Sandvik Mining and Construction Australia Pty Ltd v Fisher [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   SANDVIK MINING AND CONSTRUCTION AUSTRALIA PTY LTD -v- FISHER [No 2] [2020] WASC 123

CORAM:   ARCHER J

HEARD:   28 OCTOBER 2019

DELIVERED          :   16 APRIL 2020

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1842 of 2019

BETWEEN:   SANDVIK MINING AND CONSTRUCTION AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

JOHN FISHER

Respondent

CIVMEC CONSTRUCTION & ENGINEERING PTY LTD

Other Party


Catchwords:

Judicial review - Construction Contracts Act 2004 (WA) - Payment claim - Payment dispute - Whether permissible to bring two applications involving different items under the same progress claim - Where an assumption was made for the purposes of the total amount to be paid, was the matter assumed 'determined'

Legislation:

Construction Contracts Act 2004 (WA) s 3, s 6(2), s 25(a), s 31(2)(b), s 41(1)(b)

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : M J Feutrill SC
Respondent : No appearance
Other Party : M N Solomon SC & L S Panotidis

Solicitors:

Applicant : Squire Patton Boggs
Respondent : No appearance
Other Party : Tottle Partners

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Alliance Contracting Pty Ltd v James [2014] WASC 212

Clough Projects Australia Pty Ltd v Floreani [2018] WASC 101

Cooper & Oxley Builders Pty Ltd v Steensma [2016] WASC 386

Diploma Construction (WA) Pty Ltd v KPA Architects Pty Ltd [2014] WASCA 91

Duro Felguera Australia Pty Ltd v Samsung C&T Corporation [2018] WASCA 28; (2018) 52 WAR 323

Forrest & Forrest Pty Ltd v The Honourable William Richard Marmion, Minister for Mines and Petroleum [2017] WASCA 153; (2017) 51 WAR 425

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; (2018) 254 CLR 123

Mohammadi v Bethune [2018] WASCA 98, 13

O'Donnell Griffin Pty Ltd v John Holland Pty Ltd [2009] WASC 19

Perrinepod Pty Ltd v Georgiou Building Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 217

Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte Aala [2000] HCA 57; (2000) 204 CLR 82

Salini-Impregilo SPA v Francis [2020] WASC 72

Sandvik Mining and Construction Australia Pty Ltd v Fisher [2019] WASC 352

Table of Contents

Background

The ground of review

Sandvik's initial argument

The issues

Legal principles

Judicial review

Approach to statutory construction

The construction question

Overview of legislative framework

Object and purpose

The adjudication process under the Act

Time limit for adjudicator's decision

Deemed dismissal

Determinations

Simultaneous adjudications

Multiple applications in relation to the same dispute

Payment disputes and payment claims

Prohibition on repeated adjudications of the same payment dispute

The relevant provisions

The effect of the provisions

Sandvik's contentions

Res judicata, issue estoppel and Anshun estoppel

Reliance on O'Donnell Griffin

Multiplicity of proceedings

Multiple determinations

Simultaneous adjudication

Act intends to exclude complex disputes

Certainty

The Alliance construction

Conclusion

Further issue arising on the facts

The factual issues

What was the payment dispute in the First Application?

What was decided in the First Determination?

Was there a conflict between the First Determination and the Second Application?

Conclusion

ARCHER J:

Background

  1. The applicant (Sandvik) seeks judicial review of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sandvik Mining and Construction Australia Pty Ltd v Fisher [... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] WASC 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Sandvik Mining and Construction Australia Pty Ltd v Fisher [No 2] concerns a judicial review application brought by Sandvik against a decision made by Mr Fisher, the adjudicator. The dispute arises from a construction contract governed by the Construction Contracts Act 2004 (WA). The central issue is whether it is permissible to bring two separate applications for adjudication involving different items under the same progress claim. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether an assumption made for the purposes of calculating the total amount to be paid constituted a 'determined' matter under the Act.

Sandvik initially argued that a progress claim can only give rise to a single payment claim and a single payment dispute. This meant that once any part of a progress claim was subject to adjudication, it defined the 'payment dispute' for that progress claim, and no subsequent adjudication could be made regarding other disputed items within the same progress claim. However, Sandvik later modified its position, accepting that each itemised amount in a progress claim could be treated as a separate 'payment claim'. The court therefore had to address whether the First Determination, which involved some items from Progress Claim 26, precluded the Second Determination from being made.

The court considered the relevant statutory provisions and the established case law, particularly the decision in Duro Felguera Australia Pty Ltd v Samsung C&T Corporation. The court found that a progress claim could indeed give rise to multiple 'payment claims', each of which could be the subject of separate adjudications. Furthermore, the court determined that the First Determination did not encompass all items in Progress Claim 26, and therefore the Second Determination was not precluded. The court concluded that Mr Fisher had the jurisdiction to make the Second Determination.

As a result of the court's findings, the application for judicial review was dismissed. The decision underscored the importance of correctly interpreting the statutory provisions and highlighted the flexibility in adjudicating on different items within the same progress claim. The court's ruling reinforced the principle that each itemised amount in a progress claim can be treated as a separate 'payment claim', thereby allowing for multiple adjudications on different items under the same progress claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This submission was inconsistent with the Court of Appeal's decision in Duro Felguera Australia Pty Ltd v Samsung C&T Corporation.[8] The court said that, where a progress claim contains a number of itemised amounts, each may itself be a 'payment claim' as defined in the Act and each may be treated as its own separate 'payment claim'. Had Sandvik maintained its original submission, I would have rejected it. However, in its written reply and when making oral submissions, Sandvik modified its position.[8] Duro Felguera Australia Pty Ltd v Samsung C&T Corporation [2018] WASCA 28; (2018) 52 WAR 323 [146]. In its reply, Sandvik accepted that 'payment claim' could refer to an individual item in a progress claim and, if it did, the 'payment dispute' would be about that individual item.[9] However, Sandvik contended that, once any part of a progress claim was the subject of an adjudication, that defined the 'payment dispute' and 'payment claim' in relation to that progress claim, and the Act did not permit any subsequent adjudication in relation to that progress claim. In other words, Sandvik contended that a progress claim could only give rise to a single payment dispute. Sandvik contended that, as both determinations involved the same progress claim, they both involved the same payment dispute and therefore Mr Fisher did not have jurisdiction to adjudicate the Second Application.[10] [9] See Applicant's Outline of Submissions in Reply on Application for Judicial Review filed 9 September 2019 (Sandvik's Written Reply) [43] ‑ [45].[10] See, for example, ts 105 ‑ 106. Sandvik further contended that, factually, each of the items challenged in the Second Application had been determined in the First Determination.[11] Three questions arise. The first is a construction issue, while the second and third are factual. The first question is: on a proper construction of the Act, can a progress claim only give rise to a single payment claim and a single payment dispute? That is, once any part of a progress claim is the subject of an adjudication, does that define the 'payment dispute' in relation to that progress claim, with the result that an adjudicator would not have jurisdiction to subsequently adjudicate any of the other disputed items arising from that progress claim? If the answer to the first question is 'yes', Mr Fisher did not have the jurisdiction to make the Second Determination. If the answer to the first question is 'no', the second question is: what was the 'payment dispute' that was determined in the First Determination? Factually, was it a payment dispute in relation to only those five items Civmec challenged or was it a payment dispute in relation to the whole of Progress Claim 26 and Payment Notice 26? If the answer to the second question is that it was a payment dispute in relation to the whole of Progress Claim 26 and Payment Notice 26, Mr Fisher did not have the jurisdiction to make the Second Determination. If the answer to the second question is that it was a payment dispute in relation to only those items Civmec challenged, the third question is: on the facts in this case, had each of the items the subject of the Second Adjudication been determined in the First Determination.