Reiby and Meadowbank and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

REIBY & MEADOWBANK & ANOR [2013] FCCA 2040
Catchwords:
FAMILY LAW – Parenting orders for the two year old child of lesbian parents and a donor father – where the Applicant seeks equal shared parental responsibility and a shared care arrangement – where the Respondents seek a much more restricted role for the Applicant.
Legislation:  
Family Law Act 1975, ss.60B, 60CA, 60CC, 60H, 61C, 61DA, 64B, 64C, 65AA, 65C, 65DAA, 65DAC
Aldridge and Keaton [2009] Fam CAFC 229
Donnell and Dovey [2010] FamCAFC 15
Wilson and Anor and Roberts and Anor [2010] Fam CA 734
Groth & Banks [2013] FAMCA 430
Wadlow & Kaldman & Ors [2013] FCCA 1033
Applicant: MR REIBY
First Respondent: MS T MEADOWBANK
Second Respondent MS S MEADOWBANK
File Number: MLC 7054 of 2012
Judgment of: Judge Small
Hearing dates: 26 and 27 September  2013
Date of Last Submission: 11 October 2013
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 11 December 2013

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Puckey
Solicitors for the Applicant: Slater & Gordon Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms Smallwood
Solicitors for the Respondents: Nicholes Family Lawyers

ORDERS

  1. That all previous parenting orders in relation to the child X born (omitted) 2011 (“the child”) be discharged.

  2. That the Respondents have sole parental responsibility for the child.

  3. That the child live with the Respondents.

  4. That the child spend time and communicate with the Applicant by agreement between the parties from time to time, and failing agreement, as follows:

    (a)       Until 27 March 2014, on a two week cycle as follows:

    In week one:

    (i)              On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    (ii)            On Thursday from 5:30 pm to 8:30 pm

    In week two:

    i.      On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    ii.On Saturday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    (b)Thereafter until the child’s third birthday, on a two-    week cycle as follows:

    In week one:

    (i)              On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    (ii)            On Thursday from 5:30 pm to 8:30 pm

    In week two:

    i.      On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    ii.On Saturday from 8:30 am to 2:00 pm

    (c)Thereafter until 27 March 2015 in a two week cycle as    follows:

    (i)              On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    (ii)            On Thursday from 5:30 pm to 8:30 pm

    In week two:

    i.      On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

    ii.On Saturday from 10:00 am to 5 pm

    (d)Thereafter until 27 March 2016:

    (i)    On each Wednesday from10:00 am to 5:00pm;

    (ii)  On each alternate weekend from 4:00 pm on Saturday to 9:00 am on Sunday for four visits;

    (iii)  Thereafter on each alternate weekend from 10:00 am on Saturday to 10:00 am on Sunday;

    (iv)   By telephone on the Saturday when the child is not spending time with the Applicant between the hours of 5:30 pm and 6:00 pm, with the Applicant to make the call to a telephone number provided by the Respondents and the Respondents to ensure that the child…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reiby and Meadowbank and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCCA 2040
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned parenting orders for a child, X, born in 2011. The dispute was between the Applicant, X's father, and the Respondents, who were X's primary carers. The matter was heard by Judge Small.

The court was required to determine the future parenting arrangements for X, including the extent of parental responsibility, where X would live, and the time X would spend with the Applicant. The court also had to consider injunctions regarding drug and alcohol use by the Applicant and the conduct of the parties towards each other.

The court's reasoning was guided by the paramountcy principle, which dictates that the best interests of the child are the primary consideration in all parenting matters. The evidence established that X had lived continuously with the Respondents since birth and they were her primary carers. The Applicant had, however, established a consistent, regular, and frequent relationship with X since her birth, which had allowed X to develop a solid relationship with him. The court noted the Applicant's desire for equal shared parental responsibility and his wish to be involved in X's life in a manner typical of a father. The court also considered the Applicant's evidence of X's enjoyment of time spent with him and his family, and the provision of a dedicated room for X at his home.

The court ordered that all previous parenting orders be discharged and that the Respondents have sole parental responsibility for X, with X to live with the Respondents. Specific, phased-in time arrangements were ordered for X to spend time and communicate with the Applicant, commencing with limited day-time contact and gradually increasing to include overnight stays and longer periods as X grew older and commenced school. The court also imposed injunctions restraining the Applicant from using illicit drugs and consuming alcohol within specified periods before and during his time with X, and restraining both parties from belittling or abusing each other in X's presence. The Respondents were ordered to ensure the Applicant was named as X's father on relevant forms and was kept informed of her educational and medical progress, with provisions for the Applicant to attend school events and receive reports. The court also ordered that the parties advise each other of any significant illness or injury to X and any changes to their contact details.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That all previous parenting orders in relation to the child X born (omitted) 2011 (“the child”) be discharged.

2.

That the Respondents have sole parental responsibility for the child.

3.

That the child live with the Respondents.

4.

That the child spend time and communicate with the Applicant by agreement between the parties from time to time, and failing agreement, as follows:

(a) Until 27 March 2014, on a two week cycle as follows:

In week one:

(i) On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

(ii) On Thursday from 5:30 pm to 8:30 pm

In week two:

i. On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

ii. On Saturday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

(b) Thereafter until the child’s third birthday, on a two- week cycle as follows:

In week one:

(i) On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

(ii) On Thursday from 5:30 pm to 8:30 pm

In week two:

i. On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

ii. On Saturday from 8:30 am to 2:00 pm

(c) Thereafter until 27 March 2015 in a two week cycle as follows:

(i) On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

(ii) On Thursday from 5:30 pm to 8:30 pm

In week two:

i. On Tuesday from 8:30 am to 12:30 pm

ii. On Saturday from 10:00 am to 5 pm

(d) Thereafter until 27 March 2016:

(i) On each Wednesday from10:00 am to 5:00pm;

(ii) On each alternate weekend from 4:00 pm on Saturday to 9:00 am on Sunday for four visits;

(iii) Thereafter on each alternate weekend from 10:00 am on Saturday to 10:00 am on Sunday;

(iv) By telephone on the Saturday when the child is not spending time with the Applicant between the hours of 5:30 pm and 6:00 pm, with the Applicant to make the call to a telephone number provided by the Respondents and the Respondents to ensure that the child is available to take the call.

(e) Thereafter, until the child begins school:

(i) On each Wednesday from 10:00 am to 5:00 pm;

(ii) On each alternate weekend from 10 am on Saturday to 5:00 pm on Sunday

(iii) By telephone on the Saturday when the child is not spending time with the Applicant between the hours of 5:30 pm and 6:00 pm, with the Applicant to make the call to a telephone number provided by the Respondents and the Respondents to ensure that the child is available to take the call.

(f) Thereafter, once the child begins school:

(i) On one weekend per month during school term times by agreement, and failing agreement the first weekend of each month, from 10:00 am Saturday to 5:00 pm Sunday;

(ii) Each Wednesday from after school until 7:00 pm with the Applicant to provide the evening meal for the child before returning her to the Respondents’ home;

(iii) By telephone on each of the Saturdays when the child is not spending time with the Applicant between the hours of 5:30 pm and 6:00 pm, with the Applicant to make the call to a telephone number provided by the Respondents and the Respondents to ensure that the child is available to take the call.

(iv) For no more than two weeks per year in any school holiday period by agreement between the parties and failing agreement, for one week from after school on the last day of second term, and for one week ending at 6:00 pm on the Friday prior to the beginning of the school year;

(g) For three hours by agreement on Christmas Day and failing agreement from 9:30 am to 12:30 pm in odd years;

(h) For three hours by agreement for the child’s birthday each year and failing agreement between 10:00 am and 1:00 pm on 27 September if not a school day and between 3:30 pm and 6:30 pm on 28 September if 27 September is a school day other than Friday, when time shall be spent between 10:00 am and 1:00 pm on 28 September;

(i) For three hours by agreement for the Applicant’s birthday each year and failing agreement between 10:00 am and 1:00 pm on the following Saturday should it not fall on a day when the child is usually spending time with the Applicant, with the Applicant’s time to suspend from 10:00 am to 1:00 pm on the Saturday following each of the Respondent’s birthdays each year should they fall on a day when the child is usually spending time with the Applicant;

(j) From 10:00 am to 5:00 pm on Fathers’ Day each year should it fall on a day when the child is not usually spending time with the Applicant, with time to suspend at 10:00 am on Mothers’ Day should it fall on a day when the child is usually spending time with the Applicant.

(k) At such other times as the parties may agree from time to time.

(5) Changeover shall take place at a venue agreed by the parties from time to time and failing agreement the Applicant shall collect the child from the Respondents’ home and the Respondents or either of them shall collect the child from the Applicant’s home.

(6) The Applicant is hereby restrained by injunction from using any illicit drugs within 24 hours of and during the time that the child is in his care, and from drinking alcohol within 12 hours of such time, and from drinking alcohol to excess or having a blood alcohol reading of .05 or more during such time.

(7) The Respondents shall ensure that the Applicant is named as the child’s father on all medical and educational forms where the child’s contacts are named, and he shall be at liberty to attend all public school events and functions usually attended by a child’s family and significant others, and to receive, at his own expense, all school reports, photographs and other like items in relation to the child’s progress. The Applicant may attend parent-teacher interviews with the consent of the Respondents.

(8) The Respondents shall provide their consent to any doctor or other health practitioner who might be treating the child to speak to the Applicant about the child’s diagnosis, treatment and progress.

(9) The Applicant and the Respondents shall advise each other as soon as practicable in the event that the child suffers any significant illness or injury while she is in their respective care and shall advise each other of any treatment provided to the child as a result.

(10) The Applicant and the Respondents shall advise each other of any change in their address, telephone numbers and email or other electronic contact details within three days of such change.

(11) That the parties be and are hereby restrained by injunction from belittling, abusing or otherwise denigrating each other in the presence or hearing of the child and from allowing her to remain in the presence or hearing of any person engaging in such conduct.

(12) That all extant applications be otherwise dismissed.

AND THE COURT NOTES THAT:

A. Pursuant to ss.65DA(2) and 62B of the Family Law Act 1975 the particulars of the obligations these orders create and the particulars of the consequences that may follow if a person contravenes these orders are set out in Annexure A and these particulars are included in these orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Reiby and Meadowbank and Anor involves a dispute over the care and parenting of a child, referred to as X, born in 2011. X has lived continuously with the Respondents since birth, who have been her primary carers. The first-named Respondent has stayed at home to care for X, while the second-named Respondent works to support their family. The Applicant, X’s father, has spent consistent, regular, and frequent time with X since her birth, with their time governed by court orders made by consent since August 2012. Prior to these orders, the time spent was agreed upon by the parties. As of the final hearing, X spent time with the Applicant on Tuesday mornings, alternate Thursday evenings, and alternate Saturday mornings. The Applicant seeks to increase this time to five nights per fortnight once X commences school, aiming for equal shared parental responsibility.

The Applicant’s evidence highlights the significant and regular time he has spent with X, which has allowed them to develop a solid, though not primary care, relationship. X enjoys her time with the Applicant and appears to be happy and settled in his care. He has learned to settle X when she becomes distressed and is capable of feeding and changing her. X has also developed relationships with the Applicant’s family and friends, particularly enjoying time with his grandmother and aunt. The Applicant has his own room prepared for X at his home, which she recognises as “hers.” Despite the Respondents’ primary care role, the Applicant has maintained a consistent presence in X’s life, adhering to court-ordered schedules and demonstrating his commitment to being involved in her upbringing.

The matter of Reiby and Meadowbank and Anor came before the court following an application by the Applicant for parenting orders regarding his daughter X. The proceedings originated as a first-instance hearing, with the Applicant seeking to establish a more substantial custodial and care arrangement with X, who has lived primarily with the Respondents since her birth. Prior to this hearing, there were several consent orders made in August 2012 governing the time X spent with the Applicant. As the matter progressed, the Applicant lodged further applications to modify these orders, culminating in the final hearing before the court. The substantive evidence presented by both parties focused on the nature and extent of X's relationship with the Applicant and the Respondents, with detailed timelines and descriptions of the time X has spent with each party. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate parenting orders to ensure X's welfare, considering the detailed procedural history and previous orders in place.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

X has lived continuously with the Respondents since her birth. They are clearly her primary carers, with the first-named Respondent remaining at home to care for X while the second-named Respondent works to support her family.The Applicant’s evidence X has spent time with the Applicant since her birth and indeed he was present when she was born. Since then, he has spent consistent, regular and frequent time with X, initially at the home of the Respondents with the first-named Respondent and/or the second-named Respondent present, then without them present for a short time, and later at his own home. The time X spends with the Applicant has been governed by court orders, all made by consent, since August 2012. Before that, time was spent as agreed between the parties. As the matter came to final hearing, X was spending time with the Applicant as follows:·From 8:30 am until 12:30 pm each Tuesday·From 5:30 pm until 8:30 pm on alternate Thursdays·From 8:30 am until 12:30 pm on alternate Saturdays in the alternate week to the Thursday evening time X had also spent time with the Applicant on Fathers’ Day, just a few weeks before the final hearing. This time has been significant on any view, and the frequent and regular time spent with the Applicant since her birth has allowed X to establish a solid relationship with him, albeit not a primary care relationship. Apart from two periods of time in 2012 when the Respondents were away from Melbourne on holiday, X has spent time with the Applicant in almost every week of her life. The Applicant seeks to progress that relationship gradually to a time where X spends five nights per fortnight in his care when she commences school, and I note that that regime is quite common in orders made in this Court. He wishes to have equal shared parental responsibility for X so that he might be involved in her life in the same way as any other father might. He acknowledges that the fact that X’s surname is a hyphenated version of his name and the surname of the respondents is a sign of goodwill on their part, and that the Respondents were under no obligation to register X’s surname in that way. His evidence is that X enjoys her time with him and that she appears to be happy and settled in his care. He says that he has learned how to settle X when she becomes distressed, that he is able to feed and change her, that he loves her dearly and that he has much to offer her as a father. He says that X has developed relationships with his family and friends and especially enjoys the time she spends with her paternal grandmother and aunt. He states that X has her own room at his home which contains a cot, some toys and a couch, and that X is familiar with that room and knows it is “hers”. In his trial affidavit sworn 2 September 2013, he sets out multiple occasions in the first six months of X’s life when the Respondents brought X to spend time with him and his family for special events. He says that in November 2011 he asked if he could take X to the christening of a child of a close friend. There was some discomfort about this request and after some email correspondence, the Applicant says he understood that X was perhaps too young to be separated from the first-named Respondent at that stage and says that he “tried to thereafter pay closer attention to (the first-named Respondent’s) anxieties and remain mindful of X’s developmental needs.”[1][1] The Affidavit of the Applicant sworn 2 September 2013 paragraph 50

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What are the appropriate parenting arrangements for the child X, considering the respective roles and contributions of the Applicant and the Respondents?
2. Should the Applicant be granted equal shared parental responsibility for the child X?
3. What are the appropriate visitation arrangements for the Applicant, considering the best interests of the child X?
4. What restrictions, if any, should be imposed on the Applicant's drug and alcohol use during the time he spends with the child X?
5. Should the Respondents be required to ensure the Applicant is named as the child's father on all medical and educational forms?
6. Should the Respondents be required to provide their consent for the Applicant to be informed about the child's medical treatment and progress?
7. Should the parties be restrained from denigrating each other in the presence or hearing of the child and from allowing her to remain in such situations?
8. What other obligations and restrictions should be imposed on the parties to ensure the best interests of the child X?

Held
1. The court held that the child X should live with the Respondents and that the Respondents have sole parental responsibility for the child.
2. The court held that the Applicant should not be granted equal shared parental responsibility for the child X.
3. The court held that the Applicant should have specific visitation arrangements with the child X, which vary over time as the child grows older.
4. The court held that the Applicant should be restrained from using illicit drugs and drinking alcohol within certain time frames when the child is in his care.
5. The court held that the Respondents should ensure that the Applicant is named as the child's father on all medical and educational forms.
6. The court held that the Respondents should provide their consent for the Applicant to be informed about the child's medical treatment and progress.
7. The court held that the parties should be restrained from denigrating each other in the presence or hearing of the child.
8. The court held that the parties should follow other specific obligations and restrictions to ensure the best interests of the child X, including notifying each other of significant changes and maintaining contact details.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Reiby and Meadowbank and Anor, the court was tasked with determining a range of parenting arrangements for the child X, considering the respective roles and contributions of the Applicant and the Respondents. The court’s decision was heavily influenced by the principle of the child's best interests, which is the paramount consideration under the Family Law Act 1975. The court assessed the evidence provided by both parties regarding the child’s living arrangements, the nature and extent of time spent with the Applicant, and the emotional bonds formed.

The court acknowledged the Respondents as the primary carers of X, who has lived continuously with them since her birth. The Respondents’ role in providing primary care was deemed significant, with the first-named Respondent staying at home to care for X and the second-named Respondent working to support the family. The Applicant, while not the primary carer, has played an active role in X’s life, spending consistent, regular, and frequent time with her since her birth. This time has been governed by court orders since 2012, and the Applicant’s contributions have facilitated the development of a solid relationship with X, albeit not a primary care relationship.

Considering the Applicant’s request for equal shared parental responsibility, the court examined the legal principles outlined in sections 60CC(2) and 60CA of the Family Law Act 1975. The court found that, while the Applicant has made a significant contribution to X’s life, the primary care role of the Respondents could not be overlooked. Therefore, the court decided that the Respondents should have sole parental responsibility for X, as this arrangement was in the best interests of the child. The court’s decision was also influenced by the need for stability and continuity in the child’s life, factors which are crucial under the Act.

For visitation arrangements, the court meticulously outlined a detailed schedule considering X’s age and developmental needs, as well as the importance of maintaining a relationship with the Applicant. The court recognized the benefits of the frequent and regular time X has spent with the Applicant, ensuring that the arrangements allowed for a gradual increase in time as X grows older. This detailed schedule was designed to balance the child’s need for stability with the importance of maintaining a relationship with the Applicant.

The court also addressed the Applicant’s drug and alcohol use during the time he spends with X, imposing strict restrictions to ensure the child’s safety. The Applicant was restrained from using illicit drugs within 24 hours of and during the time he has X in his care, and from drinking alcohol within 12 hours of such time. These restrictions were deemed necessary to safeguard the child’s welfare.

Regarding the naming of the Applicant as the child’s father on all medical and educational forms, the court required the Respondents to ensure this, recognizing the Applicant’s role as X’s father. The court also mandated that the Respondents provide their consent for the Applicant to be informed about X’s medical treatment and progress, promoting transparency and cooperation in the child’s healthcare.

The court emphasized the importance of preventing any form of parental denigration in the presence or hearing of X. Both parties were restrained from belittling, abusing, or otherwise denigrating each other, and from allowing the child to remain in such situations. This injunction aimed to protect X from exposure to conflict and ensure a harmonious co-parenting environment.

In summary, the court’s decision was guided by the overarching principle of the child’s best interests, considering the respective roles and contributions of the Applicant and the Respondents. The court’s ratio decidendi includes the recognition of the primary care role of the Respondents, the need for detailed and developmentally appropriate visitation arrangements, strict restrictions on the Applicant’s drug and alcohol use, the requirement for the Respondents to recognize the Applicant’s parental role on medical and educational forms, and the prohibition of parental denigration in the child’s presence. This decision sets a precedent for future cases involving similar considerations of parental roles and child welfare.