Mann and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 791

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  N2000/102

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      RICHARD MANN   
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

Date31 July 2000   

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed. 

(Sgd Dr D Chappell)
  ..................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
  CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION: subclass 301 (interdependent visa) - citizen of the Philippines - not a person of good character – past and present general conduct – worked illegally - lodgement of application for protection visa – application false – application refused – lodgement of second application – second application refused - request for ministerial intervention – request refused – allegation of fraud and malpractice on the part of migration agent - consideration of other general conduct – applicant not of good character -consideration of exercise of Tribunal's discretion – consideration of the need to protect the Australian community – need to send a strong deterrent message – consideration of the expectations of the Australian Community – legitimate expectation that visa applicant's conduct should not be rewarded – consideration of the effect of the separation on the applicant – acknowledged emotional hardship – decision affirmed
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1238
Dumbrell v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Baker (1997) 73 FCR 187
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs 1996 68 FCR 422Goldie v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 127
Lachmaiya v Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 19 AAR 148  Prasad v Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 35 ALD 780
Naidu v Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (AAT 9753, 27 September 1994)
Oliver May v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 575
Annecchini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (AAT 11838, 7  May 1997)
May v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 480
Santos v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 567
Haines v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 575
Ngor v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 353

REASONS FOR DECISION

31 July 2000 Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President   

BACKGROUND
Application and Hearing

  1. This is an application by Mr Richard Mann (the review applicant) for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister) pursuant to s501 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) to refuse to grant to his partner, Mr Roberto Flores (the visa applicant) a subclass 301 (interdependent) visa. The refusal was based on a finding that Mr Flores was not a person of good character. Section 500(1)(b) of the Act confers jurisdiction on the Tribunal to review this decision.

  2. Mr Nigel Dobbie, solicitor, represented Mr Mann at the hearing.  Both Mr Mann and Mr Flores gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The following witnesses also testified on behalf…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mann and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 791
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Mann and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the Federal Court of Australia addressed a dispute concerning the character-based refusal of a subclass 301 (interdependent visa) application. The applicant, Mr. Flores, a citizen of the Philippines, sought to enter Australia under a visa that depended on his relationship with Mr. Mann, an Australian citizen. The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs refused the visa application on the grounds that Mr. Flores was not a person of good character due to his past and present general conduct, which included working illegally in Australia and making false statements in a previous protection visa application. The Tribunal was required to consider the application of the character test under section 501 of the Act and whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion to grant the visa despite the character concerns.

The court focused on whether Mr. Flores' conduct demonstrated a failure to pass the character test, considering factors such as his involvement in activities indicating contempt for the law, his false statements in a prior visa application, and whether he had reformed his character. The Tribunal noted that Mr. Flores' immigration status was known to Mr. Mann prior to the determination of the first refugee application and that Mr. Mann encouraged and facilitated the immigration malpractice. The Tribunal also considered the emotional hardship that the separation from Mr. Mann would cause Mr. Flores, as well as the legitimate expectations of the Australian community. Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that despite the evidence of genuine remorse and hardship, the need to protect the Australian community and send a strong deterrent message outweighed these considerations. The Tribunal's decision was to affirm the Minister's decision to refuse the visa application.

The court acknowledged the genuine and lasting nature of the relationship between Mr. Flores and Mr. Mann, as well as the trauma and health effects the separation would have on both parties. However, it found that Mr. Mann, being an intelligent and articulate individual, could not now seek the exercise of discretion on hardship grounds given his prior knowledge and involvement in the immigration malpractice. The court emphasised that the Australian community expects visa applicants' conduct to be rewarded only when they have genuinely reformed their character. In this case, the Tribunal was not fully persuaded that Mr. Flores had reformed, and therefore, the exercise of discretion was not warranted in his favour.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Mr Flores, a citizen of the Philippines, who has been involved in serious immigration malpractice while in Australia. Mr Flores initially applied for a protection visa and subsequently for an interdependent visa with Mr Mann, an Australian citizen. Both applications were refused due to Mr Flores' lack of good character, primarily based on his past and present general conduct, including illegal work and providing false information in his visa applications. Despite Mr Flores' remorse and the emotional hardship caused by his separation from Mr Mann, the decision to refuse the visa was affirmed.

The matter was initially brought before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as an appeal against the refusal of the interdependent visa application. The AAT had to consider whether Mr Flores met the character test under section 501(6)(c)(ii) of the relevant Act, taking into account his past and present general conduct. The Tribunal reviewed evidence and submissions from both parties, including the impact of Mr Flores' departure on Mr Mann and his family, as well as the broader implications for the Australian community. The Tribunal ultimately affirmed the decision to refuse the visa.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Reference will be made later in this decision to those provisions of the Policy Direction which are relevant to the Tribunal's consideration of the present matter. But first the Tribunal turns its attention to the evidence presented concerning Mr Flores and the application of the character test under s501.EVIDENCEPast and Present General Conduct As noted it was the general contention of the respondent that Mr Flores does not pass the character test pursuant to s501(6)(c)(ii) of the Act on the basis of his past and present general conduct. Paragraph 1.9 of the Policy Direction has the following to say about the way in which decision makers should apply the character test under this particular head.1.9 In considering whether a non-citizen is not of good character against subparagraph 501(6)(c)(ii), decision-makers should consider the following matters (where they are relevant to the facts of the particular case), and where they are relevant, would, in the absence of any countervailing factors, constitute a failure to pass the Character Test:(a)whether the non-citizen has been involved in activities indicating contempt, or disregard, for the law or for human rights. This could include, but need not be limited to:· engaging in business activities which fall short of criminal fraud requiring proof beyond reasonable doubt, but which, on a more likely than not basis, are disreputable and reflect poorly on a non-citizen's moral qualities;· continual evasion or non-payment of debt;· continual disregard as to payments of family maintenance;· involvement in activities such as organised crime, terrorism, drug related activities, political extremism, extortion, 'white collar' crime, fraud, breaches of immigration law; or· involvement in war crimes or crimes against humanity.(b)whether the non-citizen has, in connection with any application for the grant of a visa or any kind of Government benefit, provided a bogus document or made a false or misleading statement;(c)whether the non-citizen has ever made a false or misleading declaration on an approved form, as defined in subsection 5(1) of the Act, about the non-citizen's character or conduct or both;(d)whether the non-citizen has been removed/deported from Australia or removed/deported from another country; or(e)whether the non-citizen has been dishonourably discharged from the armed forces of any country or discharged prematurely as the result of disciplinary action in circumstances, or because of conduct, which would be regarded as serious in Australia.(T:33) The Policy Direction also indicates that:1.11 General conduct also includes recent good conduct. Any good acts of the non-citizen after reprehensible conduct are indications that the non-citizen's character may have reformed. Thus, both good and bad conduct must be taken into consideration in obtaining a complete picture of the non-citizen's character. However, where the decision-maker is not fully persuaded that the non-citizen has reformed, the discretion to refuse or cancel a visa is enlivened, and evidence of good acts and recent conduct becomes relevant to the exercise of the discretion (see Part 2).(T: 34)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Flores was now 48 years old, he had no family in the Philippines, and was similarly suffering because of his separation from Mr Mann. There was evidence that Mr Flores has asthma and problems with his sinuses. He was now having health problems because of the effect that the pollution in Manila, where he lives, is having on his asthma and sinuses. He remained housebound as a result. It was submitted that Mr Flores felt genuine remorse for his breaches of the law. He should now be a given a second chance and the discretion should be exercised in his favour.CONCLUSION As in all cases of this type the balancing process that the Tribunal must conduct in exercising its discretion under s501 of the Act is far from simple. The Tribunal feels considerable sympathy for Mr Mann, in particular, who has clearly committed himself in a dedicated fashion to maintaining his relationship with Mr Flores despite the problems that have been encountered in regard to resolving his partner's immigration status. It is a relationship which been maintained for a period of about seven years and one which has been acknowledged by all of the persons who are familiar with both Mr Flores and Mr Mann to be genuine and lasting in its nature. There is also evidence that the separation brought about by Mr Flores' departure from this country has resulted in considerable trauma for Mr Mann, and Mr Flores and has affected their health and well-being. That effect has also extended to Mr Mann's elderly mother who spoke in very positive terms about Mr Flores and her relationship with him. Despite the nature of this evidence, and the clear hardship that would be endured by both Mr Mann and Mr Flores if the latter is not permitted to return to Australia, the Tribunal is satisfied that there is also evidence which shows that Mr Mann was well aware, at least in early 1995, that Mr Flores had been involved in what has already been described as serious and sustained immigration malpractice. Among other things, Mr Mann was present at the first RRT hearing when Mr Flores gave false testimony. Mr Mann was aware that this testimony was false but he nonetheless participated with Mr Flores in pursuing a further refugee claim with the advice and assistance of Mr Lingham. Mr Mann did not at any stage, prior to Mr Flores' departure from Australia and his interviews with officials in Manila, bring to the attention of the respondent's officials the nature of the problems confronting Mr Flores. Instead, he was at best a passive participant, and at worst a complicit participant in the ongoing series of applications made by Mr Flores to prolong his stay in Australia. Mr Mann is clearly an intelligent and articulate man with professional qualifications and experience in the field of accounting. As such, he is also a person who must take responsibility for his own actions and, in the words used by McMahon DP in Dumbrell v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 443:Having determined to embark on a permanent relationship with full knowledge of the possible consequences, he cannot now be heard to seek the exercise of discretion in his favour on hardship grounds.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In his submissions, Mr Dobbie disputed that the only expectation of the Australian community would be to deny Mr Flores a visa. There was also an expectation said Mr Dobbie that where people sought to correct their ways they should be given a "fair go". Mr Flores had done the right thing and should be permitted to return: see Ngor v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 353.Other Considerations Paragraph 2.17 of the Policy Direction refers to a number of other matters which, although not primary considerations, may be relevant to the exercise of the discretion under the Act. The Policy Direction states, in part, that:2.17 It is the Government's view that where relevant, it is appropriate these matters be taken into account but that they be given less individual weight than that given to the primary considerations. These other considerations may include:(a)the extent of disruption to the non-citizen's family, business and other ties to the Australian community;(b)genuine marriage to, or de facto or interdependent relationship with, an Australian citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen: The respondent conceded that there would be emotional hardship caused to Mr Mann should his partner be refused a visa. However, Ms Maurer said that the Tribunal should take into account the fact that Mr Flores' immigration status was known to Mr Mann prior to the determination of the first refugee application. In fact, it could be seen from the oral evidence that Mr Mann encouraged and facilitated the immigration malpractice. Mr Mann was fully aware that there was a strong possibility that his partner would not be allowed back into Australia. Notwithstanding this, he committed to the relationship. Mr Dobbie submitted that at the time Mr Mann and Mr Flores started their interdependent relationship Mr Mann was not aware of Mr Flores' immigration breaches. It could not be said, therefore, that Mr Mann entered into the relationship aware (or that he was expected to have been aware) of the consequences that would follow as a result of Mr Flores' breaches of immigration law. Furthermore, when he became aware, they sought advice from Mr John Lingham, but alleged that they were poorly advised, Mr Flores accepted responsibility for his actions and did not seek to deflect it onto his former agents. However, it was submitted that some weight should be given to Mr Flores' and Mr Mann's efforts to do the right thing by seeking legal advice in relation to Mr Flores' immigration status. Mr Flores was now 48 years old, he had no family in the Philippines, and was similarly suffering because of his separation from Mr Mann. There was evidence that Mr Flores has asthma and problems with his sinuses. He was now having health problems because of the effect that the pollution in Manila, where he lives, is having on his asthma and sinuses. He remained housebound as a result. It was submitted that Mr Flores felt genuine remorse for his breaches of the law. He should now be a given a second chance and the discretion should be exercised in his favour.CONCLUSION