Tung and Migration Agents Registration Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 920

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2002/340

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )          
           Re      NEI-HWA TUNG     
  Applicant
           And    MIGRATION AGENTS REGISTRATION AUTHORITY          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Ms N Bell, Member

Date14 October 2002 

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

[SGD] Ms N Bell
  Member 
CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION AGENTS REGISTRATION AUTHORITY – suspension of registration as a migration agent – whether the Applicant is a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance – examination of the Applicant's conduct as migration agent – examination of his knowledge of the Migration Act 1958 with regard to spouse visa applications and protection visas – held that the Applicant's knowledge is seriously lacking as to migration procedures – decision of MARA affirmed.

Migration Act 1958 ss 48, 48A, 49, 290, 290(1)(2)(3), 303, 303(a)(e), 501, 501(6)(c)(ii)

Fifita v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 1719
Re May and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 480
Story v National Companies and Securities Commission (1988) 13 NSWLR 661

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms N Bell, Member            

  1. This is an application by Mr Nei-Hwa Tung ("the Applicant") for review of the decision of the Migration Agents Registration Authority ("the Respondent") dated 5 February 2002 to suspend the Applicant's registration as a migration agent until the following conditions have been satisfied:

  • a period of three years has passed from the date of notification of the Respondent's decision; or

  • the Applicant successfully completes a sound knowledge course and a reasonable time has been allowed for the Respondent to consider the matter; and

  • the Applicant provides a statutory declaration that he has not made immigration representations for a fee nor given immigration assistance whilst suspended.

  1. At the hearing before the Tribunal the Applicant spoke on his own behalf with the assistance of an interpreter in the Cantonese language and the Respondent was represented by Ms Goodman, solicitor.  The Applicant and Ms Diane Wechman, Mr Alan Hu and Mr Jingxin Wu gave oral evidence to the Tribunal.  

  2. The Tribunal had the following documents before it:
    Exhibit No    Description  Date  
    TD1 – TD34 Documents prepared pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
    TD2 Supplementary documents prepared pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975
    A1      Statutory Declaration of Nei-Hwa Tung   24 June 2002           
    A2      Letter Nei-Hwa Tung to the AAT enclosing Chronology and References     12 September 2002  
    A3      Certificates of courses undertaken by Nei-Hwa Tung              
    A4      Letter from Laurie Ferguson, MP, to the AAT     9 September 2002  
    A5      Extract from training course for Migration Agents on Australian Immigration Law and Practice           15-23 March 1997  

BACKGROUND

  1. The decision under review arose out of a complaint lodged by Mr Rafael Caliwanagan ("the Complainant") to the Respondent.  

  2. The following chronology of events is not in dispute:

Date   Event
15/11/99        Application for Complainant to remain permanently in Australia on spouse grounds           
1/8/01 Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs wrote to Complainant, care of Applicant, informing him that his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tung and Migration Agents Registration Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 920
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Tung and Migration Agents Registration Authority involved a dispute over the suspension of a migration agent's registration. The Migration Agents Registration Authority (MARA) had suspended the registration of the applicant, Mr. Tung, on the grounds that he was not a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance. The applicant contested the decision, and the matter was brought before the court. The primary legal issue was whether the applicant's registration should be suspended based on his knowledge of migration procedures and his conduct as a migration agent. The court examined the applicant's understanding of the Migration Act 1958, particularly concerning spouse visa applications and protection visas.

The court found that the applicant's knowledge of migration procedures was seriously lacking. He had assisted a client in lodging a spouse visa application despite knowing that the client was ineligible to do so onshore. Additionally, the applicant had advised the client to pursue a relationship with an Australian citizen to improve the chances of obtaining a visa, which was misleading advice. The court also noted that the applicant had not complied with the Code of Conduct prescribed under section 314 of the Act. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant was not a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance and upheld the decision to suspend his registration.

The court's reasoning was based on the applicant's inadequate understanding of the Migration Act and his misleading advice to a client. The Tribunal found that the applicant's conduct demonstrated a lack of integrity and competence, which are essential qualities for a registered migration agent. The decision was affirmed based on the applicant's failure to meet the standards required under section 303 of the Migration Act. The final orders of the court were to uphold the decision of MARA to suspend the applicant's registration as a migration agent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Peter Nei Hwa Tung was a registered migration agent. The Complainant, who arrived in Australia as a visitor on 8 October 1996, initially applied for a protection visa which was rejected. He then entered into a de facto relationship with an Australian citizen and married her on 2 January 1999. He consulted Tung and on 15 November 1999, Tung lodged a spouse visa application on his behalf. On 1 August 2001, the Complainant was notified that the spouse visa application was invalid. He subsequently complained to the Migration Agents Registration Authority (MARA) about Tung's conduct. The key facts are that Tung's knowledge of migration procedures, particularly regarding spouse visa applications, is under scrutiny, and there are concerns about whether Tung is a fit and proper person to provide immigration assistance.

The matter came before the Tribunal as an appeal against a decision by MARA to suspend Tung's registration as a migration agent. The Tribunal reviewed the decision to determine whether Tung is a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance. This involved examining the conduct of Tung as a migration agent and his knowledge of the Migration Act 1958 in relation to spouse visa applications and protection visas.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relevant legislation is section 303 of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act"). Section 303 provides:303 Discretionary cancellation or suspension of registration etc.The Migration Agents Registration Authority may:(a)cancel the registration of a registered agent by removing his or her name from the register; or(b) suspend his or her registration; or (c) caution him or her;if it becomes satisfied that:(d)the agent's application for registration was known by the agent to be false or misleading in a material particular; or(e) the agent becomes bankrupt; or(f)the agent is not a person of integrity or is otherwise not a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance; or(g)an individual related by employment to the agent is not a person of integrity; or(h)the agent has not complied with the Code of Conduct prescribed under section 314. Section 290(2)(a) of the Act provides:(2)In considering whether it is satisfied that the applicant is not fit and proper or not a person of integrity, the Migration Agents Registration Authority must take into account:(a)the extent of the applicant's knowledge of migration procedure; and … There is no issue, in this application, as to whether the Applicant's registration application was false or misleading, that the Applicant has become bankrupt or that the Applicant or an individual related to him by employment is not a person of integrity. The Respondent contends, however, that the Applicant is not a fit and proper person to give immigration assistance and that he has not complied with the Code of Conduct prescribed under section 314 of the Act. The facts giving rise to that contention are not in dispute. The Complainant arrived in Australia as a visitor on 8 October 1996. On 16 October 1996 he lodged an application for a protection visa. That application was rejected and the Complainant did not take any further action within 28 days of the rejection. In June 1997 the Complainant entered into a de facto relationship with an Australian citizen and they married on 2 January 1999. The Complainant consulted the Applicant in his capacity as a migration agent and on 15 November 1999 the Applicant lodged, on the Complainant's behalf, an application for a spouse visa. On 1 August 2001 the Complainant received a letter from the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs advising him that his application for a spouse visa was invalid. The Complainant then, on 3 October 2001, sent a letter of complaint to the Respondent. That letter said, relevantly (PT23):"I came to Australia as a visitor on 8 October 1996 with the intention to visit my mother and sisters, Australian citizens. Within a couple of days of my arrival I consulted a solicitor, Mr Gonzales (now deceased), to enquire about further stay in Australia. I was referred to him by a fellow Filipino friend of my sister. Mr Gonzales prepared an application for a protection visa for me. I had, however, no understanding of the case written for me by him, nor of the process/es involved in the application and review procedures except that making the application allowed me to stay in Australia with proper authority.I was never a refugee, as I later learned the definition of the term. Following the refusal of my application for a protection visa in April 1997 Mr Gonzales encouraged me to pursue my relationship with an Australian citizen, Mrs Evangeline Bautista, who subsequently became my wife, telling me that I would be able to apply for permanent residence were I to marry.Ms Bautista and I married in January 1999 and she gave birth to our son, Ranier Caliwanagan, on 30 November 1999. In March 1999 I was introduced to another migration agent, Peter Nei Hwa Tung, through a friend of my wife. I was told to have my divorce done first with my previous wife before he could help me to lodge an on-shore spouse application. I followed what he told me to do and he helped me to lodge my spouse application in November 1999. I was continuously assured by him that my application was being processed by the DIMA, until he informed me that he received a letter from the Department saying that my application was invalid. On 16 August 2001 Mr Tung helped me to write a letter to the Minister by way of appeal, to which he attached a letter by my wife. The Minister replied on 7 September 2001, advising me to contact the Compliance Branch at the Department's Parramatta office. I did so and was granted a Bridging "E" visa.I have arranged to leave Australia on 6 October 2001 and my wife is sponsoring my application to the Australian Embassy in Manila for readmission. Of course, in my application I have to deal with my previous abuse of migration law in the context of (Migration Regulations) criterion 4001; I have been an innocent participant in considerable abuse – I had no idea of refugee status applications in Australia and, for a long time after my spouse application was made, I had no idea it was invalid. By the time I knew, it was too late for me to do anything about it and to extricate myself from the web woven about me.My complaint centers on the fact, as I now know, that Section 48 of the Migration Act always worked to prevent me from making an on-shore spouse application. I thought I had paid Mr Tung for truthful professional advice; was he so ignorant of the law that he unwittingly mislead me and is not competent to be registered to give migration advice or did he deliberately deceive me and is not, therefore, a fit and proper person to be so registered? Had he advised me properly, that I was not able to make an on-shore application, I would have returned to the Philippines immediately – had I done so I think I would now be a permanent resident in Australia. Instead, I am to leave on 6 October 2001 at a time when "good character" testing is, I understand, more rigorous than previously. As well, did Mr Tung not know that the law prevented intercession by the Minister in a case where there was not a review refusal existing? I did not know that, yet he, a professional migration agent, advised me otherwise, to the greater detriment of the visa application I shall soon make in Manila."