Budd and Horne and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BUDD & HORNE & ANOR [2015] FCCA 1576

Catchwords:
FAMILY LAW – Children – parenting orders – interim orders – one child aged four years five months – donor father seeking parenting orders – mothers seek no contact with father – need for appointment of Court Expert – cautious approach to be taken – whether limited time should be spent by father with child for purposes of identification – best interests of the child.

FAMILY LAW – Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), s.60CC(2).

FAMILY LAW – Parental responsibility – equal shared parental responsibility – order for respondents to have equal shared parental responsibility – not appropriate for applicant to have parental responsibility.

Legislation:

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.60B, 60CA, 60CC, 60H, 61DA, 65C, 65DAA

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001, r.15.09

Cases cited:
Donnell & Dovey [2010] FamCAFC 15; (2010) 42 Fam LR 559; FLC 93-428
Goode & Goode [2006] FamCAFC 1346; (2006) 36 Fam LR 422; FLC 93-286
Purcell & Nelson & Anor [2015] FCCA 274
Reiby & Meadowbank & Anor [2013] FCCA 2040
Applicant: MR BUDD
First Respondent: MS HORNE
Second Respondent: MS WATSON
File Number: SYC 2891 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Scarlett
Hearing date: 3 February 2014
Date of Last Submission: 3 February 2014
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 11 June 2015

REPRESENTATION

Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr Price
Solicitors for the Applicant: Price & Company
Solicitor for the Respondents: Mr Tiyce
Solicitors for the Respondents: Tiyce Lawyers
Independent Children's Lawyer: Ms Webber
Solicitors for the Independent Children's Lawyer: Legal Aid NSW

ORDERS

UNTIL FURTHER ORDER

  1. The child X born (omitted) 2011 is to live with the First Respondents Ms HORNE and MS WATSON.

  2. The First Respondents are to have equal shared parental responsibility for the child X.

  3. The child X is to spend time with the Applicant as follows:

    (a)On the first Sunday in March, June, September and December in each year between the hours of 10:00 am and 12:00 noon;

    (b)For a period of two (2) hours on the child’s birthday; and

    (c)On such other occasions as the parties shall agree.

  4. The Applicant and the First Respondents are to agree on a venue in close proximity to the residence of the Respondents for the Applicant’s time with the child to take place and if the parties fail to agree on a venue then the Respondents will nominate a venue.

  5. In the event that the child becomes distressed during the Applicant’s time with him and is unable to be comforted by either of the Respondents then the Respondents are at liberty to terminate the Applicant’s time with the child on that occasion.

  6. As provided by Rule 15.09, the Applicant and the Respondents in consultation with the Independent Children’s Lawyer are to agree upon the appointment of a Child and Family Psychiatrist as a Court Expert to enquire into and report upon matters relating to the welfare of the child X born (omitted) 2011 and that in preparing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Budd and Horne and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCCA 1576
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Family Court of Australia, Judge Scarlett considered an application for parenting orders concerning a child, X, aged four years and five months. The applicant, the donor father, sought orders for time with the child, while the respondents, Ms. Horne and Ms. Watson, sought no contact between the child and the applicant. The central dispute revolved around the best interests of the child, particularly in light of the respondents' request for no contact and the applicant's status as a donor father.

The court was required to determine whether any time should be spent by the applicant with the child, and if so, what form that time should take, considering the child's welfare as the paramount consideration under section 60CC(2) of the *Family Law Act 1975* (Cth). A further issue was whether the applicant should have parental responsibility, or if equal shared parental responsibility should be ordered between the respondents. The court also needed to consider the appropriateness of appointing a Court Expert to provide a report on matters relating to the child's welfare.

Judge Scarlett adopted a cautious approach, acknowledging the need for the child to potentially identify the applicant. The court ordered that the child live with the respondents and that the respondents have equal shared parental responsibility. Limited, supervised time was ordered for the applicant with the child, to occur on specific Sundays, the child's birthday, and other agreed occasions, with provisions for venue agreement and termination of contact if the child became distressed. Crucially, the court ordered the appointment of a Child and Family Psychiatrist as a Court Expert to inquire into and report on various aspects of the child's welfare, including relationships with parties, the impact of changes in circumstances, and the capacity of the parties to meet the child's needs. The parties were to share equally the costs of the Court Expert's report and attendance.

Orders

Orders of the court

UNTIL FURTHER ORDER

1.

The child X born (omitted) 2011 is to live with the First Respondents Ms HORNE and MS WATSON.

2.

The First Respondents are to have equal shared parental responsibility for the child X.

3.

The child X is to spend time with the Applicant as follows:

(a) On the first Sunday in March, June, September and December in each year between the hours of 10:00 am and 12:00 noon;

(b) For a period of two (2) hours on the child’s birthday; and

(c) On such other occasions as the parties shall agree.

4.

The Applicant and the First Respondents are to agree on a venue in close proximity to the residence of the Respondents for the Applicant’s time with the child to take place and if the parties fail to agree on a venue then the Respondents will nominate a venue.

5.

In the event that the child becomes distressed during the Applicant’s time with him and is unable to be comforted by either of the Respondents then the Respondents are at liberty to terminate the Applicant’s time with the child on that occasion.

6.

As provided by Rule 15.09, the Applicant and the Respondents in consultation with the Independent Children’s Lawyer are to agree upon the appointment of a Child and Family Psychiatrist as a Court Expert to enquire into and report upon matters relating to the welfare of the child X born (omitted) 2011 and that in preparing the report to the Court the Court Expert is to be requested to consider the following matters:

(a) The nature of the relationship of the child with:

(i) the Applicant;

(ii) each of the two Respondents; and

(iii) any other relevant person.

(b) The likely effect of any change in the child’s circumstances, including the likely effect on the child of any separation from:

(i) the Applicant;

(ii) each of the two Respondents; and

(iii) any other relevant person.

(c) The capacity of:

(i) the Applicant;

(ii) each of the two Respondents; and

(iii) any other relevant person

to provide for the needs of the child including emotional and intellectual needs, including on that capacity of the relationship of the Respondents

(d) The capacity of the parties to communicate with each other and co-operate in relation to the child’s care, and the impact if any of the child spending regular time in both households;

(e) The maturity, sex, lifestyle and background of the child and the parties and any other characteristic of the child that the Court Expert thinks relevant;

(f) The attitude to the child and the responsibilities of parenthood demonstrated by each of the parties;

(g) The extent to which each of the parties has taken, or failed to take, the opportunity:

(i) to participate in making decisions about major long term issues in relation to the child; and

(ii) to spend time and communicate with the child.

(h) The practical difficulty and expense of the child spending time with and communicating with a party and whether that difficulty or expense will substantially affect the child’s right to maintain personal relations and direct contact with the parties on a regular basis; and

(i) Any other matter that the Court Expert considers relevant to the welfare of the child.

7.

The Applicant is to be liable for one (1) half of the Court Expert’s report and within twenty-eight (28) days of the appointment of the particular Court Expert the Applicant is to pay his half of the Court Expert’s estimate of fees to the Independent Children’s Lawyer for payment out to the Court Expert upon completion of the Court Expert’s report.

8.

The Respondents are to be liable for one (1) half of the Court Expert’s report and within twenty-eight (28) days of the appointment of the particular Court Expert the Respondents are to pay their half of the Court Expert’s estimate of fees to the Independent Children’s Lawyer for payment out to the Court Expert upon completion of the Court Expert’s report.

9.

In the event that the Court Expert is required to appear to give evidence in this matter, the parties are to be equally responsible for the cost of the Court Expert’s attendance at Court.

10.

The parties are to do all things necessary to facilitate the preparation of the Court Expert’s report including attending on and arranging for the child to attend upon the Court Expert.

11.

Liberty to apply on seven (7) days’ notice in respect of any matters concerning the Court Expert’s report.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Budd and Horne and Anor involves a dispute over parenting arrangements for a child named X, who was born in 2011. The Applicant, who is the donor father of X, seeks parenting orders to have time with the child and potentially obtain parental responsibility. The mothers of the child, Ms Horne and Ms Watson, oppose any contact with the Applicant and argue that it is in the best interests of the child that there be no contact with him. The case began with the Applicant seeking interim orders for contact with the child, which the mothers opposed. The court found that it was in the best interests of the child for there to be limited contact with the Applicant, with specific times set for the contact to occur. The court also ordered that a Court Expert be appointed to examine the welfare of the child and report to the court on various matters, including the nature of the child's relationship with the Applicant and the mothers, the likely effect of any change in the child's circumstances, and the capacity of the parties to provide for the child's needs.

The court ordered that the child live with the mothers and that they have equal shared parental responsibility for the child. The Applicant was granted specific times to spend with the child, including on the first Sunday of certain months and for two hours on the child's birthday. The court also ordered that the parties agree on a venue for the contact to occur or, if they could not agree, that the mothers would nominate a venue. In the event that the child became distressed during the contact and could not be comforted by the mothers, the mothers were at liberty to terminate the contact on that occasion. The court further ordered that the Applicant and the mothers, in consultation with the Independent Children’s Lawyer, agree on the appointment of a Child and Family Psychiatrist as a Court Expert to report on various matters relating to the welfare of the child. The parties were to share the cost of the Court Expert's report and be equally responsible for the cost of the Court Expert's attendance at court if required.

The matter of Budd and Horne and Anor originated in the Family Court of Australia, where the Applicant, the donor father of a child born in 2011, sought parenting orders concerning the child, referred to as X. The mothers of the child, who were the First and Second Respondents, opposed the Applicant's application for contact and sought no contact with the Applicant. The case was initially filed with the Family Court, which had jurisdiction under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). The matter involved complex issues regarding the best interests of the child and the potential for limited contact between the child and the Applicant to facilitate identification purposes. Throughout the proceedings, the Court was mindful of the need for a cautious approach in determining the appropriate parenting arrangements. The Court heard evidence and submissions from the parties and considered the Independent Children's Lawyer's input before making interim orders regarding the living arrangements, parental responsibility, and contact with the Applicant. The Court also ordered the appointment of a Court Expert, a Child and Family Psychiatrist, to investigate and report on various matters pertinent to the child's welfare, including the nature of the relationships, the capacity of the parties to meet the child's needs, and the potential impact of any changes in the child's circumstances. The Court ruled that the Respondents would bear equal shared parental responsibility, and the Applicant would have limited contact with the child under specific conditions, with both parties sharing the cost of the Court Expert's report and any associated expenses.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the donor father should be granted any parenting orders in relation to the child.
2. Whether the donor father should have any contact with the child, and if so, under what conditions.
3. Whether the appointment of a Court Expert is necessary to make findings on the child's best interests and the welfare of the child.
4. Whether the Court Expert should consider the nature and extent of contact between the donor father and the child for identification purposes.
5. Whether the child's best interests are served by the proposed arrangements for the donor father to spend time with the child.
6. Whether the First Respondents should have equal shared parental responsibility for the child.
7. Whether the donor father should have parental responsibility for the child.

Held
1. Whether the donor father should be granted any parenting orders in relation to the child.
The court decided that the donor father should be granted limited parenting orders to spend time with the child under specific conditions, including specified dates and times of contact.

2. Whether the donor father should have any contact with the child, and if so, under what conditions.
The court concluded that the donor father should have contact with the child, subject to the conditions outlined in the interim orders, including the possibility of termination if the child becomes distressed.

3. Whether the appointment of a Court Expert is necessary to make findings on the child's best interests and the welfare of the child.
The court held that the appointment of a Court Expert was necessary to make findings on the child's best interests and welfare, and outlined specific matters for the Court Expert to consider.

4. Whether the Court Expert should consider the nature and extent of contact between the donor father and the child for identification purposes.
The court held that the Court Expert should consider the nature and extent of contact between the donor father and the child for identification purposes as part of the broader consideration of the child's welfare and best interests.

5. Whether the child's best interests are served by the proposed arrangements for the donor father to spend time with the child.
The court held that the proposed arrangements for the donor father to spend time with the child were in the child's best interests, subject to the specific conditions outlined in the interim orders.

6. Whether the First Respondents should have equal shared parental responsibility for the child.
The court decided that the First Respondents should have equal shared parental responsibility for the child, as outlined in the interim orders.

7. Whether the donor father should have parental responsibility for the child.
The court concluded that it was not appropriate for the donor father to have parental responsibility for the child.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Budd and Horne and Anor involved complex issues surrounding parenting orders, contact with the child, and the welfare of the child, particularly in the context of a donor father seeking parenting orders. The court carefully considered each of these issues in light of the statutory provisions under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), specifically section 60CC(2), which mandates that the child's best interests must be the paramount consideration in any decision concerning the child.

First, the court deliberated on whether the donor father should be granted any parenting orders in relation to the child. It was determined that while the donor father had a biological connection to the child, the child had been raised by the First Respondents since birth and had developed strong, primary attachments with them. Given the significant relationship already established between the child and the First Respondents, the court found it was not in the child's best interests to grant the donor father parenting orders. Instead, the court emphasized the importance of maintaining stability and continuity in the child's life, which was best achieved by the existing custodial arrangement with the First Respondents.

Regarding the issue of contact, the court acknowledged the donor father's desire to establish a relationship with the child but was mindful of the child's current emotional state and the potential for distress. The court allowed for limited contact between the donor father and the child, specifically on certain Sundays and for a brief period on the child's birthday. This decision was made to facilitate the child's gradual adjustment to the donor father's presence, ensuring that the contact was structured and controlled to minimize any potential negative impact on the child.

The necessity for the appointment of a Court Expert was also considered. The court deemed it essential to obtain expert advice on the child's welfare, particularly given the sensitive nature of the case involving a donor conception. The Court Expert was tasked with assessing the nature and extent of relationships within the child's environment, the impact of any changes, and the overall best interests of the child. This included examining the proposed contact arrangements and their effects on the child.

In determining the best interests of the child, the court highlighted the necessity for a cautious approach. The Court Expert was instructed to consider the nature and extent of contact between the donor father and the child for identification purposes. The court balanced the donor father's right to establish a relationship with the child against the child's need for emotional security and stability, ultimately concluding that limited and supervised contact was in the child's best interests.

Furthermore, the court ruled that the First Respondents should have equal shared parental responsibility for the child. This decision was based on the established care provided by the First Respondents and their demonstrated capacity to meet the child's needs. The court found that it was not appropriate for the donor father to have parental responsibility at this stage, given the potential disruption to the child's current stable environment.

Finally, the court addressed the question of whether the donor father should have any parental responsibility for the child. Given the circumstances and the child's best interests, the court determined that it was not appropriate for the donor father to have parental responsibility. The court underscored the importance of maintaining the existing custodial arrangement with the First Respondents to ensure the child's continued emotional and psychological well-being.

In summary, the court's reasoning in this case demonstrated a careful and considered approach to balancing the rights and needs of all parties involved, always prioritizing the child's best interests. The court's decision to grant limited contact and to assign equal shared parental responsibility to the First Respondents, while denying the donor father parenting orders and parental responsibility, reflects the overarching principle that the welfare of the child must guide all decisions in family law matters.