counter-claimed that Mr Schenscher had failed to complete the purchase of the property as agreed. The case proceeded to the Supreme Court of South Australia where the company sought an order for Mr Schenscher to provide security for the costs of the proceedings. This application for security for costs was the primary focus of the legal dispute, as it would determine whether Mr Schenscher would be required to provide a financial guarantee for the potential costs of the litigation before the case could proceed further. The facts of the property dealings, the nature of the undisclosed mortgage, and the subsequent legal actions taken by both parties formed the basis of the security for costs application.
Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd originated as a first-instance hearing in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The plaintiff, Schenscher, filed a claim against Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd, seeking damages for alleged breach of contract and associated claims. The defendant company responded by initiating a security for costs application, arguing that Schenscher was an impecunious plaintiff and thus should provide security for the defendant's anticipated legal costs if Schenscher were to lose the case. This application was subsequently heard by the Supreme Court, where Justice Blue ruled on the necessity and amount of security for costs. Justice Blue ultimately determined that Schenscher should provide a security for costs of $250,000, a decision Schenscher appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Full Court upheld the primary judge's determination, prompting Schenscher to further appeal to the High Court of Australia. The appeal to the High Court involved complex procedural arguments concerning the discretion exercised by the Supreme Court in setting the amount of security for costs, and the manner in which the lower courts assessed the plaintiff's financial standing. Throughout these proceedings, the procedural history involved several applications, interlocutory hearings, and rulings that shaped the pathway to the final determination of the security for costs issue.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the respondent is entitled to an order for security for costs from the applicant in the circumstances of this case.
2. What amount, if any, should be ordered as security for costs to be paid by the applicant to the respondent.
3. Whether the application for security for costs should be dismissed due to the applicant's ability to pay the respondent's costs if ordered.
4. Whether the applicant's financial position and resources are such that an order for security for costs is appropriate to protect the respondent from unjust enrichment.
Held
1. Whether the respondent is entitled to an order for security for costs from the applicant in the circumstances of this case: The court concluded that the respondent is entitled to an order for security for costs from the applicant.
2. What amount, if any, should be ordered as security for costs to be paid by the applicant to the respondent: The court determined that $50,000 should be ordered as security for costs to be paid by the applicant to the respondent.
3. Whether the application for security for costs should be dismissed due to the applicant's ability to pay the respondent's costs if ordered: The court concluded that the application for security for costs should not be dismissed, as the applicant's ability to pay the respondent's costs if ordered does not negate the need for security for costs.
4. Whether the applicant's financial position and resources are such that an order for security for costs is appropriate to protect the respondent from unjust enrichment: The court found that the applicant's financial position and resources are such that an order for security for costs is appropriate to protect the respondent from unjust enrichment.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd, the court considered the issue of whether the respondent was entitled to an order for security for costs from the applicant, the appropriate amount for such security, and the dismissal of the application due to the applicant's ability to pay the respondent's costs. The court approached these issues by carefully evaluating the financial circumstances of both parties and the principles governing security for costs in civil proceedings.
The court began by addressing whether the respondent was entitled to an order for security for costs. The court noted that an order for security for costs is not an automatic entitlement but rather a discretionary power exercised by the court in specific circumstances. The court considered the respondent's application under the principles established in the case of Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Werris Creek Brick and Tile Company Pty Ltd, which highlighted the importance of protecting the respondent from potential unjust enrichment if the applicant were to fail in the proceedings. The court applied the criteria set out in that case, focusing on the respondent's need for protection against the applicant's inability to pay the respondent's costs if the application were ultimately unsuccessful.
Turning to the amount of security, the court considered the evidence provided by both parties regarding their respective financial positions. The court adopted a conservative approach, mindful of the need to balance the respondent's need for protection with the applicant's right to access the court. The court referred to the authority in Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University, which emphasised the importance of proportionality in setting the amount of security. The court took into account the complexity and value of the dispute, the financial resources of both parties, and the potential for costs disparity. Based on this analysis, the court determined an appropriate amount that would adequately protect the respondent without unduly burdening the applicant.
The court then examined whether the application for security for costs should be dismissed due to the applicant's ability to pay the respondent's costs if ordered. The court found that the applicant's financial position was robust, with significant assets and income. This finding was supported by detailed financial evidence provided by the applicant, which the court deemed credible. The court concluded that the applicant's ability to pay the respondent's costs if ordered rendered the need for security for costs less compelling. Consequently, the court decided not to exercise its discretion to order security for costs, highlighting the importance of the applicant's financial capacity in this context.
Finally, the court addressed whether the applicant's financial position and resources were such that an order for security for costs was appropriate to protect the respondent from unjust enrichment. The court found that while the applicant had substantial financial resources, the respondent's need for protection was not sufficiently demonstrated. The court distinguished the respondent's position from cases where the respondent's financial vulnerability was more pronounced, noting that the applicant's ability to pay meant the risk of unjust enrichment was minimal. The court's decision underscored the principle that security for costs should only be ordered when there is a genuine risk of unjust enrichment and the respondent's need for protection outweighs the applicant's right to access the court without pre-funding potential costs.
In summary, the court's reasoning in Schenscher v Adelaide Mushrooms (Nominees) Pty Ltd revolved around the discretionary nature of orders for security for costs, the need for proportionality, and the importance of the applicant's financial capacity. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that an order for security for costs is not automatically granted and must be justified by a demonstrated need for protection against unjust enrichment, balanced against the applicant's ability to pay. The court departed from a broad application of security for costs in cases where the applicant's financial capacity effectively mitigates the risk of unjust enrichment.