Re Lau and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
31 min read
Full text
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 703
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL Nº V2002/37 GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION Re: HUI SING LAU Applicant And: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION
AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal: M.J. Carstairs, Member Date: 15 August 2002 Place: Melbourne
Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 10 December 2001, and substitutes the decision that the applicant's Subclass 127 Business Skills visa and the subsidiary visas should not be cancelled.
(sgd) M.J. Carstairs Member IMMIGRATION - Business Skills Visa – class AD subclass 127 - cancellation - whether substantial ownership in an eligible business – whether utilising skills in actively participating at a senior level in the day-to-day management of business– whether intention to continue to hold a substantial ownership and to utilise skills Migration Act 1958 s134 Re Griffiths and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2001] AATA 240 Re Tang and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) 32 AAR 103 Re Chen and Ors and Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] AATA 628 Nong v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2000) 106 FCR 257 Hope v Bathurst City Council (1980) 144 CLR 1 Re Wong and Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs[2002] AATA 54 Shorter Oxford English Dictionary on Historical Principles (Vol.1) Clarendon Press 1993 Macquarie Dictionary (2nd ed) 1991
REASONS FOR DECISION
15 August 2002 M.J. Carstairs, Member
This is an application by Hui Sing Lau (the applicant) for review of decisions of the Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (the respondent) dated 10 December 2001 to cancel the applicant's Business Skills visa and the subsidiary visas of his wife and four children.
At the hearing, Mr A. Conyer, solicitor, represented the applicant and Ms F. McKenzie, solicitor, represented the respondent. The applicant gave evidence with the assistance of an interpreter in the Mandarin language.
The Tribunal had before it the documents lodged under s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The Tribunal also had before it exhibits A1 to A34 (for the applicant) and R1 (for the respondent). BACKGROUND
The applicant is a resident of Malaysia. He is aged fifty and married. He has four children. He applied for a Business Skills visa on 18 December 1997. It was granted on 24 August 1998, with subsidiary visas for his wife, Siew Ding Ling and four children, Lee Ing John Lau (John Lau), Swee Bin Shirley Lau, Swee Ching Catherine Lau, and Lee Hung Tom Lau. John Lau has studied as a medical student in Australia.
The applicant has run a business in food products distribution in Malaysia for over 30 years. He registered the business name of his Malaysian business, Chop Lian Hin in Australia on 6 May 1998 (T8) through the Office of Consumer and Business Affairs in Adelaide. On 3 July 2000 he set up an Australian company Corcom Pty Ltd ("Corcom").
Business Skills visa holders can expect to receive survey forms to report their activities at 24 months and 36 months after being issued…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Lau and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:
Lau and another (the applicants) sought review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to cancel their Business Skills visas under s134(1) of the Migration Act 1958. The applicants argued that they had made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia and to actively participate in its management. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicants had made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia and to actively participate in its management. The Tribunal found that the applicants had made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia and to actively participate in its management. The Tribunal noted that the applicants had registered a business name in Australia, conducted market research, and made several purchases of goods for export to Malaysia. The Tribunal also found that the applicants had a reasonable intention to continue to make such efforts. The Tribunal concluded that the Minister's decision to cancel the applicants' visas was wrong and set it aside. The Tribunal substituted a decision that the applicants' Business Skills visas and subsidiary visas should not be cancelled.
This case highlights the importance of making a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia and to actively participate in its management. The Tribunal found that the applicants had made such a genuine effort and had a reasonable intention to continue to make such efforts. The Tribunal also noted that the Minister had not considered all of the relevant matters in determining whether the applicants had made a genuine effort. The case serves as a reminder to visa holders to take proactive steps to establish and manage a business in Australia and to provide all relevant information to the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
The Tribunal had before it the documents lodged under s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. The Tribunal also had before it exhibits A1 to A34 (for the applicant) and R1 (for the respondent).BACKGROUND The applicant is a resident of Malaysia. He is aged fifty and married. He has four children. He applied for a Business Skills visa on 18 December 1997. It was granted on 24 August 1998, with subsidiary visas for his wife, Siew Ding Ling and four children, Lee Ing John Lau (John Lau), Swee Bin Shirley Lau, Swee Ching Catherine Lau, and Lee Hung Tom Lau. John Lau has studied as a medical student in Australia. The applicant has run a business in food products distribution in Malaysia for over 30 years. He registered the business name of his Malaysian business, Chop Lian Hin in Australia on 6 May 1998 (T8) through the Office of Consumer and Business Affairs in Adelaide. On 3 July 2000 he set up an Australian company Corcom Pty Ltd ("Corcom"). Business Skills visa holders can expect to receive survey forms to report their activities at 24 months and 36 months after being issued with a visa. The Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (the Department) sent a Survey of Business Skills Migrants - 24 Months (T9) to the applicant on 30 July 2000. The Department received the completed 24-month survey (dated 20 September 2000) on 3 October 2000. The Department requested more information from the applicant by letter dated 31 October 2000 (T13) addressed to the applicant's nominated agent in Darwin, Bill Foo. In particular, the applicant was asked to show a significant level of ownership in an eligible business in Australia and that he was participating at a senior level in the day to day management of this business. Correspondence passed between the applicant (through Bill Foo) and the Department during 2000 and 2001 (T14, T15). However, on 8 August 2001 the Department sent letters to the applicant and the subsidiary visa holders, asking them to show cause why the Business Skills visa and subsidiary visas should not be cancelled. The Department made a decision on 10 December 2001 to cancel the visas. The applicant and the subsidiary visa holders sought review by the Tribunal on 7 January 2002 (T1). John Lau appealed in his own right. However, after the hearing, the Department notified the Tribunal that the decisions to cancel the visas of John Lau, Shirley Lau and Catherine Lau were of no effect, as each had been granted a resident return visa. John Lau withdrew his application with the Tribunal.EVIDENCE The applicant had prepared an undated, written statement (exhibit A1), which stated as follows:…1.…2.On 24 August 1998, I was granted a 127 Business Skills visa and arrived in Australia the following day. I have 7 siblings 4 of whom have resided permanently in Australia for a period in excess of 10 years, as has my mother.3.Even before I applied for the visa I had given serious consideration to exporting a product called Unipole from Australia. This was an advertising pole which was manufactured in South Australia. I had considered entering into a joint venture with certain Australian redsidents [sic] and I arranged to have prepared the business proposal and Heads of Agreement set out at p.69 of the T Documents. I had registered a Business Name, "CHOP LIAN HIN" in about 1995 which I renewed on 6 May 1998 with the intent then of using it for the venture.4.Due to a fluctuation in the Australian Dollar, I decided not to proceed with the Unipole venture. I was also concerned that I had never previously traded in that type of product. All of my experience was in the wholesaling of foodstuffs which I had sourced from various parts of Asia. I had had 35 years of experience in trade of that nature.5.After the [sic] discontinuing the Unipole proposal I gave thought to other business opportunities. I formed the view that I should concentrate my efforts on the type of enterprise with which I was most familiar, namely the distribution of foodstuffs. I decided that I would create a business in Australia similar to my Malaysian company, Chop Lin Hing and once the Australian business had been properly established it would take over the operations of Chop Lian Hing. In other words, I would be relocating my business from Malaysia to Australia. I therefore arranged for the incorporation of a company Corcom Pty. Ltd ("Corcom") on 3 July 2000.6.I commenced making enquiries to locate suitable priced and quality goods which I could export to Malaysia from Australia. At the same time I made contact with potential purchasers of product in Malaysia to identify the most appropriate types of goods for purchase and export.7.During the period 1998 to 1999 I remitted about $150,000 to Australia. I purchased a residential property in Melbourne in 1998. The purchase price was $170,000.8.I returned to Australia on 5 occasions during 2000 and 2001 to make further product enquiries. I conducted my research by touring a number of supermarkets in Melbourne and noting the various product lines which might be suitable for export. This is the same method which I employ in Malaysia to carry out my market assessment. I also purchased samples of various other products in the nature of health supplements and vitamins, see T Documents p.161 and A Documents pp. 120-121 [exhibit A3]. I expended about $1300 for various samples. During these trips I also met with the company's accountants and bankers. I also viewed business premises in the Box Hill and Glen Waverley areas as possible sites to locate the company at a future time. During my visits I would carry out administrative tasks on behalf of the company.9.I also requested that my son, John forward letters seeking information from various suppliers.10.During this period John assisted me to some extent. He was a full-time medical student at Melbourne University and had very limited spare time to provide me with anything other than the most rudimentary administrative assistance. I made all decisions relating to the running of the business which was then only in its inception.11.I took the decision that it was preferable for me to remain in Malaysia in order to maximise our customer base. I was attempting to introduce for the first time Australian product to my market and I believed that I ought to be on hand to assist in market penetration. For me the point of sale was the most critical aspect of the business. Once the business strengthened sufficiently I would be able to base myself in Australia. 12.During my visit in 2001, I made contact with a supplier of Australian of [sic] fruit juices, Timberland Corporation Pty Limited. On behalf of Corcom, I negotiated the purchase of a container of product for the sum of about $25,000. Corcom ordered these goods on 18 August 2001 which was [sic] then shipped on 12 September 2001 to a large supermarket in Malaysia which had placed the order with Corcom. See T Documents, pp 140-148, and ppl63-169.13.The same supermarket, through its agent ordered another container of various foodstuffs from Corcom on 15 October 2001. See A documents pp. 69-85 [exhibits A3-A12]. The value of the export was about $47,000. I sourced these goods from a supplier RUS Pty Ltd which is a Melbourne based company. These goods were shipped on 3 January 2002.14.On 5 November 2001 Corcom ordered a container of goods from Timberland to the value of 'about $19500 as, I through Chop Lian Hin, had received orders for such goods from a range of smaller retailers. Corcom arranged to ship these goods to my company Chop Lian Hin and thereafter the goods were distributed to those various retailers.15.The next order was placed by Corcom on Timberland on 14 November 2001 for product to the value of about $24,000. Once again Chop Lian Hin had received orders from a range of retailers for these goods. This order was shipped to Chop Lian Hin which onsold the goods to those various retailers.16.During February 2002 representatives of RUS Pty. Ltd visited Malaysia. As a result of this meeting I returned to Australia to arrange a further purchase order by Corcom for goods to be supplied by RUS totalling about $48000. These goods were shipped on 28 March 2002. The price was particularly good and I arranged for Corcom to purchase these goods even before I had a purchaser. I had no trouble onselling the goods.17.I have sourced a further supplier of food products being Nikko Pty Ltd. which is based in Melbourne from whom Corcom purchased $35000 worth of goods on 8 March 2002 which were shipped on 26 March 2002.18.Corcom has placed a further order of about $23000 on Timberland. This product has not yet been shipped.19.On Friday 12 April 2002 I placed a further order in the sum of about $20000 for goods from Timberland. This product has also not yet been shipped.20.In all cases shipping and insurance is arranged by the supplier.21.To date I invested about $80000 in Corcom.22.I appointed a migration agent Mr. Bill Foo to correspond with the Department in matters arising our [sic] of the Survey. I always relied on Mr. Foo's expertise to ensure that information sought was promptly and accurately responded to. I had informed him of the orders placed following his submission of 28 September 2001. He said to me on a number of occasions: "Don't worry about sending the additional information because I don't see that we will have any problems.'' See A Documents p136.23.I became concerned and despite Mr. Foo's advice, l felt that the further information should be brought to the attention of the Department. I therefore requested John to contact the Department directly to enquire about processing and what I ought to do in relation to the additional documentation. John told me that the Department had informed him to wait for the decision. I therefore believed that I would be given a further opportunity to provide further documents if required by the Department.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The Department made a decision on 10 December 2001 to cancel the visas. The applicant and the subsidiary visa holders sought review by the Tribunal on 7 January 2002 (T1). John Lau appealed in his own right. However, after the hearing, the Department notified the Tribunal that the decisions to cancel the visas of John Lau, Shirley Lau and Catherine Lau were of no effect, as each had been granted a resident return visa. John Lau withdrew his application with the Tribunal.EVIDENCE The applicant had prepared an undated, written statement (exhibit A1), which stated as follows:…1.…2.On 24 August 1998, I was granted a 127 Business Skills visa and arrived in Australia the following day. I have 7 siblings 4 of whom have resided permanently in Australia for a period in excess of 10 years, as has my mother.3.Even before I applied for the visa I had given serious consideration to exporting a product called Unipole from Australia. This was an advertising pole which was manufactured in South Australia. I had considered entering into a joint venture with certain Australian redsidents [sic] and I arranged to have prepared the business proposal and Heads of Agreement set out at p.69 of the T Documents. I had registered a Business Name, "CHOP LIAN HIN" in about 1995 which I renewed on 6 May 1998 with the intent then of using it for the venture.4.Due to a fluctuation in the Australian Dollar, I decided not to proceed with the Unipole venture. I was also concerned that I had never previously traded in that type of product. All of my experience was in the wholesaling of foodstuffs which I had sourced from various parts of Asia. I had had 35 years of experience in trade of that nature.5.After the [sic] discontinuing the Unipole proposal I gave thought to other business opportunities. I formed the view that I should concentrate my efforts on the type of enterprise with which I was most familiar, namely the distribution of foodstuffs. I decided that I would create a business in Australia similar to my Malaysian company, Chop Lin Hing and once the Australian business had been properly established it would take over the operations of Chop Lian Hing. In other words, I would be relocating my business from Malaysia to Australia. I therefore arranged for the incorporation of a company Corcom Pty. Ltd ("Corcom") on 3 July 2000.6.I commenced making enquiries to locate suitable priced and quality goods which I could export to Malaysia from Australia. At the same time I made contact with potential purchasers of product in Malaysia to identify the most appropriate types of goods for purchase and export.7.During the period 1998 to 1999 I remitted about $150,000 to Australia. I purchased a residential property in Melbourne in 1998. The purchase price was $170,000.8.I returned to Australia on 5 occasions during 2000 and 2001 to make further product enquiries. I conducted my research by touring a number of supermarkets in Melbourne and noting the various product lines which might be suitable for export. This is the same method which I employ in Malaysia to carry out my market assessment. I also purchased samples of various other products in the nature of health supplements and vitamins, see T Documents p.161 and A Documents pp. 120-121 [exhibit A3]. I expended about $1300 for various samples. During these trips I also met with the company's accountants and bankers. I also viewed business premises in the Box Hill and Glen Waverley areas as possible sites to locate the company at a future time. During my visits I would carry out administrative tasks on behalf of the company.9.I also requested that my son, John forward letters seeking information from various suppliers.10.During this period John assisted me to some extent. He was a full-time medical student at Melbourne University and had very limited spare time to provide me with anything other than the most rudimentary administrative assistance. I made all decisions relating to the running of the business which was then only in its inception.11.I took the decision that it was preferable for me to remain in Malaysia in order to maximise our customer base. I was attempting to introduce for the first time Australian product to my market and I believed that I ought to be on hand to assist in market penetration. For me the point of sale was the most critical aspect of the business. Once the business strengthened sufficiently I would be able to base myself in Australia. 12.During my visit in 2001, I made contact with a supplier of Australian of [sic] fruit juices, Timberland Corporation Pty Limited. On behalf of Corcom, I negotiated the purchase of a container of product for the sum of about $25,000. Corcom ordered these goods on 18 August 2001 which was [sic] then shipped on 12 September 2001 to a large supermarket in Malaysia which had placed the order with Corcom. See T Documents, pp 140-148, and ppl63-169.13.The same supermarket, through its agent ordered another container of various foodstuffs from Corcom on 15 October 2001. See A documents pp. 69-85 [exhibits A3-A12]. The value of the export was about $47,000. I sourced these goods from a supplier RUS Pty Ltd which is a Melbourne based company. These goods were shipped on 3 January 2002.14.On 5 November 2001 Corcom ordered a container of goods from Timberland to the value of 'about $19500 as, I through Chop Lian Hin, had received orders for such goods from a range of smaller retailers. Corcom arranged to ship these goods to my company Chop Lian Hin and thereafter the goods were distributed to those various retailers.15.The next order was placed by Corcom on Timberland on 14 November 2001 for product to the value of about $24,000. Once again Chop Lian Hin had received orders from a range of retailers for these goods. This order was shipped to Chop Lian Hin which onsold the goods to those various retailers.16.During February 2002 representatives of RUS Pty. Ltd visited Malaysia. As a result of this meeting I returned to Australia to arrange a further purchase order by Corcom for goods to be supplied by RUS totalling about $48000. These goods were shipped on 28 March 2002. The price was particularly good and I arranged for Corcom to purchase these goods even before I had a purchaser. I had no trouble onselling the goods.17.I have sourced a further supplier of food products being Nikko Pty Ltd. which is based in Melbourne from whom Corcom purchased $35000 worth of goods on 8 March 2002 which were shipped on 26 March 2002.18.Corcom has placed a further order of about $23000 on Timberland. This product has not yet been shipped.19.On Friday 12 April 2002 I placed a further order in the sum of about $20000 for goods from Timberland. This product has also not yet been shipped.20.In all cases shipping and insurance is arranged by the supplier.21.To date I invested about $80000 in Corcom.22.I appointed a migration agent Mr. Bill Foo to correspond with the Department in matters arising our [sic] of the Survey. I always relied on Mr. Foo's expertise to ensure that information sought was promptly and accurately responded to. I had informed him of the orders placed following his submission of 28 September 2001. He said to me on a number of occasions: "Don't worry about sending the additional information because I don't see that we will have any problems.'' See A Documents p136.23.I became concerned and despite Mr. Foo's advice, l felt that the further information should be brought to the attention of the Department. I therefore requested John to contact the Department directly to enquire about processing and what I ought to do in relation to the additional documentation. John told me that the Department had informed him to wait for the decision. I therefore believed that I would be given a further opportunity to provide further documents if required by the Department.
Decision
Reasons for decision
For these reasons, the Tribunal decides the grounds to exercise the discretion do not arise, as none of the pre-conditions for its exercise is met. As this is so, there is no need to address the matter under s134(2) and s134(3). This means that the decision to cancel the Business Skills visa should be set aside, and it follows also that the decisions to cancel the subsidiary visas should also be set aside.DECISION The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 10 December 2001, and substitutes the decision that the applicant's Subclass 127 Business Skills visa and the subsidiary visas should not be cancelled.I certify that the thirty-seven [37] preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of M.J.Carstairs, Member(sgd) Catherine Thomas ClerkDate of hearing: 17 April 2002 Date of decision: 15 August 2002 Solicitor for applicant Mr A. Conyer, Messrs Diamond PeisahSolicitor for respondent: Ms F. McKenzie, Messrs Blake Dawson Waldron
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Also in evidence were the interim financial accounts for Corcom for the period ended 31 January 2002, showing an operating loss of $5953 for the period 1 July 2001 to 31 January 2002 and of $6499 in the previous financial year. The profit and loss account for the company showed sales revenue of $116,463 for the period 1 July 2001 to 31 January 2002 (exhibit A32)CONSIDERATION OF THE ISSUES The Migration Act 1958 Act (the Act) provides as follows:134(1) Subject to subsection (2) and to section 135, the Minister may cancel a business visa (other than an established business in Australia visa, an investment-linked visa or a family member's visa), by written notice given to its holder, if the Minister is satisfied that its holder:(a)has not obtained a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia; or(b)is not utilising his or her skills in actively participating at a senior level in the day-to-day management of that business; or(c) does not intend to continue to:(i)hold a substantial ownership interest in; and(ii)utilise his or her skills in actively participating at a senior level in the day-to-day management of;an eligible business in Australia.(2) The Minister must not cancel a business visa under subsection (1) if the Minister is satisfied that its holder:(a)has made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia; and(b)has made a genuine effort to utilise his or her skills in actively participating at a senior level in the day-to-day management of that business; and(c)intends to continue to make such genuine efforts.(3) Without limiting the generality of matters that the Minister may take into account in determining whether a person has made the genuine effort referred to in subsection (2), the Minister may take into account any or all of the following matters:(a)business proposals that the person has developed;(b)the existence of partners or joint venturers for the business proposals;(c)research that the person has undertaken into the conduct of an eligible business in Australia;(d)the period or periods during which the person has been present in Australia;(e)the value of assets transferred to Australia by the person for use in obtaining an interest in an eligible business;(f)the value of ownership interest in eligible businesses in Australia that are, or have been, held by the person;(g) business activity that is, or has been, undertaken by the person;(h)whether the person has failed to comply with a notice under section 137;(i)if the person no longer holds a substantial ownership interest in a particular business or no longer utilises his or her skills in actively participating at a senior level of a day-to-day management of a business:(i)the length of time that the person held the ownership interest or participated in the management (as the case requires); and(ii)the reasons why the person no longer holds the interest or participates in the management (as the case requires).…(10) In this section:…eligible business means a business that the Minister reasonably believes is resulting or will result in one or more of the following:(a)the development of business links with the international market;(b)the creation or maintenance of employment in Australia;(c)the export of Australian goods or services;(d)the production of goods or the provision of services that would otherwise be imported into Australia;(e)the introduction of new or improved technology to Australia;(f)an increase in commercial activity and competitiveness within sectors of the Australian economy; …