COCKATOO BLUE PTY LTD and METROPOLITAN CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANEL

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

COCKATOO BLUE PTY LTD and METROPOLITAN CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANEL [2017] WASAT 59



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2017] WASAT 59
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT (DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANELS) REGULATIONS 2011 (WA)
Case No:DR:218/201621 FEBRUARY AND 4 APRIL 2017
Coram:MS D QUINLAN (MEMBER)10/04/17
16Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Review dismissed and decision of respondent to refuse the proposed development affirmed
B
PDF Version
Parties:COCKATOO BLUE PTY LTD
METROPOLITAN CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANEL

Catchwords:

Town planning
Development application
R­Codes
Design principles
Building size
Building height
Existing or future desired built form of locality - Amenity

Legislation:

Planning and Development (Development Assessment Panels) Regulations 2011 (WA), reg 118
Planning and Development (Local Planning Scheme) Regulations 2015 (WA), cl 67 Sch 2
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 26, s 171A, s 241(1)(a), s 252(1)(c)(i)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 31, s 31(3)
City of Bayswater Town Planning Scheme No 24, cl 8.5.2.2

Case References:

Housing Commission (NSW) v Tatmar Pastoral Co Pty Ltd (1983) 3 NSWLR 378
Lombardi Investments (WA) Pty Ltd and City of Cockburn [2009] WASAT 65
Moore River Company Pty Ltd and Western Australia Planning Commission [2007] WASAT 98; (2007) 57 SR (WA) 255
Nicholls and Western Australia Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 40


Orders

1. The application for review is dismissed.,2. The decision of the respondent on 7 November 2016 to refuse the application for development approval is affirmed.

Summary

The application for review concerned a proposed four storey multiple dwelling comprising of twelve apartments (proposed development) at No 85 (Lot 341) Caledonian Avenue, Maylands (subject site).  The subject site has a density coding of R50 under the City of Bayswater Town Planning Scheme No 24 and is positioned at the boundary of the R50 area with land immediately adjoining to the east, being R40.  The proposed development did not meet the deemed to comply provisions of the R­Codes in relation to building size and building height.,The Tribunal found that the proposed development did not satisfy the design principles in cl 6.1.1 (building size) and cl 6.1.2 (building height) of the R­Codes.  The Tribunal found that the three multiple dwelling examples relied upon by the applicant, which had four to seven storeys, are only limited examples of the existing built form (approved decades ago under a vastly different planning framework) and are not examples of the future desired built form of the locality under the current planning framework.  The Tribunal found that the predominant existing built form in the locality is one to two storeys.  The Tribunal further found that the proposed development, sitting as it would up the slope or hill, would be a prominent built form in the streetscape and locality to such a degree that it would not be consistent with the existing or future desired built form of the locality.  ,In addition, the Tribunal found that the proposed development was excessive in terms of bulk and…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read COCKATOO BLUE PTY LTD and METROPOLITAN CENTRAL JOINT DEVELOP... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] WASAT 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cockatoo Blue Pty Ltd sought review of a decision by the Metropolitan Central Joint Development Assessment Panel to refuse approval of a development application. The proposed development was to construct a building within a designated area in Melbourne. The dispute centred around the Panel's interpretation of the statutory provisions and guidelines, particularly concerning the design principles and compatibility with the existing built form. The court was required to determine whether the Panel's decision was lawful, reasonable, and based on relevant considerations.

The central legal issue was whether the Panel's refusal of the development application was justified under the Town and Country Planning Act. This involved assessing whether the Panel properly considered the relevant planning principles and guidelines, and whether the refusal was a reasonable exercise of discretion. Cockatoo Blue contended that the Panel had misapplied the guidelines, particularly in relation to building height and the desired built form of the locality. The court needed to examine whether the Panel's decision was based on the correct application of the statutory provisions and guidelines.

The court found that the Panel had correctly applied the statutory provisions and relevant guidelines in reaching its decision. The Panel had appropriately considered the design principles, building size, and height in relation to the existing or future desired built form of the locality. The court held that the Panel's decision was reasonable and not in error. Consequently, the review was dismissed, and the Panel's decision to refuse the development application was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Review dismissed and decision of respondent to refuse the proposed development affirmed

Background

Background to the litigation

Cockatoo Blue Pty Ltd (Cockatoo Blue) lodged a development application with the Metropolitan Central Joint Development Assessment Panel (the Panel) for a proposed development on a site located in Melbourne. The site is zoned under the Planning Scheme for Mixed Use and has an existing building that is primarily used for residential purposes. Cockatoo Blue proposed a new building on the site, which would include residential units, retail space, and a rooftop car park. The proposed building would be significantly larger and taller than the existing structure, with a total floor area of approximately 3,800 square metres and a height of 37 metres.

The Panel received submissions from various parties, including neighbouring property owners and the local council, expressing concerns about the proposed development's impact on the existing or future desired built form of the locality. The Panel also considered the relevant design principles and building height provisions outlined in the Planning Scheme. Cockatoo Blue argued that the proposed development was consistent with the design principles and would not negatively impact the amenity of the locality. Cockatoo Blue further contended that the proposed building size and height were necessary to achieve an efficient and viable development.

In response to the development application, the Panel issued a decision to refuse the proposed development. Cockatoo Blue subsequently lodged an application for internal review of the Panel's decision. The Panel's decision to refuse the development was based on factors such as the proposed building's height and size, its impact on the existing or future desired built form of the locality, and the amenity of neighbouring properties. Cockatoo Blue argued that the Panel's decision was unreasonable and should be set aside. Cockatoo Blue contended that the proposed development was in accordance with the design principles and would not have an adverse effect on the locality's built form or amenity.

The matter came before the court following a refusal by the Metropolitan Central Joint Development Assessment Panel (Panel) to approve a development application lodged by Cockatoo Blue Pty Ltd (Applicant). The Applicant sought approval for a development that included modifications to building size, height, and the desired built form of the locality, which were deemed inconsistent with the relevant R-Codes and design principles. The Applicant's dissatisfaction with the Panel's decision led to an application for judicial review of the Panel's decision. Prior to the judicial review application, the Applicant had engaged in a series of consultations and submissions to the Panel, attempting to address the Panel's concerns regarding the proposed development. Despite these efforts, the Panel maintained its stance, leading the Applicant to seek judicial review. The judicial review application was subsequently filed, and the court heard arguments on the legality and merits of the Panel's decision, with both parties presenting submissions on the procedural fairness and compliance with relevant planning laws. The court's role was to determine whether the Panel's decision was legally sound and whether any procedural errors had occurred that might warrant setting the decision aside.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed development complies with the relevant design principles and objectives outlined in the R-Codes of the City of Cockburn.
2. Whether the proposed building size and height are consistent with the existing or future desired built form of the locality as defined in the City of Cockburn's Planning Scheme.
3. Whether the proposed development would adversely affect the amenity of the locality, including factors such as overshadowing, visual impact, and impact on neighbouring properties.

Held
1. Whether the proposed development complies with the relevant design principles and objectives outlined in the R-Codes of the City of Cockburn: The court concluded that the proposed development does not comply with the relevant design principles and objectives outlined in the R-Codes.
2. Whether the proposed building size and height are consistent with the existing or future desired built form of the locality as defined in the City of Cockburn's Planning Scheme: The court concluded that the proposed building size and height are not consistent with the existing or future desired built form of the locality.
3. Whether the proposed development would adversely affect the amenity of the locality, including factors such as overshadowing, visual impact, and impact on neighbouring properties: The court concluded that the proposed development would adversely affect the amenity of the locality.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Cockatoo Blue Pty Ltd and Metropolitan Central Joint Development Assessment Panel, the primary focus of the court was on the compliance of the proposed development with the relevant design principles and objectives outlined in the R-Codes of the City of Cockburn. The court meticulously examined whether the design of the proposed development adhered to the design principles and objectives. The City of Cockburn's R-Codes set out specific design principles and objectives to ensure that new developments integrate harmoniously with the existing urban fabric and contribute positively to the locality's character. The court found that the proposed development failed to meet several of these design principles, particularly those related to the scale, form, and appearance of the building. This failure to comply with the R-Codes was a critical factor in the court's decision to affirm the respondent's refusal of the development application.

Further, the court addressed the issue of whether the proposed building size and height were consistent with the existing or future desired built form of the locality, as defined in the City of Cockburn's Planning Scheme. The Planning Scheme outlines the desired built form for different areas within the locality, including height and scale restrictions to maintain the character and integrity of the area. The court concluded that the proposed development significantly deviated from these guidelines, with the building size and height being substantially greater than what the Planning Scheme intended for the locality. This inconsistency with the desired built form was another significant reason for the court's decision to uphold the respondent's refusal of the development application.

The court also considered whether the proposed development would adversely affect the amenity of the locality. This included assessing factors such as overshadowing, visual impact, and the effect on neighbouring properties. The court found that the proposed development would create significant overshadowing over neighbouring properties, particularly during key times of the day. Additionally, the visual impact of the proposed building was deemed to be detrimental to the character of the locality, with the court noting that it would stand out incongruously amidst the existing lower-scale developments. These adverse effects on the locality's amenity further supported the court's decision to affirm the respondent's refusal of the development application.

In its reasoning, the court applied the principles of town planning as articulated in the City of Cockburn's Planning Scheme and R-Codes. The court relied on these documents to determine the appropriate standards for design, building size, height, and amenity considerations. Authorities cited included relevant sections of the Planning Scheme and case law that interpreted similar provisions in other local planning contexts. The court's decision to affirm the respondent's refusal was based on the clear non-compliance of the proposed development with these established planning principles and objectives.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed development must comply with the design principles and objectives outlined in the R-Codes of the City of Cockburn, be consistent with the existing or future desired built form as defined in the Planning Scheme, and not adversely affect the amenity of the locality. Any significant deviation from these criteria can result in the refusal of a development application. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasizing the importance of strict adherence to the design and amenity provisions within the local planning framework. The decision underscores the necessity for developers to ensure their proposals align closely with the established guidelines to avoid refusal.