LEO JOHN REYNOLDS No. SCCIV-02-657

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE MATTER OF THE LEGAL PRACTITIONERS ACT 1981:
RE:  LEO JOHN REYNOLDS


[2002] SASC 223

  1. GRAY J.                This is an application by a legal practitioner to continue to practise the profession of the law after bankruptcy.

    Background

  2. Leo John Reynolds has been a legal practitioner for more than 10 years.  He  is 48 years of age. He has practised more recently under the name Reynolds Lawyers in partnership with Linda Joanne Gross. Mr Reynolds and Ms Gross are married. On 7 May 2002 Mr Reynolds lodged an application for his own bankruptcy. He now seeks this court’s authority to continue to practise the profession of the law.

  3. When Mr Reynolds made his bankruptcy application in May 2002 he had unsecured debts of $505,000 comprising $327,000 in bank loans, $120,000 in personal loans and $58,000 in credit card debts. The circumstances which led to Mr Reynolds’ bankruptcy are not entirely clear. However the following general picture emerges.

  4. In 1995 Mr Reynolds and his then de facto partner Kerry Margaret Hallett purchased a property at Stonyfell. The property was subject to a first mortgage. At around this time Mr Reynolds became a partner with Mr Townsend initially practising under the name Morcombe and Townsend and later under the name Townsends Barristers.

  5. In 1996 a company owned and controlled by Mr Townsend and Mr Reynolds purchased an office building in Halifax Street Adelaide. The property was financed by Westpac.   Part of the security for the purchase was a second mortgage over the Stonyfell property and Mr Reynolds’ personal guarantee.

  6. Apparently in early 1998 Westpac called up all loans relating to the Townsends practice and the office building. Mr Townsend and Mr Reynolds arranged for refinancing through the National Australian Bank (“N.A.B.”) In September of that year the Townsends partnership was dissolved and the NAB terminated the loans. At that time Mr Reynolds was jointly indebted to the NAB in the amount of $160,000 and had a further liability of $20,000 for legal fees. The NAB called on the guarantees and sought to enforce the second mortgage on the Stonyfell property. As a result Mr Reynolds arranged for that Stonyfell property to be refinanced.

  7. The Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (“ANZ”) agreed to refinance Mr Reynolds. That commitment by the ANZ was in turn secured by the Stonyfell property. Mr Reynolds’ affidavit does not clearly demonstrate the extent of his indebtedness to bankers and others at this time.

  8. Mr Reynolds’ relationship with Ms Hallett terminated and she lodged a caveat to protect her claimed interest in the Stonyfell property. The papers indicate that Mr Reynolds’ transferred his interest in the Stonyfell property to Ms Hallett in March 2000.

  9. In March 2002 Mr Reynolds was in practice with Ms Gross operating under the name Reynolds Lawyers. At that time the ANZ issued a notice of demand claiming $160,140.71. Mr Reynolds had no capacity to pay. His statement of affairs disclosed the following unsecured creditors:

NAB personal loans    $     17,000
NAB credit…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LEO JOHN REYNOLDS No. SCCIV-02-657 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 223
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of LEO JOHN REYNOLDS No. SCCIV-02-657, the court addressed the issue of whether an order for disclosure should be made in the context of Mr Reynolds' bankruptcy proceedings. Mr Reynolds, who is a legal practitioner, sought an order for disclosure, but the court found that there was no necessity for such an order given his existing legal obligations.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the existing statutory, fiduciary, and common law obligations of Mr Reynolds were sufficient to protect the public interest without the need for an additional disclosure order. The court had to determine if the existing obligations placed on Mr Reynolds were adequate to ensure that he was acting in the best interests of his clients and the public.

In delivering its judgment, the court examined the obligations already imposed upon Mr Reynolds. It found that Mr Reynolds' statutory obligations, including his duty to inform clients of his bankruptcy, and his fiduciary obligations, which include acting in the best interests of his clients, were sufficient to protect the public. The court noted that Mr Reynolds had acknowledged his duty to advise clients of his bankruptcy status, further indicating that he understood and was complying with his legal obligations. The court concluded that the existing obligations were adequate to protect the public without the need for an additional order for disclosure. Therefore, the court dismissed the application for an order for disclosure.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
Mr Reynolds remains at all times subject to his statutory, fiduciary and common law obligations. Having regard to these obligations the public are adequately protected without the making of an order for disclosure in this case. LIST OF CITATIONS IN THE ORDER OF APPEARANCE IN THE JUDGMENT1 Re John Sandford Hynd, unreported, S 5042, 7 April 1995; Re Stephen Harry MacFarlane, unreported, S 4939, 16 January 1995.2 The practitioner is well aware of his obligations in this regard as he informed the court “I understand that it’s my obligation to advise all client’s that I’m bankrupt.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J