Re Read

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

In the Matter of ROSE-MARIE ALEXANDRA READ

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Besanko

8 February 2006

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES - OTHER STATES OR TERRITORIES

Application pursuant to s 49 of Legal Practitioners Act 1981 for authority to practise profession of law as declared bankrupt – nature of inquiry under s 49 – whether applicant fit and proper person to practise profession of law – protection of public relevant consideration – relevance of circumstances surrounding bankruptcy – application granted subject to conditions.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 s 49, referred to.
Law Society (SA) v Rodda (2002) 83 SASR 541; Reynolds v Law Society of South Australia [2002] SASC 223; Re Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA); Re Jordan [2005] SASC 367, considered.

In the Matter of ROSE-MARIE ALEXANDRA READ
[2006] SASC 35

Civil

  1. BESANKO J: Rose-Marie Alexandra Read is a solicitor who was declared bankrupt on 19 December 2005. By reason of s 49 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (“LPA”), she may not practise the profession of the law without the authority of this Court. Section 49 is in the following terms:

    49. (1) A legal practitioner—

    (a)     who has become bankrupt or subject to a composition or deed of arrangement or assignment with or for the benefit of creditors; or

    (b)     who is or has been a director of an incorporated legal practitioner during the winding up of the company for the benefit of creditors,

    must not, without the authority of the Supreme Court, practise the profession of the law.

    Maximum penalty: $10,000.

    (1a) Authority may be granted under this section on the application of a legal practitioner who is or is about to become bankrupt or subject to a composition or deed of arrangement or assignment with or for the benefit of creditors or who is or has been a director of an incorporated legal practitioner that is being or is about to be wound up for the benefit of creditors.

    (2) The Supreme Court may grant an authority under this section on such conditions as it thinks fit.

    (3) A legal practitioner must not contravene or fail to comply with any condition of an authority granted by the Supreme Court under this section.

    Maximum penalty: $10,000.

  2. By ex parte summons issued on 6 January 2006, Ms Read seeks the authority of this Court to practise the profession of the law.  The Law Society of South Australia (“the Society”) has been served with the application and it appeared by counsel before me.  It does not oppose a grant of authority subject to conditions.  Certain conditions have been proposed by the applicant, and the Society has indicated that it agrees with the proposed conditions.

    The facts

  3. A number of affidavits were put before me, including a detailed affidavit of the applicant.  The relevant events extend over a period of nearly ten years (ie, 1996-2005), and, although a good deal of information was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Read and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Read, the applicant, Ms Read, sought an authority to practise law in South Australia under section 49 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981. Ms Read had been admitted as a legal practitioner in South Australia in 1978 and had been declared bankrupt in 2005. The Law Society of South Australia did not oppose the application, provided certain conditions were imposed. Ms Read agreed to these proposed conditions, which included restrictions on her practice and financial management due to her bankruptcy.

The legal issues before the court were whether Ms Read was a fit and proper person to practise law given her bankruptcy and whether the court should consider the circumstances surrounding her bankruptcy in determining her fitness to practise. The court was also required to determine appropriate conditions that should be imposed on her practising certificate to ensure the protection of the public.

The court considered Ms Read's personal and professional history, including her bankruptcy and the reasons behind it. It took into account her previous experience, her cooperation with the Law Society, and the proposed conditions that would mitigate any risk to the public. The court found that granting the authority subject to conditions would be appropriate to protect the public while also allowing Ms Read to continue her legal career under strict supervision.

The court granted Ms Read's application for an authority to practise law, subject to a number of detailed conditions that limited her practice to employed solicitor roles under the supervision of approved legal practitioners. The conditions also required her to comply with financial obligations related to her bankruptcy and to adhere to specific financial and professional conduct rules. The court detailed these conditions in its order, ensuring that the public would be protected while allowing Ms Read to resume her legal career under strict oversight.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

By ex parte summons issued on 6 January 2006, Ms Read seeks the authority of this Court to practise the profession of the law. The Law Society of South Australia (“the Society”) has been served with the application and it appeared by counsel before me. It does not oppose a grant of authority subject to conditions. Certain conditions have been proposed by the applicant, and the Society has indicated that it agrees with the proposed conditions.The facts A number of affidavits were put before me, including a detailed affidavit of the applicant. The relevant events extend over a period of nearly ten years (ie, 1996-2005), and, although a good deal of information was put before me, in some areas the information is not in a form that enables me to make precise findings. However, the picture that emerges is sufficiently clear for me to determine this application. On 2 October 1978, the applicant was admitted to practise in South Australia. She had completed articles of clerkship with the Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement in 1977 and 1978. After practising in partnership for two to three years, the applicant commenced practise as a sole practitioner under the firm name R-M.A. Cadd & Associates. From March 1982 she practised from premises in Salisbury and she continued to practise as a sole practitioner until the date upon which she was declared bankrupt. The applicant was married in 1984. There were no children of the marriage. The applicant employed her husband in her firm as the office manager and as a paralegal. The marriage did not last and the applicant separated from her husband in 1993 and they were divorced in 1994. The property at Salisbury from which the applicant practised was in her husband’s name and the applicant paid rent to him. In September 1995, the applicant re-married and, in 1997, she gave birth to a boy. The applicant was required to work up to and immediately after the birth of her son, as her second husband had resigned from his employment with the intention of carrying out further study. At the time of her second marriage, the applicant’s first husband, after a short break, was again working in the practice as the office manager and as a paralegal. From about 2002 onwards, the applicant began experiencing difficulties working with her first husband. It seems that, as office manager of the practice, he had failed in his duty to prepare, or assist in the preparation of, six Business Activity Statements for the financial quarter ending 30 June 2002. In March 2005, he left his employment with the applicant because their relationship had become unworkable. Between 1996 and 2004, the applicant also experienced a number of medical and other problems, including a miscarriage in January 1996, an undiagnosed stomach illness in 2003 and 2004, and a motor vehicle accident in 2004. It seems that she also experienced difficulties associated with her second husband’s drug addiction, which, as far as I can see, continued from December 1996 to August 2000, and her son’s learning and social problems at school, which also appear to have continued over a substantial period of time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the facts of this case and the fact that the authority will be subject to the conditions set out below, I think it is appropriate to grant an authority under s 49 of the LPA.Conclusion I will grant an authority under s 49 of the LPA subject to the following conditions:1The practitioner’s right of practice be limited to that of an employed solicitor in the employ of and under the supervision of Brett Jonathan Dixon and Phillip David Gallasch or such other legal practitioner of no less than ten years’ standing as may from time to time be approved by the court with no right of private practice;2the practitioner must forthwith advise the Law Society of South Australia should she cease to be so employed;3the practitioner must not receive or deal with money paid by her employer’s clients;4the practitioner must not render any bill for professional fees other than practice taxation invoices for the legal practice of Dixon Gallasch Pty Ltd or such other practitioner as may from time to time be approved by the court;5the practitioner must not establish or maintain a solicitor’s trust account in her own name, nor operate upon the trust account of Dixon Gallasch Pty Ltd;6the practitioner must comply with the reasonable directions of her trustee in bankruptcy;7the practitioner must pay within the prescribed periods any contributions to her bankrupt estate assessed against her income;8the practitioner must lodge her future income tax returns within the prescribed time periods and pay any income tax assessed thereon as required by the Australian Taxation Office;9the practitioner must retain the services of Grant Stephens of HLB Mann Judd Stephens, Chartered Accountants to manage her financial affairs while she remains an undischarged bankrupt. In his affidavits, Mr Brett Dixon has offered a number of undertakings in terms of the supervision of the applicant and those undertakings should be identified in the minutes of the order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established