This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the decision for a list of the amendments.
Court of Appeal
New South Wales
Case Title: Residential Housing Corporation v Esber & Ors Medium Neutral Citation: [2011] NSWCA 25 Hearing Date(s): 28 July 2010 Decision Date: 21 February 2011 Jurisdiction: Before: Campbell JA at 1
Macfarlan JA at 194
Sackville AJA at 195Decision: (1) Leave to appeal be granted, if necessary;
(2) The appeal be dismissed with costs.
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]Catchwords: TORRENS SYSTEM - MORTGAGES - SALE BY MORTGAGEE - DISPOSITION OF SURPLUS PROCEEDS OF SALE - RPA land subject to two registered mortgages and one unregistered mortgage - first mortgagee exercises power of sale and pays whole amount surplus to its entitlement to second mortgagee - second mortgagee pays whole amount surplus to its entitlement to third mortgagee - third mortgage later held to secure no debt, and third mortgagee becomes insolvent - whether second mortgagee obliged to compensate mortgagor for amount paid to third mortgagee - whether s 58(3) RPA applies at all to a mortgagee other than the mortgagee who exercises a power of sale - whether s 58(3) RPA requires payment of surplus proceeds to a mortgagee who is unregistered - comparison of s 58(3) RPA with s 88(1) Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) and s 135 Real Property Act 1886 (SA) - interaction of s 58(3) with equitable obligations of a mortgagee who holds surplus proceeds of sale
PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - INTERPLEADER - payment into court in stakeholder's interpleader, and payment into court under s 95 Trustee Act 1925 compared and contrasted
EQUITY - FIDUCIARY OBLIGATIONS - OF MORTGAGEE HOLDING SURPLUS PROCEEDS OF SALE - obligation to pay each subsequent security holder and the mortgagee the amount each is owed, in their respective order of priority - explanation of Re Thomson's Mortgage Trusts [1920] 1 Ch 508 - if there is a statutory direction about order of payment of proceeds, whether the equitable obligation operates only after the statute has run its course, or whether the equitable obligation applies immediately to whoever holds the surplus proceeds of sale
APPEAL - POINT NOT TAKEN AT TRIAL - when point not only not taken, but conceded at trial - when point could not have been affected by evidence at trial [41]-[42] - when point is failure to prove an essential element of plaintiff's case, and there was concession at trial [175]-[177]
JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS - SATISFACTION OF - rule against double satisfaction applies universally - source of rule against double satisfaction
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Residential Housing Corporation v Esber and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWCA 25
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the second mortgagee was obliged to compensate the mortgagor for the amount paid to the third mortgagee. This involved considering the application of section 58(3) of the *Real Property Act 1900* (NSW) (RPA) to mortgagees other than the one exercising the power of sale, and whether this section mandated payment to an unregistered mortgagee. The court also examined the interaction between the statutory provisions of the RPA and the equitable obligations of a mortgagee holding surplus proceeds of sale.
The Court of Appeal held that section 58(3) of the RPA applies to the distribution of surplus proceeds by the mortgagee exercising the power of sale, and that its provisions are not intended to create a direct obligation on a subsequent mortgagee to repay funds received in good faith. The court reasoned that the statutory scheme prioritises registered interests and that the second mortgagee had acted in accordance with the order of priority established by the RPA when it received the surplus funds. While acknowledging the equitable obligation of a mortgagee to account for surplus proceeds, the court found that this obligation did not extend to requiring the second mortgagee to repay funds that had been lawfully paid to the third mortgagee in accordance with the registered priority, especially given the third mortgagee's subsequent insolvency and the finding that no debt was owed.
The appeal was dismissed. The court granted leave to appeal if necessary, but ultimately upheld the decision of the lower court, finding no obligation on the second mortgagee to compensate the mortgagor for the amount paid to the third mortgagee.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Leave to appeal be granted, if necessary; (2) The appeal be dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Other relevant provisions of RPA as at February 2002 were: 36 Lodgment and registration of documents (9) Dealings registered with respect to, or affecting the same estate or interest shall, notwithstanding any notice (whether express, implied or constructive), be entitled in priority the one over the other according to the order of registration thereof and not according to the dates of the dealings. 41 Dealings not effectual until recorded in Register (1) No dealing, until registered in the manner provided by this Act, shall be effectual to pass any estate or interest in any land under the provisions of this Act, or to render such land liable as security for the payment of money, but upon the registration of any dealing in the manner provided by this Act, the estate or interest specified in such dealing shall pass, or as the case may be the land shall become liable as security in manner and subject to the covenants, conditions, and contingencies set forth and specified in such dealing, or by this Act declared to be implied in instruments of a like nature. 42 Estate of registered proprietor paramount (1) Notwithstanding the existence in any other person of any estate or interest which but for this Act might be held to be paramount or to have priority, the registered proprietor for the time being of any estate or interest in land recorded in a folio of the Register shall, except in case of fraud, hold the same, subject to such other estates and interests and such entries, if any, as are recorded in that folio, but absolutely free from all other estates and interests that are not so recorded except: [various exceptions not presently relevant] (2) In subsection (1), a reference to an estate or interest in land recorded in a folio of the Register includes a reference to an estate or interest recorded in a registered mortgage, charge or lease that may be directly or indirectly identified from a distinctive reference in that folio. 56 Lands under this Act: how mortgaged or encumbered (1) Whenever any land or estate or interest in land under the provisions of this Act is intended to be charged with, or made security for, the payment of a debt, the proprietor shall execute a mortgage in the approved form. 56A Postponement of mortgages (1) If two or more mortgages registered under this Act affect the same land, the mortgage which for the time being has priority over the other or others may, by a memorandum in the approved form registered under this Act, be postponed to the other or others in so far as the whole or a disposable part of that same land is concerned. ... (2) A memorandum under this section shall not be registered when any registered mortgage intervenes between the mortgage to be postponed and the mortgage intended to have benefit of the postponement, unless the proprietor of the intervening mortgage joins in the memorandum. (3) The Registrar-General shall register a memorandum under this section by making such recording in the Register with respect to the memorandum as the Registrar-General thinks fit. (4) After registration of a memorandum under this section, the mortgages affected by the postponement shall be entitled in priority the one over the other as if they had been registered in the order in which by the memorandum they are expressed to have priority. 57 Procedure on default (1) A mortgage, charge or covenant charge under this Act has effect as a security but does not operate as a transfer of the land mortgaged or charged. (2) A registered mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee may, subject to this Act, exercise the powers conferred by section 58 if: [list of preconditions for exercise of those powers] 58 Power to sell (1) Where a mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee is authorised by section 57 (2) to exercise the powers conferred by this section, the mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee may sell the land mortgaged or charged, or any part thereof, and all the estate and interest therein of the mortgagor, charger or covenant charger, ... all which sales ... shall be as valid and effectual as if the mortgagor, charger or covenant charger had made, done, or executed the same, and the receipt or receipts in writing of the mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee shall be a sufficient discharge to the purchaser of such land, estate, or interest, or of any portion thereof, for so much of the purchaser's purchase money as may be thereby expressed to be received. (2) No such purchaser shall be answerable for the loss, misapplication, or non-application, or be obliged to see to the application of the purchase money by the purchaser paid, ... (3) The purchase money to arise from the sale of any such land, estate, or interest, shall be applied, first, in payment of the expenses occasioned by such sale; secondly, in payment of the moneys which may then be due or owing to the mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee; thirdly, in payment of subsequent mortgages, charges or covenant charges (if any) in the order of their priority; and the surplus (if any) shall be paid to the mortgagor, charger or covenant charger, as the case may be. 59 Registration of transfer by mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee The Registrar-General shall, for the purpose of a sale authorised by section 58, register a transfer executed by a mortgagee, chargee or covenant chargee in the approved form and, upon that registration, the estate or interest of the mortgagor, charger or covenant charger in the land comprised in the transfer shall pass to and be vested in the transferee, freed and discharged from all liability on account of the mortgage, charge or covenant charge, or of any mortgage, charge or covenant charge registered subsequent thereto.