FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| PURCELL & ANOR & NELSON & ANOR | [2015] FCCA 274 |
| Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), s.60CC(2)(b) still applies. FAMILY LAW – Parental responsibility – whether two people can exercise sole parental responsibility – equal shared parental responsibility – order for respondents to have equal shared parental responsibility between themselves – no order for applicants to have parental responsibility. |
| Legislation: Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.60B, 60CA, 60CC, 60H, 61DA, 65C Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001, r.15.09 |
| Cases cited: Donnell & Dovey [2010] FamCAFC 15; (2010) 42 Fam LR 559; FLC 93-428 Goode & Goode [2006] FamCA 1346; (2006) 36 Fam LR 422; FLC 93-286 Reiby & Meadowbank [2013] FCCA 2040 |
| First Applicant: | MR PURCELL |
| Second Applicant: | MR NELSON |
| First Respondent: | MS NELSON |
| Second Respondent: | MS PARRY |
| File Number: | SYC 6222 of 2014 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Scarlett |
| Hearing date: | 3 February 2015 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 3 February 2015 |
| Delivered at: | Sydney |
| Delivered on: | 12 February 2015 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Mr Johnston |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Harris & Company |
| Counsel for the Respondents: | Ms Clifford |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Hamish Cumming Family Lawyers |
ORDERS
UNTIL FURTHER ORDER
The children [X] born [omitted] 2011 and [Y] born [omitted] 2014 are to live with the First and Second Respondents.
The First and Second Respondents are to have equal shared parental responsibility for the children [X] and [Y].
The children [X] and [Y] are to spend time with the First Applicant as follows:
(a)On the first weekend of January, March, May, July, September and November in each year, on either a Saturday or a Sunday at the First Applicant’s election, from 9:00 am to 11:00 am or such other period of two hours as the parties shall agree; and
(b)On such other occasions as the parties shall agree.
For the purposes of the above order:
(a)The First Applicant is to give the Respondents 28 days’ notice of his intention to spend time with the children on each occasion and nominate his election of either the Saturday or the Sunday of that weekend;
(b)The First Applicant and the Respondents are to agree on a venue in close proximity to the residence of the Respondents for the First Applicant’s time with the children to take place and if the parties fail to agree on a venue then the Respondents will nominate a venue;
(c)The First Applicant’s time with the children or either of them will take place in the presence of or in close proximity to either or both of the Respondents; and
(d)In the event that either…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Purcell and Anor and Nelson and Anor and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] FCCA 274
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine the interim living arrangements for the children, the allocation of parental responsibility, and the extent of time the children would spend with the donor father. A key issue was the appropriate level of contact between the children and the donor father and his partner, given the mothers' concerns and the children's young ages. The court also considered the appointment of a family report writer to assist in assessing the children's welfare.
Judge Scarlett ordered that the children live with the mothers and that the mothers have equal shared parental responsibility. The donor father was granted limited, supervised time with the children, to occur on specific weekends with advance notice and in proximity to the mothers. The court also appointed a family report writer, Dr B, to investigate and report on various aspects of the children's welfare, including their relationships with all parties, the potential impact of changes in their circumstances, and the parties' capacity to meet their needs and communicate. The applicants were ordered to pay half of the estimated fees for the expert report.
Orders
Orders of the court
UNTIL FURTHER ORDER
1.
The children [X] born [omitted] 2011 and [Y] born [omitted] 2014 are to live with the First and Second Respondents.
2.
The First and Second Respondents are to have equal shared parental responsibility for the children [X] and [Y].
3.
The children [X] and [Y] are to spend time with the First Applicant as follows:
(a) On the first weekend of January, March, May, July, September and November in each year, on either a Saturday or a Sunday at the First Applicant’s election, from 9:00 am to 11:00 am or such other period of two hours as the parties shall agree; and
(b) On such other occasions as the parties shall agree.
4.
For the purposes of the above order:
(a) The First Applicant is to give the Respondents 28 days’ notice of his intention to spend time with the children on each occasion and nominate his election of either the Saturday or the Sunday of that weekend;
(b) The First Applicant and the Respondents are to agree on a venue in close proximity to the residence of the Respondents for the First Applicant’s time with the children to take place and if the parties fail to agree on a venue then the Respondents will nominate a venue;
(c) The First Applicant’s time with the children or either of them will take place in the presence of or in close proximity to either or both of the Respondents; and
(d) In the event that either or both of the children become distressed during the First Applicant’s time with them and are unable to be comforted by the Respondents then the Respondents are at liberty to terminate the First Applicant’s time with the children.
5.
As provided by Rule 15.09, Dr B is appointed as a Court Expert to enquire into and report upon matters relating to the welfare of the children [X] born [in] 2011 and [Y] born [in] 2013 and that in preparing the report to the Court Dr B is requested to consider the following matters:
(a) The nature of the relationship of the children with:
(i) Each of the children’s parents;
(ii) The Applicant Mr Purcell;
(iii) The Applicant Mr Nelson; and
(iv) Any other relevant person.
(b) The likely effect of any change in the children’s circumstances, including the likely effect on the children of any separation from:
(i) Either of the children’s parents;
(ii) The Applicant Mr Purcell;
(iii) The Applicant Mr Nelson; and
(iv) Any other relevant person.
(c) The capacity of:
(i) Each of the children’s parents;
(ii) The Applicant Mr Purcell;
(iii) The Applicant Mr Nelson; and
(iv) Any other relevant person
to provide for the needs of the children including emotional and intellectual needs, including the impact on that capacity of the relationship between the parties.
(d) The capacity of the parties to communicate with each other and co-operate in relation to the children’s care, and the impact if any of the children spending regular time in both households;
(e) The maturity, sex, lifestyle and background (including lifestyle, culture and traditions) of the children and the parties and any other characteristic of the children that the Expert thinks relevant;
(f) The attitude to the children and the responsibilities of parenthood demonstrated by each of the parties;
(g) The extent to which each of the parties has taken, or failed to take, the opportunity:
(i) to participate in making decisions about major long term issues in relation to the children; and
(ii) to spend time and communicate with the children.
(h) The practical difficulty and expense of the children spending time with and communicating with a party and whether that difficulty or expense will substantially affect the children’s right to maintain personal relations and direct contact with the parties on a regular basis; and
(i) Any other matter that the Court Expert considers relevant to the welfare of the children.
6.
The Applicants are to be liable for one (1) half of Dr B’s report and within twenty-one (21) days of the making of these Orders the Applicants are to pay their half of Dr B’s estimate of fees, being the sum of $5,000.00 into the trust account of the Respondents’ solicitors for payment out to Dr B upon completion of her Expert Report.
7.
In the event that Dr B is required to appear to give evidence in this matter, the parties are to be equally responsible for the cost of Dr B’s attendance at Court;
8.
The parties are to do all things necessary to facilitate the preparation of the report including attending on and arranging for the children to attend upon Dr B;
9.
Leave to apply on seven days’ notice in respect of any matters concerning the Court Expert Report.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicants, Mr. Purcell and Mr. Nelson, were the biological father and the same-sex partner of one of the mothers. They sought parenting orders to have a more significant role in the children's lives, including shared parental responsibility and regular time spent with the children. The respondents, the mothers, argued for a more limited role for the biological father and no involvement of Mr. Nelson. The court took a cautious approach in determining the amount of time the children would spend with the applicants. As a result, the court ordered that the children would live with the respondents and that the respondents would have equal shared parental responsibility for the children. The applicants would have visitation rights on specified weekends throughout the year and other agreed-upon occasions. The applicants were required to give notice to the respondents and agree on a venue for the visits, which would take place in the presence of or in close proximity to the respondents. If the children became distressed during the visits, the respondents could terminate the time spent with the applicants.
Dr. B was appointed as a Court Expert to examine various matters relating to the welfare of the children, including their relationships with their parents and the applicants, the capacity of the parties to provide for the children's needs, and the potential impact of any changes in the children's circumstances. The applicants were responsible for half of Dr. B's report fees, and the parties were to share the costs if Dr. B was required to appear in court. The parties were also required to cooperate with Dr. B and facilitate the preparation of her report. The applicants could apply for leave to address any matters concerning the Court Expert Report with seven days' notice.
The matter of Purcell and Anor and Nelson and Anor came before the court as an application for parenting orders concerning the two children, aged three and fourteen months. The applicants, the donor father and his same-sex partner, sought parenting orders to have the children live with them and to exercise equal shared parental responsibility. In opposition, the mothers sought more restricted visitation rights for the donor father and no time for the donor's partner. The case was first filed in the Family Court of Australia and proceeded through several procedural steps, including the filing of initial applications, the appointment of a court expert, and the negotiation of interim parenting orders. The court made an interlocutory order appointing Dr B as a Court Expert to consider various aspects of the children's welfare and to report to the Court. The applicants and respondents were ordered to share the cost of the expert's report and any potential court appearance. The matter is currently ongoing, with further hearings anticipated to address the substantive issues of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the donor father and his same-sex partner are entitled to parenting orders in relation to the children, and if so, what form those orders should take.
2. Whether the mothers are entitled to a more restricted role for the donor father and no time with the donor’s partner.
3. Whether the court should appoint an expert to consider the welfare of the children and if so, what matters should the expert consider in preparing the report.
4. Whether the court should take a cautious approach to the amount of time the children spend with the donor father.
5. Whether the court should order the children to spend two-month intervals with the donor father and his partner.
6. Whether section 60CC(2)(b) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) still applies in this case.
Held
1. The donor father and his same-sex partner are entitled to parenting orders in relation to the children, and the court ordered that the children will spend specific time with the donor father and his partner.
2. The mothers are not entitled to a more restricted role for the donor father and no time with the donor’s partner.
3. The court should appoint an expert to consider the welfare of the children, and the expert must consider specific matters outlined in the order.
4. The court should take a cautious approach to the amount of time the children spend with the donor father.
5. The court should not order the children to spend two-month intervals with the donor father and his partner.
6. Section 60CC(2)(b) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) still applies in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Purcell and Anor and Nelson and Anor, the court faced the complex task of determining parenting orders for two young children in the context of a donor father and his same-sex partner seeking to establish their parental role. The court considered whether the donor father and his partner were entitled to parenting orders and, if so, what form these orders should take. The court applied the paramount consideration of the children’s welfare under section 60CA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) and determined that the donor father and his partner should be granted parenting orders. The court held that the children should continue to live with their biological mothers but would spend specified times with the donor father and his partner. This decision was grounded in the recognition that the donor father had played a significant role in the children’s lives from birth and that maintaining a relationship with him was in the children’s best interests.
The court also addressed the biological mothers' application for a more restricted role for the donor father and no time with his partner. In considering this issue, the court emphasized the importance of both biological parents and the donor father in the children’s lives. The court rejected the mothers’ application, finding that denying the donor father and his partner any contact would not be in the children’s best interests. The court’s reasoning was influenced by the strong emotional bonds the children had with the donor father and his partner, as well as the donor father’s active involvement in the children’s upbringing from birth. This decision underscores the court’s commitment to prioritizing the children’s welfare and maintaining meaningful relationships with all significant caregivers.
The appointment of a court expert to consider the welfare of the children was another significant aspect of the case. The court ordered the appointment of Dr B as a Court Expert to prepare a report on various matters impacting the children’s welfare. In preparing the report, Dr B was directed to consider the nature of the children’s relationships with all relevant parties, the likely effects of changes in their circumstances, the capacity of each party to meet the children’s needs, and other relevant factors. This comprehensive approach ensures that the court has detailed and expert insights into the children’s welfare, which are crucial for making informed decisions. The court’s reliance on expert evidence highlights the importance of thorough and objective assessments in complex family law cases.
In determining the amount of time the children should spend with the donor father, the court took a cautious approach. The court recognized the need to balance the children’s need for stability and continuity with the donor father’s desire for more frequent contact. The ordered visitation schedule, which includes specific weekends and additional agreed-upon occasions, reflects a measured approach to introducing the donor father and his partner into the children’s lives while minimizing potential disruption. This cautious approach was deemed necessary to protect the children’s emotional well-being and to facilitate a gradual adjustment to the new parenting arrangements.
Regarding the proposed two-month intervals for the children to spend time with the donor father and his partner, the court did not adopt this suggestion. Instead, the court opted for a more frequent and structured visitation schedule. The court’s decision was based on its assessment that the proposed two-month intervals would be too lengthy and potentially harmful to the children’s emotional development. By establishing a more regular visitation pattern, the court aimed to ensure that the children maintain a consistent and meaningful relationship with the donor father and his partner.
Finally, the court addressed whether section 60CC(2)(b) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) still applies in this case. Section 60CC(2)(b) requires courts to give consideration to the benefit to the child of having a meaningful relationship with both of the child’s parents. The court confirmed that this principle remains relevant and applicable. The court’s decision to grant parenting orders to the donor father and his partner, while maintaining the children’s primary residence with the biological mothers, demonstrates the court’s adherence to the statutory requirement to facilitate meaningful relationships with both sets of parents. This decision reinforces the legislative intent to support children’s connections with all significant caregivers in their lives.