Sartori v BM2008 Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sartori v BM2008 Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1160

Citation: Sartori v BM2008 Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1160
Parties: GARY JAMES SARTORI v BM2008 PTY LTD (ACN 005 762 685), PFL PROPERTIES PTY LTD (ACN 005 572 789), IAN DAVID WALLIS AND ROSS DELAHUNTY AS EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE WALTER RUTHERFORD MCCARTER (DECEASED), IAN DAVID WALLIS AND ROSS DELAHUNTY AS EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE BARRY HENRY LADD (DECEASED) and MAURICE AUSTIN MACKENZIE
File number: WAD 299 of 2008
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 27 October 2010
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – joinder of parties – principles to be applied – amendment of application and statement of claim - costs
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 175, 232, 233
Federal Court Rules O 6 r 8
Companies Act 1961 (Vic) reg 41 to Table A
Cases cited: Re BM2008 Pty Ltd (in liq) [2010] VSC 337
Campbells Cash and Carry Pty Ltd v Fostif Pty Ltd (2006) 229 CLR 386
Grant v John Grant & Sons Pty Ltd (1950) 82 CLR 1
John Cooke & Co Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (1922) 31 CLR 394
Re Kenneth Wright Distributors Pty Ltd (in liq); WJ Vine Pty Ltd v Paul [1973] VR 161
McIntyre v Gye and Another (1994) 51 FCR 472
Mijac Investments Pty Ltd v Graham (No 2) (2009) 72 ACSR 684
Poulton v The Commonwealth (1952) 89 CLR 540
Sartori v BM2008 Pty Ltd (ACN 005 762 685) [2009] FCA 467
Three Rivers DC v Bank of England (No.1) [1996] QB 292
Re Trade Practices Commission v Milreis Pty Ltd; Ex parte Thomson Publications (Aust) Pty Ltd (1978) 18 ALR 17
Trendtex Trading Corporation v Credit Suisse [1982] AC 679
TS & B Retail Systems Pty Ltd v 3Fold Resources Pty Ltd (No 3) (2007) 158 FCR 444
Wardley Australia Ltd v Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514
Whyked Pty Ltd t/as Ezysend v Yahoo Australia and New Zealand Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 650
Date of hearing: 20 August 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 64
Counsel for the Applicant: D Denton with L Watts
Solicitor for the Applicant: Belleli King & Associates
Counsel for Mr Small: R Harrison
Solicitor for Mr Small: Tottle Partners
Counsel for the First Respondent: GD Cobby
Solicitor for the First Respondents: Maddocks
Counsel for the Second to Fifth Respondents: GM Abbott
Solicitor for the Second to Fifth Respondents: Obst Legal

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 299 of 2008

BETWEEN:

GARY JAMES SARTORI
Applicant

AND:

BM2008 PTY LTD (ACN 005 762 685)
First Respondent

PFL PROPERTIES PTY LTD (ACN 005 572 789)
Second Respondent

IAN DAVID WALLIS AND ROSS DELAHUNTY AS EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE WALTER RUTHERFORD MCCARTER (DECEASED)
Third Respondent

IAN DAVID WALLIS AND ROSS DELAHUNTY AS EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE BARRY HENRY LADD (DECEASED)
Fourth Respondent

MAURICE AUSTIN MACKENZIE
Fifth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sartori v BM2008 Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1160
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sartori v BM2008 Pty Ltd (No 2) involves a dispute concerning the validity of the appointment of liquidators and the enforcement of a judgment against certain applicants. The applicant, Mr. Sartori, argues that the liquidators of the company, BM2008 Pty Ltd, were not lawfully appointed and, therefore, lacked the authority to act as liquidators. This includes their actions in commencing an arbitration, entering a judgment in the Supreme Court of Victoria, issuing a bankruptcy notice, and serving a statutory demand. Sartori contends that these actions were unlawful and seeks to have the judgment set aside and the shares issued in contravention of regulations voided.

The legal issues before the court included whether the proposed additional respondents should be joined as applicants and whether the existing applicants should be permitted to amend their application and statement of claim. The court had to consider principles governing the joinder of parties, particularly under Order 6 Rule 8 of the Federal Court Rules, and assess whether the joinder was necessary to effectually and completely determine the matters in dispute. The court also had to examine arguments against the relief raised by the respondents concerning delay, limitation expiry, capacity, and abuse of process.

The court found that the joinder of the proposed additional respondents was appropriate as their interests would be directly affected by any orders made in the proceeding. The court granted leave for the proposed additional respondents to be joined as applicants and for the existing applicants to amend their application and statement of claim. The court further ruled that the costs of the motion be in the cause, meaning that the applicants would bear the costs unless any party made submissions to the contrary within 14 days. The detailed examination of the evidence concerning the respondents' arguments was reserved for a later stage in the proceedings.

The final orders of the court included adding Steve Iliopoulos, Perth Freightlines Pty Ltd, and VFS Group Pty Ltd as applicants to the proceeding, permitting the joinder of certain respondents, granting leave to amend the application and statement of claim, and determining that the costs of the motion be in the cause unless contrary submissions were made within 14 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Steve Iliopoulos, Perth Freightlines Pty Ltd ACN 129 516 990 and VFS Group Pty Ltd ACN 121 880 751 all of 41 Buchanan Road, Brooklyn, Victoria be added as applicants to this proceeding.

2. The applicants have leave to join as respondents to this proceeding Dianne Margaret Cox, Wallis Securities Pty Ltd, Tony Kosovic, Arthur William Ransom, Neil Warren, Hugh Young, Janet Irene Napier, Kevin Joseph Small and Robert Ivan Guthrie.

3. Leave to amend the application and leave to amend the statement of claim is granted in accordance with the minute.

4. Costs of the motion be in the cause.

5. Any party wishing to make submissions to the contrary of costs being in the cause must file and serve the submissions within 14 days, failing which the costs order will stand.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The consequence of that insofar as the current state of affairs of the Company, being in liquidation, are concerned is said to be as follows:46 Further, in the premises, the Purported Liquidators:46.1 were never lawfully appointed as liquidators of [the Company];46.2 never had any statutory powers to so act as liquidators;46.3 never had the lawful authority to cause [the Company]:46.3.1to commence and prosecute a commercial arbitration against the Second, Third and Fourth Applicants;46.3.2to apply for and then enter judgment in the Supreme Court of Victoria on 19 November 2009 in proceeding No 9483 of 2009 (“the judgment”) for the sum of the final award by the Hon W Gillard QC against the Second, Third and Fourth Applicants;46.3.3to issue a bankruptcy notice dated 22 December 2009 against the Fourth Applicant based upon the judgment;46.3.4to serve a statutory demand dated 22 December 2009 on the Second and third Applicants based upon the judgment;46.3.5to otherwise seek to enforce the judgment. 47Further in the premises the judgment was entered against the second, third and fourth applicants by [the Company] unlawfully and the judgment is entitled to be set aside by the second, third and fourth applicants. It follows, accordingly, Mr Sartori argues, that he is entitled to a declaration that the shares issued in contravention of reg 41 are void on the basis of Grant v John Grant & Sons Pty Ltd (1950) 82 CLR 1 at 29. Secondly and, alternatively, relief is sought under s 232 and 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (CA) in relation to the directors’ duties and an order under s 233 for the cancellation of the shares issued in contravention of reg 41. Relief sought in a proposed amended application also includes a claim under s 175 CA which provides as follows:175 Correction of registers(1)A company or registered scheme or a person aggrieved may apply to the Court to have a register kept by the company or scheme under this Part corrected.(2)If the Court orders the company or scheme to correct the register, it may also order the company or scheme to compensate a party to the application for loss or damage suffered.(3)If:(a)the Court orders a company or scheme to correct its register of members; and(b)the company or scheme has lodged a list of its members with ASIC;the company or scheme must lodge notice of the correction with ASIC.The assignee applicants The reason for the joinder of the assignee applicants is that they seek the benefit of the assignment to them of Mr Sartori’s rights. Mr Sartori is the registered shareholder bringing (and remaining in) the proceeding to pursue the complaints about the conduct of the former board and the effect it had on his then shareholding. The proposed assignee applicants were the purchasers of the major asset of the Company, a national trucking business. They declined to make payment for the purchase giving rise to an arbitration to resolve a dispute between the Company and the purchasers. The arbitration was resolved adversely to the purchasers and the arbitration judgment registered. The argument is that there was no power on the part of the purported liquidators to act as liquidators, to commence an arbitration against the second, third and fourth proposed applicants; nor to have judgment under such an arbitration registered; nor to issue a bankruptcy notice; nor to serve a statutory demand; nor otherwise to seek orders to enforce the judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Sartori says that the liquidators are holding some $5 million in cash together with other assets. If the applicants are successful in increasing their shareholding percentage from 2.7% to 25%, they anticipate receiving 25% of the assets. They contend that the assets are in the order of $11-$12 million. CONSIDERATIONThe principles Order 6 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules (FCR) provides as follows:8 Addition of parties(1) Where a person who is not a party:(a)ought to have been joined as a party; or(b)is a person whose joinder as a party is necessary to ensure that all matters in dispute in the proceeding may be effectually and completely determined and adjudicated upon;the Court may order that the person be added as a party and make orders for the further conduct of the proceeding.(2)A person shall not be added as an applicant without the person’s consent. Joinder is sought of the proposed additional respondents as they are members of the Company whose shareholding would be adversely affected by the relief sought in the proposed amended statement of claim. Where all of the proposed additional respondents have property interests that will be impacted in the same way by the applicants’ claim, it is appropriate for all the parties related to the one subject matter to be dealt with at one time: John Cooke & Co Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (1922) 31 CLR 394 at 411. The appropriate tests for considering in joinder is whether the applicants’ rights against or liabilities to any party to the action in respect of the subject matter of the action be directly affected by any order which may be made in the action (Re Trade Practices Commission v Milreis Pty Ltd; Ex parte Thomson Publications (Aust) Pty Ltd (1978) 18 ALR 17). If Mr Sartori and/or the proposed applicants are entitled to pursue the proceeding, then the principles in those authorities would require that the prospective respondents be joined as their interests would most certainly be affected. Opposition to the relief Arguments against the relief have been raised by the first respondent (to which I will refer as the liquidator respondent) and the remaining respondents (to whom I will refer as the director respondents). Those arguments go to issues concerning delay, limitation expiry, capacity and abuse of process. To consider the arguments it will be necessary to examine the evidence in closer detail. Before doing so, however, it must be said that Mr Sartori has pursued this proceeding in a most languid fashion until recently. That said, there are some reasons for the delay. As noted, on 28 November 2009, Mr Sartori sold his shares in the Company and purported to assign various causes of action to the proposed assignee applicants. A deed entered into on that date was supplemented by a collateral deed in April 2010 which was between the same parties which confirmed the scope of the original assignment. However, the Company is in voluntary liquidation. The share transfer was submitted to the liquidators (as there can be no transfer without the approval of the liquidator). The liquidators declined to register the transfer unless the judgment debt owing by the assignee applicants to the Company was first paid.