Wattleup Road Development Co Pty Ltd v State Administrative Tribunal [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   WATTLEUP ROAD DEVELOPMENT CO PTY LTD -v- STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL [No 2] [2016] WASC 279

CORAM:   CHANEY J

HEARD:   3-4 MAY 2016

DELIVERED          :   6 SEPTEMBER 2016

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1769 of 2015

BETWEEN:   WATTLEUP ROAD DEVELOPMENT CO PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
First Respondent

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Second Respondent

ALCOA OF AUSTRALIA LTD
Third Respondent

Catchwords:

Administrative law - Judicial review - Report and recommendation to Minister under Planning and Development Act 2005 - Precautionary principle - Whether irrelevant consideration - Application of precautionary principle - Adverse planning precedent - Subdivision - Effect of dust from neighbouring property - Adequacy of dust monitoring

Legislation:

Alumina Refinery Agreement Act 1961 (WA)
Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA), s 4A
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 3(1), s 3(1)(c), s 32, s 81, s 82, s 135, s 138, s 138(3), s 138(4), s 165, s 246(1), s 246(2), s 246(2)(b), s 251(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27(2), s 105(1)

Result:

Application dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr S Penglis & Mr P McQueen

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent      :     No appearance

Third Respondent          :     Mr P G McGowan

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Lavan Legal

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent      :     No appearance

Third Respondent          :     Clayton Utz

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Alliance to Save Hinchinbrook v Environmental Protection Agency [2006] QSC 84; (2006) 145 LGERA 32

Applicant A169 of 2003 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 8

Aspen Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (Unreported, WATPAT 13 of 1998, 21 October 1988)

Austin Construction Company (Aust) Pty Ltd v North Sydney Municipal Council (1967) 14 LGRA 154

BGP Properties Pty Ltd v Lake Macquarie City Council [2004] NSWLEC 399; (2004) 138 LGERA 237

Blick v Ashfield Municipal Council (1957) 3 LGRA 131

Blissett and Western Australian Planning Commission [2012] WASAT 54

BP Australia Ltd v Campbelltown City Council (1994) 83 LGERA 274

Collis Radio Ltd v Secretary of State for the Environment (1975) 29 P&CR 390; (1975) 73 LGR (UK) 211

Cornhill and Western Australian Planning Commission [2009] WASAT 9

Craig v The State of South Australia [1995] HCA 58; (1995) 184 CLR 163

Crowle v Manly Municipal Council (1950) 17 LGR (NSW) 217

Emmott v Ku-ring-gai Municipal Council (1954) 3 LGRA 177

Environment East Gippsland Inc v VicForests [2010] VSC 335; (2010) 30 VR 1

Falc Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (1991) 5 WAR 522

Friends of Hinchinbrook Society Inc v Minister for Environment (1997) 142 ALR 632

Girvan v Willoughby Municipal Council (1952) 18 LGR (NSW) 222

Goldin v Minister for Transport [2002] NSWLEC 75; (2002) 121 LGERA 101

Hewison and Shire of Augusta‑Margaret River [2014] WASAT 62

Humby v Woollahra Municipal Council (1964) 10 LGRA 56

Leatch v National Parks and Wildlife Service (1993) 81 LGERA 270

Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226

Marshall…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wattleup Road Development Co Pty Ltd v State Administrative... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] WASC 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wattleup Road Development Co Pty Ltd brought an application for judicial review of a decision of the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). The application sought to overturn the SAT's decision to refuse the applicants' application for a planning recommendation to the Minister for Planning. The application was for approval of a planning proposal to subdivide a 10.7 hectare site into approximately 100 residential lots. The SAT's decision was based on the finding that the proposed subdivision would not adequately protect the amenity of future residents from dust from neighbouring properties. The applicants argued that the SAT had erred in concluding that the dust monitoring was inadequate and that it should have applied the precautionary principle in their favour. The court had to decide whether the SAT had erred in concluding that the dust monitoring was inadequate and in failing to apply the precautionary principle in the applicants' favour. The court also had to determine whether the SAT had erred in finding that the proposed subdivision would not adequately protect the amenity of future residents from dust from neighbouring properties.

The court found that the SAT had not erred in concluding that the dust monitoring was inadequate. The court held that daily monitoring for total suspended particulates was necessary for an adequate monitoring program given the proximity of the site to the neighbouring dust sources and the nature of the proposal. The court also found that the SAT had not erred in finding that the proposed subdivision would not adequately protect the amenity of future residents from dust from neighbouring properties. The court held that the evidence suggested that had the dust monitoring been undertaken for the full year or close to it, exceedances of the amenity standard would have been observed. The court further held that the SAT had not erred in refusing to apply the precautionary principle in the applicants' favour. The court held that the precautionary principle was not an irrelevant consideration but that it did not apply in the circumstances of this case.

The SAT's decision was affirmed. The applicants' application for judicial review was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal noted that the air quality expert witnesses also agreed that the currently accepted regulatory standard in the area of the site for amenity impacts of dust on residential populations is the Kwinana Environmental Protection Policy (Kwinana EPP) standard of Total Suspended Particulates (TSP) of 90 micrograms per cubic metre of dust particles of any size, averaged over 24 hours. It noted that the applicants' monitoring did not detect any exceedances of that standard but that that monitoring for TSP was undertaken for a total of only 72 or 74 days (there was a discrepancy in the evidence as to the total number of days), or only approximately one‑fifth of the monitoring year. The Tribunal referred to the evidence of various of the witnesses as to the significance of the frequency of monitoring. After noting that the applicant had conferred with the Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC) and the Department of Health (DoH) in relation to the monitoring regime, the Tribunal said (at [30]):Ms Dewan's evidence does not provide a satisfactory explanation as to why DEC/DER and DoH required sampling for amenity purposes for days adding up to only approximately one-quarter of the year and accepted sampling for amenity purposes for days adding up to only approximately one-fifth of the year. Sampling for a full year may well be 'costly' and 'onerous'. However, the proposed subdivisions would facilitate the introduction of large, permanent, residential populations on the site in circumstances where '[t]here is a threat of serious or irreversible environmental damage for residents of the proposed subdivision in relation to dust from the RDA and the sand quarry …' (2011 Wattleup decision at [68]). The 'cost' and 'onerousness' of undertaking a full year of monitoring for amenity purposes, rather than days adding up to one-fifth or one‑quarter of a year, is necessary given the proximity of the site to the RDA and the WA Limestone sand quarry and the nature of the proposal. In the circumstances of this case, daily monitoring for TSP is not only 'ideal', but necessary for an adequate monitoring program [30]. More detailed reference was then made to the evidence of various experts as to the significance of sampling periods. The Tribunal then referred to evidence as to sampling of TSP taken by Alcoa at Sayer Road, which is a short distance to the west of the site. The Tribunal said:In light of Mr Gwynne's and Mr Coffey's sound criticism, we do not accept the correctness or utility of Dr Forster's 'correlation' assessment in relation to the results of sampling at Sayer Road. Although the Sayer Road monitoring station is located north of the RDA, whereas the site is located north­east of the RDA, and although the Sayer Road monitoring station may well be affected by near­field dust sources which may not affect the site (just as the site may be affected by near­field dust sources, such as the sand quarry, which may not affect the Sayer Road monitoring station), the Sayer Road monitoring station is located only 300 metres closer to the RDA than the site. The fact that TSP monitoring was undertaken at the Sayer Road monitoring station for approximately 360 days between July 2012 and June 2013 and that 12 exceedances of the Kwinana EPP TSP amenity standard were observed in that location during that period, whereas only 72 or 74 days of TSP monitoring was undertaken during the same period at the site, strongly suggests that had TSP monitoring been undertaken at the site for the full year or close to it, exceedances of the amenity standard would have been observed. (Interestingly, in its submissions, Alcoa notes that the two exceedances of PM10 that were recorded in the applicants' monitoring at the site (26 February 2013 and 10 April 2013) occurred on days when no TSP sampling was undertaken at the site) [48].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.