Samootin v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Samootin v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2009] FCA 408

ALEXANDRA SAMOOTIN v OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY

NSD 1943 of 2008

JACOBSON J
21 APRIL 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1943 of 2008

BETWEEN:

ALEXANDRA SAMOOTIN
Applicant

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY
Respondent

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 APRIL 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1943 of 2008

BETWEEN:

ALEXANDRA SAMOOTIN
Applicant

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY
Respondent

JUDGE:

JACOBSON J

DATE:

21 APRIL 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant, Ms Samootin, is bankrupt.  She was made bankrupt by a sequestration order of the Federal Magistrates Court dated 24 May 2006.  The judgment debt upon which the petition was founded arose in part from costs incurred by Ms Samootin in proceedings heard in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, matter 1973/01, and in appeals and related proceedings. 

  2. The genesis of Ms Samootin’s complaint arises from the sale of her former matrimonial home at 82 Waterview Street, Mona Vale.  That property was owned jointly by Ms Samootin and her former husband, Mr Christopher Shea.  The proceeds of sale of the property were used by Mr Shea, his friend, Mr Deans, and a company now called Loan Design Pty Ltd, to purchase properties at 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road, Beacon Hill. Mr Deans’ company, S.R. Deans Pty Ltd, was the sole shareholder of Loan Design.  Title to the properties at Beacon Hill was taken in the name of Shea Delite Pty Ltd, now known as Loan Design, as sole registered proprietor. 

  3. The trial of the proceedings brought by Ms Samootin against Mr Shea, Mr Deans and Loan Design, took place before Palmer J.  His Honour described the proceedings as a tragic case for all who have been involved in it.  He said, at [1], that Ms Samootin has developed a fixation that she has been a victim of a fraudulent conspiracy between Mr Shea and Mr Deans, in which she has been cheated out of her home.  His Honour referred, at [4], to the ocean of litigation that has enveloped the parties since 1998.  He described it in stronger terms as a “nightmarish web of litigation”, although Ms Samootin objects to that description.

  4. However it is described, it is plain that the tally of cases continues to mount and that, by reason of her bankruptcy, Ms Samootin has embroiled the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy in the costly and time-consuming exercise of dealing with the processes of the courts. 

  5. In this application Ms Samootin seeks an order pursuant to s 19 and other sections…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Samootin v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 408
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Samootin v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy, the applicant, Ms Samootin, contested the orders made by Palmer J regarding her property interests and sought to challenge the actions of the Official Trustee, represented by Ms Nash, in the management of her bankruptcy estate. The central dispute revolved around the equitable division of interests in two properties located at 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road, as well as the administration of Ms Samootin's bankruptcy. The court was tasked with determining the validity of the orders made by Palmer J and whether the Official Trustee had acted appropriately in the administration of Ms Samootin's estate.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the orders made by Palmer J correctly applied the principles established by the High Court in Calverley v Green. Ms Samootin argued that the orders wrongly allocated her equitable interest in the properties, asserting that she and her former husband should each have received 50% of the beneficial interest, with the remaining 50% going to Mr Deans or Loan Design. Additionally, she accused Ms Nash and the Official Trustee of misconduct in the administration of her estate, alleging they deliberately miscalculated her entitlements to ensure she received nothing from the accounting process. Furthermore, Ms Samootin sought orders for the sale of the property under section 66G of the Conveyancing Act or an order compelling the Official Trustee to seek such orders from the Supreme Court, claiming a breach of their duties under section 19 of the Bankruptcy Act.

The court found that it could not accept Ms Samootin's account of the events and her interpretation of the equitable principles. The court ordered a declaration of the respective interests in the properties and referred the matter to the Master in Equity to ascertain the equitable contributions and proportionate interests of the parties involved. This decision was upheld by the Court of Appeal, which deemed the initial appeal incompetent but granted leave to appeal against certain orders made by Palmer J. The subsequent orders by Palmer J, intended to implement the Court of Appeal's directions, declared Loan Design as holding the properties in trust for Ms Samootin, Mr Shea, and Loan Design, with their interests proportional to their equity contributions.

Ms Samootin made several further applications to the Court of Appeal for a stay of the orders and leave to appeal, which were ultimately dismissed by Giles JA, who found her applications misconceived and without substance, noting the unnecessary waste of resources and disruption caused.

The court dismissed Ms Samootin's application and ordered her to pay the respondent's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Not withstanding Ms Nash’s best efforts, neither Mr Deans nor Loan Design purchased the property pursuant to the leave granted by Palmer J. On 12 March 2009, Ms Nash wrote to Derham Houston stating that since the property at 24 Oxford Falls Road had not been purchased, she was seeking instructions to re-list the matter with a view to obtaining orders for its sale. However, for reasons which are stated in Mr Karolyi’s affidavit evidence, no such application has been pursued. MR KAROLYI’S EVIDENCE Mr Karolyi’s evidence was set out in an affidavit of 9 April 2009. He says at [12] that the Official Trustee does not expect to receive any funds on the sale and account for 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road pursuant to the orders made by Hammerschlag J. This is explained further in [21] in which Mr Karolyi sets out the reasons why he has not taken any steps to approach the Supreme Court for orders for sale of the property. He observes that the Official Trustee has no prospect of any payment to the estate. He points out that the Official Trustee has paid nearly a hundred thousand dollars in legal fees to the date of the affidavit in the numerous applications made by Ms Samootin to the courts. He estimates the amount required to discharge Ms Samootin’s bankruptcy at in excess of $660,000. The principal components of this are the claim of the petitioning creditors in an amount of $467,000 and the amount of nearly $100,000 being the Official Trustee’s legal costs incurred to date. DISCUSSION The essence of Ms Samootin’s submissions was that the orders made by Hammerschlag J wrongly applied the principles stated by the High Court in Calverley v Green (1984) 155 CLR 242. Ms Samootin submitted that on a proper application of the principles, Mr Deans or Loan Design ought to have had only 50% of the beneficial interest in the properties at 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road with the remaining 50% to be divided equally between Ms Samootin and her former husband. Ms Samootin accused Ms Nash of wrongfully consenting to the orders made by Hammerschlag J which declared the interest of Ms Samootin and Mr Shea in the proportions that I have mentioned above. Ms Samootin also accused Ms Nash and the Official Trustee of deliberately increasing the amount contributed by Mr Deans in calculating the net amount due to Ms Samootin on the accounting so as to ensure that Ms Samootin received nothing from the taking of accounts between the parties. In addition, Ms Samootin complained that there has been delay in finalising the administration of her estate, in particular, the property of 24 Oxford Falls Road which has not been sold. She submitted that Hammerschlag J should have made an order for sale and as I have said above, she sought orders under section 66G of the Conveyancing Act or an order compelling the official receiver to seek such orders from the Supreme Court. Ms Samootin accused Ms Nash and the Official Trustee of breach of their duties under section 19 of the Bankruptcy Act in failing to seek such orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JACOBSON J
His Honour then set out in some detail Ms Samootin’s account of the disputed facts, however, in his findings commencing at [65], his Honour came to the view that he could not accept Ms Samootin’s account of the events. He set out his reasons in some detail. His Honour was of the view that there ought to be a declaration as to the respective interests of Ms Samootin, Mr Shea and Loan Design in the properties at 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road and that there should be an enquiry before the Master in Equity and a taking of accounts between the parties to ascertain the respective interests of the parties. He said at [82] that when the enquiry and the accounts determined the interests of the parties in the properties, the terms of the declaration could be finalised. Court of Appeal decision of 3 June 2004 Ms Samootin appealed to the Court of Appeal. The purported appeal was heard by Handley, Sheller and Ipp JJA. The reasons for judgment were delivered by Handley JA, with whom Sheller and Ipp JJA agreed. The Court was of the view that the appeal was incompetent, but their Honours granted leave to appeal against the orders made by Palmer J on 29 September 2003 which they considered to contain a number of difficulties and inconsistencies. The reasons given by Handley JA deal with the matters to be considered on the taking of accounts, including the necessary allowances to be made in the carrying out of that exercise. Orders of Palmer J dated 28 June 2004 On 28 June 2004, Palmer J made orders which were apparently intended to give effect to the reasons for judgment of the Court of Appeal. His Honour’s orders were entered on 4 August 2004. The orders included a declaration that Loan Design holds the properties at 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road upon trust for Ms Samootin, Mr Shea and Loan Design with their respective interests being in proportion to the equity contributions made by them or on their behalf to the acquisition costs of the properties at 24 and 26 Oxford Falls Road. His Honour ordered that the matter be referred to the Master in Equity to enquire as to what the respective equity contributions and what the respective proportionate interests of the parties were. His Honour also ordered that the matter be referred to the Master in Equity to enquire into and take accounts between Ms Samootin, Mr Shea and Loan Design, with respect to a number of matters, including the amount which Ms Samootin should reasonably pay for her own use and occupation of the property at 26 Oxford Falls Road. Further applications to the Court of Appeal Following upon the orders of 28 June 2004, Ms Samootin made a number of further applications to the Court of Appeal for a stay of the orders and for leave to appeal. I do not propose to set out in any detail the lengthy history of those applications. One of them was an application for a stay which was determined by Giles JA on 17 February 2005: see Samootin v Shea & Ors [2005] NSWCA 16. Giles JA observed at [63] that Ms Samootin’s application was in large part misconceived and in whole without substance. His Honour said that he did not think Ms Samootin was entitled to any of the relief she sought. He observed that the waste of time and resources, and the unwarranted disruption and expense occasioned to the defendants was evident.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JACOBSON J

Full text does not contain this section.