Kingshott and Trident LNG Shipping Services (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

Kingshott and Trident LNG Shipping Services (Compensation) [2020] AATA 4848 (1 December 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/7010

Re:Philip Kingshott

APPLICANT

AndTrident LNG Shipping Services

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:1 December 2020  

Place:Perth

The decision made on 6 October 2017 which affirmed a deemed determination which disallowed the Applicant’s claim for compensation lodged on 10 March 2017 under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) is affirmed.

...............................[SGD]................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – workers compensation – chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) – emphysema – environmental tobacco smoke – material contribution to or aggravation of ailment – inconsistent active smoking histories – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) – ss 3, 26(1), 28, 31, 73(2)(a), 73(6)

CASES

Comcare v Canute [2005] FCAFC 262
Comcare v Sahu-Khan [2007] FCA 15
Ryan and Swire Pacific Ship Management (Australia) Pty Ltd [2020] AATA 2049

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

1 December 2020

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision made on 6 October 2017 which affirmed a deemed determination which disallowed the Applicant’s claim for compensation lodged on
    10 March 2017 under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (SRC Act).

    BACKGROUND

  2. The Applicant was a seafarer who was employed by the Respondent between
    28 January 2008 and 3 February 2017 as a catering assistant. He is 81 years of age.

  3. The Applicant says that he was exposed to secondary cigarette smoke throughout the entire period of his employment by the Respondent. He says that his “symptoms became worse in the middle of 2016 and he left the ship for the last time on the 3rd August 2016”.[1]

    [1] Paragraph 6 of Applicant’s SFIC.

  4. On 10 March 2017 the Applicant lodged a claim for workers’ compensation under the SRC Act for “COPD [chronic obstructive pulmonary disease]/chronic cough” which the Applicant claimed to be attributable to exposure to passive cigarette smoking while working on board the NW Sanderling.[2] The claim was for “lost wages resulting from an incapacity for work”, “medical and related expenses” and “travel expenses to attending medical examination/rehabilitation”.

    [2] R2, T8.

  5. A workers’ compensation first medical certificate completed by Dr Iain Russell dated

    [3] R2, T7.

    8 March 2017 identified the clinical diagnosis as, “moderate emphysema/COPD” with clinical findings of “[n]ow excessive mucous production, cough, exertional dyspnoea”.[3]
  6. On 5 July 2017 the Applicant, through his representatives, provided further medical certificates dated 10 April 2017 and 29 June 2017. The Tribunal notes that the claim form submitted by the Applicant on 10 March 2017 was in the form approved by the Seafarers Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Authority. That form at part 15 provides as follows:

    15. For what are you claiming (tick all that apply)

    Note: This question does limit your entitlement to make further claims in relation to the injury or illness. You do not need…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kingshott and Trident LNG Shipping Services (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4848
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an applicant, Mr Kingshott, who claimed compensation for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and emphysema against his employer, Trident LNG Shipping Services. The applicant alleged that his condition was caused or aggravated by exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) during his employment. The primary issue for the court was to determine whether the applicant's COPD and emphysema constituted an injury under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (SRC Act), and if so, whether the exposure to ETS was a material contributing factor to his condition.

The court was required to assess the medical evidence concerning the applicant's diagnosis of severe COPD with a significant component of emphysema, and the potential causal link between this condition and his reported exposure to ETS on board a vessel. A key aspect of the dispute involved the applicant's inconsistent smoking histories as recorded by various medical practitioners, which the respondent argued undermined the applicant's claim. The court also needed to consider whether the applicant's condition had given rise to incapacity for work or impairment, as required for liability under section 26 of the SRC Act.

The court considered expert medical evidence, including reports from Professor Iven Young, who diagnosed severe COPD and emphysema. Professor Young opined that the applicant's condition was most commonly caused by active cigarette smoking and that ETS exposure was unlikely to have materially contributed to or permanently aggravated his COPD and emphysema. While acknowledging that ETS might have caused some acute irritation during exposure, he concluded it would not have accelerated or permanently worsened the underlying condition. The court also noted documentary evidence of inconsistent reporting of the applicant's smoking history, but ultimately found the applicant's consistent evidence regarding his smoking period and intensity to be strong. The court determined that the applicant's exposure to ETS was more than trivial, but this did not alter the conclusion regarding causation.

Ultimately, the court affirmed a previous decision that disallowed the applicant's claim for compensation. Having determined that the applicant's condition was not a compensable injury under the SRC Act due to the lack of material contribution from ETS, the court found it unnecessary to determine whether the applicant had suffered any incapacity for work or impairment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The secondary issue raised by the Respondent is, if it is found that the Applicant suffers from a disease, that is an injury, as those terms are defined in s 3 of the SRC Act (see [22] above), whether the injury has given rise to incapacity for work or impairment in order for liability under s 26 of the SRC Act (see [19] above) to arise.The medical evidenceProfessor Young Professor Iven Young, BSc(Med), MB BS, PhD, FRACP, respiratory physician, provided three reports and gave evidence at the hearing. In his first report, dated 20 September 2017, Professor Young advised that:(a)He had examined the Applicant on 12 September 2017.(a)The record from the Applicant’s local doctor, Dr Iain Russell, indicated that the Applicant had been treated for recurrent respiratory tract infections in September 2004 and that a Seretide inhaler (a recognised treatment for COPD) was prescribed in September 2007 and changed to a different type of inhaler in 2017.(b)The Applicant reported that he was exposed to ETS through the air conditioning on the vessel for one hour during lunchtime and two to three hours at night for six months a year that he spent at sea. The exposure was heavier from 2014 until his employment was terminated in August 2016 after he was judged unable to cope with the firefighting drill because of breathlessness.(c)The Applicant gave his smoking history as having started smoking in 1974 at around 35 years of age and as having stopped in 1989 at age 50. He described himself as a light smoker smoking three to four cigarettes per day. (d)Professor Young noted, however, that the records of the Applicant’s treating doctor, Dr Russell, from 26 September 2007, referred to a “[h]istory of sever smoking” and that email correspondence from Neil Griffiths noted verbal reports of the Applicant being a regular/heavy smoker all of his life before starting with Shell, at which time he gave up smoking.(e)The Applicant’s spirometry is consistent with, and it was Professor Young’s diagnosis that, the Applicant had severe chronic obstructive pulmonary disease with a significant component of emphysema.(f)Professor Young did not believe that the Applicant’s severe COPD was caused by exposure to ETS on the ship while employed by the Respondent. “There is no evidence published in the scientific medical literature to support causation of COPD or emphysema from passive cigarette exposure” and “[t]he most common cause of emphysema is active cigarette smoking”.(g)Professor Young stated that “I believe the emphysema process would have commenced when he started smoking in 1974 but it is possible that his exposure to wood dust from the age of 28 or 29 to the age of 36 in Swaziland, Bangladesh and Syria could have contributed”.(h)The Applicant’s severe COPD with predominant emphysema would have been present prior to his employment with Shell. COPD and emphysema take decades to develop and tend to be progressive and become more symptomatic with time due to lung function that has been lost while the person has been actively smoking. The Applicant’s condition would have developed whether or not he had been employed by Shell and his condition would have developed whether or not he had been exposed to ETS.(i)Exposure to passive smoking was not a “material contributing factor for Mr Kingshott’s COPD and emphysema”. The exposure to ETS may have acted as a mild acute irritant during the times that the Applicant was exposed to ETS because of his underlying COPD “…but it would not have acted to accelerate or permanently aggravate his underlying COPD/emphysema”.(j)“…it is possible that some acute irritation of his underlying COPD when exposed to [ETS] but this would not have acted beyond the period of exposure. This may be the reason why Mr Kingshott has associated this exposure with his respiratory condition but there is no evidence that passive cigarette smoke exposure can cause or materially permanently aggravate underlying COPD or emphysema”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having so determined it is not necessary for the Tribunal to determine whether the Applicant has suffered any incapacity for work or impairment.DECISION The decision made on 6 October 2017 which affirmed a deemed determination which disallowed the Applicant’s claim for compensation lodged on 10 March 2017 under the SRC Act is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant’s submissions in reply were:7-8. Notwithstanding extensive cross-examination, the Applicant did not resile from his position that he smoked a packet of cigarettes a week.11. There is “clearly documentary evidence of inconsistent recording of the applicant’s smoking history”.13. The notation of “severe” smoking on the 26th September 2007 is a highly subjective notation and the medical officer who may have made the note did not testify. It ought to be disregarded.14. The next record is that of Dr Claxton who was called by the Applicant. The notation made in a report dated the 10th November 2016 was identified later by the Applicant has being incorrect and he attended upon Dr Claxton to make a change in his records on the 28th February 2018. Dr Claxton made the change. The change is consistent with what the Applicant told all of the other specialists in the case.15. The smoking history in the two spirometry reports are consistent with what Dr Claxton had reported in 2016 in the first report and then consistent with what the Applicant had reported to the specialists and what he had testified to on oath in this Tribunal hearing in the second document dated the 4th December 2017. The second document came into existence before Dr Claxton made his change on the 28th February 2018.16. The 8th March 2017 notes from Dr Russell which describe in shorthand form: Gave up smoking 25 years ago, 10-15 per day, could well have been wrongly noted as being a reference to 10-15 per week.19-20. As at 8th March 2017 the Applicant had not lodged a claim for seafarer’s compensation. He obtained a First medical certificate on that day and lodged the claim 2 days later. It is unhelpful to link the applicant’s smoking history reporting in some way to his unfair dismissal claim. There is no established link or relevance.21. The allegations of inconsistent previous reporting, whilst casting some doubt on the issue, does not dislodge the applicant’s strong and consistent evidence as to the period being from 1974 to 1989 and being a pack of cigarettes a week.23. To suggest that because his parents both smoked, that there was no environmental influence against the Applicant smoking from a young age, is quite baseless. 25-26. The Respondent’s submissions that the Applicant was exposed to and even encouraged to smoke in the Royal Navy has no evidential basis.27. the fact that the Applicant’s first wife smoked ought not be taken into account by the Tribunal in determining the Applicant’s smoking history.28. The Respondent’s submissions that most people take up smoking at an earlier age than the Applicant says he started smoking and suggestions that the Applicant faced stressors in the Royal Navy are speculation.31. The foundation of the OHMS (Mr Ward) report is destroyed by Mr Hoffman’s evidence as to the changes made in the ducting system.32. The contemporary evidence (AMSA issue of an Improvement Notice, reports by the Applicant) establishes that the ETS exposure was more than trivial.35. The level or intensity of that exposure is irrelevant provided that it is more than trivial.CONSIDERATION