Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
Medium Neutral Citation: Rema Tip Top Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Grüterich [2019] NSWSC 1594 Hearing dates: 6-8, 10, 13-15, 17 May 2019 Date of orders: 18 November 2019 Decision date: 18 November 2019 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Ward CJ in Eq Decision: 1. Declare that the plaintiff would have been justified in terminating the contract of employment between itself and the defendant on 16 March 2018 for serious misconduct by the defendant.
2. Declare that moneys in respect of the car allowance, the double salary payments and the expenses said to be incurred under the claimed private business class travel budget (as opposed to the claimed business travel expenses on Mr Grüterich’s company credit card) totalling $187,037.67 were wilfully and dishonestly misappropriated by the defendant and that those moneys were impressed with a presumed or resulting trust and are held on trust by the defendant for the benefit of the plaintiff.
3. Declare that those moneys, together with the moneys in respect of the bonus payment of $103,210.88 and the unauthorised credit card expenses (including the Poliform furniture deposit) totalling $21,413.75, that the defendant caused to be paid to himself or for his benefit in breach of his fiduciary duty not to make an unauthorised profit from his position, are held by the defendant subject to a constructive trust in the plaintiff’s favour.
4. Order that, subject to the set-off ordered below, funds held in the HSBC bank account to the amount of $311,662.30 (being the total of the amounts the subject of the trust declarations in Orders 2 and 3 above) be released to the plaintiff.
5. Order that the defendant pay the following sums to the plaintiff (totalling $336,413.69) as damages (for breach of contract, in equity or under s 1317H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for breach of fiduciary or statutory duties owed by the defendant as managing director of the plaintiff) and/or by way of restitution:
(a) Car allowance: $22,750.
(b) Double salary: $69,999.99.
(c) Bonus payment: $103,210.88.
(d) Poliform furniture: $9,616.40.
(e) Travel expenses: $94,287.68.
(f) Annual leave overpayment: $24,751.39.
(g) Other miscellaneous credit card expenses: $11,797.35.
6. Order the payment of interest up to judgment on the above amounts.
7. Order that the plaintiff pay to the defendant accrued long service leave calculated taking into account his employment within the Rema Group of companies from 25 October 2012 to the date of termination of his employment on 16 March 2018, with interest calculated up to judgment on that amount, but otherwise dismiss the defendant’s cross-claim.
8. Order that the amounts payable pursuant to the plaintiff under Orders 4 and 5 be set-off against the amount ordered to be paid to the defendant under Order 7; with the remaining balance of the amounts so ordered to be paid to the plaintiff or the defendant, as the case may be, within 28 days.
9. Reserve the question of costs to be dealt with on the papers following any…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rema Tip Top Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Grüterich and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWSC 1594
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues involved the validity of the termination of the defendant's employment, both on notice and potentially summarily, and the equitable and statutory considerations relevant to the recovery of payments and the entitlement to long service leave. The court had to assess whether the defendant's conduct justified a summary termination and whether the plaintiff's decision not to investigate further prior to terminating the employment constituted an unjust enrichment.
The court found that the defendant's contract was not for a fixed term and that the plaintiff was justified in terminating the employment on notice. Furthermore, the court concluded that the plaintiff would have been justified in terminating the defendant's employment summarily for serious misconduct. Regarding the notice payment, the court determined that the payment was made voluntarily, and the plaintiff's decision not to investigate further rendered the retention of the payment unjust. The court also held that the defendant held moneys misappropriated by him on a presumed or resulting trust for the plaintiff and that unauthorised profits were held by the defendant subject to a constructive trust in the plaintiff's favour. Finally, the court ruled that the defendant was entitled to long service leave as his employment was terminated in lieu of notice and not for misconduct.
The court's final orders included a declaration that the plaintiff was justified in terminating the defendant's employment on notice and would have been justified in summarily terminating the employment. Additionally, the court ordered the recovery of the notice payment and the misappropriation profits from the defendant, and it declared that the defendant was entitled to long service leave.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case was brought before the court as an action by Rema Tip Top against Grüterich, its former managing director. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Rema Tip Top filed the claim, seeking the recovery of the notice payment, claiming that Grüterich was unjustly enriched. The case proceeded on the basis of Rema Tip Top's allegations of unauthorised directions, payments, and fiduciary breaches by Grüterich. The court was required to determine whether Rema Tip Top was justified in terminating Grüterich's employment, whether the notice payment was unjustly enriched, and whether Grüterich was entitled to long service leave.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was Rema Tip Top justified in terminating the employment contract of Grüterich on notice, and would it have been justified in terminating summarily on the ground of serious misconduct?
2. Could Rema Tip Top recover the notice payment paid to Grüterich on the basis of unjust enrichment?
3. Did Grüterich have a reasonable expectation of disclosure that would have negated the need for Rema Tip Top to establish misleading or deceptive conduct by silence?
4. Were the moneys misappropriated by Grüterich held on a presumed or resulting trust by Grüterich for the benefit of Rema Tip Top?
5. Were the unauthorised profits made by Grüterich in breach of his fiduciary duties held by Grüterich subject to a constructive trust in Rema Tip Top's favour?
6. Was Grüterich wrongly denied long service leave accruals on termination of his employment under s 4(2)(a)(ii) of the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW)?
Held
1. The court held that Rema Tip Top was justified in terminating the employment contract of Grüterich on notice and would have been justified in terminating summarily on the ground of serious misconduct.
2. The court held that Rema Tip Top could not recover the notice payment paid to Grüterich on the basis of unjust enrichment.
3. The court held that Grüterich did not have a reasonable expectation of disclosure that would have negated the need for Rema Tip Top to establish misleading or deceptive conduct by silence.
4. The court held that the moneys misappropriated by Grüterich were held on a presumed or resulting trust by Grüterich for the benefit of Rema Tip Top.
5. The court held that the unauthorised profits made by Grüterich in breach of his fiduciary duties were held by Grüterich subject to a constructive trust in Rema Tip Top's favour.
6. The court held that Grüterich was wrongly denied long service leave accruals on termination of his employment under s 4(2)(a)(ii) of the Long Service Leave Act 1955 (NSW).
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the employment contract between Rema Tip Top and Grüterich and found that it was not for a fixed term. This meant that Rema Tip Top was entitled to terminate the contract on notice, and the court held that the company was justified in doing so. The court also found that Rema Tip Top would have been justified in terminating Grüterich's employment summarily on the ground of serious misconduct, as the information regarding unauthorised directions and payments made by Grüterich was discovered after the termination. The court further held that Rema Tip Top could not recover the notice payment paid to Grüterich because the payment was made voluntarily in circumstances where the company chose not to investigate further but to bring the employment to an end immediately.
In considering the issue of misleading or deceptive conduct, the court held that there was no need to establish a reasonable expectation of disclosure because Grüterich did not have such an expectation. The court found that the moneys misappropriated by Grüterich were held on a presumed or resulting trust by Grüterich for the benefit of Rema Tip Top. The court also held that the unauthorised profits made by Grüterich in breach of his fiduciary duties were held by Grüterich subject to a constructive trust in Rema Tip Top's favour. Finally, the court held that Grüterich was wrongly denied long service leave accruals on termination of his employment, as his employment was terminated in lieu of notice and not for misconduct. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where an employment contract is not for a fixed term, the employer is justified in terminating the contract on notice and may also be justified in terminating summarily for serious misconduct. Additionally, the court's decision regarding the recovery of notice payments, the lack of a reasonable expectation of disclosure, the imposition of a presumed or resulting trust, the imposition of a constructive trust for unauthorised profits, and the entitlement to long service leave accruals in certain circumstances provide important precedents in employment and equity law.