Note: Judicial review of this decision [FCA-VID1082/2013] pending.
[2013] FWCFB 6191 |
FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604—Appeal of decision
v
Australian Postal Corporation T/A Australia Post
(C2011/6623)
VICE PRESIDENT LAWLER | SYDNEY, 28 AUGUST 2013 |
Appeal against decision [[2011] FWA 7126] of Commissioner Lewin at Melbourne on 4 November 2011 in matter numbers U2010/15319, U2010/15398, U2010/15320 - Appeal – unfair dismissal – emailing pornography in breach of policy – dismissal may be harsh, unjust or unreasonable notwithstanding valid reason – correct approach to assessing valid reason – correct approach to assessing whether dismissal is harsh, unjust and unreasonable notwithstanding a finding that there was a valid reason for dismissal..
REASONS FOR DECISION OF VICE PRESIDENT LAWLER AND COMMISSIONER CRIBB
[1] This Full Bench has before it applications for permission to appeal and cross-appeal against a decision ([2011] FWA 7126) in relation to unfair dismissal applications brought by three employees of Australia Post. Section 400 applies to each of the appeals and, accordingly:
(a) permission to appeal pursuant to s.604(1) must not be granted from a decision made under Part 3.2 unless FWA considers that it is in the public interest to do so (s.400(1)); and
(b) appeals on a question of fact can only be made on the ground that the decision involved a ‘significant error of fact’ (s 400(2)).
[2] This is not a case where there is any serious challenge to the Commissioner’s primary findings of fact.
[3] There is an emerging trend in the decided cases towards regarding the accessing, sending or receiving and storing pornography by an employee as a form of serious misconduct that invariably merits termination of employment. Such a proposition is inconsistent with basic principle. Accessing, sending or receiving and storing pornography is not a separate species of misconduct to which special rules apply. In the context of an application for an unfair dismissal remedy, it is a form of misconduct to which the same general principles apply as apply in all unfair dismissal matters involving reliance on misconduct.
[4] We are satisfied that the emerging prominence of dismissals based on pornography related breaches of employer policy, and a concern that the decision of the Full Bench in Queensland Rail v Wake (2006) 156 IR 393 (Queensland Rail) is being misinterpreted, supplies the public interest required for grant leave to appeal in this case. This case proves to be a suitable vehicle to address that matter of public interest. We grant permission to appeal. Having granted permission to appeal, the appeal proceeds as a rehearing albeit that the Full Bench cannot exercise any of the powers conferred by s.607(3) unless error is established: Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v AIRC (2001) 203 CLR 194 at [17] and [32].
The relationship between “valid reason” and “harsh, unjust and unreasonable”
[5] This appeal has highlighted a tension or ambiguity in the jurisprudence going to what is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read B, C and D v Australian Postal Corporation T/A Australia Pos... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FWCFB 6191
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the dismissals were based on a valid reason, as the respondents had breached company policy by emailing pornography. However, the court also held that the dismissals may have been harsh, unjust, or unreasonable, as the respondents had not acted with malice or ill-intent and had otherwise been good employees. The court considered the nature and seriousness of the breach, the respondents' conduct and employment history, and the employer's response to the breach. The court held that the dismissals were not proportionate to the breach and that there were alternative disciplinary measures that could have been taken. The court also held that the employer had not provided adequate opportunities for the respondents to address the breach before dismissing them.
The court remitted the matter to the Commissioner for reconsideration, with directions to consider the appropriate remedy, including reinstatement or compensation. The court held that the Commissioner should take into account the factors set out in the decision of the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission in Craig and Anor v WorkCover Authority of NSW [2010] FWAFB 4099. The court also held that the Commissioner should consider the respondents' conduct and employment history, the nature and seriousness of the breach, and the employer's response to the breach. The court emphasised that the Commissioner should not simply focus on the breach itself, but should also consider the overall circumstances of the case.
The final orders of the court were that the appeal be allowed and the matter be remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration, with directions. The court also ordered that the respondents be paid compensation for the period of their unlawful dismissal, and that the employer pay the respondents' legal costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi