Russell Phelps v Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
[2024] FWC 3017

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Russell Phelps

v

Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd

(U2024/6644)

Taylor McDonald

v

Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd

(U2024/6662)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT EASTON

SYDNEY, 30 OCTOBER 2024

Application for relief from unfair dismissal – redundancy – not genuine redundancy because of a failure to comply with consultation obligations - valid reason found – failure to notify the applicants of the valid reason for dismissal – dismissal was unreasonable – remedy – minimal loss – compensation ordered.

  1. Mr Jason Buckley and Ms Melissa Casey used to be married. In better times Mr Buckley and Ms Casey were both directors of Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd and together operated two 4WD parts and accessories stores on the NSW north coast.

  1. However cooperation between Mr Buckley and Ms Casey appears to have ended in early 2024. On 20 March 2024 Mr Buckley notified ASIC that Ms Casey was no longer a director of Northern Rivers 4WD. Ms Casey claims that Mr Buckley’s notification to ASIC was fraudulent.

  1. Ms Taylor McDonald is Ms Casey’s daughter. Ms McDonald worked for Northern Rivers 4WD until she was dismissed on 27 May 2024. Mr Buckley made the decision to terminate Ms McDonald's employment. Ms McDonald has made a claim under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act), alleging that her dismissal by Northern Rivers 4WD was unfair.

  1. Mr Russell Phelps was also employed by Northern Rivers 4WD and is Ms McDonald's de-facto partner. Mr Buckley also made the decision to terminate Mr Phelps’ employment on 27 May 2024. Mr Phelps has similarly made an unfair dismissal claim against Northern Rivers 4WD.

  1. Ms McDonald’s claim and Mr Phelps’ claim were heard at the same time. The circumstances of each dismissal are not materially different.  

  1. The evidence provided by each party included a significant amount of material that was relevant to the awful breakdown in relationships between Mr Buckley, Ms Casey, Ms McDonald and Mr Phelps, but was irrelevant to the matters I must decide. Most of this material was not admitted into evidence, or if it was admitted, it is not material to which I have attached any significant weight.

  1. For the reasons that will become apparent, it is not necessary to describe in intricate detail the breakdown of the relationships within Northern Rivers 4WD’s business. Instead I will refer to the key matters of fact to be drawn from the evidence.

  1. Immediately prior to the dismissal of the Applicants, Northern Rivers 4WD operated two stores selling and installing 4WD equipment under a franchise arrangement with an external franchisor.

  1. Mr Phelps worked for Northern Rivers 4WD for approximately four years, although there was an interruption when Mr Phelps resigned over an incident in 2022. Mr Phelps worked as a full-time salesperson and manager and was also nearing the end of an apprenticeship as a mechanic. Ms McDonald was employed by Northern Rivers 4WD as a part-time salesperson.

  1. Mr Phelps and Ms McDonald worked…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell Phelps v Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FWC 3017
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Russell Phelps and Taylor McDonald, made separate claims for unfair dismissal against Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd, their employer, under the Fair Work Act 2009. The applicants were dismissed on 27 May 2024, and both sought compensation for the dismissals. The dismissals arose from the closure of the Ballina store, one of two stores operated by Northern Rivers 4WD. The company claimed that the dismissals were genuine redundancies because of the closure of the Ballina store, however, this defence failed because of the company’s failure to comply with its consultation obligations under a relevant modern award. The Deputy President found that the dismissals were unfair because of procedural unfairness. The Deputy President ordered that Northern Rivers 4WD pay each applicant 24 hours' pay in compensation for their unfair dismissal. This amount took into account all the circumstances of the case, including the fact that the applicants had received workers' compensation benefits since their dismissals. The Deputy President ordered that Northern Rivers 4WD pay Ms McDonald $960 in compensation and Mr Phelps $1,080 in compensation, less tax as required by law. The Deputy President also ordered that Northern Rivers 4WD pay each applicant an additional amount for superannuation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr. Jason Buckley and Ms. Melissa Casey, former spouses and directors of Northern Rivers 4WD Pty Ltd, experienced a breakdown in their relationship and business partnership in early 2024. This led to a significant deterioration in their working relationship and that of their respective associates, including Ms. Taylor McDonald and Mr. Russell Phelps. Both Ms. McDonald and Mr. Phelps were employed by Northern Rivers 4WD, with Ms. McDonald as a part-time salesperson and Mr. Phelps as a full-time salesperson and manager nearing the completion of a mechanic apprenticeship. The business operated two 4WD parts and accessories stores under a franchise agreement. Tensions between those affiliated with Mr. Buckley and Ms. Casey escalated, culminating in Ms. Casey, Ms. McDonald, and Mr. Phelps being deployed to the Ballina store. Mr. Buckley eventually decided to close the Ballina store due to financial discrepancies, leading to the dismissal of Ms. McDonald and Mr. Phelps on 27 May 2024. Both employees subsequently made claims for unfair dismissal under the Fair Work Act 2009.

The claims for unfair dismissal by Ms. Taylor McDonald and Mr. Russell Phelps were heard together by the Fair Work Commission. The Commission had to determine whether the dismissals were genuine redundancies and, if not, whether they were harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. The procedural history involved the submission of evidence and witness statements, with the Commission considering the breakdown of relationships and the circumstances leading to the closure of the Ballina store. The Commission also reviewed the letters of termination and the procedural fairness of the dismissal process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the dismissal of the Applicants a genuine redundancy as defined under section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009?
2. Was there a valid reason for the dismissal related to the Applicants’ capacity or conduct?
3. Were the Applicants notified of the valid reason for the dismissal?
4. Were the Applicants given an opportunity to respond to any valid reason related to their capacity or conduct?
5. Did the Respondent unreasonably refuse to allow the Applicants to have a support person present to assist at discussions relating to the dismissal?
6. Was the Applicants warned about unsatisfactory performance before the dismissal?
7. What other matters are relevant in determining whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable?

Held
1. The dismissal of the Applicants was not a genuine redundancy as defined under section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009, because the employer failed to comply with consultation obligations.
2. There was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the Applicants' capacity or conduct, as the employer decided to cease trading at the Ballina site.
3. The Applicants were not notified of the valid reason for their dismissal prior to the dismissal taking effect.
4. The Applicants were not given an opportunity to respond to the valid reasons for their dismissal.
5. The employer did not unreasonably refuse to allow the Applicants to have a support person present to assist at discussions relating to the dismissal, as the Applicants were not given an opportunity to respond in the first place.
6. The Applicants were not warned about unsatisfactory performance before the dismissal as the dismissal was not related to unsatisfactory performance.
7. Other matters relevant in determining whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable include the procedural unfairness identified, the size of the employer’s enterprise, and the lack of dedicated human resource management expertise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the dismissals of the Applicants were genuine redundancies under section 389 of the Fair Work Act 2009. To establish a genuine redundancy, the employer must demonstrate that the Applicants' jobs were redundant, and that they complied with consultation obligations. The court found that Northern Rivers 4WD did not consult with the Applicants about their potential redundancy, as required by the relevant modern award. Therefore, the court did not need to consider whether the Applicants' jobs were redundant or whether it would have been reasonable to redeploy the Applicants, as the dismissals were not genuine redundancies.

The court then assessed whether the dismissals were harsh, unjust or unreasonable under section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009. The court found that there was a valid reason for the dismissal related to the Applicants' capacity or conduct, as the employer decided to cease trading at the Ballina site. However, the Applicants were not notified of the valid reason for their dismissal prior to the dismissal taking effect, and they were not given an opportunity to respond to the reasons for their dismissal. These factors pointed in favour of the dismissals being unfair.

The court also considered other factors relevant to determining whether the dismissals were harsh, unjust or unreasonable, such as the size of the employer’s enterprise and the lack of dedicated human resource management expertise. While these factors slightly favoured the employer, the procedural unfairness identified in the dismissals was significant enough to render the dismissals unfair. Therefore, the court found that the dismissals of the Applicants were unfair.

In determining the appropriate remedy, the court considered compensation as an alternative to reinstatement. The court found that the Applicants had suffered minimal financial loss due to their workers' compensation benefits, but nevertheless, an order for compensation was appropriate to compensate them for being unfairly dismissed. The court awarded each applicant 24 hours' pay as compensation, considering all the circumstances of the case. The court also ordered that Northern Rivers 4WD pay the Applicants their respective compensation amounts within 21 days of the decision, plus an additional component for superannuation.