Sarah Morgan (a pseudonym) v Public Trustee and Guardian (Appeal)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

SARAH MORGAN (A PSEUDONYM) v PUBLIC TRUSTEE AND GUARDIAN (Appeal) [2022] ACAT 105

AA 61/2021 (XD 590/2021)

Catchwords:               APPEAL – civil dispute – negligent disposal of goods – principles for assessing loss – loss assessed as value of goods at time of disposal – value of goods as used goods – Tribunal may rely on own knowledge – Original Tribunal misapplied principles – Appeal Tribunal must conduct real review applying correct principles and own knowledge

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 79

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 180

Cases cited:Butler v Egg & Egg Pulp Marketing Board (1966) 114 CLR 185

Dodd Properties Ltd v Canterbury City Council [1980] 1 WLR
433
Excel Intelligent Pty Ltd v Thomson [2018] ACAT 4
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499
Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351
Livingstone v Rawyards Coal Co (1880) 5 App Cas 25
Mansour v Dangar [2017] ACAT 49
Morgan v Public Trustee and Guardian [2021] ACAT 102
The Clyde (1856) Swab 23
Zheng v Crane & Anor [2022] ACAT 70

Tribunal:Presidential Member MT Daniel

Senior Member J Lennard

Date of Orders:  15 December 2022

Date of Reasons for Decision:      15 December 2022

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AA 61/2021

BETWEEN:

SARAH MORGAN (A PSEUDONYM)

Appellant

AND:

PUBLIC TRUSTEE AND GUARDIAN

Respondent

APPEAL TRIBUNAL:        Presidential Member MT Daniel

Senior Member J Lennard

DATE:15 December 2022

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The pseudonyms used for the applicant and her sister in the decision appealed from continue to apply, and there is to be no publication of the name of the applicant or her sister in relation to this proceeding.

  2. Order 1 of the Orders of 25 October 2021 is set aside and replaced with the following order:

    (a)The respondent is to pay to the applicant the sum of $2,095 within 28 days.

………………………………..

Presidential Member MT Daniel
For and on behalf of the Tribunal

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 25 October 2021 the tribunal (Original Tribunal) ordered the Public Trustee and Guardian (PTG) to pay to the applicant the sum of $545.[1],[2] It made those orders because it was satisfied that the PTG had breached the duty that it owed to the applicant by allowing the disposal of goods that the applicant was entitled to.

    [2] The names of the applicant and the applicant’s sister appear as pseudonyms in the reasons of the Original Tribunal, we have maintained that approach in these reasons for decision.

  2. The applicant appealed from that decision on the basis that the amount of compensation awarded was inadequate. She argued that the goods disposed of had a purchase price of around $3,535 and that the Original Tribunal had erred in the way it quantified her loss. Before the Original Tribunal she had sought an order for compensation in the amount of 90% of $3,535 (i.e. $3,181.50)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sarah Morgan (a pseudonym) v Public Trustee and Guardian (Ap... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] ACAT 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sarah Morgan, under a pseudonym, appealed a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning a claim against the Public Trustee and Guardian (PTG) for negligent disposal of goods. The dispute arose from the PTG's failure to return personal property belonging to Morgan and her sister Nadine, which was disposed of by the Commissioner for Social Housing (Housing ACT) after the PTG surrendered a lease on Nadine's rental property. The AAT found that the PTG had breached its duty to Morgan by not affording her a reasonable opportunity to retrieve the personal property. The primary legal issue before the court was the assessment of damages for the loss of the goods. Specifically, the court had to determine the appropriate valuation date for the goods and the applicable discount for their used condition at the time of disposal.

The court considered that the original tribunal had erred in its assessment of the loss by not applying the correct principles. The tribunal should have used the date of disposal as the valuation date, and applied a discount for the used condition of the goods. The court noted that the tribunal had misapplied the principles by not considering the condition of the goods at the time of disposal and had failed to conduct a real review of the evidence and apply the correct principles. The tribunal's reliance on new values for the goods, rather than their used values at the time of disposal, was deemed incorrect. The court concluded that the tribunal should have used its own knowledge and the evidence before it to determine the appropriate discount for the used condition of the goods. The tribunal's error in principle warranted a full review of the decision.

The court set aside the original tribunal's order and substituted it with an order that the PTG pay Morgan $2,095 within 28 days, reflecting the correct assessment of damages based on the used value of the goods at the time of disposal. The court emphasized the importance of tribunals applying the correct principles and conducting a real review of the evidence when assessing damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The pseudonyms used for the applicant and her sister in the decision appealed from continue to apply, and there is to be no publication of the name of the applicant or her sister in relation to this proceeding.

2.

Order 1 of the Orders of 25 October 2021 is set aside and replaced with the following order:

(a) The respondent is to pay to the applicant the sum of $2,095 within 28 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Where factual errors are asserted, and the application of incorrect principles which are material to the decision is conceded, a full review of the decision must be conducted. Indeed, it is not possible to know what is within the reasonable exercise of discretion without first considering whether the contested factual findings were available on the evidence, and then applying the correct principles to those findings. We have proceeded to undertake that task below.What loss has the applicant suffered, on the evidence available to the Original Tribunal? The applicant asserted – and it was not disputed – that the goods were purchased around the time that Nadine moved into the property in around early April 2019. The applicant asserted that Nadine moved out of the premises around 7 May 2019 (the Original Tribunal did not make a clear finding on this point) and the Original Tribunal found that the property was disposed of around 20 October 2020. There being no submission from either party[14] that the value of the items should be assessed at anything other than the date of breach, the date of disposal of the items – somewhere between 13 and 20 October 2020 – would ordinarily be relied upon as the relevant date for valuation purposes. The Original Tribunal did not at the hearing or in its reasons note any circumstances which justified a departure from the norm, nor were we able to identify any such factors which would lead to a different date of assessment of loss. The date of disposal should be used as the date at which the value of the items is assessed.[14] Either before the Original Tribunal or on the appeal The evidence before the Original Tribunal relevant to assessment of the value of the goods at the time of their disposal consisted of:(a)the applicant’s investigations of purchase price (new) for like goods dated early – mid 2021;(b)evidence of the applicant as to the condition of the goods, and extent to which they had been used, at the time of disposal in October 2020;(c)submissions/evidence by the applicant that in her view overall the value of the disposed goods was around 90% of the ‘as new’ purchase price;(d)photographs of the goods in situ in the vacated premises, some still in their original packaging or shopping bag. The transcript discloses that at the conclusion of the hearing the Original Tribunal raised the question of the use of new values with the applicant as follows:SENIOR MEMBER: …if it turned out to be the case, that these items could be returned to you, that they hadn’t been disposed of, if they came back to you they wouldn’t be brand spanking new replacement value items, would they?APPLICANT: I agree with you but it would only be a small percentage of them being in use because she only stayed in the property for three weeks. So everything was brand new.…SENIOR MEMBER: Yes, just because they were bought 18 months plus ago doesn’t mean they’re brand new, does it, I mean if they haven’t been used?APPLICANT: Okay. Sure. So I don’t say – so you might, you know, you might lost 20 per cent but you wouldn’t lose 80 per cent. I mean, you know, everything was brand new, like it was brand spanking new. Everything. The whole lot and she only used it – she was only in there under four weeks….[15][15] Transcript of proceedings 24 September 2021, page 112

Decision

Reasons for decision

With these principles in mind, we turn to review the decision of the Original Tribunal.The decision of the Original Tribunal The Original Tribunal heard the application on 24 September 2021 and gave its decision with written reasons around four weeks later.[6][6] Morgan v Public Trustee and Guardian [2021] ACAT 102 The Original Tribunal found, and it was not disputed before us, that the PTG was at the relevant time appointed as guardian for the applicant’s sister Nadine. In performance of this statutory role the PTG surrendered a lease over premises that Nadine had been renting from the Commissioner for Social Housing (Housing ACT). Located within the premises was personal property which had been jointly purchased by the applicant and Nadine, to which Nadine had relinquished any claim. After returning the keys, the PTG authorised Housing ACT to dispose of any personal property remaining in the premises, despite being on notice that the applicant sought the return of the personal property. It transpired that Housing ACT disposed of the personal property. The Original Tribunal concluded that the PTG had not afforded the applicant a reasonable opportunity to retrieve the personal property and that in failing to do so it had breached the duty it owed to the applicant. In reaching this conclusion the Original Tribunal referred, among other things, to the general duty of care and diligence required to be exercised by a director of a corporation pursuant to section 180 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and concluded at paragraph 37:37 Given this, I find the respondent owed the applicant a duty to consider her interests on 9 October 2020 when it authorised Housing ACT to dispose of the items of furniture in the premises. I find it did not give those interests adequate attention. I find in doing so the PTG breached its corporate obligation to the applicant in that it failed to exercise the requisite care and diligence. … There was no cross-appeal by the PTG on the question of liability. However, before the Appeal Tribunal the PTG submitted that the Original Tribunal had been incorrect to rely upon section 180 of the Corporations Act as a source of the duty the PTG owed the applicant, because the word ‘corporation’ in that legislation does not include a corporation sole. We accept that submission. The damages application lodged by the applicant indicated that the claim was brought as a claim for compensation for negligence or another tort, and this was the claim that the PTG had responded to. The PTG on appeal did not dispute that the Original Tribunal was correct to find that the PTG owed a general duty of care to the applicant, which in the circumstances had been breached.The question of compensation It is clear from the transcript and the written reasons that the greater part of the hearing before the Original Tribunal on 24 September 2021 was focussed on the facts in issue around the disposal of the goods, and the question of the PTG’s legal liability.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established