CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2019] QCAT 191

PARTIES:

CMG HOMES PTY LTD
(applicant)

v

QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR171-18

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review matters

DELIVERED ON:

28 June 2019

HEARING DATE:

27 May 2019

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Susan Burke

ORDERS:

1.   The Direction to Rectify No 0103352 issued by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission on 1 May 2019 is set aside.

2.   Costs to be determined on the papers upon each party delivering submissions to the tribunal in relation to costs on or before 18 July 2019.

CATCHWORDS:

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – DIRECTION TO RECTIFY – where complaint by homeowners that building work defective – whether it is unfair in the circumstances to require rectification.

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s72, s86, s87, Schedule 2

Chew v QBSA [2010] QCAT 501
Dixon Projects Pty Ltd v QBSA [2009] QCCTB 2
Glen Williams Pty Ltd v QBSA [2012] QCAT 127
Imperial Homes (Queensland) Pty Ltd v QBSA [2014] QCAT 42
JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd v QBSA [2013] QCAT 502
Kehl v Board of Professional Engineers of Queensland [2010] QCATA 58
Laidlaw v QBSA [2010] QCAT 70
QBSA v O’Brien & Ors [2002] QDC 329
R v His Honour Judge Miller and  the Builder’s Registration Board of Queensland, exparte Graham Evans & Co (Qld) Pty Ltd [1987] 2 Qd R 446
Stephenson v QBSA [2005] QCCTB 59; Mackay v QBSA [2011] QCAT 346

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

S Taylor, Counsel, instructed by Crouch & Lyndon Solicitors

Respondent:

S Tabai Walu, in-house solicitor for the Queensland Building Construction Commission

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. On 1 May 2019, the Queensland Building Construction Commission (“the QBCC”) made a decision to issue a direction to rectify (“the DTR”) in relation to alleged defective work performed by CMG Homes Pty Ltd (“CMG”) at 18 Haigh Crescent Samford Valley Queensland (“the property”).[1]

    [1]Exhibit 1 – Statement of Ian Chaplin at annexure “IC-2”

  2. CMG seeks a review of the DTR pursuant to sections 86(1)(e), 86E(a) and 87 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (“QBCC Act”) and seeks to set aside the decision of the QBCC to issue a direction to rectify.

    Jurisdiction of Tribunal to review a Decision of the QBCC

  3. Section 87 of the QBCC Act provides that a person affected by a reviewable decision of the QBCC may apply to the tribunal for a review of the decision.

  4. Section 86(1)(e) of the QBCC Act relevantly provides that a decision of the QBCC to give a direction to rectify or remedy, or not to give a direction, is a reviewable decision.

  5. Section 20(1) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (“QCAT Act”) provides that the purpose of a review is to produce a correct and preferable decision. The QCAT Act provides that the tribunal must hear and decide a review of a reviewable decision by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CMG Homes Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Com... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QCAT 191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

CMG Homes Pty Ltd applied for review of a decision by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC) to issue a Direction to Rectify (DTR) under section 72 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991. The QBCC had found that CMG’s work was defective in relation to soil moisture, the operation of the slab, and brick efflorescence. The tribunal was required to determine if the building work was defective, whether CMG was responsible for the defects, and whether it was fair to require CMG to rectify the defects. The tribunal considered evidence from experts and found that the soil moisture and slab edge dampness issues were caused by the homeowners’ landscaping work rather than CMG’s construction work. The tribunal held that it would be unfair to require CMG to rectify the defects, given the homeowners’ landscaping work had exacerbated the problems. The tribunal set aside the QBCC’s decision to issue the DTR and ordered that costs be determined on the papers.

The central legal issue before the tribunal was whether it was fair to require CMG to rectify defects in the building work, given that the homeowners had undertaken landscaping works that had contributed to the problems. The tribunal considered the statutory objects of the QBCC Act and the relevant policy, which required rectification of defective work by the builder. However, the tribunal found that it would be unfair to require CMG to rectify the defects, as the homeowners’ landscaping work had exacerbated the issues. The tribunal exercised its discretion to set aside the QBCC’s decision to issue the DTR. The tribunal’s decision was based on the evidence that the homeowners’ landscaping work, not CMG’s construction work, was the primary cause of the soil moisture and slab edge dampness problems. The tribunal concluded that it would be unfair to require CMG to rectify defects caused by the homeowners’ actions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Direction to Rectify No 0103352 issued by the Queensland Building and Construction Commission on 1 May 2019 is set aside.

2. Costs to be determined on the papers upon each party delivering submissions to the tribunal in relation to costs on or before 18 July 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

In an application for review of a decision to issue or not issue a direction to rectify under section 72 of the QBCC Act, the following matters must be determined by the tribunal:-(a)Is the building work defective?(b)Is the builder responsible for the building work”(c)Is it fair, in all the circumstances, for the tribunal standing in the shoes of the QBCC to exercise the discretion to issue the direction to rectify to the builder? Factual Background On or about 25 March 2011, CMG entered into a contract with David and Jill Van Dorssen and Carl and Kylie Houlihan (‘the homeowners”) for the construction of a low set brick dwelling at the property.[5][5]Exhibit 1 – Statement of Ian Chaplin dated 10 August 2018 – annexure “IC-3” The works commenced on 2 April 2011 and were completed to Practical Completion on 30 November 2011. Sometime after Practical Completion, the homeowners undertook further works to the property including landscaping works which included:(a)installation of raised garden beds within the courtyard area (Drawing number J180462-01 at “LOC2”);(b)planting of vegetation within the above mentioned garden bed area;(c)laying of gravel and stepping stones throughout the courtyard area, such placement being over the existing above-ground drainage system;(d)various landscaping works including placement of a retaining wall at the front left hand side of the property (Drawing number J180462-01 at “LOC1”) and the placement of a swimming pool and other landscaping works at the front right hand side of the property (Drawing number J180462-01 at “LOC3”).[6][6]Exhibit 1 - Statement of Ian Chaplin dated 10 August 2018 – see photo of works performed by CMG at annexure “IC-21” and photo of works performed by the homeowners at annexure “IC-22”. On 20 July 2012, the homeowners made a complaint to the QBCC regarding purported defective works (“the first complaint”).[7][7]Exhibit 1 – annexure “IC-6” On 14 September 2012, after consulting the builder, the QBCC undertook an inspection of the property. On 7 October 2012, the QBCC produced an initial inspection report addressing the main complaint being efflorescence in the bricks concluding that the works were not defective and that the matters of complaint did not affect the structural integrity of the brickwork.[8][8]Exhibit 1 – annexure “IC-8” On 17 October 2012, the QBCC issued a direction to rectify to the builder with respect to 23 items of work but no direction was given in relation to the issue of brick efflorescence.[9][9]Exhibit 1- annexure “IC-9” During November and December 2012, CMG attended to the scope of works identified in the direction to rectify dated 17 October 2012. In the end result, it was determined by the QBCC that it would not be issuing a direction to rectify with regard to the brick efflorescence. Subsequently. the homeowners filed an application with the Queensland Commercial Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“the tribunal”) seeking to review the decision of the QBCC not to issue a direction to rectify with respect to a number of the 23 items the subject of complaint, namely those related to soil moisture, the operation of the slab and brick efflorescence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

According to Mr Chaplin, photographic evidence supports the conclusion that the garden beds installed by the homeowners outside or near the pantry have resulted in poor drainage in the area.[13] Drainage pits installed by CMG for the purpose of subsequent concreting of the area would have ensured the correct fall in the concrete slab and proper drainage. Landcaping carried out by the homeowners did not take advantage of the raised drainage pits.[14][13]Exhibit “5” – photographs of courtyard area[14]Annexures “IC21” and “IC22” to Exhibit 1; See also photgtaphs forming part of Exhibit “5”Expert Evidence Slab relative humidity testing was undertaken at the property to identify the extent of slab edge dampness, efflorescence and other relevant factors on 10 August 2018. An inspection report dated 15 August 2018 was prepared by a senior structural engineer, Mr Martin Illsley, engaged by NJA Consulting.[15] [15]Exhibit 6 – Statement of Mr Martin Illsley dated 18 April 2018 - annexure “MJI-2” A very comprehensive report was prepared by Mr John van de Hoef, senior structural engineer and director of NJA Consulting, after an inspection of the property on 14 June 2018. Mr van de Hoef produced a report dated 28 August 2018 and a supplementary statement dated 24 April 2019 which annexed documents referred to but omitted from the report dated 28 August 2018.[16][16]Exhibit “2” dated 20 March 2019 being a statement of Mr John van de Hoef with report dated 28 August 2018 at annexure “JVH-2” and Exhibit “3” being the supplementary statement of Mr John van de Hoef Mr van de Hoef undertook, as part of his scope of works, the tasks of determining the severity of any slab edge dampness and rising damp problems including:(a)carrying out a general inspection of the dwelling with particular emphasis on the signs of rising damp around the perimeter of the residence in a number of locations;(b)carrying out an inspection of the pantry to the left hand side of the residence to determine if there is slab edge dampness problems in this location;(c)attempting to determine the cause of moisture related problems. In relation to slab edge dampness, Mr van de Hoef concluded that the fundamental problem occurring on site is that the perimeter footings are effectively sitting in wet soils and the polythene membrane that extends under the footing system is most likely not terminated at the external ground surface adjacent to the perimeter footing. The result is that soil moisture is migrating through the edge footing via capillary action and is evaporating at the internal surface of the slab at the perimeter. It was noted that the slab edge dampness is presently limited to the pantry of the residence. Mr van de Hoef noted that the problem would be more severe if not for the site drainage conditions present around the residence. Mr van de Heof pointed to the following causes:(a)adopted termination point for the polythene membrane being at the inside edge of the perimeter footing (contrary to AS2870 which indicates that the normal termination point for the polythene membrane is at the external ground surface to the perimeter footings);(b)the site drainage conditions are not satisfactory and the presence of significant depths of gravel mulch around the perimeter of the residence creates conditions where evaporation and transpiration may not occur and therefore elevated moisture levels around the footing system would occur;(c)the sorptivity of the concrete footing system as a result of insufficient vibration and compaction of the concrete during construction.[17][17]Exhibit “2” at pages 23 and 24

Decision

Reasons for decision

CMG seeks a review of the DTR pursuant to sections 86(1)(e), 86E(a) and 87 of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld) (“QBCC Act”) and seeks to set aside the decision of the QBCC to issue a direction to rectify.Jurisdiction of Tribunal to review a Decision of the QBCC Section 87 of the QBCC Act provides that a person affected by a reviewable decision of the QBCC may apply to the tribunal for a review of the decision. Section 86(1)(e) of the QBCC Act relevantly provides that a decision of the QBCC to give a direction to rectify or remedy, or not to give a direction, is a reviewable decision. Section 20(1) of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act (“QCAT Act”) provides that the purpose of a review is to produce a correct and preferable decision. The QCAT Act provides that the tribunal must hear and decide a review of a reviewable decision by way of a fresh hearing on the merits.[2][2]Kehl v Board of Professional Engineers of Queensland [2010] QCATA 58 at [9] Section 24 of the QCAT Act provides that in a proceeding for a review of a reviewable decision, the tribunal may:(a)confirm or amend the decision; or(b)set aside the decision and substitute its own decision; or(c)set aside the decision and return the matter for reconsideration to the decision-maker for the decision, with directions that the tribunal considers appropriate.Power to Direct Rectification Part 6 of the QBCC Act sets out the QBCC’s power to require rectification of defective building work. Section 72 of the QBCC Act relevantly provides:“72 Power to require rectification of building work(1)This section applies if the commission is of the opinion that – (a) building work is defective or incomplete; or(b) consequential damage has been caused by, or as a consequence of, carrying out building work.(2)The commission may direct the person who carried out the building work to do the following within the period stated in the direction –(a) for building work that is defective or incomplete – rectify the building work;(b) for consequential damage – remedy the damage.(3)In deciding whether to give the direction, the commission may take into consideration all the circumstances it considers are reasonably relevant and, in particular, is not limited to a consideration of the terms of the contract for carrying out the building work (including the terms of any warranties included in the contract).(4)……….(5)The commission is not required to give the direction if the commission is satisfied that, in the circumstances, it would be unfair to the person to give the direction.Example for subsection (5) – The commission might decide not to give a direction for the rectification of building work because an owner refuses to allow a building contractor to return to the owner’s hoe or because an owner’s failure to properly maintain a home has exacerbated the extent of defective building work carried out on the home.” Schedule 2 of the QBCC Act defines the terms “building work” and “defective” for the purpose of assisting the commission in its deliberation as whether a direction to rectify should issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The exercise of the discretion of the tribunal must be exercised in accordance with the objects of the QBCC Act which are clearly defined in section 3 of the QBCC Act.Policy Considerations In addition to the requirements of the QBCC Act, the tribunal, standing in the shoes of the QBCC, is required to exercise its discretion in considering whether a direction to rectify should issue by taking into account relevant policies.[3][3]Chew v QBSA [2010] QAT 501 at [28]; Imperial Homes (Queensland) Pty Ltd v QBSA [2014] QCAT 42 at [15]; Ramke Constructions Pty Ltd v QBSA (No 2) [2103] 575 The applicable version of the policy in force at the time of the DTR under review is that in force effective from 10 October 2014[4] which relevantly provides:“(i) Rectification of Defective Work(1)It is a policy of the Queensland Building Services Board that a building contractor who carries out defective work should be required to rectify that work.(2)To remove any doubt, subsection (1) applies despite the building contractor failing to comply with the contracted plans and specifications for the work.” [4]Rectification of Building Work Policy being annexure SOR-1 of the Statement of Reasons filed 11 July 2018 – Exhibit “7” Under the Rectification Policy, defects are categorised as to whether they are structural defects or non-structural defects and each of those terms are expressly defined in the Rectification Policy.Issues for Determination In an application for review of a decision to issue or not issue a direction to rectify under section 72 of the QBCC Act, the following matters must be determined by the tribunal:-(a)Is the building work defective?(b)Is the builder responsible for the building work”(c)Is it fair, in all the circumstances, for the tribunal standing in the shoes of the QBCC to exercise the discretion to issue the direction to rectify to the builder? Factual Background On or about 25 March 2011, CMG entered into a contract with David and Jill Van Dorssen and Carl and Kylie Houlihan (‘the homeowners”) for the construction of a low set brick dwelling at the property.[5][5]Exhibit 1 – Statement of Ian Chaplin dated 10 August 2018 – annexure “IC-3” The works commenced on 2 April 2011 and were completed to Practical Completion on 30 November 2011. Sometime after Practical Completion, the homeowners undertook further works to the property including landscaping works which included:(a)installation of raised garden beds within the courtyard area (Drawing number J180462-01 at “LOC2”);(b)planting of vegetation within the above mentioned garden bed area;(c)laying of gravel and stepping stones throughout the courtyard area, such placement being over the existing above-ground drainage system;(d)various landscaping works including placement of a retaining wall at the front left hand side of the property (Drawing number J180462-01 at “LOC1”) and the placement of a swimming pool and other landscaping works at the front right hand side of the property (Drawing number J180462-01 at “LOC3”).[6][6]Exhibit 1 - Statement of Ian Chaplin dated 10 August 2018 – see photo of works performed by CMG at annexure “IC-21” and photo of works performed by the homeowners at annexure “IC-22”.