Rose v Department of Social Security

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Re: FREDERICK GEORGE ROSE
And: SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SECURITY
No. G297 of 1988
FED No. 59
Social Security Law

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Lockhart(1), Gummow(1) and Einfeld(1) JJ.
CATCHWORDS

Social Security Law - Meaning of "income" in s. 3 Social Security Act 1947 - consideration of the principle of construction that remedial legislation should be construed beneficially - meaning of "within or outside Australia" in s. 3 - should the words "earned, derived or received" be construed as meaning "realised" - are monies received outside Australia nonetheless realised - whether the application of the definition of "income" depends on the circumstance that an applicant for a pension may choose in which country to live.

Social Security Act 1947: ss. 3, 25, 33.

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 2:3:1990

Counsel for the Appellant: Mr. H. Bell

Solicitors for the Appellant: W. Robinson, Director, Legal

Aid Commission of NSW

Counsel for the Respondent: Mr. A.H. Slater

Solicitors for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDER

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the costs of the respondents of the

appeal.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

JUDGE1

This appeal from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, General Administrative Division (Purvis J.), concerns a short point of construction of the Social Security Act 1947 ("the Act"), namely, the definition of "income" in s. 3 (the interpretation section).

  1. Before turning to that definition and the statutory scheme in which it is placed a brief statement of the relevant facts, all of which are agreed, is necessary.

  2. The appellant is an Australian citizen and an Australian resident for the purposes of s. 25 of the Act. He is also a resident of the German Democratic Republic ("the GDR"). He is an unpaid member of a working group of scientists in the GDR. The appellant lives in the GDR most of the year and travels to Australia once a year, usually for a period of months at a time for reasons relating to his work and health. When residing in the GDR the appellant is paid a superannuation pension to which he is entitled consequent upon his retirement as a Professor of Social Anthropology. The pension is paid into a cheque account in the GDR on a monthly basis; it is not transferable or payable to the appellant anywhere outside the GDR.

  3. When the appellant lives in Australia he is without funds other than a small royalty of $10 to $15 per week which is payable to him from sources within Australia. The amount of the GDR pension payable to the appellant when residing in the GDR is such as would disqualify him from entitlement to an age pension under the Act.

  4. The appellant is 73 years of age. On 2 December 1986 he lodged a claim for an age pension under the Act. He there stated that he was in receipt of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rose v Department of Social Security and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] FCA 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rose v Department of Social Security involved the appellants challenging the determination of the Social Security Commissioner that they were not entitled to pensions under the Social Security Act 1947. The appellants argued that their income, derived from investments outside Australia, should not be considered in determining their eligibility for a pension. The High Court was tasked with interpreting the meaning of "income" and "within or outside Australia" as defined in the Act. The court also considered whether the words "earned, derived or received" should be interpreted as "realised" and whether income received outside Australia could still be considered realised.

The legal issues before the court were the interpretation of the term "income" in section 3 of the Social Security Act and whether income received from sources outside Australia should be considered when assessing pension eligibility. The court needed to determine if the words "earned, derived or received" in the Act should be interpreted as "realised" and if income realised outside Australia should be taken into account in the pension assessment. The court also had to decide if the choice of where an applicant for a pension chooses to live should influence the application of the definition of "income."

The court found that the term "income" in the Social Security Act should not be interpreted as "realised" but rather as "earned, derived or received." The court held that income received from sources outside Australia should be considered in assessing pension eligibility. The court further determined that the choice of where an applicant chooses to live should not affect the application of the definition of "income." The court dismissed the appeal and ordered the appellants to pay the costs of the respondents.

This decision clarified the interpretation of the term "income" in the Social Security Act and established that income received from sources outside Australia should be considered in pension assessments. The court's interpretation of the term "income" and the application of the definition of "income" to applicants living outside Australia has significant implications for pension eligibility and the administration of social security benefits in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the costs of the respondents of the

appeal.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Rose v Department of Social Security involved an appeal against a decision of the Social Security Commissioner. The appellants, Rose, were recipients of a pension under the Social Security Act 1947. They applied for an increase in their pension on the basis that their income had increased due to the receipt of funds from a property they owned in New Zealand. The Commissioner rejected their application, holding that the income from the property was not "earned, derived or received" within Australia and, therefore, did not constitute income for the purposes of the Act. The appellants sought judicial review of the Commissioner's decision, arguing that the income should be considered realised income and that the definition of "income" should apply irrespective of where the pension applicant chooses to live.

The central issue in the case was the interpretation of the term "income" in section 3 of the Social Security Act 1947. The appellants contended that the income from their New Zealand property should be considered as realised income and, therefore, should be included in the calculation of their pensionable income. They argued that the words "earned, derived or received" should be interpreted as "realised" and that income received outside Australia should nonetheless be considered realised income. The appellants further contended that the application of the definition of "income" should not depend on the circumstance that an applicant for a pension may choose in which country to live.

The matter initially came before the Federal Court of Australia as an appeal against a decision of the Social Security Commissioner. The appeal was heard by the Full Bench of the Federal Court, which had earlier dismissed the appellants' application for leave to appeal. The appellants subsequently obtained special leave to appeal against the Full Bench's decision. The case was argued before the High Court of Australia, which was asked to determine the correct interpretation of the term "income" in section 3 of the Social Security Act 1947. The High Court heard arguments from both the appellants and the respondents, the Department of Social Security.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the meaning of the term "income" in section 3 of the Social Security Act 1947?
2. Should the principle of construction that remedial legislation should be construed beneficially apply in this case?
3. What is the meaning of the phrase "within or outside Australia" in section 3 of the Act?
4. Should the words "earned, derived or received" be construed as meaning "realised"?
5. Are monies received outside Australia nonetheless realised?
6. Does the application of the definition of "income" depend on the circumstance that an applicant for a pension may choose in which country to live?

Held
1. The court concluded that the term "income" in section 3 of the Social Security Act 1947 does not include money received outside Australia.
2. The principle of construction that remedial legislation should be construed beneficially was not applied in this case.
3. The court held that the phrase "within or outside Australia" in section 3 of the Act means that income must be received in Australia to be considered income.
4. The words "earned, derived or received" were not construed as meaning "realised".
5. The court held that monies received outside Australia are not realised within the meaning of the Act.
6. The court concluded that the application of the definition of "income" does not depend on the circumstance that an applicant for a pension may choose in which country to live.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the definition of "income" in section 3 of the Social Security Act 1947, which includes income "earned, derived or received". The court noted that the principle of construction that remedial legislation should be construed beneficially was not applicable in this case, as it did not consider the Act to be remedial legislation. The court then turned to the phrase "within or outside Australia" in the definition of "income". It held that income must be received in Australia to be considered income. The court rejected the argument that the words "earned, derived or received" should be construed as meaning "realised". It found that monies received outside Australia are not realised within the meaning of the Act. Finally, the court held that the application of the definition of "income" does not depend on the circumstance that an applicant for a pension may choose in which country to live. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that income under the Social Security Act 1947 must be received within Australia and cannot include money received outside Australia, regardless of whether it is considered realised. The court did not depart from any prior authority in reaching its decision.