Sanjiv v Coleman Greig Lawyers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Sanjiv v Coleman Greig Lawyers Pty Ltd [2025] NSWSC 528
Hearing dates: 26 September 2024, 7-8 April 2025 (hearing); 14, 23, 26 April 2025 (further submissions provided); 22 May 2025 (mention)
Date of orders: 26 May 2025
Decision date: 26 May 2025
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Meek J
Decision:

Summons dismissed.

Catchwords:

COSTS — Solicitor-client — Background — In late June 2018, Plaintiff confers with D2 (a solicitor) and engages D1 (D2’s law firm) to act for her in family law litigation, having previously engaged two prior firms of solicitors — D2 in the initial conference gives an estimate for work up until the next court listing (August 2018) and, from early August 2018 progressively over the next 9 months, gives further estimates by means of Family Law Rules Cost Notices — Proceedings fixed for final hearing in late April/early May 2019 and settled following negotiations at the hearing — 11 invoices rendered over 11 months totalling approximately $470,579 — First 7 invoices rendered during 2018 paid by mid-January 2019 and the 2019 invoices are at that time unpaid — Following the Family Court Orders, there are issues regarding payment of fees and enforcement of the orders — D1 ceases to act, sues for fees and obtains a default judgment against the plaintiff in the District Court — Subsequently plaintiff requests D1 to further act and D1 renders 2 further invoices for fees in July and August 2022 for approximately $12,286 — Matrimonial property sold and plaintiff authorises D1 to receive proceeds of sale to pay most of the outstanding fees — Plaintiff subsequently complains about amount of fees and disclosure

COSTS — Solicitor-client — Plaintiff (self-represented) commences proceedings and, prior to hearing, abandons relief seeking a declaration that costs agreements are void and invalid but presses orders requesting repayment of fees allegedly charged exorbitantly and without authorisation — Hearing is not completed on the allocated listing day — Shortly after the hearing is adjourned part heard, the plaintiff commences fresh proceedings attempting to re-instigate the abandoned relief — D1 named as the sole defendant in the fresh proceedings and seeks to have them summarily dismissed — Orders made in those proceedings dismissing that claim — On the resumed part heard hearing of these proceedings, the plaintiff presses claims for repayment and continues to raise issues regarding alleged inadequate disclosure of costs — Notwithstanding abandonment of claim that the costs agreement(s) are void and invalid, the (retained) claim for repayment of funds is essentially underpinned by various complaints of the plaintiff, including nondisclosure of total costs, inadequate disclosure of significant increases in costs, and assertions that D1 had agreed to act for a limited sum — Held, as repayment issue is premised on nondisclosure issues and other complaints, the Court ought to address those issues — Other issues including allegations of duress in respect of costs agreements and costs notices, allegations that that defendants guilty of contempt in failing to comply with Family…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sanjiv v Coleman Greig Lawyers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWSC 528
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sanjiv commenced proceedings against Coleman Greig Lawyers Pty Ltd (D1) and one of its solicitors (D2), seeking a declaration that the costs agreements between the parties were void and invalid, as well as orders for the repayment of fees allegedly charged without authorisation. The dispute arose from Sanjiv's engagement of D1 in family law litigation in June 2018, following two prior engagements with different firms of solicitors. D2 provided an initial estimate for work up until the next court listing in August 2018, and subsequently gave further estimates by means of Family Law Rules Cost Notices. Sanjiv paid the first seven invoices, but the later invoices were unpaid at the time of the final hearing in April/May 2019. Following the Family Court orders, there were issues regarding the payment of fees and enforcement of the orders. D1 ceased to act and obtained a default judgment against Sanjiv in the District Court. Sanjiv subsequently requested D1 to further act and D1 rendered two further invoices in 2022.

The court was required to determine whether the costs agreements between Sanjiv and D1 were void and invalid, and if not, whether Sanjiv was entitled to repayment of the fees on the basis of various complaints, including nondisclosure of total costs, inadequate disclosure of significant increases in costs, and assertions that D1 had agreed to act for a limited sum. The court was also required to address other issues including allegations of duress in respect of costs agreements and costs notices, allegations that the defendants were guilty of contempt in failing to comply with Family Court Orders, and claims for making a gross sum costs order or referring costs to be assessed by a referee. The court found that Sanjiv's various claims were dismissed.

The court held that the repayment issue was premised on nondisclosure issues and other complaints, and that it ought to address those issues. The court outlined and discussed the principles regarding costs agreements, disclosures, billing and assessment, and emphasised the requirement to provide an estimate of the total legal costs as soon as practicable after instructions are initially given in the matter. The court also discussed the meaning of significant change and the requirement to disclose significant change to anything previously disclosed. The court found that D1 had taken all reasonable steps to satisfy itself that Sanjiv had understood and given consent to the proposed course of action for the conduct of the matter and the proposed costs. The court further found that the communication by a witness with others whilst under cross-examination did not warrant any further action.

The court dismissed Sanjiv's claims and ordered Sanjiv to pay D1's costs of the proceedings on an indemnity basis. The court also noted that Sanjiv had not identified the real issues in dispute and had failed to comply with its obligations as a self-represented litigant. The court further found that Sanjiv had not satisfied the requirements of procedural fairness and had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claims.

Background

Background to the litigation

In late June 2018, the plaintiff, Sanjiv, engaged Coleman Greig Lawyers Pty Ltd (D1) to act for her in family law litigation. Sanjiv had previously engaged two other firms of solicitors for the same matter. During the initial conference, D2, a solicitor from D1, provided an estimate for work up until the next court listing in August 2018. From early August 2018, D2 progressively gave further estimates by means of Family Law Rules Cost Notices over the next nine months. The proceedings were fixed for a final hearing in late April or early May 2019 and were eventually settled following negotiations at the hearing. Over the course of the litigation, D1 rendered eleven invoices totalling approximately $470,579. The first seven invoices, rendered during 2018, were paid by mid-January 2019, while the 2019 invoices remained unpaid. Following the Family Court orders, issues arose regarding the payment of fees and the enforcement of the orders. Subsequently, D1 ceased to act, sued for fees, and obtained a default judgment against Sanjiv in the District Court. Later, Sanjiv requested D1 to further act, resulting in two additional invoices for approximately $12,286 rendered in July and August 2022. Sanjiv authorised D1 to receive proceeds from the sale of matrimonial property to pay most of the outstanding fees. Sanjiv subsequently complained about the amount of fees charged and the disclosure provided.

Sanjiv, self-represented, commenced proceedings against D1 prior to the hearing and abandoned the relief seeking a declaration that the costs agreements were void and invalid. However, Sanjiv pressed orders requesting repayment of fees allegedly charged exorbitantly and without authorisation. The hearing was not completed on the allocated listing day. Shortly after the hearing was adjourned part heard, Sanjiv commenced fresh proceedings attempting to re-instigate the abandoned relief. D1 was named as the sole defendant in the fresh proceedings and sought to have them summarily dismissed. Orders were made dismissing that claim. On the resumed part heard hearing of the original proceedings, Sanjiv pressed claims for repayment and continued to raise issues regarding alleged inadequate disclosure of costs. Despite abandoning the claim that the costs agreements were void and invalid, the retained claim for repayment of funds was essentially underpinned by various complaints of Sanjiv, including nondisclosure of total costs, inadequate disclosure of significant increases in costs, and assertions that D1 had agreed to act for a limited sum. The Court dismissed Sanjiv's various claims.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the costs agreements between the plaintiff and D1 are void and invalid.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a repayment of fees allegedly charged exorbitantly and without authorisation.
3. Whether there was nondisclosure of total costs, inadequate disclosure of significant increases in costs, and whether D1 had agreed to act for a limited sum.
4. Whether there were allegations of duress in respect of the costs agreements and costs notices.
5. Whether D1 is guilty of contempt in failing to comply with Family Court orders.
6. Whether a gross sum costs order should be made or whether costs should be referred to be assessed by a referee.
7. What are the obligations of parties, including self-represented litigants, regarding the identification of issues.
8. What are the content of procedural fairness obligations for unrepresented litigants.
9. What are the principles regarding costs agreements, disclosures, billing, and assessment.
10. What is the meaning of "significant change" in the context of disclosure.
11. What steps must the legal practice take to satisfy itself that the client has understood and given consent to the proposed course of action for the conduct of the matter and the proposed costs.
12. What are the principles regarding communication by a witness with others whilst under cross-examination.

Held
1. The court held that the costs agreements between the plaintiff and D1 are not void and invalid.
2. The plaintiff is not entitled to a repayment of fees allegedly charged exorbitantly and without authorisation.
3. The court found that there was no nondisclosure of total costs, no inadequate disclosure of significant increases in costs, and no agreement by D1 to act for a limited sum.
4. The court dismissed the allegations of duress in respect of the costs agreements and costs notices.
5. The court found that D1 is not guilty of contempt in failing to comply with Family Court orders.
6. The court dismissed the plaintiff's claims for a gross sum costs order or for referring costs to be assessed by a referee.
7. The court emphasised the obligations of parties, including self-represented litigants, to identify the real issues in dispute.
8. The court outlined the procedural fairness obligations for unrepresented litigants.
9. The court discussed the principles regarding costs agreements, disclosures, billing, and assessment, including the requirement to provide an estimate of total legal costs and the meaning of "significant change."
10. The court held that a "significant change" in the context of disclosure refers to any substantial alteration in previously disclosed information.
11. The court emphasised the steps legal practices must take to ensure clients understand and consent to the proposed course of action for the conduct of the matter and the proposed costs.
12. The court discussed the principles regarding communication by a witness with others while under cross-examination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the legal principles and authorities related to solicitor-client costs agreements, disclosures, billing, and procedural fairness. It examined the obligations of parties, including self-represented litigants, to identify the real issues in dispute and the procedural fairness obligations for unrepresented litigants. The court emphasised the requirement for legal practices to provide an estimate of total legal costs and to disclose any significant changes to previously disclosed information. It also addressed the meaning of "significant change" in the context of disclosure and the steps legal practices must take to ensure clients understand and consent to the proposed course of action and costs. The court discussed the principles regarding communication by a witness with others while under cross-examination. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that the costs agreements between the plaintiff and D1 are valid, and the plaintiff's claims for repayment of fees and other relief were dismissed. The court also highlighted the obligations of parties to identify issues, the procedural fairness obligations for unrepresented litigants, and the principles regarding costs agreements, disclosures, billing, and assessment.