Ryan and Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Ryan and Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2020] AATA 2049 (1 July 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2019/0058

Re:Stephen Ryan

APPLICANT

Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member M East

Date:1 July 2020

Place:Perth

The decision to refuse the Applicant’s claim for seafarers’ compensation is affirmed.

........................[sgd]................................................

Member M East

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – seafarer’s rehabilitation and compensation – whether applicant’s ailment was ‘contributed to in a material degree’ by his employment with the respondent as an Integrated Rating on the vessel – meaning of ‘ailment’ considered – meaning of ‘contributed to’ considered – meaning of ‘in a material degree’ considered – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 (Cth)
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act (Cth), No. 75 of 1988 Compilation prepared on 14 March 2007 – ss 4(1), 5B
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation and Other Legislation Amendment Act2007 (Cth)

Seafarers, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) – ss 3, 4(1) 8, 10(2), 26, 76, 78(5), 78(6), 79(1), 79(1)(b), 79(6)

CASES
Beer v Duracraft Pty Ltd [2004] WASCA 192
Briginshaw v Briginshaw

[1938] HCA 34; 60 CLR 336
[2005] FCAFC 262
[2006] FCA 840
(1976) 133 CLR 580
[1964] HCA 34


Comcare v Canute
Comcare v Sahu–Khan [2007] FCA 15
Coward v Military Compensation and Rehabilitation Service
Favelle Mort Pty Ltd v Murray
Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19
Pollock v Wellington

(1996) 15 WAR 1
Re Raymond John Welsford and Commonwealth Banking Corporation
[1984] AATA 95
Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations v Comcare
[2008] FCA 52
[1990] FCA 511
[2002] FCA 1464
[1987] FCA 484


Treloar, K.R. v Australian Telecommunications Commission
Weigand v Comcare Australia
Westgate, C.W. v Australian Telecommunications Commissions

SECONDARY MATERIALS
Commonwealth Employees’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Bill 1988 (Cth)

Commonwealth, Parliamentary Debates, House of Representatives, 27 April 1988, 2191 (Brian Howe, Minister for Social Security)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member M East

1 July 2020

HISTORY OF CLAIM

  1. The Applicant is seeking review of a decision made by Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd (the Respondent) to refuse his claim for seafarers’ compensation made for injuries allegedly sustained during the course of his employment with the Respondent as an A/B Integrated Rating.

  2. By his claim form dated 18 September 2018, the Applicant claims that he has suffered ‘Severe multy [sic] level cervical disc disease with nerve entrapment’ to his ‘2,3,4 neck, lower back’ (T36, p83).

  3. The Applicant alleges that the cause of his injury is due to his hard work as an able seaman over the course of 20 years of employment with the Respondent and/or specific incidents identified.

    THE HEARING

  4. The

    application was heard by the Tribunal on 12 and 13 February 2020. The Applicant was represented by Mr David Bruns, Counsel,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ryan and Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 2049
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the applicant, Ryan, against a determination by the respondent, Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd, to decline his claim for seafarers' compensation. The applicant sought compensation for an ailment he claimed arose out of or in the course of his employment as an Integrated Rating on a vessel. The respondent's initial determination, made on 9 October 2018, was that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim that the alleged incidents occurred or caused injury, and therefore the claim was declined.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant's ailment was "contributed to in a material degree" by his employment with the respondent. This required the Tribunal to consider the meaning of "ailment," "contributed to," and "in a material degree" within the context of the relevant legislation. The Tribunal also had to assess the available medical and other evidence to determine if a causal connection between the applicant's employment and his condition could be established on the balance of probabilities.

The Tribunal considered the medical evidence, which presented a variety of diagnoses and potential contributing factors, including natural degeneration, inflammatory disease, and the applicant's work history with previous employers. The Tribunal noted that while work may have instigated or accelerated the condition, it was unable to conclude on the balance of probabilities that the applicant's employment with the respondent contributed to the contraction, acceleration, or aggravation of his ailments. The Tribunal found that the evidence presented amounted, at best, to a hypothesis as to causation, and it was not satisfied as to the necessary causal connection.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the respondent's decision to refuse the applicant's claim for seafarers' compensation.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant, Mr Ryan, was employed by the Respondent, Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd, as an Integrated Rating on a vessel. His employment involved duties typical of seafarers, which included working in various conditions on board the vessel. Mr Ryan lodged a claim for seafarers' compensation, asserting that his ailments, specifically injuries to his neck and back, arose from his employment with the Respondent. The Respondent declined the claim, stating that there was insufficient evidence to support the assertion that the claimed injuries were a result of the employment. The Applicant subsequently requested a reconsideration of the decision, which was sought to be facilitated by Comcare, an Australian government agency responsible for workers' compensation and rehabilitation. Comcare provided advice indicating that the available evidence was inadequate to support the Respondent's determination and recommended further investigation into the nature of Mr Ryan's condition and its possible link to his employment. Despite this advice, the Respondent did not proceed with the reconsideration within the required timeframe, leading to the claim being disallowed by operation of law. The matter was then brought before a Tribunal which was tasked with determining whether the Respondent's decision to refuse the compensation claim was justified. The Tribunal found that while Mr Ryan suffered from the ailments claimed, the evidence did not sufficiently establish a causal connection between these ailments and his employment with the Respondent. The Tribunal also noted the complexity of the case, with various diagnoses and contributing factors to Mr Ryan's condition, including his previous employment history.

The matter before this court is an appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which affirmed a determination made by Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd declining the Applicant’s claim for seafarers’ compensation. The Applicant, who was employed as an Integrated Rating on a vessel, claimed that his ailments were materially contributed to by his employment. Following the Respondent's initial determination declining the claim on 9 October 2018, the Applicant requested an extension for reconsideration of the decision, which the Respondent treated as a request for reconsideration. The Respondent subsequently sought assistance from Comcare, which provided a report recommending that the Respondent should gather additional evidence to properly assess the claim. However, the Respondent failed to comply with statutory obligations to proceed with the reconsideration within the stipulated timeframe, resulting in the claim being deemed disallowed under section 79(6) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The Applicant then appealed the AAT’s decision affirming the Respondent's determination to this court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 9 October 2018, the Respondent made a determination declining the Applicant’s claim for seafarers’ compensation for his claimed injury on the basis that (T39, pp94-96):Dr Jones, your treating general practitioners [sic] has confirmed that he supports your claim. However, we note that there is currently no other evidence supporting that the incidents referred to in your claim form either occurred or caused you any injury to your neck/back.Considering the current evidence available to Swires, we are not satisfied your claimed injury arose out of, or in the course of, your employment with Swires. As you have not suffered an injury as defined in the Act, your claim is declined. (Original emphasis.) On 29 October 2018, the Applicant requested an ‘extension for 60 days on My workers Compensation Determination’ which was taken by the Respondent to be a request for a reconsideration of the determination (T40, pp97-98). Solicitors for the Respondent wrote to Comcare on 15 November 2018 requesting their assistance on the reconsideration (T41, pp99-103) and on 11 December 2018, Comcare provided their report (T42, pp104-106). In that report, the Comcare officer noted they had limited their advice to whether there was ‘sufficient medical and other evidence to support the determination’ (T42, p106). The Comcare officer refers to s 10(2) of the SRCA which requires the employer to consider if an employee has suffered a disease whether or not the incidence of the disease is greater among people who have engaged in the employee’s type of employment than in those engaged in other employment. It further states that ‘[t]he link between employment and the onset of a disease is not taken to be limited to a specific incident, but rather to the duties performed by the employee’ (T42, p106). The Comcare officer then stated (T42, p106):I do not find that there is sufficient medical evidence to support the determination, regardless of whether or not the claimed condition is treated as a disease or not. The evidence is largely restricted to medical certificates which, while evidence that the employee suffers from the claimed condition, does not provide any information allowing the claimed condition to be considered separately from the possibility of constitutional, age related degeneration, or of the potential impact of the employee’s cancer diagnosis and treatment. In order to properly consider liability for the claimed condition the employer should undertake to gather additional evidence under s66 and s67 in order to ascertain the nature of the employee’s claimed condition, which will in turn provide more evidence of any link to employment that may exist, whether or not the injury is treated as a disease or injury simpliciter. After receiving the recommendation from Comcare, the Respondent failed to comply with its obligation under ss 78(5) and (6) of the SRCA to proceed with the reconsideration. Section 79(1) says the reconsideration should have been completed within 60 days in the ordinary course (although s 79(1)(b) permits the Respondent to obtain more time which did not happen here). As a consequence, the Respondent is deemed under s 79(6) to have made a determination disallowing the claim at the end of the 60 day period. Medical and Incident History

Decision

Reasons for decision

At best, the Tribunal has been presented with a hypothesis as to causation. It may have been the natural effects of degeneration; it may have been an inflammatory disease, or it may have been both. Work may have instigated or accelerated the condition and that work includes 20 years with another employer. What is clear is that not only is there a variety of diagnoses, there is also a variety of contributing factors. The Tribunal needs to be satisfied as to the causal connection. Once the contribution is established, the extent of that contribution is less important. Having carefully considered all the medical evidence available in this matter The Tribunal is unable to conclude on the balance of probabilities that the Applicant’s employment with the Respondent contributed to the contraction, acceleration or aggravation of the Applicant’s ailments.DECISION For the reasons above, the Tribunal affirms the decision of the Respondent to refuse the Applicant’s claim for seafarers’ compensation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Australian Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the Applicant’s claimed injury was caused by, or contributed to in a material degree by, his employment with the Respondent. In addressing this issue, the Tribunal examined the various diagnoses and contributing factors surrounding the Applicant's claimed injury. The Tribunal concluded that while the Applicant's employment may have contributed to his condition, it could not be established on the balance of probabilities that the employment was a significant factor in the contraction, acceleration, or aggravation of the Applicant’s ailments.

In defining the term ‘ailment’ within the context of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth), the Tribunal considered the wide array of diagnoses provided by the Applicant’s medical practitioners. The Tribunal noted that while the Applicant’s general practitioner supported his claim, the evidence did not sufficiently distinguish between the Applicant’s claimed condition and other potential causes, such as natural degeneration or pre-existing conditions. The Tribunal held that for the purposes of the Act, an ‘ailment’ encompasses any physical condition that affects a seafarer’s health and can be related to their employment, but it must be clearly distinguishable from other non-occupational factors.

The Tribunal also addressed the meaning of the phrase ‘contributed to’ in the context of the Act. The Tribunal emphasised that the Act requires a causal connection between the employment and the ailment, which means that the employment must play a significant role in the contraction, acceleration, or aggravation of the ailment. The Tribunal found that while work may have played some role in the Applicant’s condition, the evidence did not sufficiently establish this connection to a degree that would warrant compensation under the Act.

Regarding the phrase ‘in a material degree,’ the Tribunal interpreted it to mean that the contribution of the employment to the ailment must be significant. The Tribunal held that the evidence did not demonstrate a material degree of contribution by the Applicant’s employment with the Respondent, as the various potential causes of the ailment remained unclear and indistinguishable.

The Tribunal also examined whether the Respondent’s failure to comply with the statutory requirements for reconsideration constituted a valid reason to affirm the decision to refuse the Applicant’s claim. The Tribunal noted that the Respondent did not proceed with the reconsideration within the mandated 60-day period, as required by sections 78(5) and (6) of the SRCA. Although the Tribunal recognised the importance of compliance with statutory obligations, it concluded that the failure to reconsider did not change the outcome of the claim, as the evidence did not support the Applicant’s case.

Lastly, the Tribunal assessed whether the Applicant provided sufficient evidence to establish a causal connection between his employment with the Respondent and his claimed injury. The Tribunal found that the evidence primarily consisted of medical certificates which, while indicating the Applicant’s condition, did not provide sufficient information to separate the claimed condition from other potential causes. The Tribunal emphasised that the employer must gather additional evidence to ascertain the nature of the employee’s claimed condition and any link to employment. Given the lack of sufficient evidence, the Tribunal upheld the Respondent’s decision to refuse the Applicant’s claim for seafarers’ compensation.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for an Applicant to successfully claim compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth), there must be clear and compelling evidence establishing that their employment contributed to their ailment in a material degree, distinguishing it from other potential causes. The Tribunal's decision underscores the necessity of substantial evidence to support a causal link between the employment and the ailment, and the importance of compliance with statutory obligations regarding reconsideration.