MOORE RIVER COMPANY PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 1928 (WA)

CITATION:   MOORE RIVER COMPANY PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 98

MEMBER:   JUDGE J CHANEY (DEPUTY PRESIDENT)

MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)
MS M CONNOR (MEMBER)

HEARD:   27 ­ 30 NOVEMBER, 1, 4, 5, 6 AND 11 DECEMBER 2006

DELIVERED          :   1 MAY 2007

FILE NO/S:   DR 277 of 2004

BETWEEN:   MOORE RIVER COMPANY PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Subdivision application - Call in of application by Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Minister directed SAT to hear application but, without determining it, to refer it with recommendations to the Minister for determination - Proposed subdivision to create 550 lots principally for residential purposes with town centre commercial uses - Proposed subdivision first stage in total subdivision contemplated in approved Outline Development Plan to ultimately accommodate 13 500 residents in 5000 dwellings, schools, commercial uses and tourist development - Site located adjacent to Moore River approximately 25 kilometres by road north of Perth Metropolitan Region - Site zoned "Urban Development" under local planning scheme - Site proposed to be zoned "Residential" under draft local planning scheme adopted by local government and publicly advertised - Western Australian Planning Commission recommended modification to draft local planning scheme to zone site "Rural" - Minister directed local government to publicly advertise modification to draft local planning scheme - Local government resolved that, in the absence of indemnification by the State Government, it will not proceed with advertising modification given compensation issues that may arise - Sustainability - Whether proposed subdivision is inconsistent with Western Australian State Sustainability Strategy, State Planning Policy No. 2.6 - State Coastal Planning Policy and  State Planning Policy 3 - Urban Growth and Settlement in relation to sustainability in settlements - Whether proposed subdivision inconsistent with subregional structure plan - Weight to be given to inconsistency - Whether modification to draft local planning scheme is a seriously-entertained planning proposal and therefore relevant in planning assessment - Weight to be given to inconsistency -  Coty principle - Whether change in government policy can properly affect strategic planning decision ­ Whether proposed subdivision is not generally in accordance with Outline Development Plan - Change in interface between subdivision and tourist development contemplated in Outline Development Plan - Change in location and increase in number and size of areas of public open space - Change in road configuration - Inclusion of medium density lots outside town centre and inclusion of cottage lots - Whether departures from Outline Development Plan are minor in nature - Whether safe and efficient road access reasonably capable of being provided - Whether the application should be refused because resolution of both Houses of Parliament required to enable use of part of State Forest for roadworks - Whether safe drinking water and wastewater treatment reasonably capable of being provided - Whether proposed subdivision design can be assessed and approved…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MOORE RIVER COMPANY PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Moore River Company Pty Ltd sought judicial review of a decision by the Western Australian Planning Commission to refuse approval for a proposed subdivision. The proposed subdivision would create 550 lots, principally for residential purposes, with town centre commercial uses. The site is located adjacent to the Moore River, approximately 25 kilometres north of the Perth Metropolitan Region. The site was zoned "Urban Development" under the local planning scheme, but the local government had adopted a draft local planning scheme that proposed to rezone the site to "Residential". The Western Australian Planning Commission recommended modifying the draft local planning scheme to rezone the site to "Rural". The Minister directed the local government to publicly advertise the modification, but the local government refused to do so without indemnification from the State Government. The court was required to determine whether the proposed subdivision was inconsistent with the Western Australian State Sustainability Strategy, State Planning Policy No. 2.6 - State Coastal Planning Policy, and State Planning Policy 3 - Urban Growth and Settlement. The court also had to determine whether the modification to the draft local planning scheme was a seriously-entertained planning proposal and therefore relevant in the planning assessment. The court found that the proposed subdivision was inconsistent with the Western Australian State Sustainability Strategy, State Planning Policy No. 2.6 - State Coastal Planning Policy, and State Planning Policy 3 - Urban Growth and Settlement. The court also found that the modification to the draft local planning scheme was a seriously-entertained planning proposal and therefore relevant in the planning assessment. The court affirmed the decision of the respondent to refuse to approve the proposed subdivision. The court dismissed the application for review and recommended that the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure affirm the decision of the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal recommends to the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure that: 1. The application for review should be dismissed. 2. The decision of the respondent to refuse to approve a plan of subdivision in relation to Swan Location 2802, Pt Swan Location 2424 and Pt Swan Location 2914, Barragoon Road, Shire of Gingin should be affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The report dated 8 March 2006 from the Acting Secretary of the Commission to the Acting Minister in relation to the final approval of draft TPS 9 included the following:"Background7.2.1The zoning of this land for urban development was approved in 1995 by the previous State Government. The 'urban development zone' required the preparation of an outline development plan (ODP) prior to development and an ODP was subsequently adopted by the Shire and endorsed by the Western Australian Planning Commission in January 2000. The ODP provides for urban development of 557 ha catering for a population of 13 500 people residing in 5200 dwellings.7.2.2The current government at the time of election in February 2001 made a commitment to review the development potential of this land with a view to moderating the scale and ensuring adequate setbacks and coastal management of any proposed development.7.2.3The Minister, at the time of considering the request to advertise the new scheme and local planning strategy, required the inclusion of a modification to the strategy to advise that the State Government did not necessarily believe that the current Outline Development Plan (ODP) for South Guilderton represents the preferred form of development for the area.7.2.4In March 2004, after the advertising of the scheme was completed, the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure wrote to the Chairman of the Commission … requesting a review of the current ODP Plan and 'Urban Development' zoning in the Shire's Town Planning Scheme No 8. This was to include a scientific assessment of the setbacks proposed in the ODP and advice on its compliance with SPP 2.6 – State Planning Coastal Policy and other WAPC Policies.7.2.5This review was undertaken at a strategic level in the context of the Gingin Coast Structure Plan, a draft of which had been advertised from December 2003 to March 2004. Submissions to this plan were evaluated and amendments made to the Structure Plan, the most significant being the designation of the South Guilderton land for rural use with a recreation and tourist node investigation over part of the land. The rationale for this change was that urban development on this site would be contrary to the State's sustainability agenda in that it would not achieve environmental, social and economic sustainability principles.7.2.6As the above amendment was considered to be a significant change by the Minister, this proposal was advertised. Attachment 8 provided an explanation of the change and the implications for a future review of the urban zoning of the land. Following significant community support, the Commission adopted the Structure Plan incorporating this significant change over the subject land in October 2005.7.2.7A large number of submissions to the new Gingin scheme raised objections to the 'Residential' zoning of the land south of Moore River. In some cases it was requested that the TPS and the proposed subdivision of the land be deferred pending the finalisation of the Gingin Coast Structure Plan and other submissions requested that the land be rezoned from 'Residential Development' to 'Rural'. …Comment and Recommendations7.2.11The Gingin Coast Structure Plan has undertaken a review of the settlement strategy for the study area. The WAPC, in adopting the Structure Plan[,] have made a clear decision to reduce the settlement status of Guilderton from a major land centre to a village status for the next 25 years. The current and advertised zoning of this land in the scheme and the recommended development of this area as part of the expansion of Guilderton in the Local Planning Strategy are not in accordance with the adopted Structure Plan.7.2.12If the appeal against the refusal to subdivide this land for urban residential purposes were successful and urban residential subdivision was established, the opportunity to implement the recommendations of the Gingin Coast Structure Plan would be severely limited.7.2.13The WAPC is required to endorse the local planning strategy for the Shire of Gingin provided it satisfies State and regional policy and to make recommendations with regard to the finalisation of the town planning scheme. In this regard, the WAPC in adopting this plan has a responsibility to implement the recommendations of the Structure Plan at the time of considering the new town planning scheme and local planning strategy.7.2.14The rezoning of any land from urban development to rural without agreement by the owner/owners is rare, if not unprecedented, in Western Australia. The Shire of Gingin has requested written indemnification from the State Government in relation to any costs which may arise as a result of removal of the urban potential of the land. …7.2.16A change in zoning of the land from Residential Development to 'General Rural' in Town Planning Scheme No 9 and the modification of the local planning strategy to identify the area as a tourism and recreation node investigation area would be in accordance with the recommendations for this area in the Structure Plan. …7.2.18If the Commission resolves to proceed with the change in zoning of this land as indicated above to ensure the implementation of the Gingin Coast Structure Plan, it is recommended that this be regarded as a substantial change from the zoning in the current scheme and advertised for public comment."

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established