Re May and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 480

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  N1999/1424

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      OLIVER MAY         
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

Date15 June 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed.             
  ..............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – subclass 300 prospective spouse visa – citizen of the Philippines - not a person of good character – past and present general conduct – lodgement of application for protection visa – application false – application refused – request for ministerial intervention – request refused – continued working illegally – allegation of fraud and malpractice on the part of migration agent - consideration of other general conduct – consideration of exercise of Tribunal's discretion – consideration of the need to protect the Australian community – need to send a strong deterrent message – consideration of the expectations of the Australian Community – legitimate expectation that visa applicant's conduct should not be rewarded - consideration of the best interests of the child – no evidence that child would be adversely affected by return to the Philippines – consideration of the effect of the separation on the applicant – acknowledged emotional hardship – decision affirmed
Migration Act (1958) s501
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1238
Goldie v The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs 199 FCA 1277
Lachmaiya v Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 19 AAR 148
Prasad v Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 35 ALD 780
Annecchini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (AAT 11838, & May 1997)
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Multicultural Affairs (1996) FCR 422
Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Multicultural Affairs v Baker (1997) 73 FCR 187

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President   

BACKGROUND
Application and Hearing

  1. This is an application by Mr Oliver May (the review applicant) for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister) pursuant to s501 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) to refuse to grant to his fiance, Ms Rebecca Monis (the visa applicant), a subclass 300 (prospective spouse) visa. The refusal was based on a finding that Ms Monis was not a person of good character. Section 500(1)(b) of the Act confers jurisdiction on the Tribunal to review this decision.

  2. Mr Nicholas Poynder, of counsel, instructed by Mr Sasko Markovski, represented Mr May at the hearing.  Both Mr May and Ms Monis gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The following witnesses also testified on behalf of the applicant:

    Ms Maria Stegeman
    Ms Susan Chun Yao
    Mr Rodante Monis

  3. Ms Juanita Kapel, a departmental advocate, represented the respondent.  Ms Sally Reay-Young gave personal testimony on behalf of the respondent.

  4. The Tribunal had before it documents and supplementary documents filed for the purpose of s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the T and S documents). The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re May and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 480
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re May and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved a challenge to the refusal of a subclass 300 prospective spouse visa application by Ms Monis, a citizen of the Philippines. The primary legal issue was whether Ms Monis met the character test under section 501(6)(c)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958. The respondent argued that Ms Monis did not meet the character test due to her past and present general conduct, which included engaging in deceitful activities related to her protection visa application and continuing to work illegally in Australia. Ms Monis argued that there were countervailing factors justifying a finding that she did meet the character test.

The Tribunal considered the Policy Direction on the character test, which requires decision-makers to consider both good and bad conduct when assessing a non-citizen's character. The Tribunal noted that Ms Monis's past conduct, including the lodgement of a false protection visa application and ongoing illegal employment, indicated a disregard for the law and human rights. While the Tribunal acknowledged the genuine relationship between Ms Monis and Mr May, it found that Ms Monis did not disclose her immigration issues to Mr May until after the Minister declined to exercise his discretion to allow her to obtain a visa. The Tribunal concluded that the best interests of Ms Monis's daughter, Jharizz, would not be adversely affected by her return to the Philippines. The Tribunal also considered the emotional hardship caused to Mr May but found it insufficient to outweigh the need to send a strong deterrent message and protect the Australian community.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse Ms Monis's visa application, finding that she did not meet the character test and that there were no compelling reasons to exercise the Tribunal's discretion in her favour. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of upholding the integrity of the immigration system and ensuring that visa applicants' conduct is properly assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Monis, a citizen of the Philippines, applied for a subclass 300 prospective spouse visa. The application was refused on the basis that Ms Monis did not meet the character test under section 501(6)(c)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958. The Minister had previously declined to exercise his discretion to allow Ms Monis to obtain a visa, a decision which was communicated to her. Ms Monis had a daughter, Jharizz, who was not an Australian citizen and lived primarily in the Philippines. Mr May, an Australian citizen, had entered into a relationship with Ms Monis. The relationship had resulted in Mr May proposing marriage to Ms Monis on Australia Day in 1998. The Minister's refusal to grant Ms Monis a visa had led to Mr May experiencing emotional hardship and receiving treatment for depression.

This case involves a review of the decision by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to refuse Ms Monis' subclass 300 prospective spouse visa under section 501(6)(c)(ii) of the Migration Act 1958. The review was conducted by the Migration Review Tribunal. The Tribunal heard evidence from both parties and considered various factors including Ms Monis' past and present general conduct, the nature of her relationship with Mr May, and the best interests of her daughter, Jharizz. The Tribunal also considered the Policy Direction on the character test and other relevant considerations.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Reference will be made later in this decision to those provisions of the Policy Direction which are relevant to the Tribunal's consideration of the present matter. But first the Tribunal turns its attention to the evidence presented concerning Ms Monis and the application of the character test under s501.EVIDENCEPast and Present General Conduct As noted it was the general contention of the respondent that Ms Monis does not pass the character test pursuant to s501(6)(c)(ii) of the Act on the basis of her past and present general conduct. Paragraph 1.9 of the Policy Direction has the following to say about the way in which decision makers should apply the character test under this particular head.1.9 In considering whether a non-citizen is not of good character against subparagraph 501(6)(c)(ii), decision-makers should consider the following matters (where they are relevant to the facts of the particular case), and where they are relevant, would, in the absence of any countervailing factors, constitute a failure to pass the Character Test:(a)whether the non-citizen has been involved in activities indicating contempt, or disregard, for the law or for human rights. This could include, but need not be limited to:· engaging in business activities which fall short of criminal fraud requiring proof beyond reasonable doubt, but which, on a more likely than not basis, are disreputable and reflect poorly on a non-citizen's moral qualities;· continual evasion or non-payment of debt;· continual disregard as to payments of family maintenance; The Policy Direction also indicates that:1.11 General conduct also includes recent good conduct. Any good acts of the non-citizen after reprehensible conduct are indications that the non-citizen's character may have reformed. Thus, both good and bad conduct must be taken into consideration in obtaining a complete picture of the non-citizen's character. However, where the decision-maker is not fully persuaded that the non-citizen has reformed, the discretion to refuse or cancel a visa is enlivened, and evidence of good acts and recent conduct becomes relevant to the exercise of the discretion (see Part 2).(T: 48) In both its Statement of Facts and Contentions, and in the presentation of its case at the hearing, the respondent indicated that it was principally paragraph 1.9(a) and (b) of the Policy Direction which were most relevant to Ms Monis. While not disputing this, the applicant's case proceeded on the basis that there were countervailing factors which would justify a finding by the Tribunal that Ms Monis did meet the character test.Protection Visa Application The claims that were made by Ms Monis at the time of lodging her protection visa application have already been set out in detail. In her personal testimony to the Tribunal Ms Monis stated that she had come to Australia on her visitor's visa, in company with her daughter, in order to stay with her relatives who she had not seen for many years. Upon her arrival on 26 June 1996 she had gone to live with these relatives - her two sisters and a brother. She then decided that she wished to stay longer and was then told by a friend of one of her sister's that there was somebody who could help her assist her. That person was Mr Gonzales.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Poynder contended on behalf of the applicant that the genuineness of the relationship between Mr May and Ms Monis had to be given some weight, as did the fact that Mr May had not been aware of the character issues involved when he entered into the relationship. Mr May had also given compelling evidence about the effect that the separation from his fiance had upon him, including his receipt of treatment for depression.CONCLUSION In all cases of this type in which a decision can have a profound impact upon people's lives, the balancing process required in exercising the discretion under s501 of the Act is not an easy one. The Tribunal has some sympathy for the situation in which the review applicant, Mr May, finds himself after entering into a relationship with one of his fellow employees who has been judged, on the basis of her past and present general conduct, to not be of good character. The Tribunal has no doubt that Mr May entered into this relationship with Ms Monis in good faith and without any prior knowledge of her immigration malpractice. Indeed, the Tribunal found Mr May to be an honest and frank witness who spoke in quite moving terms of the hardship that he had already experienced as a result of his separation from his fiance. The overall genuineness of the relationship between Mr May and Ms Monis was not put in issue before the Tribunal. The Tribunal nonetheless observes that Ms Monis does not seem to have been willing to disclose her misdeeds to Mr May until after the date upon which he proposed marriage to her. Mr May said that this proposal was made on Australia Day in 1998 but that Ms Monis had not responded immediately to his offer (see paragraph 37 above). Ms Monis herself, in her personal testimony, was certain that she had said yes to Mr May's marriage proposal on the day that it was made (see transcript 24 February 2000: 57-58). This discrepancy in the respective memories of Mr May and Ms Monis may on the face of it seem insignificant but it must be recalled that on the day after the marriage proposal had been made by Mr May the Minister declined to exercise his discretion to allow Ms Monis to obtain a visa, and that this decision was communicated to her shortly afterwards. Given Ms Monis' predilection to engage in deceitful behaviour it does not seem an unreasonable inference to draw that she waited until she knew of the outcome of this Ministerial request before deciding to tell Mr May about her migration problems. The Tribunal accepts Mr May's version of when the marriage proposal was actually accepted by Ms Monis. In regard to the primary considerations which must be taken into account under the provisions of the Policy Direction the Tribunal is satisfied on the evidence before it that little weight should be attached in the balancing process to the best interests of Ms Monis' daughter, Jharizz. Her attachments to both Australia and Mr May have been of a limited duration and it would appear that she continues to have strong ties to the Philippines which would be retained if her mother were not allowed to enter Australia. Ms Monis has full-time employment in the Philippines and is able to provide the economic and allied support she requires quite apart from the relationship with Mr May.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In her submissions, Ms Kapel noted that Jharizz, like her mother, was not an Australian citizen and her natural father lived in the Philippines as did her grandparents. There was no evidence of a close relationship between Mr May and Ms Monis' daughter and the child's interests would not be affected by the extended separation of Ms Monis and Mr May. It would also be in the best interests of Jharizz if she were to remain in the Philippines where she had strong social support and had spent the majority of her childhood.Other Considerations Paragraph 2.17 of the Policy Direction refers to a number of other matters which, although not primary considerations, may be relevant to the exercise of the discretion under the Act. The Policy Direction states, in part, that:2.17 It is the Government's view that where relevant, it is appropriate these matters be taken into account but that they be given less individual weight than that given to the primary considerations. These other considerations may include:(a)the extent of disruption to the non-citizen's family, business and other ties to the Australian community;(b)genuine marriage to, or de facto or interdependent relationship with, an Australian citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen: The respondent conceded that there might be some emotional hardship caused to Mr May should his fiance be refused a visa. Nonetheless the relationship had been of relatively short standing and there were not other compelling reasons why Ms Monis should be granted a visa. Mr Poynder contended on behalf of the applicant that the genuineness of the relationship between Mr May and Ms Monis had to be given some weight, as did the fact that Mr May had not been aware of the character issues involved when he entered into the relationship. Mr May had also given compelling evidence about the effect that the separation from his fiance had upon him, including his receipt of treatment for depression.CONCLUSION In all cases of this type in which a decision can have a profound impact upon people's lives, the balancing process required in exercising the discretion under s501 of the Act is not an easy one. The Tribunal has some sympathy for the situation in which the review applicant, Mr May, finds himself after entering into a relationship with one of his fellow employees who has been judged, on the basis of her past and present general conduct, to not be of good character. The Tribunal has no doubt that Mr May entered into this relationship with Ms Monis in good faith and without any prior knowledge of her immigration malpractice. Indeed, the Tribunal found Mr May to be an honest and frank witness who spoke in quite moving terms of the hardship that he had already experienced as a result of his separation from his fiance. The overall genuineness of the relationship between Mr May and Ms Monis was not put in issue before the Tribunal. The Tribunal nonetheless observes that Ms Monis does not seem to have been willing to disclose her misdeeds to Mr May until after the date upon which he proposed marriage to her. Mr May said that this proposal was made on Australia Day in 1998 but that Ms Monis had not responded immediately to his offer (see paragraph 37 above). Ms Monis herself, in her personal testimony, was certain that she had said yes to Mr May's marriage proposal on the day that it was made (see transcript 24 February 2000: 57-58). This discrepancy in the respective memories of Mr May and Ms Monis may on the face of it seem insignificant but it must be recalled that on the day after the marriage proposal had been made by Mr May the Minister declined to exercise his discretion to allow Ms Monis to obtain a visa, and that this decision was communicated to her shortly afterwards. Given Ms Monis' predilection to engage in deceitful behaviour it does not seem an unreasonable inference to draw that she waited until she knew of the outcome of this Ministerial request before deciding to tell Mr May about her migration problems. The Tribunal accepts Mr May's version of when the marriage proposal was actually accepted by Ms Monis.