Rockett v. Moneycorp Securities P/L & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Rockett v Moneycorp Securities P/L & Anor [2008] QSC 258

PARTIES:

LYNETTE JOY ROCKETT
(plaintiff)

v

MONEYCORP SECURITIES PTY LTD ACN 115 414 803
(first defendant)
ZORZAN – 0003 PTY LTD ACN 107 476 004
(second defendant)
WIDE BAY AUSTRALIA LIMITED ABN 40 087 652 060
(third defendant)

FILE NO:

BS9525/06

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application filed 10 October 2008
Application filed by leave 13 October 2008

DELIVERED ON:

21 October 2008

DELIVERED AT:

Supreme Court, Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

13 October 2008

JUDGE:

Wilson J

ORDERS:

1.   That upon settlement of the contracts between the plaintiff and the first defendant for the sale of Units 216 and 301, The Sands, 40 The Esplanade, Surfers Paradise (‘the Units’), the monies arising from the said sales and in fact received by the first defendant (as mortgagee in possession) are to be held on trust by the first defendant and applied by the first defendant as follows:

a.    Firstly, in discharge of the mortgage money, interest and costs due and owing pursuant to the first registered mortgage held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd over the Units (Mortgage No. 708057759);

b.    Secondly, in payment of the commission due to PRD Realty, Surfers Paradise, with respect to the sale of the Units by the first defendant to the plaintiff;

c.     Thirdly, in discharge of the mortgage money, interest and costs due and owing pursuant to the second registered mortgage held by Moneycorp Securities Pty Ltd over the Units (Mortgage No. 709482826).

2.   That there be no order as to costs.

3.   That this order be served by the plaintiff on the second defendant by way of facsimile to its solicitors, HW Litigation, and by posting a copy by ordinary post to its registered office.

4.   That the operation of Order 1 be stayed until 10 business days from service of the second defendant.

5.   That any Application by the second defendant for these orders to be vacated or varied be made within that period of 10 days and upon 2 business days notice to the plaintiff, and the first and third defendants.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – COSTS – RECOVERY OF COSTS – where the second registered mortgagee exercises its power of sale over two properties – where purchase prices paid by the plaintiff on settlement of contracts to be applied firstly to discharge the first registered mortgage, with balance to be held in trust pending assessment or agreement of amount of costs payable to the plaintiff – whether the agent's commission is payable out of the sale proceeds in priority to the amount secured by the first registered mortgage to the third defendant

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) s 88(1)

Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Evans [1992] 2 QdR 230, considered
Emerson & Anor v Custom Credit Corporation Limited (1991) Q Conv R [54-414], cited
Mercantile Credits Ltd v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1988) 48 SASR 407, cited
re Burns Philp Trustee…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rockett v. Moneycorp Securities P/L & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QSC 258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rockett v. Moneycorp Securities P/L & Anor involves a dispute concerning the application of funds received from the sale of two properties, Units 216 and 301, The Sands, 40 The Esplanade, Surfers Paradise. The plaintiff, Rockett, had entered into contracts for the sale of these units with the first defendant, who acted as the mortgagee in possession. The proceeds from these sales were to be applied to various debts, including mortgage payments, interest, costs, and an agent's commission. The second defendant, Moneycorp Securities, held a second registered mortgage over the units. The central issue was whether Moneycorp Securities' commission was payable from the sale proceeds in priority to the amount secured by the first registered mortgage held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd.

The court had to determine the order in which different debts were to be satisfied from the sale proceeds. Specifically, it needed to establish if the commission due to PRD Realty, Surfers Paradise, for the sale of the units was to be paid before the second mortgage was discharged, or if the first mortgage, held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd, had priority over these funds. The court's analysis involved interpreting the terms of the mortgages, the trust arrangements, and the obligations of the parties involved in the sale. The court concluded that the monies from the sale were to be applied in the order specified in the contracts, ensuring that the first mortgage was paid off before the second mortgage and the commission.

The court's reasoning was based on the contractual terms and the principles of trust law. It held that the monies were to be applied first to discharge the mortgage held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd, second to pay the commission due to PRD Realty, and third to discharge the mortgage held by Moneycorp Securities. This order was consistent with the terms of the contracts and the priority of the mortgages. The court further held that any application by Moneycorp Securities to vacate or vary these orders must be made within ten business days of service and with appropriate notice to the other parties.

The orders of the court required the first defendant to hold the sale proceeds on trust and apply them according to the specified order. Costs were not awarded to any party, and the orders were to be served on Moneycorp Securities by facsimile and by post. The operation of the order was stayed for ten business days to allow for any objections or applications to be made by Moneycorp Securities.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That upon settlement of the contracts between the plaintiff and the first defendant for the sale of Units 216 and 301, The Sands, 40 The Esplanade, Surfers Paradise (‘the Units’), the monies arising from the said sales and in fact received by the first defendant (as mortgagee in possession) are to be held on trust by the first defendant and applied by the first defendant as follows:

a. Firstly, in discharge of the mortgage money, interest and costs due and owing pursuant to the first registered mortgage held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd over the Units (Mortgage No. 708057759);

b. Secondly, in payment of the commission due to PRD Realty, Surfers Paradise, with respect to the sale of the Units by the first defendant to the plaintiff;

c. Thirdly, in discharge of the mortgage money, interest and costs due and owing pursuant to the second registered mortgage held by Moneycorp Securities Pty Ltd over the Units (Mortgage No. 709482826).

2. That there be no order as to costs.

3. That this order be served by the plaintiff on the second defendant by way of facsimile to its solicitors, HW Litigation, and by posting a copy by ordinary post to its registered office.

4. That the operation of Order 1 be stayed until 10 business days from service of the second defendant.

5. That any Application by the second defendant for these orders to be vacated or varied be made within that period of 10 days and upon 2 business days notice to the plaintiff, and the first and third defendants.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two properties known as Units 216 and 301, The Sands, 40 The Esplanade, Surfers Paradise. The plaintiff, Rockett, had entered into contracts to purchase these properties from the first defendant, who was the mortgagee in possession. The contracts included a provision that the purchase prices were to be applied firstly to discharge the first registered mortgage held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd over the properties, with any balance to be held in trust pending the assessment or agreement of the amount of costs payable to the plaintiff. The second defendant, Moneycorp Securities P/L, held the second registered mortgage over the properties and exercised its power of sale over the same properties. The plaintiff sought a declaration regarding the priority of payments from the sale proceeds, specifically whether the agent's commission was payable in priority to the amount secured by the first registered mortgage to the third defendant.

The matter came before the court on an application by the plaintiff seeking a declaration on the priority of payments from the sale proceeds of the two properties. The plaintiff argued that the agent's commission should be paid before the second mortgagee's amount, while the second defendant contended that the commission should not take priority over the first mortgagee's secured amount. The court heard arguments and submissions from both parties before making the orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the monies arising from the sale of the Units are to be held on trust and applied in the manner specified by the plaintiff.
2. Whether the agent's commission is payable out of the sale proceeds in priority to the amount secured by the first registered mortgage held by the third defendant.

Held
1. The court held that the monies arising from the sale of the Units are to be held on trust and applied in the manner specified by the plaintiff. Specifically, the first defendant (as mortgagee in possession) is to apply the sale proceeds in discharge of the mortgage money, interest, and costs due and owing pursuant to the first registered mortgage held by Wide Bay Australia Ltd over the Units, in payment of the commission due to PRD Realty for the sale of the Units, and in discharge of the mortgage money, interest, and costs due and owing pursuant to the second registered mortgage held by Moneycorp Securities Pty Ltd over the Units.
2. The court held that the agent's commission is not payable out of the sale proceeds in priority to the amount secured by the first registered mortgage held by the third defendant. Instead, the commission is to be paid after the first mortgage is discharged and before the second mortgage is settled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the terms of the contracts for the sale of the Units and the legal principles concerning priorities of charges and trusts. It was determined that the plaintiff had the right to specify how the sale proceeds should be applied, given the terms of the contracts and the trust arrangement. The court examined the priority of the two mortgages and the rights of the parties involved. The court noted that the agent's commission was not secured by the first mortgage, and therefore, it could not take precedence over the secured debt. The court followed established principles regarding the application of sale proceeds and the priority of charges, applying them to the specific facts of this case. The ratio decidendi is that where a trust is specified for the application of sale proceeds, and an agent's commission is not secured by the first mortgage, the commission does not take precedence over the secured debt in the application of sale proceeds.