Re Wong and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 54

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2001/596

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )          
           Re      Yuk Chun Wong   
  Applicant
           And    Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs  
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr R P Handley, Deputy President         

Date31 January 2002

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and substitutes a new decision that Ms Wong's Subclass 127 Business Skills Visa should not have been cancelled.  
  ..............................................
  R P Handley
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
  IMMIGRATION – Business Skills Visa – Applicant failed to comply with visa requirement to notify Department of her residential address and provide information on business activities – Business Skills Visa subsequently cancelled – whether Applicant had made a genuine effort to obtain a "substantial ownership interest" in an "eligible business" in Australia
JURISDICTION – cancellation of visa – Tribunal must determine the correct or preferable decision at the time the decision was made

Migration Act 1958: ss 134(1), 134(2), 134(3), 134(10)

Birds Eye and Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board [2000] AATA 783
Freeman v The Secretary, Department of Social Security (1988) 19 FCR 342
Re Griffiths and Migration Agents Registration Authority [2001] AATA 240

REASONS FOR DECISION

31 January 2002     Mr R P Handley, Deputy President   

  1. This is an application by Yuk Chun Wong ("the Applicant") for a review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (as it then was named) ("the Respondent") made on 9 April 2001 to cancel Ms Wong's Subclass 127 Business Skills Visa pursuant to s134(1) of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act"). At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by Arnold Conyer, Solicitor, of Didmond Persah, Solicitors, and the Respondent was represented by Zak Chami, Solicitor, of Clayton Utz, Lawyers. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the documents produced pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T Documents"), together with the documents tendered by the parties. Oral evidence was given by the Applicant and by Vincent You.
    BACKGROUND

  2. Ms Wong was born in Hong Kong on 21 January 1959.  She is aged 42 and single.  On 11 April 1996, Ms Wong applied for a business skills visa to migrate to Australia.  At that time, she worked as a manager for the Wing Fung Metal Co. Ltd in Kowloon, whose core business is the wholesaling and retailing of metal and related products.  In Form 928 Supplementary Information, also dated 11 April 1996 (T13), Ms Wong stated that she intended to conduct an export business in Sydney, exporting Australian metal products to Asian countries.  She stated that she planned to invest $500,000 in her business in Australia. 

  3. On 11 March 1997, Ms Wong was notified by the Australian Consulate General in Hong Kong that her application for a permanent entry visa to Australia had been granted (T71).  Ms Wong was subsequently issued with a Subclass 127 visa on 28 April 1997 and made her initial entry into Australia on 22 January 1998.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Wong and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affai... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yuk Chun Wong applied for a review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to cancel her Subclass 127 Business Skills Visa. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether Ms Wong had made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia, as required by s 134(2) of the Migration Act 1958. This determination was critical as it would influence whether the visa cancellation decision was correct at the time it was made.

The Tribunal considered the evidence provided by Ms Wong and Vincent You, including the minutes of the directors' meeting of Sinem Pty Ltd, to assess whether Ms Wong had made a genuine effort to acquire a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business. The Tribunal found that Ms Wong had indeed purchased a 25% share in Sinem Pty Ltd, which constituted a substantial ownership interest. Additionally, the Tribunal determined that Sinem Pty Ltd qualified as an eligible business under s 134(10) of the Act, as it created or maintained employment and aimed to increase commercial activity within the fast food sector. The Tribunal concluded that Ms Wong had made a genuine effort to fulfil the visa requirements, leading to the decision that the visa cancellation was not correctly made at the time it was issued.

The Tribunal, having found that Ms Wong had made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business, ordered that the decision to cancel Ms Wong's Subclass 127 Business Skills Visa be set aside. The Tribunal's decision emphasised the importance of assessing the visa holder's efforts at the time the cancellation decision was made, in accordance with established legal principles.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application by Yuk Chun Wong ("the Applicant") for a review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (as it then was named) ("the Respondent") made on 9 April 2001 to cancel Ms Wong's Subclass 127 Business Skills Visa pursuant to s134(1) of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act"). At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by Arnold Conyer, Solicitor, of Didmond Persah, Solicitors, and the Respondent was represented by Zak Chami, Solicitor, of Clayton Utz, Lawyers. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised the documents produced pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T Documents"), together with the documents tendered by the parties. Oral evidence was given by the Applicant and by Vincent You.BACKGROUND Ms Wong was born in Hong Kong on 21 January 1959. She is aged 42 and single. On 11 April 1996, Ms Wong applied for a business skills visa to migrate to Australia. At that time, she worked as a manager for the Wing Fung Metal Co. Ltd in Kowloon, whose core business is the wholesaling and retailing of metal and related products. In Form 928 Supplementary Information, also dated 11 April 1996 (T13), Ms Wong stated that she intended to conduct an export business in Sydney, exporting Australian metal products to Asian countries. She stated that she planned to invest $500,000 in her business in Australia. On 11 March 1997, Ms Wong was notified by the Australian Consulate General in Hong Kong that her application for a permanent entry visa to Australia had been granted (T71). Ms Wong was subsequently issued with a Subclass 127 visa on 28 April 1997 and made her initial entry into Australia on 22 January 1998. In a Form 926 Declaration dated 11 April 1996 (T11), Ms Wong agreed to notify the then Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs of her residential address within 28 days of her first entry into Australia as a migrant. She did not do so, although Ms Wong noted that she had stated her mother's address at Strathfield on the incoming passenger card when she first came into Australia on her business visa on 1998. Both her mother and sister live at this address. Ms Wong also declared she understood that the Department conducted "regular surveys of business skills migrants (usually at 12/24 and 36 month intervals)" and agreed to complete such survey forms and provide information as required. Ms Wong said she would have speeded up negotiations for the purchase of her share of the business had she been aware of the necessity to complete the survey forms. On 7 December 1999, a standard letter asking Ms Wong to complete a 24 month survey about her business activities was prepared and, subsequently, on 1 December 2000, a similar letter requiring her to complete a 36 month survey about her business activities was prepared. In both cases, because she had not provided a residential address in Australia in accordance with the Form 926 Declaration, the letters were not sent to her.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

With regard to whether or not Ms Wong made a genuine effort to satisfy the requirements of s 134(2), Mr Chami referred the Tribunal to s 134(3) and the matters listed there. In particular, he noted with regard to sub paragraph (a) the brevity of Ms Wong's business proposal (A2), with regard to sub paragraph (d), the short period – 84 days to the time of the decision - which Ms Wong has spent in Australia, with regard to sub-paragraph (e, the fact that the $700,000 transferred by Ms Wong to Australia was transferred before the grant of a visa and has for the most part been a passive investment, with regard to sub-paragraph (g), Mr You seemed unclear as to when he had sought Ms Wong's assistance in sourcing food processing machines but it seemed this might not have occurred until February 2001, and with regard to sub-paragraph (h), the fact that Ms Wong had failed to comply with her obligation to provide an Australian residential address.CONSIDERATION OF LAW AND FINDINGS The Tribunal notes the preliminary point made by Mr Chami as to the evidence that the Tribunal should take into account in reviewing the Respondent's decision to cancel Ms Wong's business visa. The Tribunal acknowledges the approach adopted in Freeman (supra) that the jurisdiction of the Tribunal in respect of a cancellation is to determine the correct or preferable decision at the time that the decision to cancel was made. This approach has been followed in a number of cases, and was recently re-affirmed by Deputy President Forgie in Griffiths (supra) at paragraph 39, where the Deputy President said:Where the decision under consideration is a cancellation decision, the Tribunal must consider whether or not that decision was correctly made at the time it was made. The decision under review is a decision dated 9 April 2001 to cancel Ms Wong's Subclass 127 Business Skills visa pursuant to s 134(1) of the Act. Section 134(2) provides that the Minister must not cancel a visa under sub-section (1) if the Minister is satisfied that the person:(a) has made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in ` an eligible business in Australia; and (b) has made a genuine effort to utilise his or her skills in actively participating at a senior level in the day-to-day management of that business; and (c) intends to continue to make such genuine efforts. The first issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether or not Ms Wong has made a genuine effort to obtain a substantial ownership interest in an eligible business in Australia. A definition of "eligible business" and "ownership interest" appears in s 134(10) quoted above. Based on the oral evidence of both Ms Wong and Mr You and on the Minutes of a meeting of the Directors of Sinem Pty Ltd (R1) the Tribunal finds that Ms Wong has purchased 1 ordinary share representing a 25% interest in Sinem Pty Ltd. While the Tribunal notes the formal transfer took place on 26 April 2001 (R2), the Tribunal accepts Ms Wong's and Mr You's evidence that they had concluded their agreement for Ms Wong to purhase this share for the sum of $150,000 in a telephone conversation in early February 2001, when Ms Wong was still in Hong Kong. The formal transfer of the share took place after Ms Wong had arrived in Australia on 30 March 2001 and had withdrawn funds from her term deposit with the Westpac Bank in Sydney to pay for the share. The Tribunal notes that by purchasing a 25% interest in Sinem Pty Ltd as a shareholder, Ms Wong acquired an "ownership interest" as defined in s 134(10) which in the Tribunal's view should be considered substantial. Furthermore, in the Tribunal's view, Sinem Pty Ltd is an "eligible business" within the definition in s 134(10) on the basis that the business is creating or maintaining employment in Australia, and will lead to an increase in commercial activity and competitiveness within the fast food sector of the Australian economy. The Tribunal notes that the business is also seeking to develop links into the South East Asian regional market which may in the future involve the export of processed food.