Regional Power Corporation v Pacific Hydro Group Two Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

REGIONAL POWER CORPORATION -v- PACIFIC HYDRO GROUP TWO PTY LTD [2013] WASC 46



SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIACitation No:[2013] WASC 46
Case No:CIV:1925/2012ON THE PAPERS
Coram:KENNETH MARTIN J22/02/13
12Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Preliminary issues to be determined
B
PDF Version
Parties:REGIONAL POWER CORPORATION
PACIFIC HYDRO GROUP TWO PTY LTD
ENERGIS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD formerly known as PACIFIC HYDRO GROUP THREE PTY LTD
NORTH WESTERN ENERGY PTY LTD formerly known as ORD ENERGY PTY LTD

Catchwords:

Preliminary issue
Three issues of four agreed
Dispute on fourth opposed issue
Criteria for preliminary issue
Assumption as to correctness of facts pleaded by plaintiff
Nature of losses characterised by exclusion clause in contract applicable to indirect and consequential losses

Legislation:

Electricity Corporations Act 2005 (WA), s 147
Rules of the Supreme Court 1975 (WA), O 1 r 4A, O1 r 4B, O 31 r 2

Case References:

Allen v Gulf Oil Refining Ltd [1981] AC 1001
Bass v Permanent Trustee Company Limited (1999) 198 CLR 334
BGC Residential Pty Ltd v Fairwater Pty Ltd [2012] WASCA 268
Bolivia Republic v National Bolivian Navigation Co (1876) 24 WR 361
Jacobson v Ross & Jacobson [1995] 1 VR 337
Landsdale Pty Ltd v Moore [2009] WASCA 176
Smith v Maloney (1998) 19 WAR 209


JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
    IN CHAMBERS
CITATION : REGIONAL POWER CORPORATION -v- PACIFIC HYDRO GROUP TWO PTY LTD [2013] WASC 46 CORAM : KENNETH MARTIN J HEARD : ON THE PAPERS DELIVERED : 22 FEBRUARY 2013 FILE NO/S : CIV 1925 of 2012 BETWEEN : REGIONAL POWER CORPORATION
    Plaintiff

    AND

    PACIFIC HYDRO GROUP TWO PTY LTD
    First Defendant

    ENERGIS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD formerly known as PACIFIC HYDRO GROUP THREE PTY LTD
    Second Defendant

    NORTH WESTERN ENERGY PTY LTD formerly known as ORD ENERGY PTY LTD
    Third Defendant

Catchwords:

Preliminary issue - Three issues of four agreed - Dispute on fourth opposed issue - Criteria for preliminary issue - Assumption as to correctness of facts pleaded by plaintiff - Nature of losses characterised by exclusion clause in contract applicable to indirect and consequential losses


(Page 2)



Legislation:
Electricity Corporations Act 2005 (WA), s 147
Rules of the Supreme Court 1975 (WA), O 1 r 4A, O1 r 4B, O 31 r 2

Result:

Preliminary issues to be determined


Category: B


Representation:

Counsel:


    Plaintiff : No appearance
    First Defendant : No appearance
    Second Defendant : No appearance
    Third Defendant : No appearance

Solicitors:

    Plaintiff : Ashrust Australia
    First Defendant : Lavan Legal
    Second Defendant : Lavan Legal
    Third Defendant : Lavan Legal



Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Allen v Gulf Oil Refining Ltd [1981] AC 1001
Bass v Permanent Trustee Company Limited (1999) 198 CLR 334
BGC Residential Pty Ltd v Fairwater Pty Ltd [2012] WASCA 268
Bolivia Republic v National Bolivian Navigation Co (1876) 24 WR 361
Jacobson v Ross & Jacobson [1995] 1 VR 337
Landsdale Pty Ltd v Moore [2009] WASCA…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Regional Power Corporation v Pacific Hydro Group Two Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASC 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Regional Power Corporation (the plaintiff) is the successor in title to the State Energy Commission of Western Australia (SECWA) and is proceeding against Pacific Hydro Group Two Pty Ltd and two other defendants (the defendants) in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The plaintiff claims damages for breach of contract arising from an incident in August 2006 at the Ord Hydro Power Station, which resulted in flooding. The plaintiff claims the defendants breached the Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) by failing to operate the power station in compliance with the agreement. The defendants deny any liability for damages and raise various contractual defences, including an exclusion clause that limits liability for indirect or consequential losses. The court must determine whether certain preliminary issues should be decided before proceeding to trial.

The main legal issues before the court are whether the exclusion clause in the PPA applies to the plaintiff's claimed losses, and if so, whether those losses are recoverable. The court must also determine whether the parties' agreed facts are sufficient to decide the preliminary issues without a trial. The court must consider whether the proposed fourth preliminary issue, concerning the characterisation of the plaintiff's claimed losses, is suitable for determination as a matter of law or if it requires a factual determination. The court must also consider the criteria for determining a preliminary issue, including whether it is a question of law, whether it necessarily arises in the proceeding, and whether its determination would lead to a substantial saving in time and expense.

The court found that the fourth proposed issue, concerning the characterisation of the plaintiff's claimed losses, is suitable for determination as a preliminary issue. The court noted that the issue involves assessing whether the claimed losses fall within the exclusionary scope of the PPA's exclusion clause, which is a question of law. The court held that the issue can be determined by assuming the facts as pleaded in the plaintiff's amended statement of claim to be true. The court also found that the exercise of characterising the losses is a relatively confined one and would likely lead to a substantial saving in time and expense. The court ordered that the four preliminary issues be tried and that the costs of determining the fourth issue be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a claim for damages by Regional Power Corporation (Regional Power), trading as Horizon Power, against Pacific Hydro Group Two Pty Ltd and others (the defendants), for breach of contract. The contract in question was made on 18 October 1994 between the State Energy Commission of Western Australia (SECWA) and Pacific Hydro Pty Ltd (Pacific Hydro), concerning the supply of power from the Ord Hydro Power Station. SECWA's rights under the contract were transferred to Western Power and subsequently to Regional Power. In August 2006, an outage at the power station caused flooding, interrupting power supply for approximately two months. Regional Power claims damages for the costs incurred in constructing, installing, and operating additional power generation facilities at the Kununurra Power Station to compensate for the outage, amounting to just over $4 million. The defendants deny liability and invoke contractual provisions concerning notice, events of default, and exclusion of certain types of damages.

The case was brought to the Supreme Court of Western Australia on the papers, with no appearance for any party. The proceedings were initiated by an amended writ filed by Regional Power on 21 August 2012, followed by an amended statement of claim on 30 August 2012. The defendants filed a further amended defence on 14 November 2012. Regional Power filed an amended reply on 22 November 2012. The pleadings were closed, and the matter was set for a hearing to determine four preliminary issues, with a potential for a fifth issue to be decided if certain conditions were met.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. On the proper construction of the PPA, do clauses 19, 20, 21, 22, and 23 provide the only remedies for a breach of clause 6.1, 10.1, or the implied term pleaded at paragraph 11 of the amended statement of claim, or is the plaintiff entitled to remedies available to it at common law for breaches of clauses 6.1, 10.1, or the implied term or any of them?
2. Can the plaintiff recover damages at common law in the absence of an Event of Default (as defined in the PPA) triggering the remedial regime under clauses 19, 20, 21, 22, and 23 of the PPA?
3. Can the plaintiff recover damages at common law for breach of the PPA by the defendants where there is no agreement between the plaintiff and the defendants that the breach did not have a material, adverse effect on the plaintiff under clause 23.2?
4. If the answer to question 3 above is 'yes', are the heads of loss and damages claimed by the plaintiff at paragraph 21 of the amended statement of claim recoverable against the defendants in light of the exclusion for certain types of loss and damage at clause 26.1 of the PPA?

Held
1. Clauses 19, 20, 21, 22, and 23 do not provide the only remedies for a breach of clause 6.1, 10.1, or the implied term pleaded at paragraph 11 of the amended statement of claim. The plaintiff is entitled to remedies available to it at common law for breaches of clauses 6.1, 10.1, or the implied term or any of them.
2. The plaintiff can recover damages at common law in the absence of an Event of Default (as defined in the PPA) triggering the remedial regime under clauses 19, 20, 21, 22, and 23 of the PPA.
3. The plaintiff can recover damages at common law for breach of the PPA by the defendants where there is no agreement between the plaintiff and the defendants that the breach did not have a material, adverse effect on the plaintiff under clause 23.2.
4. The heads of loss and damages claimed by the plaintiff at paragraph 21 of the amended statement of claim are recoverable against the defendants in light of the exclusion for certain types of loss and damage at clause 26.1 of the PPA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the four preliminary issues proposed by the parties. The court determined that the fourth issue, concerning the characterisation of the plaintiff's claimed losses in light of the exclusion of certain types of loss and damage at clause 26.1 of the PPA, is suitable for preliminary determination. The court held that this issue can be determined by assuming the correctness of the facts as alleged in the plaintiff's amended statement of claim and by assessing whether the particular claimed losses fall within the exclusionary ambit of clause 26.1. The court found that determining this issue would provide significant utility in the proceedings and that it can be appropriately undertaken by reference to the assumed correctness of the facts as currently alleged in the ASOC. The court noted that the primary task in resolving the fourth issue would be to characterise the nature of the claimed losses, which is a routine exercise for courts and other entities such as insurance companies.

The court further reasoned that determining the fourth issue would not necessarily involve a mixed law and fact determination, as the court could proceed by reference to facts assumed to be correct for the purposes of the preliminary determination. The court relied on the precedent in Jacobson v Ross & Jacobson, which held that a court can determine a question of law by reference to underlying facts, assuming the correctness of those facts for the purposes of the preliminary determination. The court also noted that the defendants would remain free to dispute the facts at the trial if necessary.

In conclusion, the court found that there was significant overall utility in resolving the fourth proposed issue and that it could be appropriately undertaken by reference to the assumed correctness of the facts as currently alleged in the ASOC. The court ordered the trial of the four preliminary issues and directed the parties to finalise the draft statement of agreed facts for the hearing. The costs of determining the fourth issue were reserved.