Rosecove Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Rosecove Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission  & Ors [2022] QCAT 235

PARTIES:

ROSECOVE PTY LTD 

(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(First respondent)

DIAMANTINA SHIRE COUNCIL 

(Second respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR055-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

27 June 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

A/ Senior Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.   The time for compliance with Direction 2 of the Tribunal Directions dated 22 February 2022 is extended to 4:00pm on 29 March 2022.

2.   The time for compliance with Direction 3 of the Tribunal Directions dated 22 February 2022 is extended to 4:00pm on 24 March 2022.

3.   The application for a notice to produce filed by the applicant on 4 January 2022 is allowed in the following terms:

In respect of categories 1 to 9 (with the exception referred to in these Reasons in relation to category 6):

(a)   that if in a position to do so, the second respondent file and serve on the applicant within 7 days an affidavit, which may be on information and belief, deposing to whether and if so what documents, if any, within the possession and control of the Council exist in each of the said categories, beyond those already provided and produce such documents to the applicant;

(b)  if such an affidavit not be filed and served as required in Order 3(a), that the second respondent produce to the applicants the documents in each of the said categories.

4.   Costs of the application for a notice to produce filed by the applicant on 4 January 2022 are reserved.

5.   The parties are to agree and file two (2) copies in the Tribunal of an indexed and paginated Hearing Book which contains all of the material upon which each party intends to rely, the Hearing Book to be filed not less than 7 days prior to the Hearing.

6.   The Hearing Book should include the following material in so far as each party intends to rely upon it:

(a)     Formal documents;

(b)     Applicant’s statements of evidence, including reports;

(c)     Respondents’ statements of evidence, including reports;

(d)        Joint Expert Report;

(e)        Submissions.

7.   Any objections to any material contained in the Hearing Book should be filed and served at least 3 days prior to the Hearing. The objections will be determined at the Hearing by the Presiding Member.

8.   No party will be permitted to rely on any evidence not contained in the Hearing Book without the leave of the Tribunal.

9.   The parties must file a proposed Hearing Plan which includes the names and contact details of all witnesses to be called by either party not less than 7 days prior to the Hearing.

10.  Unless the Tribunal otherwise orders, all witnesses must attend the Hearing in person for cross examination. Any application for a witness to attend the Hearing by remote conferencing must be made, not less than 14 days before the Hearing.

11.  The matter is listed for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rosecove Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Comm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCAT 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rosecove Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission involves an application by the applicant for the production of certain documents from the Council in the context of a review of an internal review decision confirming a direction to rectify (DTR) issued to the applicant by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC). The applicant disputes that the building work carried out by it was the cause of the movement and damage to a dwelling, and seeks documents that it believes may support its case. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal should order the production of certain documents from the Council, and if so, under what conditions. The court considered the principles governing the production of documents, the objects of the QCAT Act, and the importance and likely benefits of the documents to the applicant.

The court reasoned that the Tribunal has a discretion to order the production of documents, which should be exercised by balancing the costs, time, and possible oppression to the party required to produce against the importance and likely benefits to the applying party. The court noted that the production of documents will generally only be ordered if certain criteria are met, such as the documents probably relating to a matter in question in the proceedings, being specified with sufficient particularity, and the order being in the interests of justice. The court also considered the objects of the QCAT Act, which include dealing with matters in a way that is accessible, fair, just, economical, informal, and quick. The court found that the Council had not provided sufficient evidence to support its assertion that certain documents did not exist or had already been provided, and ordered the Council to file and serve an affidavit deposing to the relevant facts and produce the documents, if they existed, within 14 days. If the Council failed to do so, the court directed that the documents be produced.

In conclusion, the court ordered the Council to provide an affidavit deposing to the existence and location of certain documents, and to produce those documents if they existed, within 14 days. The court also noted that the applicant's purported reply submissions were generally inappropriate, but had taken them into account. The costs of the application were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before turning to considering each category of documents separately and the parties’ respective submissions,[1] it is instructive to set out the statutory provision and principles to be applied in determining the application and the issues raised by the matter. I granted a short extension to each of the respondents to file any submissions in response to the application.[2][1]Application for miscellaneous matters (for direction requiring another party to produce a document) filed by the applicant on 4 January 2022; Submissions by First Respondent filed on 29 March 2022; Submissions by Second Respondent filed on 24 March 2022. [2]Application to extend a time limit filed by the second respondent on 24 March 2022.Relevant background The applicant is seeking to review an Internal Review decision of the QBCC to give a direction to rectify (DTR) to it pursuant to s 72 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (QBCC Act) to rectify alleged defective work said to be carried out by the applicant. The internal review decision to issue the DTR was made on 14 December 2017 and the DTR was issued on 16 January 2018. In conducting a review of a DTR decision, the Tribunal must consider whether:(a)the work performed was “building work”;(b)the building work is “defective”;(c)the applicant carried out the building work; and(d)it is fair, in all the circumstances, to give a DTR to the applicant.[3][3]CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 191. In brief, the applicant and the Council entered into a contract on 8 April 2010 for the construction of a lowset brick veneer dwelling which was completed on 12 December 2011. The Council wrote to the applicant on 12 March 2015 regarding possible subsidence occurring to the dwelling and lodged a complaint with the QBCC on 12 December 2016. The movement of the dwelling was outside the acceptable degree of movement as prescribed by the BCA and AS2870. The QBCC considered the subsidence was due to defective building work and so issued a DTR to the applicant. The decision to issue the DTR was confirmed on internal review.[4] The applicant disputes that building work carried out by it was the cause or the primary cause of the movement to and/or consequential damage to the dwelling on the Property. The applicant refers to other potential causes, including that the Council was responsible for obtaining the soil classification; the Council’s tenant overwatered the Property; the Council by its agent prepared the building pad and that the Council by its agent supplied and delivered the concrete for the applicant to construct the footings and slab.[4]Internal Review Decision Notice dated 14 December 2017. A Joint Expert Report (JER) prepared by Mr Peter Wright (engaged by Council), Mr Lindsay Reid (engaged by applicant) and Mr Adam Buckley (engaged by the QBCC) was filed in the Tribunal on 11 May 2021 and forwarded to the parties on 8 June 2021. The applicant refers to the following points made in the JER relating to: an absence of a water meter reading at the commencement of construction (Mr Wright); the addition of water to an agitator truck on site can have an impact on the final strength of the concrete (Mr Wright); the concrete strength was lower than specified in the design; the deflection would have been less if the specified concrete strength had been used (Mr Reid); site classification is “P” due to uncontrolled fill on the site (Mr Buckley and Mr Wright, dissent by Mr Reid); builder has obligation to make owner aware of appropriate homeowner management practices (Mr Buckley and Mr Wright, dissent by Mr Reid).Applicant’s submissions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am satisfied these documents are relevant. I note the Council says that they have been disclosed.Conclusion The application for the production of the requested documents in category 6, in so far as it relates to geotechnical reports not in relation to the subject property, is refused. In respect of all categories of documents the Council has submitted, in reliance on Ms Ling’s statement, that the documents do not exist. Ordinarily, in my opinion, where a respondent seeks to resist an application for production of documents on the basis the documents do not exist, or that all of those sought have been provided, it will be insufficient for it to rely on a statement. In such circumstances, an affidavit deposing to the relevant facts is preferable. I note that in the UCPR, and in the Supreme Court Rules (Qld) which preceded them, the Court had power to order a party to provide an affidavit deposing to whether documents exist and whether they are, or were, within its possession or control. The Tribunal has power to make such an order and I propose to do so here, failing which I will direct the documents be produced. Accordingly, I order, in respect of categories 1 to 9 (with the exception above in relation to 6): (a)That if in a position to do so, the second respondent file and serve on the applicant within 14 days an affidavit, which may be on information and belief, deposing to whether and if so what documents, if any, within the possession and control of the Council exist in each of the said categories, beyond those already provided, and produce such documents to the applicant;(b)If such an affidavit is not filed and served as required in (a), that the second respondent produce to the applicants the documents in each of the said categories (save the exception above in relation to category 6). I note that the applicant filed submissions dated 10 May 2022 in purported reply to the Council’s submissions. The applicant did not seek a direction, and no direction was made in the Tribunal Directions dated 22 February 2022, for the applicant to make such submissions. The Council objected to the receipt of the submissions by the Tribunal and was entitled to do so. It is generally inappropriate for further submissions to be filed in circumstances where there is no direction permitting them and in the absence of the leave of the Tribunal.[26] That is particularly so here because much of what was submitted in reply should have been part of the respondent’s primary submissions.[26]Miller and Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Ltd (2010) 241 CLR 357 at [111]; NT Power Generation Pty Ltd v Power and Water Authority (2004) 219 CLR 90 at [192]. That said, I have read the purported reply submissions and taken them into account. The costs of the application are reserved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents’ submit that the application should be dismissed because the categories of requested documents are either:(a)not relevant; (b)where the Council has already made clear that there are no other documents to be disclosed; and(c)is in respect of document that would already be in the possession of the applicant but which he himself has failed to disclose.Consideration The Tribunal has a discretion as to whether to make directions that a party produce certain documents. In exercising that discretion, the Tribunal will balance the costs, time and possible oppression to the party required to produce against the importance and likely benefits to the applying party.[5] [5]Simpson v Thorn Australia Pty Ltd trading as Radio Rentals[2018] FCA 1219 at [9], applied in Douglas v CTML Pty Ltd & Ors [2018] QCAT 461 at [6]. The applicant refers to the following principles they say are “well-established”, as set out in Abbott v Queensland Building and Construction Commission:[6]The production of documents will generally only be ordered if an applicant can establish that: (a) The documents probably relate to a matter in question in the proceedings; (b) The documents sought must be specified with sufficient particularity to enable the specific documents or categories of documents to be identified; (c) An order for the production of the documents is in the interests of justice and will facilitate the just and expeditious resolution of the real issues in the proceedings at a minimum of expense.[7] [6][2021] QCATA 145.[7]Ibid at [15]. The discretion should also be exercised in view of the objects of the QCAT Act, which include to have the Tribunal deal with matters in a way that is:accessible, fair, just, economical, informal and quick.[8][8]QCAT Act, s 3(b). Also relevant is s 28(3) of the QCAT Act which provides:….(d) must act with as little formality and technicality and with as much speed as the requirements of this Act, an enabling Act or the rules and a proper consideration of the matters before the tribunal permit; and(e) must ensure, so far as is practicable, that all relevant material is disclosed to the tribunal to enable it to decide the proceeding with all the relevant facts. The Tribunal, in the exercise of its discretion under s 62(3) of the QCAT Act, should do so in the context of and within the parameters of the scope of review before it. In this case, that is a review of a decision on internal review confirming the original decision to give a direction to rectify to the applicant pursuant to s 72 of the QBCC Act. The Tribunal on review must determine whether the correct and preferable decision is to give a direction to rectify to the applicant. The applicant asserts that, in respect of the first six categories of documents that the Council has failed to provide evidence in support of a number of issues identified in the JER. The applicant asserts, in respect of the other 3 categories, that the documents should have been provided by the Council.