JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: ROBERTSON and CITY OF ALBANY [2019] WASAT 3
MEMBER: DEPUTY PRESIDENT, JUDGE PARRY
MS M CONNOR (MEMBER)
HEARD: 14-16 AUGUST, 4 SEPTEMBER (VIEW) AND 12-14 SEPTEMBER 2018 - FURTHER DOCUMENTS AND SUBMISSIONS FILED ON 1, 2, 15, 16 AND 18 OCTOBER 2018
DELIVERED : 10 JANUARY 2019
FILE NO/S: DR 354 of 2017
BETWEEN: GRAEME ROBERTSON
Applicant
AND
CITY OF ALBANY
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning - Development application - Extractive industry - Limestone quarry - Nullaki Peninsula - Proximate to Bibbulmun Track and Nullaki campsite - Nullaki Peninsula Conservation Zone - Whether proposed development is capable of approval under City of Albany Local Planning Scheme No. 1 - Whether proposed development is consistent with orderly and proper planning Sustainable development Principles of sustainable development Whether proposed development would have unacceptable impact on amenity and character of locality as Conservation Zone - Whether proposed development would have unacceptable impact on natural environment - Whether traffic generation would exceed capacity of road system or have adverse impact on traffic flow and safety - Whether proposed variation of development standards and requirements would have adverse impact upon inhabitants of locality - Whether Bushfire Management Plan adequately addresses bushfire risk - Words & phrases: 'non defined activities'
Legislation:
City of Albany Local Planning Scheme No. 1, cl 1.4.2, cl 1.6(c), cl 1.7, cl 1.7.1, cl 1.7.1(b)(i), cl 5.2, cl 5.2.3(b), cl 5.5.14, cl 10.2, Sch 12 (CZ1), cl 2.1, cl 3, cl 3.1, cl 3.2, cl 3.3, cl 3.4, cl 4, cl 4.2.18, cl 4, cl 4.3, cl 4.5, cl 4.6(i), cl 4.6(v), cl 4.7(i)
City of Albany Town Planning Scheme No. 3
Environmental Protection (Noise) Regulations 1997 (WA)
Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA), s 38
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2 (deemed provisions), cl 2, cl 67, cl 67(b)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 3(1)(c), s 87(1), s 87(2), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 3, s 27(2), s 35(1), s 61(2), s 61(4)(g), s 62(3)
Result:
Conditional development approval granted
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
Mr Graeme Robertson sought review by the Tribunal of the refusal by the City of Albany of a development application for an extractive industry, in particular limestone extraction, on a property situated on the Nullaki Peninsula. The site is zoned 'Conservation' and forms part of the 'Nullaki Peninsula Conservation zone' under the local planning scheme. The site is also proximate to the Bibbulmun Track and the Nullaki campsite.
The Tribunal determined that the proposed development is capable of development approval under the local planning scheme. The Tribunal also determined that the proposed development merits conditional development approval. The Tribunal found that the proposed development is consistent with orderly and proper planning, because it is broadly consistent with the objectives and provisions of the local planning scheme in relation to the zoning of the site, only limited weight should be given to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ROBERTSON and CITY OF ALBANY and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] WASAT 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide if the proposed development would have an unacceptable impact on the locality's amenity and character, the natural environment, and the road system. It also needed to assess whether the traffic generated by the development would exceed the road system's capacity and have an adverse effect on traffic flow and safety. Additionally, the court examined whether the proposed variation of development standards and requirements would adversely impact the locality's inhabitants and whether the Bushfire Management Plan adequately addressed bushfire risk.
The court concluded that the proposed development would have an acceptable impact on the natural environment. Although the development did not strictly comply with all the development standards and requirements, the non-compliance with certain standards would not adversely affect the locality or its future development. The court imposed a condition proposed by the applicant, considering the potential environmental benefits and the agreement of several experts. The court also accepted the City's 'without prejudice' conditions for improving the public road system and found that the bushfire risk was adequately addressed by the Bushfire Management Plan.
The court approved the development application with specific conditions, including the implementation of the Bushfire Management Plan and the improvement of the public road system. The applicant agreed to these conditions, which align with the principles of sustainable development and address the concerns raised during the review process.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Although it was not explicitly put in these terms, the condition proposed by the applicant involves, in effect, the application of the sixth principle of sustainable development referred to by Justice Preston in Telstra Corporation Limited v Hornsby Shire Council [119], namely 'the internalisation of environmental costs into decision-making for economic and other development plans, programs and projects likely to affect the environment'. The Tribunal has not, to date, applied the sixth principle of sustainable development in planning review proceedings. For the reasons set out earlier, we consider that the proposed development would have an acceptable impact on the natural environment. Therefore, the condition proposed by the applicant is not strictly necessary in order for the development to be approved. However, as the condition was proposed by the applicant and as Mr Mack, Ms Price and Mr Bowman each consider that the condition would have environmental benefits, we will impose it. As indicated earlier, Mr Wallefeld and Mr Laybutt agree that, if the proposed haulage route is upgraded in the manner proposed by Mr Laybutt and agreed by Mr Wallefeld, then the traffic generated by the proposed development would not exceed the capacity of the road system and would not have an adverse affect on traffic flow and safety. The City formulated 'without prejudice' conditions of approval requiring the applicant to carry out or fund the necessary improvement works to the public road system.[180] As also indicated earlier, these conditions are agreed to by the applicant. For the reasons given at [139]-[147] above, the proposed development is generally compliant with all of the development standards and requirements in cl 4 of Sch 12 of LPS 1 in relation to the CZ1 zone, other than cl 4.3 which imposes a development standard that the Development Area 'must be confined and is not to exceed one hectare'. However, for reasons given at [136]-[138] above, we are satisfied that the noncompliance with the development standard in cl 4.3 will not have an adverse effect upon the inhabitants of the locality or the likely future development of the locality for the purposes of cl 5.2.3(b) of LPS 1. The applicant submitted a Bushfire Management Plan dated 6 May 2018 prepared by Mr Peter Bidwell, who is employed by the bushfire consultancy Working on Fire, to the City. The City sought comments from the Department of Fire & Emergency Services (DFES) in relation to the Bushfire Management Plan under SPP 3.7 and the Guidelines for Planning in Bushfire Prone Areas. On 27 June 2018, DFES informed the City that it had assessed the Bushfire Management Plan and the planning report submitted with the development application and advised as follows:[181]As the proposed development is not considered a high-risk land use it should be noted that future referral to DFES is not required.[181] Exhibit 10 tab 40 page 3. The City accepts and we concur that bushfire risk is satisfactorily addressed by conditions 35 and 36 of the 'without prejudice' conditions which state as follows:[182]35.A revised Bushfire Management Plan shall be submitted for approval of the City of Albany acting reasonably, prior to commencement of operations.36.The Bushfire Management Plan as approved by the City of Albany shall be implemented to the reasonable satisfaction of the City of Albany.