Richmond Sales Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Robert McDermott

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Richmond Sales Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Robert McDermott [2006] FCA 52

CORPORATIONS – application under s 536 to set aside a warrant issued under s 530C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – challenge to the validity of the warrant – need for full trial before validity could be impugned successfully – further inquiry not justified where defendants no longer have a proprietary or pecuniary interest in the outcome and application to set aside delayed for over 20 months after warrant issued – other factors also considered

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 530C, 536

Burns Philp Investments Pty Ltd v Dickens (1993) 11 ACLC 525 referred to
GIS Electrical Pty Ltd v Melsom (2002) 172 FLR 218 referred to
Re Glowbind Pty Ltd (in Liq); Takchi v Parbery (2003) 181 FLR 208 referred to

RICHMOND SALES PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 073 538 959) PAUL ANDREW BURNESS (IN HIS CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATOR) v ROBERT ARTHUR McDERMOTT, ANN LANGDON, MAXWELL ROGER LATIMER, JOHN McDONALD, MICHAEL GUIFFRE, ROBERT NOMINEES PTY LTD and MARY ANN MARTINEK

VID 3276 OF 2003

KENNY J
8 FEBRUARY 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 3276 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

RICHMOND SALES PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 073 538 959) & PAUL ANDREW BURNESS (IN HIS CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATOR)
APPLICANTS

AND:

ROBERT ARTHUR McDERMOTT
FIRST RESPONDENT

ANN LANGDON
SECOND RESPONDENT

MAXWELL ROGER LATIMER
THIRD RESPONDENT

JOHN McDONALD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

MICHAEL GUIFFRE
FIFTH RESPONDENT

ROVER NOMINEES PTY LTD
SIXTH RESPONDENT

MARY ANN MARTINEK
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 FEBRUARY 2006

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application filed on 29 August 2005 be dismissed.

2.The defendants (save for the sixth defendant, Rover Nominees Pty Ltd) and RAM Parts Australia Pty Ltd pay the plaintiff’s costs of the application.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 3276 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

RICHMOND SALES PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 073 538 959) & PAUL ANDREW BURNESS (IN HIS CAPACITY AS LIQUIDATOR)
APPLICANTS

AND:

ROBERT ARTHUR McDERMOTT
FIRST RESPONDENT

ANN LANGDON
SECOND RESPONDENT

MAXWELL ROGER LATIMER
THIRD RESPONDENT

JOHN McDONALD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

MICHAEL GUIFFRE
FIFTH RESPONDENT

ROVER NOMINEES PTY LTD
SIXTH RESPONDENT

MARY ANN MARTINEK
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE:

8 FEBRUARY 2006

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. Before the Court is an application by the defendants (save for Rover Nominees Pty Ltd) in this matter to set aside a warrant issued by this Court on 4 December 2003.  When issued, this application sought other relief, which is no longer pursued. For the reasons that follow, the defendants’ application is dismissed with costs.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  2. The facts that lead the Court to consider this application are as follows. Paul Burness (“Burness” or “the plaintiff”) was appointed liquidator of Richmond Sales Proprietary Limited (ACN 073 538 959) (“Richmond Sales” or “the Company”) on 19 February…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Richmond Sales Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Robert McDermott and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 52
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Richmond Sales Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Robert McDermott involved an application by the defendants to set aside a warrant issued by the Court on 4 December 2003, seeking to seize property and books of the Company in the possession of Robert McDermott. Paul Burness, the liquidator of Richmond Sales, had applied for the warrant under section 530C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and alleged that McDermott had concealed the Company’s property. The defendants contended that the warrant was obtained on inaccurate or misleading affidavit material and sought its setting aside.

The primary legal issue was whether the warrant should be declared void ab initio or set aside without a full trial. The Court had to determine whether the warrant should be set aside based on the current evidence or if a trial was necessary to resolve the complex factual disputes between the parties. The Court noted that the defendants had not previously applied to set the warrant aside despite being informed of their right to do so, and that it would be unfair to determine disputed issues of fact without allowing Burness an opportunity to cross-examine the defendants.

The Court concluded that the case was too complex to determine the validity of the warrant without a full trial. The parties presented conflicting factual positions, and the Court could not ascertain who was correct without hearing the evidence. The Court also noted that the defendants had acted on the basis that they were entitled to a trial. Therefore, the application to set aside the warrant was dismissed with costs.

The Court ordered that the application filed on 29 August 2005 be dismissed and that the defendants pay the plaintiff’s costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application filed on 29 August 2005 be dismissed.

2.

Background

Background to the litigation

Before the Court is an application by the defendants (save for Rover Nominees Pty Ltd) in this matter to set aside a warrant issued by this Court on 4 December 2003. When issued, this application sought other relief, which is no longer pursued. For the reasons that follow, the defendants’ application is dismissed with costs.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The facts that lead the Court to consider this application are as follows. Paul Burness (“Burness” or “the plaintiff”) was appointed liquidator of Richmond Sales Proprietary Limited (ACN 073 538 959) (“Richmond Sales” or “the Company”) on 19 February 2003. Burness initiated this proceeding on 3 December 2003 when he applied under s 530C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for a warrant. The application named Robert McDermott (“McDermott”) as the defendant and requested a warrant authorizing Burness, as liquidator, to seize property and books of the Company in the possession of McDermott. Burness filed an affidavit in support of this application alleging that McDermott had concealed property of the Company. Merkel J issued the warrant on 4 December 2003 and it was served the next day. Pursuant to the warrant, Burness seized books and records and seven vehicles, mostly from the Company’s premises at 420 Burnley Street, Richmond. The seized vehicles were:1) 1913 Rolls Royce, Chassis No. 2316 (“Vehicle 1”)2) 1980 Rolls Royce, Chassis No. SRH0040192 (“Vehicle 2”)3) 1985 Black Bentley Sedan, Registration QNX023 (“Vehicle 3”)4) 1984 Rolls Royce Carmague, Registration QFZ 408 (“Vehicle 4”)5) Rolls Royce Silver Shadow, Chassis No. SRH2522 (“Vehicle 5”)6) 1930 Rolls Royce Phantom II Sedan, Chassis No. 39GY (“Vehicle 6”)7) 1971 Mercedes Benz 230 Sedan, Registration KWK538 (“Vehicle 7”) On the day the warrant was served, McDermott was given a letter which, amongst other things, informed him that: “Should you be aggrieved by reason of issue of the Warrant you should immediately seek legal advice and, if so advised, make an application to the Federal Court of Australia under Proceeding No V-3276 of 2003 seeking appropriate relief.” In a letter dated 23 December 2003, McDermott, through his then solicitor, stated that he intended to “apply to court to set aside the warrant as it has been obtained on supporting Affidavit material that in material parts is either inaccurate or deliberately misleading”. On 10 December 2003, Mr Maxwell Latimer (“Latimer”) wrote to Burness stating that if Vehicles 1, 4 and 6 were not returned to him, he would issue legal proceedings. Similarly, on 7 January 2004, Ms Mary-Ann Martinek (“Martinek”), through her then solicitor, wrote to Burness’s solicitor stating that legal action would be instituted unless Vehicle 7 was returned to her by noon on 9 January 2004. Although Burness did not comply with these demands, none of McDermott, Latimer and Martinek applied to set the warrant aside. On 24 March 2004, Burness filed an interlocutory application in this proceeding asking that he be directed to sell Vehicles 1 to 7 (inclusive). This application was supported by an affidavit, sworn by Burness on 23 March 2004, setting out the reasons why he believed the vehicles were the property of Richmond Sales. The affidavit noted that other persons claimed ownership of some of the vehicles. Latimer claimed ownership of Vehicles 1, 4 and 6. BMW Group Finance Services also claimed Vehicle 4. Mr Michael Giuffrey (“Giuffre(y)” or “Guiffre”) claimed ownership of Vehicle 3. Mr John McDonald (“McDonald”) claimed Vehicles 3 and 5. Martinek claimed Vehicle 7. Burness noted that Ms Ann Langdon (“Langdon”) claimed a security interest in Vehicle 1 and that Rover Nominees Pty Ltd might have an interest in Vehicle 3.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KENNY J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KENNY J

On 3 February 2006, the plaintiff filed further submissions, addressing, amongst other things, the relevant authorities and the position of RAM Parts in the litigation. CONSIDERATIONThe Validity of the Warrant Having regard to the parties’ submissions and the affidavits that have thus far been filed, it is plain enough that the Court could not determine whether the warrant should be declared void ab initio or otherwise set aside as the defendants desire without trial of the evidence. The case, particularly as alleged by the defendants, is complex. The parties have presented very different factual pictures. For example, the defendants claim that McDermott did not conceal any of the Company’s records. In contrast, Burness claims that McDermott actively concealed records. Moreover, Burness claims to have seized numerous Company documents pursuant to the warrant although the significance of this seizure is denied by the defendants. The parties also dispute whether Richmond Sales ceased to trade on 30 June 2002 and whether the impending move to the Footscray premises was for the purpose of concealing the property of Richmond Sales. Clearly, the Court cannot determine who is correct without full trial. It must be noted that, as things currently stand, only Burness has been subject to cross-examination in relation to the application of 24 March 2004, the hearing of which was adjourned in the circumstances already mentioned. Thus, it would be grossly unfair to determine disputed issues of fact without providing Burness with an opportunity to cross-examine the defendants. Moreover, in their filing of affidavits subsequent to 10 October 2005, the defendants have apparently acted on the basis that, contrary to the plaintiff’s submissions, they are entitled to such a trial. It is fair to say that, had the hearing in this matter continued, the credibility of the defendants, and McDermott and Latimer in particular, would have come under serious challenge. Without delving into all of the intricacies of this case, I provide two examples. In his affidavit filed in this Court on 18 May 2004, Latimer claimed to have purchased Vehicle 1 in 1999 for a very substantial sum of money. He attached a written contract of sale as an exhibit to his affidavit. However, in a letter dated 22 April 2002 which is exhibited to the affidavit of Burness filed 24 March 2004, Latimer informed the Australian Taxation Office (“ATO”) that he had no records relating to any vehicles purchased by him after 1 July 1996. One might reasonably anticipate that counsel for Burness would have used this apparent inconsistency to challenge Latimer’s credibility and the authenticity of the written contract of sale. Similarly, the plaintiff might have challenged McDermott’s credibility with a letter he wrote to the State Revenue Office (“SRO”) on 8 April 2003, which is also exhibited to the affidavit of Burness filed 24 March 2004. In that letter, McDermott stated that vehicle RR909 (apparently Vehicle 1) had been registered by Richmond Sales for the purpose of selling it as a licensed motor car trader. However, in this letter, McDermott failed to inform the SRO that Richmond Sales was then in liquidation or that Latimer was the actual owner of the car. The latter fact would be relevant because, according to the plaintiff, a licensed motor car trader is not permitted to sell cars on a consignment basis.