Roy Hoppenbrouwer v Aurrum Pty Ltd T/A Aurrum Norah Head

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read
[2017] FWC 6747
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Roy Hoppenbrouwer
v
Aurrum Pty Ltd T/A Aurrum Norah Head
(U2017/7636)

COMMISSIONER SAUNDERS

NEWCASTLE, 15 DECEMBER 2017

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – breaches of medication management policy – valid reason for dismissal – inconsistent treatment – summary dismissal disproportionate to misconduct – dismissal harsh and unreasonable – compensation ordered.

[1] Mr Roy Hoppenbrouwer was employed as a Registered Nurse by Aurrum Pty Ltd T/A Aurrum Norah Head (Aurrum) from 30 October 2015 until his summary dismissal on 26 June 2017. Mr Hoppenbrouwer filed an application for unfair dismissal remedy in the Fair Work Commission (Commission) on 14 July 2017 pursuant to s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) in which he alleges that his dismissal was harsh, unjust and unreasonable. Aurrum denies those allegations.

Determinative Conference

[2] After taking into account the views of the parties, I decided to deal with the matter by way of a determinative conference.

[3] The determinative conference took place on 16, 17 and 18 October 2017 and 3 November 2017. Mr Hoppenbrouwer was represented at the hearing by his brother, Mr Paul Hoppenbrouwer, who is not a lawyer but who has experience in human resources. Aurrum was represented with permission by Mr Benjamin Gee, solicitor, of FCB Group.

[4] Mr Hoppenbrouwer gave evidence in support of his application and adduced evidence from the following witnesses:

    ● Mr Sean Paton, a Registered Nurse who formerly worked at Aurrum Norah Head;

    ● Mrs Jennifer Hoppenbrouwer, the applicant’s wife;

    ● Dr Mary Dover, a General Practitioner who had patients at Aurrum Norah Head;

    ● Mr Vaneshkumar Nayak, a Pharmacist at Chemist Warehouse Gosford; and

    ● Dr Rodney Jilek, CEO of Gallipoli Health Care and Principal Adviser at Aged Care Advisory Services.

[5] Aurrum adduced evidence in support of its case from:

    ● Ms Glenda Walker, National Clinical and Operations Director of Aurrum;

    ● Ms Angy Dinevska, Human Resources Director of Aurrum;

    ● Ms Caroline Mwania, National Quality & Education Director of Aurrum; and

    ● Mr Kenneth Gleeson, a Registered Nurse working at Aurrum Norah Head.

Initial matters to be considered

[6] Section 396 of the Act sets out four matters which I am required to decide before I consider the merits of Mr Hoppenbrouwer’s application.

[7] There is no dispute between the parties and I am satisfied on the evidence that:

    (a) Mr Hoppenbrouwer’s application was made within the period required in s.394(2) of the Act; and

    (b) Mr Hoppenbrouwer was a person protected from unfair dismissal; and

    (c) Aurrum was not a “small business employer” as defined in s.23 of the Act, so the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code does not apply to the dismissal; and

    (d) Mr Hoppenbrouwer’s dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy.

Was the dismissal harsh, unjust and/or unreasonable?

[8] Section 387 of the Act requires that I take into account the matters specified in paragraphs (a) to (h)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roy Hoppenbrouwer v Aurrum Pty Ltd T/A Aurrum Norah Head and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FWC 6747
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Roy Hoppenbrouwer v Aurrum Pty Ltd T/A Aurrum Norah Head involved an employee, Mr Hoppenbrouwer, who was summarily dismissed by his employer, Aurrum Pty Ltd, trading as Aurrum Norah Head. The Fair Work Commission was tasked with determining whether the dismissal was unfair, and if so, what remedy, if any, should be ordered. The crux of the dispute centred around alleged breaches of the employer’s medication management policy and inconsistent treatment of the employee compared to others in similar situations.

The primary legal issues before the Commission were whether the employer had a valid reason to dismiss Mr Hoppenbrouwer and, if so, whether the dismissal was fair and reasonable in the circumstances. The employer argued that the dismissal was justified due to Mr Hoppenbrouwer's failure to adhere to the medication management policy, while the employee contended that the dismissal was disproportionate and unfair, particularly in light of the employer's inconsistent application of its own policies.

In assessing these issues, the Commission found that while Mr Hoppenbrouwer did breach the medication management policy, the employer’s decision to summarily dismiss him was disproportionate and therefore harsh and unreasonable. The employer had not consistently enforced its policies, treating other employees who had breached similar policies more leniently. The Commission concluded that the dismissal was not a fair response to the misconduct and ordered compensation for the unfair dismissal.

The Fair Work Commission ordered Aurrum Pty Ltd to pay Mr Hoppenbrouwer compensation for the unfair dismissal. The amount of compensation was determined based on the loss suffered by Mr Hoppenbrouwer, which included lost wages and the distress caused by the unfair dismissal process.